Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 241Heat demand and sizing of the heat generationChapter 1 of 10 in the section

Calculating the required output: heat losses, design temperature and heat gains

After this chapter, you will be able to determine a building's heat load rigorously in accordance with SIA 384/1. You will master the survey of heat-loss surfaces, the selection of the design outdoor temperature by weather station and the treatment of heat gains, so as to size the heat generator without risking oversizing or critical undersizing.

Key takeaways

  • The empirical per-square-metre method produces sizing errors that frequently exceed thirty per cent.
  • SIA 384/1 calculates the peak output without deducting instantaneous solar gains.
  • The design outdoor temperature depends directly on altitude and on the cantonal climate station.
  • Envelope insulation and hygienic ventilation determine the actual distribution of heat losses.

Determining the peak heat load in accordance with SIA 384/1

A rough assessment of the heat output based solely on floor area per square metre systematically leads to serious errors on modern installations. Between an unrenovated 1970s villa with requirements of 120 W/m² and a contemporary building down below 30 W/m², applying a generic ratio exposes you to a sizing error of more than 30 %. In a heat pump project or a centralised boiler room, an oversized generator multiplies short operating cycles, degrades the seasonal coefficient of performance and wears out compressors prematurely. Conversely, an undersized generator fails to cover requirements during cold spells without switching on an energy-hungry electric backup.

The calculation of the rated heat load comprises the sum of the transmission losses through the walls of the thermal envelope and the ventilation losses, established for the outdoor design climate conditions and the indoor set-point temperatures, without taking into account temporary free gains.

Norme SIA 384/1

The standard calculation in accordance with SIA 384/1 is based on a steady-state balance carried out under the least favourable conditions, when the building must guarantee the comfort room temperature without any outside help. The design output of the generator combines two inseparable components: transmission losses through the thermal envelope and ventilation losses. For each element bounding the heated volume (façades, roofs, slabs on ground or over unheated rooms, glazing), the technician applies the actual thermal transmittance coefficients U multiplied by the developed surface area measured overall.

Factors influencing transmission losses according to SIA 384/1
Envelope elementQuantity measuredTechnical point of attention
External wallsU-value in W/(m²·K)Actual thickness and continuity of the insulation against the masonry
Roofs and atticsDeveloped surface areasAirtightness at the roof-frame junctions
Glazing and framesUw and g valuesPresence of old double glazing that has not been replaced
Thermal bridgesLinear Psi valuesSlab-balcony junctions and window surrounds

The second component comes from the required fresh air flow. Where there is natural ventilation through opened windows or uncontrolled infiltration, the air change rate heavily penalises the rated output. If the building includes a controlled mechanical ventilation system covered by CFC 244, the CFC 241 heating installer includes in the heat balance only the residual output needed to warm the fresh air after it has passed through the heat recovery exchanger.

Setting the design temperature and accounting for heat gains

The calculation of heat losses requires quantifying the design temperature difference between the indoor environment and the outside. The indoor set-point temperature is standardised at 20 °C for living rooms and offices, and at 22 °C for bathrooms. The outdoor design temperature does not correspond to the absolute historical cold record, but to an official statistical value defined for each Swiss region according to the altitude of the site and MeteoSwiss climate data.

Arbitrarily choosing a lower design temperature as a precaution distorts the sizing substantially. An assessment error of 3 K on the outdoor design temperature changes the required peak output by nearly 10 % on a single-family house. The installer must absolutely identify the reference weather station assigned to the postcode of the construction site and correct the design value according to the actual altitude of the building relative to the measuring station.

  1. Surveying the envelope surfaces and insulationMeasure the walls in contact with the outside, the ground and unheated zones, then record the exact composition of each insulating layer.
  2. Assigning the local design temperatureIdentify the project's reference station and set the outdoor design temperature, corrected for the exact altitude of the plot.
  3. Calculating the base ventilationDetermine the minimum hygienic air volume flow and include the certified thermal efficiency of any energy recovery.
  4. Adding the hot water production loadAdd the continuous output or the recovery time needed to cover the requirements of the domestic hot water cylinder connected to the primary circuit.

Once the gross heat load has been established in accordance with SIA 384/1, the installer checks the operating mode of the installation. When the generator also supplies the heat load of the domestic hot water cylinder without absolute priority, an additional output is included depending on the storage volume and the allotted reheating time. If the system provides for full domestic hot water priority with temporary interruption of heating, the building's thermal inertia makes it possible to avoid systematically stacking the outputs, thereby limiting the equipment investment and guaranteeing an optimal load factor of the generator in the mid-season.

The three envelope quantities versus the illusion of per-square-metre ratios

Sizing a heat generator from an empirical ratio expressed in watts per square metre remains a major source of malfunction in the field. Two buildings with an identical energy reference area can have output requirements that vary by a factor of three depending on their architectural compactness, the condition of their insulation and their geographical location. The rigorous calculation of the heat load in accordance with SIA 384/1 is based on a steady-state physical model that rules out any global area-based approximation.

The first decisive input is the transmission loss through the external thermal envelope. It includes the sum of the products of the exchange surfaces and their respective thermal transmittance coefficients, supplemented by the linear losses of the thermal bridges. In existing unrenovated buildings, slab junctions, uninsulated lintels and window surrounds generate considerable localised losses. Underestimating the thermal value of a rubble-stone wall or ignoring the deterioration of roof insulation immediately distorts the required output by several kilowatts.

The second input concerns losses through air renewal and infiltration. The ventilation heat load derives from the heated volume and the air change rate prescribed for hygiene or measured according to the permeability of the envelope. In an old building with original leaky windows, the flow of cold air entering under the effect of wind greatly inflates the required heating output. Conversely, installing controlled mechanical ventilation with heat recovery drastically reduces this item, which fundamentally changes the thermal balance without a single square metre having changed.

The third fundamental input is the outdoor design temperature assigned to the location of the building. This statistical value does not correspond to the absolute historical cold record, but to a minimum average outdoor temperature over several consecutive days, determined from the meteorological records of the most representative reference station. An altitude or climate assignment error shifts the temperature difference between the indoor environment and the outside, directly moving the nominal operating point of the boiler or heat pump.

Calculation bias: accounting for gains and sizing drift

The peak output calculation differs profoundly from the annual energy demand balance. The most serious drift is to blindly deduct solar gains and internal gains from the generator sizing. On a dark winter night with a cold bise wind at the outdoor design temperature, solar gains through the glazing are strictly zero. As for internal gains from occupants or electrical appliances, there is no guarantee that they will be continuous over time. Under SIA 384/1, the installed output must cover all the losses without counting on these random gains.

Impact of input errors on the overall heat output result
Incorrectly assessed parameterFrequent input errorConsequence on the calculated outputOperating risk
Outdoor design temperatureLowland weather station used for a construction site at altitude (+300 m)Temperature difference underestimated by 2 to 4 K (output too low by 10 to 15 %)Inability to maintain the indoor set point in severe cold
Envelope thermal bridgesSlab-façade junctions neglected or flat-rate value too optimisticTransmission losses underestimated by 15 to 25 %Undersized generator, electric backup constantly called upon
Infiltration and permeabilityNew-build airtightness assumed for old joinery that has not been resealedParasitic air flow underestimated by 0.5 air changes per hourInsufficient ventilation output, feeling of cold walls
Deduction of solar gainsAverage midday solar gains taken into account in the peak sizingOutput artificially underestimated by 10 to 30 %Room temperature drops as soon as the sun sets in severe cold
Accumulation of safety marginsSystematic addition of flat-rate reserves at each calculation stepOverall oversizing of 30 to 50 %Choppy operation, short cycles destructive for the equipment

For renovation construction sites where the original building plans lack precision, the installer must carry out non-destructive probing of the envelope in order to identify the nature of the materials and the insulation thicknesses. Analysing historical fuel invoices provides a valuable cross-check, provided that the raw consumption figures are corrected by the actual degree-days of the corresponding heating period. This verification using the energy signature method makes it possible to compare the theoretical result obtained under SIA 384/1 with the thermal reality experienced by the building.

Remedies and corrective measures in a sizing dispute

When a heating installation does not maintain the indoor set point during frost or a generator oscillates in destructive short cycles, the initial sizing must be subjected to an adversarial technical audit. Blaming the output of the boiler or heat pump from the outset is an analytical error. The first operation on site is to instrument the installation with flow and temperature recorders for at least seven days of sustained cold. These measurements make it possible to check whether the outdoor temperature has fallen below the design temperature of the local weather station and whether the hydraulic network is carrying the planned temperature regime.

  1. Audit of the building envelopeRecord the actual insulation thicknesses, the exact type of glazing and the façade junctions. The envelope losses calculated in accordance with SIA 384/1 must be recalculated with the components actually installed on the building, and not from the theoretical values in the building permit application file.
  2. Hydraulic check and flow ratesMeasure the mass flow at the main circulator as well as the pressure losses on each distribution branch. A heat deficit felt in the rooms regularly stems from faulty balancing or an inadequate fluid velocity, and not from a lack of output of the heat generator.
  3. Examination of air renewalQuantify the outdoor air infiltration and the actual setting of the ventilation outlets. An uncontrolled fresh air flow drastically increases the peak ventilation losses, distorting the overall heat balance without the initial design calculation being directly responsible.

If the expert assessment reveals an output deviation caused by erroneous input data supplied during the tenders, the installer records these facts in writing in accordance with SIA 118. Remedial work on the installation does not systematically require removal of the generator: adjusting the heating curve, optimising the circulation flow rates or adding a temporary electric backup frequently suffices to restore indoor comfort without upsetting the building's energy operation.

Frequently asked questions

Why is it risky to size a heating installation on the basis of a per-square-metre ratio?

The area ratio ignores the geometric shape of the building, the orientation of the openings and the insulation level of the external walls. For the same useful area of two hundred square metres, a compact, highly insulated house requires four kilowatts, whereas an old building with a large envelope area requires twenty. Applying an average ratio produces systematic oversizing or critical undersizing, causing premature wear failures or complaints of thermal discomfort.

Should solar and internal gains be deducted when calculating the peak output?

According to SIA 384/1, solar gains and internal heat gains must not be deducted from the rated output of the generator. The peak load is calculated for the least favourable conditions, for example on a moonless night with the thermometer at the outdoor design temperature and an unoccupied dwelling. Including free gains would artificially lower the required output and make it impossible to ensure the required set-point temperature.

How do you choose the outdoor design temperature for a project located at an isolated high altitude?

The designer refers to the official climate data associated with SIA 384/1. For a municipality that does not have its own weather station, the data of the nearest reference station must be extrapolated, correcting the value according to the official altitude gradient. Arbitrarily choosing a flat-rate value that is too mild underestimates the output by ten per cent per degree of deviation, jeopardising the heating guarantee in severe cold.

What impact does a change in the U-value of the windows have on the installed output?

Replacing high-performance triple glazing with a standard model increases the U-value by more than fifty per cent. The transmission heat losses through the glazed surfaces then climb sharply. If the boiler or heat pump is ordered before the load is recalculated in accordance with SIA 384/1, the installation will lack output as soon as sub-zero temperatures set in for a prolonged period in winter at the building.

Texts and standards cited

  • norme SIA 384/1Heating installations in buildings - Required output
  • norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work
  • CO art. 368client's rights in the event of defects in the work: refusal, price reduction, rectification, damages; any clause agreed in advance that restricts or excludes the right to have defects remedied is void if the defect concerns a building (para. 2bis, since 1 January 2026)

In the same section