Key takeaways
- The check in February validates the hydraulic balancing and the thermal sizing under design temperatures.
- The joint reading of thermal energy and electrical energy gives the real coefficient of performance.
- Comparing consumption with unified degree-days isolates the drifts specific to the building.
- Methodical adjustment of the slope and of the curve offset eliminates short-cycling of the generator.
Reading the meters and measuring the real coefficient of performance in February
Acceptance of a heating installation in the mid-season or at the end of summer in no way guarantees its operational efficiency. The factory settings or the theoretical values entered at commissioning only face the test of truth in February, when the outdoor temperature drops towards the design values and the power demand reaches its maximum. During this critical period, indoor comfort may seem flawless even though the machine is compensating for an unsuitable curve by permanently engaging its electric back-up heaters, or by overconsumption that is invisible without dedicated instrumentation.
To objectify the behaviour of the system, the installer must rely on the simultaneous reading of two essential instruments: the thermal energy meter (an ultrasonic calorimeter measuring the mass flow rate and the temperature difference between water flow and return) and the sub-meter dedicated to the thermal generator. The analysis cannot rely on the building's overall bill, which is polluted by domestic uses.
| Physical indicator | Measuring device | Quantity read | Purpose of the check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Useful thermal energy | MID heat meter | kWh of heat produced | Assess the real load on the circuit |
| Electrical energy absorbed | kWh sub-meter | kWh of electricity consumed | Account for the compressor and the back-up |
| Operating mode | Heating controller | Compressor hours and cycles | Detect destructive short cycles |
| Temperature difference | Immersion sensors flow/return | Delta T in Kelvin | Check the real flow rate of the circulator |
The ratio between the total thermal energy fed into the distribution network and the total electrical energy absorbed by the generator gives the effective seasonal coefficient of performance over the month in question. If the value measured in February falls by more than 15 % below the manufacturer's data for the prescribed water temperature regime, the installation has a hydraulic anomaly or an incorrect setting of the weather-compensated control.
Comparing with the initial calculation and correcting the slope of the heating curve
The raw data collected over the months from October to February must be systematically compared with the initial heat load calculation drawn up in accordance with standard SIA 384.201. To make this comparison meaningful, the measured thermal energy consumption must be normalised by taking into account the actual climatic severity of the winter. The tradesperson uses the unified degree-days (DJU) calculated by the local weather station on the 20/12 °C basis. This calculation separates the drifts linked to the occupants' ventilation habits from those resulting from an anomaly in the water distribution system.
- Recording the readings on the last day of the monthOn a fixed date, read the cumulative heat energy, the electrical energy absorbed, the volume of water circulated and the generator's start counter.
- Calculating the average power demandedDivide the monthly thermal energy by the number of hours in the month and compare this ratio with the design power weighted by the average outdoor temperature.
- Adjusting the heating slope in very cold weatherWhen the outdoor temperature is below zero degrees, modify the slope of the curve without touching the curve offset if the rooms drift away from the set point.
- Modifying the curve offset in the mid-seasonIf the building shows thermal discomfort in autumn or spring at mild outdoor temperatures, correct the intercept (curve offset).
The correction of the heating curve is carried out in progressive steps. In a network connected to high-inertia underfloor heating, a change in slope must not exceed 0.1 point per intervention, with a thermal stabilisation period of at least 48 hours. For low-temperature radiators, the change in set point shall not exceed 2 to 3 Kelvin at a time. The methodical lowering of the flow temperature to the strict level needed to maintain comfort directly improves the thermodynamic efficiency of the compressor.
- Heating curve (weather-compensation curve)
- Control algorithm that determines the set-point temperature of the water leaving the boiler or heat pump exclusively as a function of the outdoor temperature measured by the façade sensor.
The monthly reading protocol: separating the loads and normalising to degree-days
A one-off check carried out at acceptance in autumn tells nothing about the efficiency of a boiler room. Operation at very low partial load and the evaporation of construction moisture in the slabs distort the thermal behaviour. To make an incontestable diagnosis, the installer carries out a campaign of three periodic readings: end of November to assess the start of the intermediate regime, end of January to analyse the generator's response under the most severe cold, and end of February to draw up the stabilised full-season balance. At each of these dates, the simultaneous reading of the physical meters provides the only objective quantities needed for analysing the system.
This rigorous monitoring requires the flows to be isolated by means of sub-meters compliant with legal metrology. Three readings taken on the same day establish the energy balance:
- The main thermal energy meter (MID calorimeter), mounted on the heating manifolds, which integrates flow rate and temperature difference to measure the useful heat delivered to the emitters.
- The secondary heat meter connected to the load of the domestic hot water cylinder, essential to separate the draw-off load from the needs of the building envelope.
- The electrical active-energy sub-meter (kWh), connected exclusively to the boiler-room switchboard, covering the thermal unit, the electric back-up, the controls and the primary circulators.
The quantity of heat recorded cannot be compared with the initial studies without climatic correction. The sizing calculation, drawn up in accordance with standard SIA 384/201 and standard SIA 380/1, is based on a theoretical model of heating degree-days (DJU). During the February analysis, the technician collects the local weather data from the reference station. If the cumulative degree-days prove to be 10 % below the thirty-year normal, the useful heat production must show an equivalent reduction. A thermal consumption equal to or higher than the theoretical calculation despite a mild winter reveals room set points above the contractual 20 °C or an uncontrolled fresh-air flow compared with the assumptions of the design.
| Reading period | Space heating heat [kWh] | Domestic hot water heat [kWh] | Total electricity [kWh] | Average monthly COP [-] | Deviation from design DJU |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| End of November | 4 850 | 920 | 1 560 | 3.70 | + 4 % |
| End of January | 9 400 | 980 | 2 880 | 3.60 | + 8 % |
| End of February | 7 650 | 890 | 2 280 | 3.75 | + 3 % |
Adjusting the curve offset and formalising the final calibration
After consolidating the slope of the heating curve during the January cold, the February review often reveals a thermal drift during the days of milder weather. If the occupants notice marked overheating between 6 °C and 12 °C outdoors while comfort was perfect at −5 °C, altering the inclination of the slope would upset the winter balance. The installer therefore intervenes in a targeted way on the translation of the control, called the curve offset or parallel shift. A methodical lowering of 1 K to 1.5 K reduces the water flow temperature in the mid-season without weakening the power in severe cold. During this visit, the technician also checks the temperature difference: a return that is too hot reveals an excessive circulator flow rate that flattens the delta T and penalises the efficiency of the machine.
The February check structures the closing of the optimisation services. According to art. 367 CO, after delivery of the work, the client inspects its condition and notifies the contractor of any defects. By submitting a first-season report bringing together the readings taken, the real operating COP and the corrected heating curve, the heating installer formalises the end of the fine-tuning. This record fixes the settings and confirms that the energy performance provided for in the works contract has been achieved.
Consumption drift in the first season: diagnosing deviations and lifting reservations
In February, cross-checking the electricity meter against the heat meter sometimes reveals a sharp deviation from the initial sizing. An excessive electricity bill or a seasonal coefficient of performance below forecasts does not necessarily indicate a faulty machine, but most often reflects a hydraulic regime unsuited to peak climatic conditions. The installer must intervene methodically before the end of the heating season to avoid the dispute dragging on.
- Identifying the origin of the overconsumptionFirst check the hour counter for the engagement of the electric back-up resistance. A bivalence threshold set too high or a domestic hot water set point that cannot be reached puts the immersion heater element under load at the expense of the compressor, which immediately degrades the overall efficiency.
- Analysing the operating cyclesRead the ratio between the number of starts and the running time of the compressor. More than three starts per hour in cold weather characterises short cycles caused by insufficient water flow, a clogged filter or an overestimated heating curve that shuts the machine down on high-pressure safety.
- Correcting the heating curve and the flow ratesLower the set-point slope by 0.1 to 0.2 point if the measured room temperature exceeds the comfort set point. Check the secondary circulator to guarantee the nominal flow rate and bleed the residual air trapped at the high points of the distribution circuits.
If the initial calculation according to standard SIA 384/201 is not achieved because of residual construction moisture or a solar gain below the cantonal average, formalise in writing the impact of these factors on the operating balance. Any adjustment of a hydraulic balancing or control device is the subject of an intervention sheet signed by both parties.
Frequently asked questions
How can you tell an overconsumption linked to the building from a problem with the heat pump?
The heat meter and the electricity meter settle the question. By dividing the thermal kilowatt-hours delivered by the electrical kilowatt-hours consumed over the month of February, you obtain the real coefficient of performance. If this efficiency matches the manufacturer's data at the outdoor temperature recorded but the overall energy soars, the cause lies in the building's heat losses, excessive ventilation or the drying of the slabs.
Why must the correction of the slope wait for the severe cold of January or February?
In the mid-season, when the outdoor temperature fluctuates between 8 and 12 degrees, the decisive anchor point of the control is the curve offset. The slope of the line only has a measurable influence on the flow temperature when there is a large temperature differential. Trying to set the slope in mild weather upsets the balance; February offers the climatic severity required to validate the inclination.
What should you do if the electric back-up resistance runs continuously at minus five degrees?
First check the outdoor temperature sensor, its position on the north façade and its calibration. Then check the bivalence set point in the installer menu: it is often left at the factory setting of zero degrees instead of the calculated threshold. Finally, make sure that domestic hot water production is not monopolising the machine continuously, which would force the back-up elements to engage on the heating.
Should the circulator flow rate be changed at the same time as the heating curve?
No, the operations should be separated, otherwise the origin of the drifts will be masked. The installer first adjusts the heating curve in progressive steps of 0.1 point and observes the indoor thermal behaviour for 48 hours. The circulation flow rate of the heat-transfer fluid is adjusted solely according to the temperature difference between flow and return recommended by the generator manufacturer.
Texts and standards cited
- CO art. 367inspection of the work and notice of defects
- norme SIA 384/201Heating systems in buildings - Calculation of the nominal heat load
