Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 241Heat pump: source, installation and noiseChapter 10 of 10 in the section

A complaint arrives: measuring at the receiving point, corrective measures and what is negotiable

As soon as a noise complaint arises after a heat pump has been commissioned, opinion-based debate must give way to metrological findings. You will be able to determine the exact measuring point at the complainant's premises according to the requirements of standard SIA 181, quantify the real impact against the night-time background noise and implement the three physical interventions capable of remedying the installation.

Key takeaways

  • Acoustic measurement is carried out at the complainant's premises, with the window open, at the centre of the exposed sensitive room.
  • The night-time assessment compares the sound level with the machine running against the residual background noise with it switched off.
  • Night-time throttling of the compressor and fan speed directly reduces the sound emission at source.
  • The absorbing acoustic screen and the redirection of the discharge eliminate direct propagation towards neighbouring openings.

Measure at the receiving point to put the complaint on an objective footing

A noise nuisance complaint is never handled by verbal negotiation about perceived intensity. The heating installer must immediately move the debate onto the metrological level by applying standard SIA 181. This technical reference sets the limit values applicable to building-services noise in rooms for sensitive use. The aim is to establish whether the immission sound level complies with the contractual or legal tolerances, setting aside from the outset the neighbours' subjective impressions.

Receiving point
Standardised measuring location inside the complainant's sensitive room, at the centre of the bedroom at one metre fifty above the floor, with the window open facing the outdoor unit.
  1. Choose the night-time periodMeasurement must be carried out between 22:00 and 6:00 in the morning. This window corresponds to the strictest requirements of standard SIA 181 and to the drop in road traffic, a situation in which the sound emergence of the evaporator becomes critical.
  2. Measure the immission in forced operationThe Class 1 integrating sound level meter records the equivalent continuous level with the heat pump forced to its maximum night-time output. This step ensures the compressor and fan are assessed at their most unfavourable operating point.
  3. Quantify the residual background noiseThe installer switches the machine off completely to capture the residual ambient noise in calm weather. If the difference between the overall noise and the background noise is less than ten decibels, a mathematical correction removes the system's own contribution.

Beyond the overall level in A-weighted decibels, the operator checks for distinct tonal components by one-third-octave band spectral analysis. A marked tone, often produced by the pulsations of the scroll compressor or by the fan blades passing in front of the frame uprights, generates a flat-rate acoustic penalty under standard SIA 181. This tonality penalty lowers the effective tolerance threshold and on its own justifies the installer's intervention, even when the overall sound volume appears moderate.

The approach distinguishes the external immission requirements set by the Noise Abatement Ordinance from the indoor thresholds of standard SIA 181. If the residual sound level without the heat pump already reaches the normative threshold, the installation is not at fault. If an actual exceedance is recorded with the sound level meter, the client has the rights conferred by art. 368 CO in the case of defects in the work. The installer starts the remediation work without delay.

Implement the three physical corrective measures that work

As soon as an exceedance of the limit value or a tonal emergence is established at the receiving point, the tradesperson deploys three proven solutions on the outdoor unit. These actions target the mechanical source, the acoustic obstacle and the air path, without degrading the overall efficiency of the heating installation.

Sound attenuation measures on the outdoor unit of a heat pump
Corrective measurePhysical principle appliedExpected acoustic gain
Night-time control throttlingForced reduction of the compressor and fan rotation speed2 to 4 dB(A)
Absorbing acoustic screenBreaking the direct line of sight with a heavy panel whose inner face is absorbing4 to 8 dB(A)
Airflow redirectionDeflecting the air discharge with a deflector or by rotating the outdoor frame3 to 6 dB(A)

The first corrective measure is software throttling. In the installer menu of the controller, the technician activates the night-time silent mode. The electronic board caps the frequency of the inverter compressor and reduces the rotation setpoint of the axial fan. The resulting instantaneous loss of heating output is absorbed by bringing forward domestic hot water production to before 22:00 and by using the thermal inertia of the underfloor heating during the day.

The acoustic screen and the redirection of the outdoor unit deal with direct airborne propagation. The screen must have a minimum surface mass of twenty kilograms per square metre and an absorbing inner face in mineral wool protected by a weather-resistant fabric to avoid reflection back towards the machine. The obstacle must completely break the line of sight between the fan and the neighbouring windows. If the space on the plot allows, turning the unit by ninety degrees or installing an air-deflecting elbow directs the flow towards a non-sensitive area, which immediately attenuates the direct field.

Adversarial protocol: night-time measurement and background noise according to standard SIA 181

As soon as a complaint reaches the installer, verbal debate must give way to metrological findings. Acoustic disputes involving air-to-water heat pumps almost always crystallise around sleeping hours. Standard SIA 181 governs noise protection in buildings and sets planning, immission and requirement limit values according to the sensitivity of the affected zone. Trying to placate a neighbour without instrumental measurement exposes the company to endless disputes or ineffective interventions paid for at a loss.

To put the situation on an objective footing, measurement must be carried out at night, generally between 22:00 and 06:00, a period during which the requirements of standard SIA 181 are strictest and road traffic is at a minimum. The method requires rigorous determination of the background noise (or residual noise). This residual noise corresponds to the natural sound environment of the site, measured when the compressor and fan of the outdoor unit are completely switched off.

  1. Reading the total noise under forced loadManually switch the machine on at its nominal night-time output (full-load mode or reduced mode depending on the disputed setting) and measure the equivalent continuous sound level Leq over a representative period of at least ten minutes.
  2. Clean shutdown of the installationTake the thermal installation out of service via its local isolator to record the residual environmental noise over the same period, at the same coordinates.
  3. Logarithmic correction of the immission levelIf the total level exceeds the residual noise by more than 10 dB(A), the background noise is negligible: the measured value is attributable to the machine. If the difference is between 3 dB(A) and 10 dB(A), a logarithmic correction is subtracted from the raw measurement to isolate the exact share emitted by the heat pump. If the difference is less than 3 dB(A), the installation's noise cannot be quantified scientifically because it is masked by the site.

Proven corrective measures on the outdoor unit and negotiation framework

If the exceedance of the standard is established, or if the immission is close to the tolerance limit with a marked low-frequency tone, three families of physical corrective measures allow the installation to be remedied without replacing the heat generator. The choice depends on the available space and the propagation paths.

Comparison of acoustic corrective measures for outdoor units
Technical solutionTypical acoustic gainAirflow and thermal constraintsPreferred application
Absorbing acoustic screen5 to 10 dB(A)Maintain a minimum clearance of at least 1.0 m to 1.5 m in front of the evaporator to avoid thermal short-circuiting and loss of airflow.Direct propagation towards a nearby terrace or party-wall window.
Physical redirection of the airflow3 to 6 dB(A)Requires reworking the refrigerant or hydraulic connections; beware of secondary reflections off a bare concrete wall.Discharge initially directed perpendicular to the complainant's façade.
Electronic time-based throttling (silent mode)2 to 4 dB(A)Heating output drops by 15 to 25% at night; check that the bivalence point and the backup heating cover the building's heat losses.Moderate night-time exceedance with a slightly oversized installation.

The acoustic screen must have sufficient surface mass (at least 15 to 20 kg/m²) and an absorbing inner face oriented towards the machine to avoid increasing the sound level through reverberation off the client's façade. To break the direct wave, the line of sight between the fan and the receiving window must be cut entirely, including above the top edge of the barrier. Redirecting the unit makes it possible to turn the discharge cone (the most emissive direction) towards a non-sensitive area, such as an open public road or an embankment of loose earth.

Contractually, if the initial location was imposed by the client despite the heating installer's written reservations, the adaptation costs are borne by the client. In the absence of a prior technical warning from the installer, the provisions of the Code of Obligations on defects in the work require the contractor to bear the cost of bringing the delivered installation into compliance with the requirements of the state of the art.

Failure of conciliation: official expert opinion, cost sharing and technical limits

When the usual physical corrective measures — a silencer on the fan, redirection of the airflow and an absorbing acoustic screen — do not defuse the neighbourhood dispute, informal dialogue must give way to a rigorous technical assessment procedure. The heating installer must refuse successive empirical modifications that degrade the appliance's coefficient of performance without providing any acoustic guarantee. From this stage on, the only fair course of action is to have the situation recorded by an independent acoustician applying standard SIA 181.

  1. Recording the condition and verifying the parametersThe acoustic expert checks the integrity of the installation, inspects the anti-vibration mounts and locks the controller on the maximum night-time mode. Measurements can only be carried out in the absence of major weather disturbances, with wind below five metres per second and outside any period of precipitation.
  2. Measurement at the standard receiving pointThe Class 1 integrating sound level meter is set up at the complainant's premises, at the geometric centre of an open window facing a noise-sensitive room, in accordance with standard SIA 181. Sound acquisition records the continuous assessment level over a representative operating cycle of the compressor and fan.
  3. Deduction of the night-time residual noiseThe heating installation is forced to stop in order to determine the residual background noise of the area. If the difference between the total noise and the residual noise remains below ten decibels, a standardised correction is calculated to extract the sound share attributable solely to the heat pump.

When the neutral expert opinion confirms strict compliance with the limit values, the installer has fulfilled his technical obligations. The costs of the acoustic firm's intervention are then borne in accordance with the prior agreement, usually by the complaining party whose grievance proves unfounded. Any demand for additional work made by the neighbours is from then on a matter of purely private convenience. If the client nevertheless wishes to carry out landscaping or a specific silent enclosure, these services must be priced separately in a proper contractual addendum.

Frequently asked questions

Where exactly should the sound level meter be placed in a neighbourhood noise complaint?

The official measurement is not taken at the foot of the heat pump, but at the most exposed immission point at the complainant's premises, in accordance with standard SIA 181. The microphone must be placed at the geometric centre of the plane of an open window of a sensitive room, such as a bedroom or living room. A measurement taken on the property boundary without a window of a living space is not an admissible legal basis for alleging a technical defect.

Why must the noise measurement be carried out at night?

The planning values set in the Noise Abatement Ordinance are considerably stricter during the night-time period, between 22:00 and 06:00. It is also during this time slot that the surrounding background noise falls, making the compressor more distinctly audible. Night-time measurement makes it possible to determine precisely the real emergence of the heat pump relative to the residual quiet of the neighbourhood and to validate the night mode.

Does an acoustic screen placed against the heat pump reduce heating efficiency?

Yes, if the minimum distances prescribed by the manufacturer are not respected. An acoustic screen placed too close to the evaporator causes air short-circuiting: the cold discharged air is drawn back in, which causes premature icing of the coil and a drop in seasonal efficiency. To maintain optimum thermal efficiency while attenuating the sound, the sound barrier must keep a sufficient clearance and include an absorbing inner face.

What does redirecting the outdoor unit involve as a noise-reduction measure?

The acoustic directivity of an outdoor unit is asymmetrical: the fan projects most of the sound energy straight ahead. Turning the appliance by ninety degrees makes it possible to direct the airflow and sound waves towards a non-sensitive area, such as a blank façade, rather than towards the neighbour's windows. This technical intervention reduces the perceived sound immission by several decibels without altering the nominal heating output of the installation.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 181Noise protection in buildings
  • CO art. 368Client's rights in the case of defects in the work

In the same section