Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 241Heat pump: source, installation and noiseChapter 9 of 10 in the section

Advertised COP, real-world efficiency: what the catalogue doesn't tell you

Data sheets show coefficients of performance measured in the laboratory at mild temperatures. This chapter teaches you how to recalculate efficiency over the season according to the requirements of SIA 384/2, how to factor in the severe impact of defrost cycles in mid-winter, and how to word a contractual performance commitment that cannot be challenged.

Key takeaways

  • The catalogue COP reflects a static measurement far removed from winter climate reality.
  • The seasonal coefficient of performance takes into account all operating temperature regimes and auxiliary consumption.
  • SIA 384/2 requires a heat load calculation based on the outdoor design temperature.
  • A technical offer must state strict operating assumptions in order to exclude any guarantee of absolute consumption.

From laboratory test measurement to the climate reality of February

The catalogue values promoted by manufacturers come from tests carried out under standardised measurement conditions. For an air-to-water heat pump, the standardised test point A7/W35 sets an outdoor air temperature of 7 °C for a heating water flow temperature of 35 °C. These ideal parameters show the heat exchangers and the compressor at their best, commonly yielding an efficiency coefficient above 4.5. However, this thermal situation corresponds to mild shoulder seasons during which the heat losses of the building envelope remain minimal. As soon as the outdoor temperature drops to the design conditions of February, the thermodynamics of the machine change radically.

COP (Coefficient of Performance)
Instantaneous ratio between the useful thermal output delivered to the hydraulic distribution system and the total electrical power absorbed by the machine, measured under steady-state conditions for a strictly defined pair of source and flow temperatures.

When the outdoor air falls to -8 °C on the Swiss Plateau or at altitude, the temperature difference between the evaporator and the condenser increases sharply. The compression ratio rises, which reduces the mass flow of refrigerant and increases the mechanical work of the compressor. Moreover, in the outdoor temperature range between -2 °C and 4 °C with high humidity, the evaporator ices up rapidly. The cycle reversal required for defrosting draws heat directly from the technical water volume of the installation, severely penalising the net energy balance of the generator.

Performance degradation of an air-to-water heat pump according to actual operating points
Operating pointSource / flow temperature regimeDirect impact on the cycleOrder of magnitude of instantaneous COP
Test standard A7/W35Air 7 °C / Water 35 °CNo frost, low compression ratio4.6 to 5.1
Damp shoulder season A2/W35Air 2 °C / Water 35 °CSevere coil icing, reversal cycles3.2 to 3.6
Winter peak A-8/W35Air -8 °C / Water 35 °CDrop in the specific volume drawn into the compressor2.3 to 2.7
Radiator renovation A-8/W55Air -8 °C / Water 55 °CMaximum discharge pressure, increased heat losses1.6 to 1.9

Seasonal efficiency therefore cannot be derived from a linear reading of commercial documentation. To reflect the real behaviour of the building, the sizing of the required output must be based on SIA 384/2. This standard sets the method for calculating the nominal heat load as a function of the reference weather station and the local altitude. It prohibits oversizing the heat pump solely on the basis of the bivalence point without analysing the distribution of heating degree-days.

Defining the seasonal performance factor and locking down the installation offer

To give the client technically defensible figures, the installer must replace the generic term COP with seasonal performance factor (SPF) or seasonal coefficient of performance (SCOP). This quantity is the total thermal energy produced over the full year divided by the total electrical energy fed into the system. The calculation boundary must include the primary and secondary circulators, the controllers, any backup heating elements and the energy lost during successive defrosts.

When submitting the tender, the installer puts their technical credibility on the line. Writing a promise on the electricity bill or guaranteeing a quantified efficiency without reservations exposes the company to the rules on contractual non-performance under art. 97 CO. If consumption proves markedly higher because of a particularly harsh winter or indoor room temperatures pushed to 23 °C instead of the conventional 20 °C, the customer may claim that the services announced do not conform.

  1. Calculate the load according to SIA 384/2Establish the real heat losses without excessive empirical margins, using the reference outdoor temperature of the exact construction location.
  2. Define the contractual heating curveState in black and white in the offer the maximum flow temperature required at base load (for example 35 °C for underfloor heating or 50 °C on radiators).
  3. Set the indoor temperature assumptionsState explicitly that the energy projections are based on a standardised indoor setpoint of 20 °C, without abnormal ventilation losses from open windows.
  4. Write the performance commitment in the offerWord the indicators as a technical estimate derived from the standards in force, expressly excluding any guarantee of result on the monetary amount of electricity billed.

Predictive calculation according to SIA 384/2 and operating temperature regimes

To move beyond the illusion of manufacturers' data sheets, the installer must base the sizing on SIA 384/2. This reference sets the methods for calculating the nominal heat load of buildings, taking into account local weather data for French-speaking Switzerland, the outdoor design temperature and the inherent thermal inertia of the envelope. A machine showing an exceptional efficiency coefficient in test-bench trials loses all its advantage if the control curve requires an excessive water flow temperature to compensate for poorly sized heat emitters.

Standardised laboratory measurement conditions evaluate the heat pump at stable fixed points, without taking into account the real defrost cycles by cycle reversal, the progressive fouling of the evaporator or the consumption of the hydraulic auxiliaries. As soon as the temperature drops to the design temperature set by SIA 384/2, the gap between the source and the distribution system widens. The mechanical compression work increases considerably, causing the instantaneous coefficient to fall to values close to 2.0 on outdoor air, where the commercial documentation highlighted a figure above 4.0.

Comparison of standardised test-bench conditions and real winter operating regimes
Operating parameterStandardised test conditionsReal operation in January and February
Source temperature (outdoor air)+7 °C dry bulb / +6 °C wet bulb-8 °C to -2 °C depending on altitude on the Romandy Plateau
Heating flow / return regime35 °C / 30 °C (low-temperature floor)45 °C to 55 °C (existing radiators retained)
Frost management on the coilStabilised cycle without ice formationRepeated defrosts by refrigeration cycle reversal
Auxiliary consumptionOutside the standard measurement boundaryCirculation pumps and crankcase heaters included

Fine adjustment of the heating curve is the installer's first lever. Lowering the flow temperature by just 1 K improves seasonal efficiency by about 2 to 3 %. At commissioning, the weather-compensated controller must be set precisely to the minimum slope that ensures the indoor setpoint temperature, without needless overheating of the buffer volume.

Drafting the technical offer and securing performance commitments

When submitting the offer, the performance commitment in the offer must absolutely distinguish the purely intrinsic performance of the generator from the overall performance factor of the complete system. The installer is responsible for the correct operation of the installation in accordance with the quote and the recognised rules of Swiss building practice. Carelessly announcing a high annual efficiency without stating the operating assumptions exposes the company to serious disputes at the first utility bill.

The contract for work and services is governed by the Code of Obligations (CO). In accordance with art. 365 CO, the contractor is liable for the good quality of the material they supply. If the existing networks, the quality of the filling water or the insulation conditions of the building jeopardise the achievement of the planned performance, the installer must document these technical reservations in writing from the tender phase in order to preserve their rights.

  • State explicitly the seasonal coefficient of performance estimated by the standardised method, specifying that it is a theoretical calculation value and not a contractual guarantee of consumption in kilowatt-hours.
  • Define precisely the maximum permissible flow water temperature for the selected nominal output, linked to the condition of the existing heat-exchange surfaces.
  • Specify the bivalence point and the threshold for switching to the electric backup, excluding any permanent emergency operation without an explicit instruction.
  • Make the promised performance conditional on the prior hydraulic balancing of the risers and distribution loops.
  • State the obligation to treat the filling water in line with the technical recommendations against scaling and magnetic sludge in plate heat exchangers.

By locking down the tender in this way, the site manager and the foreman have a clear contractual framework. The client understands that real performance results from the consistency of the entire hydraulic installation and its controls, and not from an isolated value taken from an advertising brochure.

Managing consumption discrepancies and resolving complaints

When temperatures fall below zero in the depths of winter, complaints about excess electricity consumption regularly reach the technical office. The client compares their bill directly with the nominal COP of 4 or 5 touted in the machine's sales brochure. Yet this test figure reflects standardised workshop measurement conditions and not the thermal reality of a building subjected to the rigours of February. Faced with a dissatisfied customer who notes an increase in operating costs, the installer must set aside any empirical discussion and start a methodical metrological verification protocol. This approach makes it possible to distinguish concretely between real installation faults and mere differences in use.

  1. Read the thermal and electrical energy metersCheck the consumption of the compressor and of the electric heating element on the dedicated meters. Compare these values with the thermal energy output recorded by the ultrasonic calorimeter installed on the heating water loop.
  2. Analyse the temperature regimes and the heating curveCheck the slope of the heating curve in the controller. A water temperature that is too high, set to compensate for insufficient flow in the emitters or poor hydraulic distribution, directly lowers the seasonal efficiency originally calculated.
  3. Track down unwanted activation of the electric backupInspect the operating cycle history and the bivalence point. Early use of the electric heating element during evaporator defrosts or in severe cold drastically lowers the performance factor compared with the engineering forecasts.

If a formal complaint arises for failure to achieve the energy performance, the legal framework of the contract for work and services applies. Under CO, the client may assert rights where the work suffers from defects. However, the installer is bound to a quantified result only if the performance commitment in the offer specified a contractual value verifiable over the whole heating season. A deviation from the COP of a data sheet does not constitute a legal defect if the technical tender file correctly set out the calculation bases of SIA 384/2. The joint diagnosis makes it possible to prove whether the anomaly stems from poor adjustment of the heating installation or from a use of the building deviating from the design parameters. The tradesperson then carries out the necessary hydraulic adjustments to restore the planned water regimes.

Frequently asked questions

Why does the heat pump consume more in February than the value given in the catalogue?

The catalogue shows an efficiency coefficient measured at outdoor air temperatures that are often mild, generally seven degrees. In February, with outdoor air at minus five degrees and a heating network requiring hotter water, the compressor works against an increased pressure difference. In addition, the automatic defrost cycles of the evaporator draw heat from the water network, which inevitably increases overall electricity consumption.

How do you justify the difference between COP and seasonal efficiency to a demanding customer?

Explain that the COP is an instantaneous snapshot taken in the laboratory under fixed standardised measurement conditions. By contrast, seasonal efficiency, or seasonal performance factor, measures the total energy delivered divided by the electricity actually consumed over a whole year. This result depends on the severity of the winter climate, the water setpoint required by the emitters, the defrosts and the distribution losses within the building.

Which calculation reference should be used in a quote to avoid any unrealistic commitment?

The offer should be based on SIA 384/2, which governs the calculation of the design heat requirements of buildings. State clearly the planned water flow and return regimes for the emitters, for example thirty-five and twenty-eight degrees. Specify in the quote that the stated value is a thermal forecast subject to real climatic variations and not a firm contractual financial operating guarantee.

What should you do if the electric backup heater switches on too often in winter?

First check the bivalence point set in the heating controller. If the electric heating element cuts in above the planned temperature, check the water flow through the condenser and that there is no air in the pipes. A clogged filter or an undersized circulator limits heat transfer to the heating network, which forces the heat pump to call on the backup element.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 384/2Heat requirements for building heating
  • COClient's rights in the event of defects in the work

In the same section