Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 241Emitters: underfloor heating and radiatorsChapter 5 of 10 in the section

Radiators at low temperature: heat-exchange surface, actual output and replacement

Connecting a heat pump to an existing radiator network requires checking the actual heat output room by room. You will be able to calculate the output delivered at low temperature from the initial nominal operating regime, determine the correction factor according to SIA 384/1 and identify precisely which radiators to replace in order to guarantee comfort without degrading the coefficient of performance of the installation.

Key takeaways

  • Lowering the distribution regime from 70/50 to 45/35 halves the output.
  • SIA 384/1 requires heat losses to be calculated room by room before conversion.
  • The characteristic thermal exponent of the model directly determines the output correction factor.
  • Replacement targets first the critical rooms lacking heat-exchange surface.

Calculating the drop in heat output with the radiator emission law

When changing from an oil or gas boiler to a heat pump, the flow temperature of the distribution circuit must be lowered to preserve the seasonal coefficient of performance (COP). A historic regime calculated at 75/65 °C or 70/55 °C with a room temperature of 20 °C has a mean temperature difference, denoted Delta T, clearly higher than the regimes required by a heat pump, typically set at 45/35 °C or even 50/40 °C. However, the output of a radiator does not decrease in a strictly linear way with the drop in water temperature: it follows a logarithmic law governed by an exponent specific to the geometry of each unit.

Logarithmic Delta T (ΔTln)
Effective mean difference between the water temperature in the radiator and the room air. It incorporates the actual cooling profile of the fluid between flow and return: ΔTln = (T_flow - T_return) / ln[(T_flow - T_room) / (T_return - T_room)].

To size the emitter or assess its potential, the emission formula is P = P_nom * (ΔTln / ΔT_nom)^n, where n is the characteristic exponent of the radiator. This exponent generally ranges between 1.25 and 1.35 for flat-panel steel models fitted with convectors, and rises to 1.30 to 1.40 for old cast-iron radiators or tubular elements. The emission correction factor F_corr follows directly from the ratio of these deltas: it quantifies the percentage of output remaining.

Output reduction factors according to operating regime (T_room = 20 °C, exponent n = 1.30)
Flow / return regimeMean ΔTlnCorrection factor F_corrRelative residual output
75 / 65 °C (EN 442 reference)49.8 K1.00100 %
70 / 55 °C (old standard)42.0 K0.8080 %
55 / 45 °C (medium temperature)29.4 K0.5050 %
45 / 35 °C (low-temperature heat pump)19.6 K0.3030 %

The physical finding is unequivocal: a radiator delivering 2,000 W under the old 75/65 °C reference regime provides only about 600 W when the network is supplied at 45/35 °C. If the building has not undergone simultaneous work on the thermal envelope, the water flow cannot make up for this deficit without causing hydraulic whistling at the thermostatic valves and excessive electricity consumption by the circulator.

Determining the radiators to replace according to SIA 384/1

Converting a heating installation to a thermodynamic generator cannot be done by guesswork. SIA 384/1 sets the methods recognised in Switzerland for calculating design heat loads, room by room. The heating installer must proceed in steps: first survey the heat-losing surfaces and the actual U-values of the building, calculate the output required to maintain the standard set point (for example 20 °C in living rooms and bedrooms, 24 °C in bathrooms), then list every emitter in place.

The required heat output must be calculated room by room on the basis of transmission and ventilation heat losses, taking into account the design indoor and outdoor temperatures.

Norme SIA 384/1
  1. Technical survey on siteMeasure the height, length and depth and identify the internal structure of each unit (type 11, 21, 22 or 33 for steel; number of columns and elements for cast iron).
  2. Calculation of the net requirement according to SIA 384/1Establish the static heat loss of each room at the reference outdoor temperature of the Swiss location (for example -8 °C in Lausanne or -10 °C in Fribourg).
  3. Applying the correction factorDivide the calculated requirement of the room by the correction factor F_corr corresponding to the maximum water temperature targeted for the heat pump, in order to find the nominal catalogue output at 75/65 °C that is needed.
  4. Assessment and replacement decisionCompare the existing nominal output with the minimum required value. Any shortfall above 10 % classes the radiator as an emitter to be replaced.

In buildings constructed before 1990 that have already undergone partial refurbishment (windows replaced by triple glazing, attic insulation), the original radiators, oversized by the heating engineers of the time, are sometimes sufficient to operate at 50 °C. On the other hand, bathrooms and corner rooms with two cold façades almost always have insufficient heat-exchange surface. The tradesperson replaces these critical elements with deeper radiators (replacing a type 22 with a type 33), with vertical models offering a large radiating length, or installs compact fan convectors connected to the low-temperature circuit.

Emission correction factor and switch to low temperature

When converting from an oil or gas boiler to a heat pump in an existing building, keeping the original flow regime at 70 °C or 75 °C severely degrades the seasonal coefficient of performance (SCOP). To guarantee economical operation and meet the requirements of SIA 384/1, the distribution network must be operated at a lowered regime, typically 45/35 °C or 50/40 °C at the design outdoor temperature. This change drastically lowers the heat output emitted by convection and natural radiation.

The heat output of a radiator does not decrease in a strictly linear way with the mean water temperature. It follows the physical exchange law governed by SIA 384/1, where the actual output depends on the logarithmic or arithmetic excess temperature raised to a characteristic exponent, denoted n. For conventional panel radiators in tubular or pleated steel, this exponent generally varies between 1.28 and 1.33. For old cast-iron column radiators or finned convectors, it can rise to 1.35 or even 1.45, further accentuating the collapse of output at low temperature.

Emission correction factors f_cor according to the water regime for an indoor temperature of 20 °C (exponent n = 1.30)
Flow / return regime [°C]Mean difference Delta T_m [K]Correction factor f_corRelative residual output [%]Equivalent exchange surface required
75 / 65 °C (EN 442 reference)50.0 K1.00100 %1.0 × initial surface
70 / 55 °C (conventional oil-fired central heating)42.5 K0.8181 %1.2 × initial surface
55 / 45 °C (medium-temperature heat pump)30.0 K0.5151 %1.9 × initial surface
50 / 40 °C (low-temperature heat pump)25.0 K0.4141 %2.4 × initial surface
45 / 35 °C (maximum heat pump optimisation)20.0 K0.3131 %3.2 × initial surface

To size the emitter under the new regime, the heating fitter multiplies the heat loss of the room, calculated according to SIA 384/1, by the inverse of the correction factor. If a living room needs 1,200 W of heat loss in severe cold and the network is lowered to 50/40 °C (f_cor = 0.41), the new radiator must be selected with a nominal output, standardised at 75/65/20 °C, of at least 2,927 W in the manufacturer's catalogue in order to deliver the 1,200 W required on the construction site.

Strategy for sorting, selecting and replacing radiators before conversion

In a renovation with partial refurbishment of the envelope, not all existing radiators necessarily have to be replaced. Radiators installed in the 1970s or 1980s were often considerably oversized by the engineering offices of the time. In addition, the earlier replacement of single-glazed windows by triple glazing greatly reduces local heat loss. The tradesperson therefore carries out a meticulous room-by-room survey of the existing exchange surfaces before finalising the quote.

  1. Survey of emitters and calculation of residual outputsRecord the exact model of each radiator (material, height, length, thickness, number of fins or panel type 11, 21, 22 or 33). Calculate the actual output using the correction factor at the low-temperature regime planned by the weather-compensated control.
  2. Comparison with the heat load per roomCompare the calculated output with the heat requirement of the room according to SIA 384/1. Mark as deficient the rooms with a shortfall above 10 %, often bathrooms, corner rooms under the roof or spaces with untreated thermal bridges.
  3. Selecting substitute solutions suited to the space availableReplace the deficient models without changing the pipe centre distances where possible. Substitute a single panel of type 11 or 21 with a type 22 or 33 of the same length, or install a low-temperature fan radiator fitted with integrated micro-motors.
  4. Checking pipe diameters and balancingCheck that the increase in volume flow required by the reduced temperature drop (Delta T often going from 15 K to 8 K) does not generate excessive velocities or whistling in the existing distribution risers.

Under art. 365 para. 3 CO, if a circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work, the contractor informs the client. Installing a heat pump on undersized radiators without prior warning exposes the installer to an obvious energy-efficiency defect and to non-compliant indoor temperatures.

Thermal defects after conversion: diagnosis and corrective measures

When the first cold weather arrives after a heat pump has been connected to an existing network, a lack of output in some rooms often indicates an uncompensated drop in emission. The reflex of raising the heating curve on the control immediately degrades the seasonal coefficient of performance of the installation and increases the electricity bill. Before considering any modification of the generator, the site foreman must methodically investigate the hydraulics and the geometry of the radiators.

  1. Checking flows and balancingMeasure the temperature drop across each radiator using a contact thermometer. A difference above 10 Kelvin at low temperature indicates insufficient flow. Adjust the balancing fittings or replace the valve bodies with models with dynamic differential-pressure control to guarantee the nominal flow calculated according to SIA 384/1.
  2. Checking pressure losses and sludge removalA fouled heat exchanger or a network clogged with ferrous sludge reduces the effective exchange surface of cast-iron or steel radiators. Carry out a hydrodynamic flush of the circuit and check the strainer and the magnetic sludge separator fitted on the return of the machine.
  3. Replacing the critical radiatorIf the flow is correct but the output remains deficient at a flow temperature of 45 °C, replace the emitter with a type 33 steel-sheet panel radiator with three rows of fins, or with an emitter with integrated fan assistance, without changing the pipe centre distance.

Under art. 365 CO, the contractor informs the client when a circumstance jeopardises the proper execution of the work. If the client refuses the prior replacement of the critical radiators identified during the initial thermal study, this formal notification documents the risks of not reaching the comfort temperature at design outdoor temperatures.

Frequently asked questions

How should I react if only one room stays cold while the other rooms are at temperature?

First check the stem of the thermostatic valve, which is often seized after the circuit has been drained. Then measure the actual flow at the balancing fitting. If the flow is at maximum and the radiator is uniformly lukewarm, the installed output is inherently insufficient for the lowered water regime. The solution requires replacing the radiator with a type 22 or 33 model of equivalent size.

Can the lack of output be compensated by increasing the speed of the main circulator?

Increasing the circulator speed reduces the delta T between flow and return, which slightly raises the mean temperature of the radiator. However, this increase in output remains marginal, in the order of 5 to 8 %. In return, you generate parasitic flow noise at the thermostatic valves and increase the consumption of the circulator. This measure never replaces an exchange surface calculated according to SIA 384/1.

Must all radiators be bled systematically after switching to low temperature?

Yes, complete bleeding is essential when the system is refilled. At 45 °C, the water circulation does not always manage to drive out air pockets trapped in the upper part of tall radiators or risers. An air pocket neutralises several heat-exchange elements, which divides the useful output of an emitter that has already been halved by the change in the water regime of the installation.

What alternative should be chosen if the wall dimensions prevent a larger radiator?

When the width under the window is fixed, install a low-temperature radiator fitted with tangential micro-fans under the radiator body. This device forces convection over the internal fins and multiplies the heat-transfer coefficient by two or three for the same size. A 230-volt power supply or a low-voltage connection is, however, required in the immediate vicinity to power the integrated fans.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 384/1Heating installations in buildings - Required output
  • CO art. 365material and ground: the contractor is responsible for the good quality of the material he supplies; if the material supplied by the client or the ground designated by the client is found to be defective, or if another circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work, he must inform the client immediately, failing which he bears the consequences (para. 3)

In the same section