Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 241Heat pump: source, installation and noiseChapter 5 of 10 in the section

Drilling a borehole heat exchanger: suitability map, authorisation and protected groundwater

This guide explains how to consult the cantonal suitability map for borehole heat exchangers, identify the prohibition zones linked to groundwater protection and factor the real administrative processing time into your commercial and technical planning before any contract is signed.

Key takeaways

  • Consulting the cantonal geological register beforehand avoids selling a ground-source installation that cannot be carried out.
  • Water protection zones S1, S2 and Sh categorically prohibit any vertical geothermal drilling.
  • The SIA 384/2 standard frames the sizing of the borehole field and the spacing requirements.
  • The cantonal processing time of two to six months means the execution schedule must absolutely be planned ahead.

Consulting the cantonal map and identifying prohibited protection zones

Selling a brine-to-water heat pump without having checked the legal feasibility of the subsoil is a major planning error for the heating installer. Even before preparing a firm offer or ordering the heat unit, the plot outline must be checked against the cantonal geothermal register available on the public geoportal (for example the Vaud, Geneva or Fribourg mapping portals). This initial step determines whether the subsoil allows borehole heat exchanger use without restriction, under particular geological conditions (presence of artesian conditions, anhydrite or swelling gypsum layers), or whether it is subject to a strict refusal by the cantonal environment department.

The main legal and technical obstacle concerns the protection of groundwater intended for public or private supply. Under federal water protection legislation, the territory is divided into vulnerable sectors. Within this perimeter, access to the subsoil is strictly locked in order to prevent any contamination of the aquifers by heat-transfer fluids or by connecting separate hydrogeological layers during drilling.

Admissibility of vertical geothermal boreholes according to hydrogeological designation
Subsoil designationDrilling statusTechnical measures and administrative constraints
Catchment zone S1Formal prohibitionImmediate perimeter of drinking-water catchment wells. No drilling permitted.
Protection zone S2Strict prohibitionZone slowing underground flows. Geothermal drilling excluded.
Transition zone S3General refusal or rare exemptionsVery restricted exceptional authorisation, subject to an in-depth hydrogeological expert report.
Protection sector Au (usable aquifer)Conditional and heavily restrictedDrilling generally prohibited through the aquifer or limited to the top of the aquifer.
Sector ÜB (unusable groundwater)Permitted under conditionsInjection of a bentonite-cement grout over the full height of the borehole is mandatory.

The SIA 384/2 standard sets the rules of good practice for vertical borehole heat exchangers, including thermal design, the minimum spacing between boreholes and the requirements for watertight backfilling of boreholes.

norme SIA 384/2

Submitting the authorisation application and building the processing time into the schedule

Under art. 22 LAT, no installation may be built or altered without the authorisation of the competent authority. In the case of a heat pump with a borehole heat exchanger, two administrative tracks intersect: the municipal or cantonal building permit linked to the change of heat generator, and the drilling permit issued by the cantonal water and geology department. Where the ground presents difficulties, art. 365 CO para. 3 requires the installer to inform the client without delay of defects that jeopardise the execution of the work, failing which the installer must bear the consequences.

Preparing the file requires close collaboration between the CFC 241 heating installer and the specialist geothermal drilling company. The technical file submitted to the authority must specify the precise geographical coordinates (national coordinates MN95), the planned depth, the borehole diameter, the cooling capacity extracted from the rock, the characteristics of the heat-transfer fluid (non-toxic brine solution, without harmful additives) and the hydraulic connection diagram complying with the requirements of the SIA 384/2 standard.

  1. 1. Initial register checkCheck the plot on the cantonal geographic information system (GIS) to confirm the suitability zone and the absence of underground conflicts (gas pipes, sewers, high-voltage cables).
  2. 2. Sizing of the heat exchangerCalculate the thermal extraction capacity according to the SIA 384/2 standard to set the exact borehole length needed for the operating regime of the heat pump without risking depletion of the ground.
  3. 3. Submitting the drilling authorisation applicationComplete the official cantonal form, together with the dimensioned site plan at 1:500, the estimated geological profile and the technical sealing sections.
  4. 4. Cantonal processing and coordinationFollow the examination procedure involving the water authority, the municipality and the nature protection services. Order the drilling rig only after the permit has formally come into force.

Requirements of the cantonal opinion and of the SIA 384/2 standard

The decision issued by the cantonal environment department is not merely an agreement in principle. The authorisation to install a vertical borehole heat exchanger is systematically accompanied by technical specifications that are binding on the heating installer and the driller. This document sets the maximum permissible depth to avoid piercing an impermeable aquifer cap or a swelling anhydrite layer, prescribes the nature of the heat-transfer fluid and dictates the quality of the annular sealing. Any deviation from these requirements makes the work non-compliant and engages the company's liability.

Technical execution requirements according to the water protection sector
Protection sectorDrilling statusTechnical execution requirements
Protection zones S1 and S2Absolute prohibitionNo drilling tolerated; drinking-water supply takes priority.
Protection zone S3Refusal in principleDrilling excluded except for an exceptional exemption backed by an in-depth hydrogeological expert report.
Sector Au (usable aquifers)Permitted under conditionsDouble-U probe in PE100-RC, biodegradable heat-transfer fluid or pure water, automatic cut-off pressure switch and certified grout.
Sector Üb / Zone B (remaining)Permitted with ordinary opinionInjection of the bentonite-cement grout from bottom to top according to the SIA 384/2 standard, pressure check before backfilling.

The sizing of the underground heat exchanger derives directly from the SIA 384/2 standard. This standard establishes the permissible specific extraction capacities, expressed in watts per linear metre of borehole, according to the lithology encountered. Where a cantonal restriction caps the depth at 120 metres while the building's heat balance called for 180 metres of active probe, the installer must resize the geothermal field. The solution is to install two boreholes of 90 metres, spaced at least 6 metres apart to prevent any underground thermal bridge and avoid premature depletion of the geological resource.

Contractual safeguards and coordination of the construction site schedule

Selling a ground-source heat pump before obtaining formal feedback from the cantonal authorities is a major imprudence. The quote given to the client must include a resolutive or suspensive clause stating that the final order depends on the granting of the cantonal drilling permit without prohibitive financial constraints. The authorisation processing time commonly extends over several months. The installer must build this administrative inertia into the initial schedule to avoid tying up equipment or prematurely scheduling installation crews.

The constraints set out in the authorisation opinion often change the financial scope of the project. A cantonal obligation to split the borehole field into several shorter boreholes, the need to install a leak-monitoring device or the specific disposal of alkaline drilling muds increase the overall bill by several thousand francs. By providing contractually for these contingencies in the commercial offer, the installer reserves the right to adjust the execution price or to propose an air-source alternative in the event of refusal, without bearing the extra cost linked to subsoil uncertainties.

Once the authorisation has been issued, technical coordination on the ground determines the success of the work. The installer checks the access clearances for drilling rigs of 15 to 30 tonnes, the stabilised drilling platform and the mandatory settling skips for treating return water before any discharge. Buried horizontal collectors are laid below the frost line, at a minimum depth of 1 metre 20, protected by a bed of sand and fitted with a blue warning mesh before the pressure tightness tests.

Drilling refusal or subsoil incident: corrective measures and technical reorientation

When a borehole heat exchanger file meets a formal refusal from the cantonal authority or a geological hazard arises when the subsoil is first drilled, the installer must act methodically. The most frequent case remains the veto issued by the cantonal water protection department due to the presence of a protection zone S1, S2, a sector Sh or an artesian aquifer under pressure that is incompatible with vertical drilling. If the order for the brine-to-water heat pump was concluded without a condition precedent for authorisation, the company is stuck with an unusable heat unit and advance payments committed to the driller.

  1. Stopping operations and formalising the incidentOn receipt of the written refusal or in the event of unforeseen artesian water on the drill string, stop drilling. Draw up a record noting the cantonal decision.
  2. Examining the layout or the residual depthCheck with the geological consultancy whether a reduction in depth completed by a second borehole complies with the SIA 384/2 standard, or whether a shift outside the buffer zone allows a new application.
  3. Proposing a technical substitutionIf the subsoil is prohibited for borehole heat exchangers, present a replacement solution with an air-to-water heat pump, recalculating the heat balance and the outdoor noise level.
  4. Drawing up a contractual addendumDraw up a contractual addendum specifying the revised costs, the substitute heat machine, the readjusted execution schedule and the cancellation of the drilling items not carried out.

The remediation of an interrupted borehole requires a very rigorous protocol. If an exploratory casing was drilled before reaching an unstable or polluted horizon, the driller must inject a bentonite and cement grout under pressure over the full length to restore the geological seal between the layers. The heating installer ensures that the sealing record and the abandonment sheet are sent to the cantonal environment department, thus guaranteeing the formal closure of the permit file.

Frequently asked questions

What does the company risk if drilling work begins before receipt of the formal cantonal authorisation?

Drilling without an enforceable decision exposes the construction site to an immediate administrative stop by the building inspectorate or the environment department. The offender must then bear the costs of the idle machine, any restoration of the ground by pressure sealing and substantial administrative fees. The heating installer directly puts their credibility with the client at stake and risks a definitive refusal to connect the generator to the technical network.

Why does the cantonal map show a red zone when the direct neighbour has a borehole heat exchanger?

Geothermal suitability maps change with the revision of the protection perimeters of drinking-water catchments and the updating of subsoil registers. An older installation may have been authorised under earlier, less restrictive regulations or in a sector where the aquifer has since been reclassified as particularly threatened. The prior existence of a neighbouring installation confers no acquired right: only the hydrogeological status in force at the time of the application counts.

How long does the cantonal drilling authorisation remain valid once issued?

The validity of a drilling authorisation issued by the cantonal authority generally ranges between one and two years depending on the legislation of the canton concerned. This period allows the drilling machines' intervention to be coordinated with the overall progress of the heating construction site. If the setting-out work has not begun before the permit expires, the installer must submit a formal extension request to the competent cantonal department before expiry, failing which the full processing must be restarted.

What should be done if the cantonal geologist requires a heat-transfer fluid without chemical additives?

In sensitive hydrogeological transition zones, the authority may prohibit mixtures based on ethylene or propylene glycol and prescribe the exclusive use of pure water as the heat-transfer fluid. The heating installer must then recalculate the loop in accordance with the SIA 384/2 standard to ensure that the evaporation temperature never causes the underground circuit to freeze. This constraint often involves oversizing the borehole length and a specifically approved water-to-water machine.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 384/2Borehole heat exchangers

In the same section