Key takeaways
- The hot work permit jointly binds the site's principal and the heating fitter's team leader.
- A suitable extinguisher must be within immediate reach without obstructing the escape route.
- The brazing perimeter requires a heat shield and the removal of surrounding combustible materials.
- Post-brazing monitoring requires regular rounds for at least two hours after the work.
Issuing the permit and securing the brazing workstation
On a renovation site as on a new-build, lighting an oxyacetylene torch or an air-propane set to braze a hydraulic connection must never be improvised. The hot work permit is a formal, temporary authorisation, required whenever a hot spot is generated outside a fixed workshop. This document is not a mere administrative formality: it sets out responsibilities and describes the physical protections to be put in place before the first flame is lit.
Issuing the permit necessarily involves two parties: the person responsible for the site (client, site management or building operator) and the heating contractor carrying out the work. Under art. 82 LAA, the employer must take all measures necessary to prevent occupational accidents and illnesses that experience has shown to be necessary, that are feasible according to the state of the art and that are appropriate to the given conditions. The heating fitter does not sign alone in a corner; he validates the checklist on site with the site's safety representative before the operation begins.
- Systematic removal of flammable substances within a radius of five metres around the heating point.
- Installation of rigid flame screens or certified non-combustible thermal blankets in front of combustible walls, cable trays and insulating linings.
- Sealing of duct openings, floor slots and floor openings to stop drops of molten braze falling to the levels below.
- Checking of the extinguisher assigned to the workstation, positioned between two and five metres from the brazing area and directly accessible.
Extinguishing equipment is not chosen at random. In a boiler room, the standard provision comprises a water-spray extinguisher with additive or a multi-purpose powder extinguisher of at least six kilograms, supplemented by a bucket of water and a wet cloth for directly cooling pipe clamps and pipework supports. Access to a main water shut-off valve or a working basement tap must be identified in advance.
Monitoring after the flame: neutralising the smouldering fire
The classic mistake on thermal installation sites is to pack up the equipment, sign the work slip and leave as soon as the last braze feels cool to the touch. Yet insurers' damage statistics and SUVA reports show that a major proportion of fires resulting from hot work break out between one and three hours after the torch is extinguished. Thermal energy conducted along a copper tube easily passes through a masonry wall and can ignite wood dust, synthetic insulation or a bed of cables in the adjoining room.
- Smouldering fire
- Slow combustion without a visible flame, sustained by residual heat in a confined flammable material, which can develop into an open fire after an influx of air or the critical rise in temperature of the pyrolysis gases.
- Active cooling and first inspectionAs soon as brazing is finished, moderately spray or dab with a damp sponge the heated areas, flanges, fixing clamps and pass-through sleeves. Visually inspect the back of partitions for signs of scorching or suspicious smells.
- Instrumented thermal checkSweep the work area, fixings and penetrations with an infrared thermometer or a site thermal camera. No area must show an abnormally high residual hot spot compared with the ambient temperature.
- Continuous static watch periodKeep one person on site during the first 30 to 60 minutes after the flame is finally extinguished. This person keeps the extinguisher ready beside them and carries out no task that would distract their vigilance.
- Intermittent rounds until the permit is liftedCarry out regular check rounds every 20 to 30 minutes until the end time set by the hot work permit. The minimum monitoring period required is generally two hours, extendable depending on the vulnerability of the premises.
The hot work permit is formally closed only at the end of this watch. Art. 3 OPA provides that the employer must take the protective provisions and measures that meet the requirements of the ordinance, the other applicable occupational safety provisions and the recognised rules of safety engineering and occupational medicine. The team leader and the person responsible for the works countersign the permit on site after the last visual and thermal inspection. This initialled document is filed in the site's execution file, protecting the company against claims in the event of a delayed fire.
Thermal measurement protocol and staggered post-brazing rounds
Extinguishing the oxyacetylene torch does not mark the end of the intervention on the heat distribution network. The heat accumulated in the copper or steel walls of a heating manifold spreads by conduction well beyond the visible joint area. A smouldering fire often starts without any visible flame in contact with old thermal insulation, compacted site dust or a timber cross-member hidden in a slab opening. The critical phase develops quietly, sometimes more than two hours after the workers have left, when the residual heat reaches the auto-ignition temperature of the confined materials.
To neutralise this invisible risk, a simple visual inspection is not enough. The heating fitter or team leader assigned to the watch post uses a non-contact infrared thermometer or a portable thermal camera. Art. 82 LAA reminds us in this respect that the employer must take all necessary measures shown by experience and suited to operating conditions. The operator systematically aims at the braze point, the fixing clamps with elastomer lining, the wall penetrations and the framing elements located within a radius of at least five metres around the workstation.
| Time | Area checked | Detection method | Compliance criterion |
|---|---|---|---|
| T + 0 min | Brazed tube, brazed fitting, sound-insulating clamps | Thermal camera or pyrometer | Active cooling carried out, no glowing or smoke |
| T + 30 min | Wall penetrations, sleeves, neighbouring insulation | Infrared thermometer and smell check | Surface temperature below 60 °C, no acrid smell |
| T + 60 min | Rear faces of walls, adjacent rooms and basement | Manual touch and optical thermometry | Return to the ambient temperature of the boiler room |
| T + 120 min | Entire area covered by the hot work permit | Overall thermal survey and check of the surroundings | No remaining hot spot, complete thermal stabilisation |
The data recorded must be entered on the annex sheet of the hot work permit. Where there is adjacent thermal insulation in mineral wool with a bituminous vapour barrier or a polyurethane shell, the thermal check extends to the pipework sections upstream and downstream of the heated area. If the temperature measured exceeds 80 °C after thirty minutes, forced ventilation of the room or targeted wetting of the non-combustible walls must be maintained until fully back to normal.
Response equipment, keeping escape routes clear and formal closure
Throughout the assembly operation and during the watch phase, the back-up extinguishing equipment must never leave the immediate perimeter of the workstation. Art. 5 OTConst provides that the employer must appoint on the construction site a competent person responsible for occupational safety and able to give instructions to workers. The person on watch must have within reach at least one six-litre water-spray extinguisher with additive or a foam appliance suited to class A and B fires. The multi-purpose powder extinguisher is often avoided in a completed boiler room to prevent corrosive damage to the electronic components of the heating controls, but it remains acceptable during structural work.
Compressed gas cylinders, acetylene and oxygen, are the most acute danger in the event of an uncontrolled fire. As soon as work stops, the cylinder valves are closed, the regulators depressurised by purging the torches, and the hoses coiled without obstructing the floor. The escape route leading to the exit of the technical room or the outside of the building must have a clear width, free of any obstacle, of at least 90 centimetres. It is forbidden to block the fire doors of the boiler room with wooden wedges or offcuts of tube to run temporary ventilation ducts through: these openings must remain functional to contain any potential fire.
The guidelines of SUVA and of the Association of Cantonal Fire Insurance Establishments stress the importance of this transfer of responsibility. When work ends at the end of the working day, the team leader adapts the schedule so as to ensure the full two hours of watch before the construction site is finally closed. If the configuration of the building requires it, for example when connecting a secondary network in vertical shafts passing through several occupied floors, rounds are organised in the flats on the upper levels with the prior agreement of the site management.
Smouldering fire outbreak and emergency response: the operational switch
When post-brazing monitoring detects an abnormal rise in temperature or a suspicious wisp of smoke two hours after the torch is turned off, the response tolerates no hesitation. In accordance with art. 82 LAA, the employer must take, to prevent accidents, all measures that experience has shown to be necessary and that the state of the art makes it possible to apply. Faced with slow combustion started in a slab penetration or behind a thermal lining, the operator applies the fundamental principle: secure people before attempting to put out the outbreak.
- Evacuate the work area using the emergency exit kept clear throughout the work.
- Trigger the building alarm or alert the fire service on 118, stating the exact address and the presence of gas cylinders.
- Attack the incipient fire with the appropriate extinguisher only if the fire remains superficial and there is no risk of being cut off.
- Close the fire doors of the boiler room to contain the toxic fumes produced by the charred insulation.
From a legal standpoint, a fire caused by premature abandonment of the watch directly implicates the person carrying out the work and their supervisors. Art. 229 CP punishes anyone who, while directing or carrying out a construction, breaches the rules of the art and knowingly endangers the life or physical integrity of persons. The monitoring sheet of the hot work permit, countersigned with the usual temperature readings, is the only material evidence that the installer complied with the guidelines of the coordination commission and of Suva for hot work.
Frequently asked questions
What should be done if the brazing area is still warm two hours after the work?
A persistent hot spot signals a risk of smouldering fire in the insulation or an adjacent component. It is forbidden to sign off the end of the hot work permit. The installer extends active monitoring with rounds every thirty minutes. If the temperature does not fall back towards ambient, he probes the nearby materials and dampens the area with a sprayer before alerting the site's safety officer.
Who is responsible for monitoring if the heating team leaves the construction site?
Monitoring cannot be abandoned. If the heating fitters have to leave at the end of contractual hours, the watch duty must be formally handed over in writing to the person responsible for the hot work permit or to a designated security company. Without a signed handover on the official document, the installer remains fully responsible for any fire starting at his workstation.
What type of extinguisher should be placed next to the brazing workstation on a distribution pipe?
On a thermal installation construction site, the minimum equipment comprises a water-spray extinguisher with additive or a multi-purpose ABC powder extinguisher of at least six kilograms, inspected and sealed. The appliance is placed on the floor less than five metres from the flame point, on the escape route side, never locked in a van or hidden behind pallets of tools or coils of tube.
Is a hot work permit required to braze a small-diameter copper tube during renovation?
Any work involving an open flame requires a written hot work permit, regardless of the tube diameter or the duration of the task. In renovation, the age of the partitions, combustible dust and the presence of old thermal insulation increase the danger. The client or their safety delegate must sign the authorisation before the torch is lit, then validate the final round after extinction.
Texts and standards cited
- LAA art. art. 82 LAAgeneral prevention rules: to prevent occupational accidents and illnesses, the employer must take all measures that experience has shown to be necessary, that are feasible according to the state of the art and that are appropriate to the given conditions; workers assist him (in particular by using personal protective equipment).
- CP art. art. 229 CPbreach of the rules of the art of construction: anyone who, while directing or carrying out a construction or demolition, intentionally breaches the rules of the art and knowingly endangers the life or physical integrity of persons is liable to a custodial sentence of up to five years or a monetary penalty; if through negligence, up to three years or a monetary penalty.
