Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 241Heat pump: source, installation and noiseChapter 8 of 10 in the section

Defrosting: frequency, loss of efficiency and the sign of a wrong setting

When an air-to-water heat pump runs one cycle reversal after another in cold weather, the reflex is often to blame the refrigerant. In this chapter you will learn to measure the actual rate of defrosts, to identify an airflow short-circuit on the evaporator and to correct the hydraulic faults on the condenser side that collapse the useful heat output of the installation.

Key takeaways

  • A reversal cycle every twenty minutes signals a severe hydraulic or airflow fault.
  • The regular interval between two defrosts in damp winter conditions is between fifty and ninety minutes.
  • Recirculation of discharged air against a wall causes a sharp drop in the evaporating temperature.
  • Insufficient water flow in the condenser prolongs the defrost and prevents the temperature from recovering.

Identifying the abnormal rate and airflow faults

With an outdoor temperature fluctuating between -2 °C and 5 °C under dense fog, the outdoor air saturates the finned heat exchanger with moisture. Passing the dew point together with the negative refrigerant temperature inevitably leads to a layer of frost forming on the outdoor coil. Under correct operating conditions, a modern heat pump manages this layer without collapsing its overall coefficient of performance: the machine maintains a heat production phase of fifty to ninety minutes, interspersed with a cycle reversal of four to seven minutes to clear the evaporator.

Normal defrost frequency
Thermally acceptable cycle reversal rate for an air-to-water heat pump, generally spaced 50 to 90 minutes apart in periods of high relative humidity (80 to 95 %) and air close to 0 °C, maintaining a net heat output to the distribution system.

When the controller triggers a defrost every twenty or thirty minutes, the energy balance turns negative. The cycle reversal draws heat directly from the heating water to melt the outdoor frost. If the operation lasts six minutes and repeats three times an hour, the machine spends eighteen minutes per hour thermally working against itself, while the secondary circulators let the slabs or radiators cool down. The output delivered to the building becomes almost nil, causing immediate complaints about lack of comfort.

The first non-refrigerant cause of premature icing is insufficient airflow through the coil. If the airflow pressure losses increase, the evaporator drops to a lower temperature to capture the necessary heat, crossing the trigger threshold of the differential pressure switch or the coil sensor prematurely. Fouling by plant dust, dead leaves pressed against the rear face or a fan speed throttled by overly strict acoustic programming in silent mode produce exactly this symptom.

Diagnosing the hydraulic origin and analysing the daily cycles

Contrary to the received ideas that systematically blame a refrigerant leak or a failure of the four-way valve, the origin of repeated icing is almost always hydraulic. To reverse its cycle and defrost quickly by hot gas, the heat pump must draw a massive amount of energy from the heating water via the condenser, which has become a temporary evaporator. If the internal system cannot supply this energy at a sufficient flow rate, the evaporating pressure collapses on the water side, the defrost drags on, the water risks freezing in the plates and the machine restarts a heating cycle with an imperfectly cleared outdoor coil.

Comparative analysis of defrost cycles over a winter day
Monitored parameterNormal operationHydraulic fault or air short-circuit
Interval between defrosts60 to 90 minutes18 to 25 minutes
Duration of the reversal phase3 to 6 minutes8 to 12 minutes (often interrupted by a safety cut-out)
Flow temperature dropBrief drop of 4 to 8 KMassive drop of 15 to 20 K with low-pressure cut-out
Visual condition of the coilClean, drained aluminiumBlock of residual ice at the bottom of the exchanger

The absence of a hydraulic separator or of a buffer tank of sufficient volume is the most destructive design error. When the building's thermostatic valves close under the effect of internal gains, the water flow through the heat pump falls below the critical threshold. A clogged strainer on the heating return produces the same blockage. The plate heat exchanger no longer has the volume of hot water needed to vaporise the refrigerant during the reversal; the process aborts before the lower ice has melted completely, condemning the machine to ice up faster and faster.

  1. Reading the cycle history on the controllerExtract the operating data over twenty-four hours on a cold day (temperature below 2 °C). Note the time gap between reversals and check whether the short cycles coincide with mass closures of terminal circuits.
  2. Measuring the flow rate and the usable water volumeCheck the differential pressure on the primary circulator and inspect the dirt separator or sludge filter. Make sure that the volume of water in permanent circulation is at least 15 to 20 litres per kilowatt of installed heat output, excluding zones regulated by thermostatic valves.
  3. Inspecting the surroundings of the outdoor unitCheck that there is no return of cold air to the discharge, measure the temperature difference between the free air and the air entering the coil, then make sure the condensate drains properly to avoid the formation of an ice heel that blocks the bottom of the fins.

Siting corrections and remedies for airflow disturbances

On an air-to-water heat pump, a reversal rate of one every twenty minutes indicates a collapse of heat exchange. When the evaporator no longer receives the nominal airflow specified by the manufacturer, the evaporating temperature drops artificially below the dew point, causing accelerated icing of the finned coil. The machine then spends most of its running time in reversal cycle melting frost instead of transferring heat to the distribution system.

The normal defrost frequency is between sixty and ninety minutes for outdoor temperatures fluctuating between -2 °C and +3 °C in foggy weather or high relative humidity. If the coil clogs up three times faster, the fitter must immediately check the immediate surroundings of the outdoor unit. Icing caused by an obstruction to the discharge frequently occurs when the cold air expelled by the propeller fan hits a boundary wall, a dense hedge or a façade return less than two and a half metres from the discharge grille.

  • Removal of solid visual screens located in the discharge cone at forty-five degrees.
  • Fitting of smooth metal deflectors angled upwards if the plot layout requires proximity to a property boundary.
  • Checking the fan speed and direction of rotation after electrical work on the phases.
  • Cleaning with a fin comb of the aluminium rows clogged by pollen, leaves or construction site residues.

Hydraulic measurement protocol and validation over a complete cycle

The real origin of a pathological defrost very often lies in the inability of the heating circuit to supply the energy required during the cycle reversal. When the four-way valve switches, the condenser becomes an evaporator: the heat pump draws heat directly from the water of the emitters or the buffer tank to defrost the outdoor exchanger in three to six minutes. If the water volume flow on the condenser side is restricted by closed thermostatic valves or an undersized circulator, the machine exhausts itself thermally.

Correlation matrix between hydraulic flows and defrost behaviour
Hydraulic parameterAbnormal measured valueDirect consequence on the cycleCorrective action required
Active buffer volumeLess than 12 litres per kWSudden drop of the return temperature below 18 °CIntegration of a hydraulic separator or hydraulic decoupling tank
Flow-return temperature differenceDelta T greater than 10 KInsufficient flow, incomplete exchange during the reversalSetting the main circulator to the high proportional pressure curve
Y-strainerPressure losses greater than 150 mbarEvaporation too low in defrost mode, safety cut-outRemoval of the strainer, flushing of the sludge and differential pressure measurement
Differential valvePermanent bypass to the returnShort-circuiting of the emitter volume, short cyclingCalibration of the pressure relief valve according to the calculated system curve

To validate the remediation of the installation, the foreman records the cycles over a cold day, ideally when the base outdoor temperature stays between -4 °C and +2 °C. The recording tool connected to the controller makes it possible to plot the time evolution of the flow temperature, the return temperature, the evaporator sensor and the absorbed consumption of the compressor. This twenty-four-hour analysis shows whether the heat output delivered really compensates for the building's heat losses or whether the controller activates the emergency backup heating elements.

  1. Connecting the temperature loggersPlace calibrated contact sensors on the common flow, the general return and the hot-gas pipe at the compressor outlet, under sealed insulation.
  2. Neutralising the thermostatic valvesOpen to one hundred per cent at least sixty per cent of the reference heating units to ensure the minimum flow loop during the test period.
  3. Observing the reversal phaseCheck that the return water temperature does not fall below 22 °C during the defrost, which guarantees complete clearing of the ice at the bottom of the coil.
  4. Checking condensate drainageCheck the gravity flow from the tray to the frost-proof drain pipe in order to prevent the re-formation of a base of ice that would trigger premature icing again.

Escalation procedure in case of persistent abnormal defrost cycles

When an air-to-water heat pump maintains a defrost rate of less than thirty minutes despite bleeding and careful cleaning of the fins, the machine suffers a severe heat deficit. The compressor consumes electrical energy from the grid to reverse the cycle without managing to raise the building's set temperature. On site in French-speaking Switzerland, this technical blockage almost always reveals a fault in the water supply to the condenser or an ineffective buffer volume that deprives the evaporator of the heat essential for the cycle reversal.

  1. Continuous monitoringFit contact sensors with a logger on the primary flow and return for forty-eight hours of severe cold. Plot the temperature difference across the plate heat exchanger and look for the differential pressure drops that signal an undersized circulator or a clogged strainer.
  2. Airflow measurement and short-circuit detectionCheck the discharge air velocity with a calibrated vane anemometer. Check that no overly dense hedge, boundary wall or eaves return causes a thermal short-circuit by sending the discharged chilled air straight back to the evaporator intake.
  3. Checking the water volume actually availableCalculate the effective water volume available during the reversal of the four-way valve. If the thermostatic valves close off the distribution without a decoupling buffer tank of at least twenty litres per kilowatt, the cycle draws on too small a reserve and aborts prematurely.
  4. Formal notice of hydraulic anomalyArt. 365 CO provides that the contractor informs the client when a circumstance jeopardises the proper execution of the work. Send the measurement report showing the incompatibility of the existing system, the circulator or the pipe diameters with the minimum flow rates of the heat pump.

If the original installation has a manifest undersizing of the system or no decoupling in accordance with the manufacturers' requirements, simply recalibrating the heating curve is not enough. The heating engineer records these hydraulic deviations and is relieved of responsibility for the coefficient of performance as long as the nominal draw-off flow has not been restored.

Frequently asked questions

What is the normal frequency of a defrost cycle in cold weather?

In typical Swiss winter conditions, with an outdoor temperature between minus two and five degrees and high relative humidity, a defrost cycle generally occurs every sixty to ninety minutes. If the machine triggers its valve reversal every twenty to thirty minutes, operation is abnormal. The evaporator no longer has time to supply heat output to the building between two reversal phases.

How does a lack of primary water flow cause rapid icing of the evaporator?

When a filter is clogged with sludge or a circulator runs at insufficient speed, the plate heat exchanger does not receive the required volume flow. To deliver the output demanded by the controller despite this reduced flow, the compressor has to run at a lower evaporating pressure. The surface temperature of the coil then falls well below zero, which accelerates condensation and premature icing of the outdoor fins.

Why does an obstruction to the discharge of the outdoor unit degrade the heating cycle?

If a wall, a sunken area or planting blocks the discharge flow, part of the air expelled at sub-zero temperature is drawn in again by the evaporator. This airflow short-circuit plunges the coil into an artificial environment that is colder and more saturated than the ambient air. The exchanger then quickly becomes covered with compact frost, forcing the controller to multiply the cycle reversals while the seasonal energy efficiency collapses.

How can you confirm that a defrost problem comes from the installation and not from the refrigerant?

The diagnosis is made by simultaneously recording the water flow on the flow meter, the primary flow-return temperature difference and the superheat of the refrigerant circuit. If the subcooling and superheat remain stable while the water-side temperature difference exceeds seven kelvins with a temperature drop during the reversal, the refrigerant circuit is not at fault. The fault comes from a lack of water supply or an insufficient decoupling volume in the boiler room.

Texts and standards cited

  • CO art. 365material and ground: contractor's liability and duty to inform the client if a circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work (para. 3)

In the same section