Key takeaways
- Joint measurements per riser technically document the hydraulic balancing defect of the installation.
- Formal notification of the defect relies on the rules of the SIA 118 standard.
- The formal notice sets a reasonable time limit before recourse to performance by substitution.
- Dynamic balancing using pressure-independent valves is imposed at the expense of the defaulting installer.
Establishing the hydraulic defect through a campaign of joint measurements
In a residential building, a poorly balanced distribution network causes glaring thermal disparities: the apartments close to the boiler room overheat while those at the end of the line struggle to reach the set point. When the original installer claims that the boiler room operates normally without checking the circulation per riser, the dispute takes on a legal dimension. To break the deadlock, the site management or the client's representative must build an indisputable technical file.
The first step is to organise a joint measurement session in the presence of the parties. Without this confrontation on site, the data collected may be challenged before the courts for a flaw in method. The boiler room must run at a stable nominal rate, with circulators set to their operating set point and all thermostatic valves fully open for at least two hours before the intervention.
- Fitting calibrated contact thermometers on the flow and return of each riser in the basement.
- Measuring actual flow rates using a non-intrusive ultrasonic flowmeter fitted on a straight pipe with no upstream disturbance.
- Recording differential pressures on the existing manual regulating devices using an electronic differential pressure gauge.
- Recording the ambient temperature in reference rooms on the ground floor and on the top floor under the roof.
| Riser | Calculated design flow rate | Flow rate measured on site | Flow/return temperature difference | Technical finding |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Riser A (base of riser, boiler room) | 1250 l/h | 2450 l/h | ΔT = 6 K | Massive over-flow, abnormally hot return |
| Riser B (south façade) | 980 l/h | 1150 l/h | ΔT = 11 K | Slight over-supply of the network |
| Riser C (north façade) | 1100 l/h | 620 l/h | ΔT = 24 K | Pronounced under-flow, excessive cooling |
| Riser D (end of network) | 1300 l/h | 380 l/h | ΔT = 31 K | Critical flow deficit, cold radiators |
The record drawn up at the end of the measurement lists the flow rates, the temperatures and the serial numbers of the instruments used. Signed by the installer or noting his refusal to sign, this document turns a simple user complaint into material evidence of failure to comply with the rules of the heating trade.
Serving the formal notice and carrying out rectification by substitution
Once the hydraulic imbalance has been quantified, the client activates the warranty for defects of the work under the SIA 118 standard. Art. 368 CO governs the client's rights in the event of defects in the work, including rejection, price reduction, rectification and damages. The client then serves a formal notice of defects by registered letter, requiring the installer to intervene to bring the work back into conformity with the calculated flow rates.
Art. 107 CO specifies that in a bilateral contract, the other party may set a reasonable time limit for performance. This time limit must be technically realistic to allow for the calculation of the flow rates and the installation of the equipment, generally set at twenty or thirty working days depending on the size of the building. If the contractor disputes his liability or refuses to act within the time limit set, the client may have recourse to performance by substitution at the expense of the original installer.
- Formal noticeSending a registered letter enclosing the joint measurement record, recalling the breach of the calculation requirements and granting a firm time limit to start the rectification.
- Finding of defaultAt the end of the time limit, a bailiff's record or a report from the site management certifies that no corrective work whatsoever has been started on the distribution network.
- Order for performance by substitutionPlacing an order with a qualified third-party company to replace the unsuitable manual devices with automatic pressure-independent control valves.
- Commissioning and final protocolMeasurement of the stabilised dynamic flow rates under all load conditions and production of a complete hydraulic validation report sent to the client's lawyer.
The final invoice of the new company, including the remedial engineering, the dynamic valves and the setting hours, is then charged directly to the defaulting company. The claim also covers lawyer's fees, the technical expert's fees and compensation for the additional energy costs caused by the prolonged overheating of the apartments located in the immediate vicinity of the boiler room.
Joint measurement protocols and requalification towards dynamic balancing
When the hydraulic imbalance of a central heating installation persists after handover of the work, the dispute leaves the realm of simple site discussion and enters a formal contentious phase. An installer who refuses to intervene or disputes the existence of the defect is exposed to a substitution procedure. For the rectification costs to be fully enforceable against the defaulting company before a civil court, the technical file must demonstrate unambiguously that the network is unable to distribute the calculated nominal flow rates.
The material evidence rests on a campaign of joint measurements carried out riser by riser. Two technicians, representing respectively the client and the contracting company or an appointed expert, carry out simultaneous measurements on the regulating devices at the base of the riser and at the terminals of the terminal emitters. The deviation between the design flow rates and the flow rates measured at full thermal load establishes the non-conformity of the original work.
| Item checked | Parameter measured | Permissible deviation | Legal consequence of the finding |
|---|---|---|---|
| Base of disadvantaged riser | Residual differential pressure (kPa) | Below the minimum required value | Lack of hydraulic authority established, obligation of full rectification |
| Existing manual valves | Actual mass flow rate (l/h) | Deviation greater than 15 % from the calculation | No enforceable initial setting under the SIA 118 standard |
| Risers close to boiler room | Return temperature (°C) | Overheating with clear short-circuit | Proof of a parasitic over-flow depriving the remote branches |
| Thermostatic valve bodies | Whistling and upstream pressure (kPa) | Cavitation threshold exceeded | Acoustic and functional non-conformity attributable to the installation |
In a staged two-pipe system with many load variations due to the sporadic closing of the thermostatic valves, any attempt at balancing with static manual valves alone proves technically obsolete. The independent expert or consulting engineer therefore imposes rectification with pressure-independent differential pressure control valves or valves combined with dynamic control (PIBCV). This change in type of device is not regarded as an improvement adding value but as the minimum technical means necessary to guarantee the balancing prescribed by the rules of the trade.
Formal notice, substitution of contractor and allocation of costs
The signed joint finding documents the defect of the work within the meaning of the SIA 118 standard. The client's lawyer then sends a formal notice of defects together with a formal notice requiring rectification. This notification grants the original installer a reasonable time limit to start the work and to present his balancing method statement. Failure to respond within the time limit or refusal to carry out the dynamic balancing immediately opens the way to substitution measures.
In accordance with art. 366 CO, if the contractor is in default or refuses to carry out the requested corrections, the client may entrust the continuation of the work or the rectification to a third-party company, at the expense and risk of the defaulting installer. The company appointed by substitution removes the unsuitable static valves, brazes the new differential modules onto the risers and carries out the complete instrumented dynamic balancing, documented point by point in a certified setting log.
- Bailiff's or expert's recordFormal verification of the thermal failure by a sworn specialist with ambient temperature loggers over seven continuous days.
- Formal summons with a firm deadlineSending a registered letter detailing the technical shortcomings observed and setting a peremptory time limit for carrying out the dynamic balancing.
- Award of the rectification contract to a third partyAward of the hydraulic modification work to a second qualified heating company, on the basis of the expert's specifications.
- Legal recovery of the amounts incurredSubmission of the paid invoices, the final measurement records and the claim for financial compensation against the retention money or by way of debt enforcement.
The final invoice sent to the defaulting tradesman covers the supply and installation of the automatic valves, the labour time of the substitute company, the fees of the engineer who led the joint measurement campaign and the compensation for the excess fuel consumption incurred during the months of malfunction. The strict rigour of the chain of technical action protects the client from any challenge to the legitimacy of the rectification costs.
From joint expert assessment to judicial recovery
When the thermal imbalance persists on a distribution network and the company refuses to intervene, the dispute moves from the amicable stage to technical litigation. The SIA 118 standard governs the exercise of the right to have defects remedied. For the costs of a third-party intervention to be charged to the original installer, the client must build a documented chain of evidence, free of procedural flaws.
- Joint measurement campaignSimultaneous measurement of the mass flow rates and the flow and return temperatures at the base of each riser. The readings are recorded in a record signed by both parties, highlighting the favoured risers and the under-supplied branches.
- Formal noticeNotification by registered letter of a precise notice of defects, together with a reasonable time limit for performance to carry out the setting and bring the installation back into conformity.
- Substitution of contractorAppointment of a specialised third-party company to carry out dynamic balancing using differential pressure regulators or pressure-independent combined valves.
Art. 366 CO allows the client, where defective performance is established through the contractor's fault, to set him a reasonable time limit, notifying him that the repairs will be entrusted to a third party at his expense and risk. If delivery has already taken place, CO establishes the client's right to demand rectification of the work free of charge where the defect is not so significant as to justify outright rejection.
The file sent to the lawyer must contain the annotated principle diagram, the initial hydraulic calculation sheets, the calibration certificates of the measuring instruments and the detailed substitution account. This technical lock-down deprives the opposing party of any argument based on alleged improper operation.
Frequently asked questions
Who bears the fees of the expert appointed for the joint measurements?
The client initially advances the costs of the consulting engineers' office. As soon as the expert assessment demonstrates the hydraulic non-conformity and the reality of the defect attributable to the installer, these amounts constitute consequential damage. They are included in the overall financial claim notified to the defaulting company, then recovered as part of the final account for rectification in accordance with the rules of the Code of Obligations (CO).
Can the installer be compelled to finance dynamic valves not provided for in the original quote?
Yes, if the joint expert assessment proves that keeping the original static devices does not allow the contractual temperature differentials to be met under variable conditions. The contractor is responsible for the overall functionality of his work. If adding differential regulators or pressure-independent valves proves to be the only technical means of guaranteeing the supply of heat to all the apartments, this expense forms an integral part of the rectification.
Can the client withhold payment of the retention money during the dispute?
Under the usual rules of the SIA 118 standard, the retention money serves precisely to cover the client's claims in the event of defects found during the notice period. The amount withheld or the equivalent bank guarantee remains held until the reservations are formally lifted. It may be used to directly finance rectification by substitution if the installer refuses to intervene.
How can the hydraulic imbalance be documented without entering all the dwellings?
Probative measurements are carried out directly in the basement, on the distribution manifolds and at the base of the risers. Temperature readings by infrared thermography or contact probes, combined with ultrasonic flow measurement on the common pipes, provide indisputable physical proof of the overall imbalance. This method technically removes the need for systematic access to the heating units located in the private apartments.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work
- CO art. 366Delay and foreseeable defective performance
- COClient's rights in the event of defects in the work
