Key takeaways
- A radiator that is cold at the top indicates an air pocket, never a hydraulic balancing problem.
- A network is always bled from the bottom upwards, with the circulators completely stopped.
- Magnetite sludge settles at the bottom of the emitters and requires mechanical flushing under pressure.
- Any water top-up after sludge removal must be recorded and carried out exclusively with softened or demineralised water.
Diagnosing thermal discomfort and bleeding air from the bottom upwards
On a renovation construction site or during commissioning, a radiator that is cold at the top is systematically a sign of trapped air or non-condensable gases, and not of a faulty presetting of the thermostatic valve. When the heat-transfer fluid does not reach the top of the radiator body, circulation is interrupted locally by a break in the water column. Confusing this phenomenon with a balancing fault often leads to opening the regulating components excessively, which unbalances the entire riser.
- Preparing the installationSwitch off the power supply to the heating circulators. Leave the network to settle for about fifteen minutes so that the air bubbles can agglomerate and migrate naturally towards the high points.
- Methodical bleeding from the bottom upwardsBegin manual bleeding with the emitters on the lowest level of the building (ground floor or basement), then work up floor by floor to finish on the top level. This progression avoids pushing air released by the depressurisation of the upper floors back down to the lower floors.
- Continuous pressure monitoringMonitor the pressure gauge in the boiler room at all times. As soon as the static pressure drops by more than 0.3 bar below the set value, refill the circuit with water to prevent the risers from losing their prime.
To capture the air released during heating, installing a microbubble air separator on the flow of the boiler or heat pump is essential. At this precise point, the water reaches its maximum temperature and its lowest pressure, which promotes the degassing of dissolved microbubbles. Automatic float air vents, for their part, are reserved for the geometric high points of the risers and distribution manifolds.
- Microbubble separator
- Hydraulic device installed on the main flow, incorporating a metal mesh or coalescing rings that slow down the speed of the heat-transfer fluid in order to force the dissolved microscopic bubbles to rise into a venting chamber.
Removing sludge by flushing and stabilising water quality
Unlike air, sludge cannot be bled out through simple vent valves at the high point. Made up of ferric or ferrous iron oxides (magnetite) and limescale precipitates, it inevitably settles in zones of low flow velocity: the bottom of radiators, supply elbows and underfloor heating loops. A radiator that is cold at the bottom and warm at the top reveals a massive accumulation of sludge blocking the passage of the heat-transfer fluid.
| Observation on the emitter | Physical cause | Corrective action required |
|---|---|---|
| Cold top, hot bottom | Air pocket or non-condensable gases | Methodical manual bleeding from the bottom upwards |
| Hot top, cold or lukewarm bottom | Settling of magnetite and sludge | Mechanical sludge removal and flushing with clean water |
| Gurgling noises | Air circulating in the flow | Stop the circulator and carry out active degassing |
| No flow on a manifold | Plug of organic or limescale sludge | Hydrodynamic flushing loop by loop |
- Isolating the circuitIsolate the heat generators using the isolating valves so as not to send debris or overpressure into the fragile heat exchangers of the heat pump or boiler.
- Hydrodynamic flushing loop by loopConnect the sludge-removal pump to the drain and fill valves of the manifold. Close all loops except one. Inject a pulsed mixture of water and compressed air until the water is perfectly clear, then move on to the next loop.
- Cleaning the magnetic settling potRemove the magnetic rod from the sludge separator installed on the main return, and open the flushing valve to discharge the retained ferrous oxides without having to drain the boiler room.
The contractor carrying out these operations remains bound to perform work in accordance with the recognised rules of the art, a principle recalled in art. 364 CO concerning the obligations of the contractor. Once the network has been flushed, the final filling and any future top-ups must under no circumstances be made with raw water from the distribution network if its hardness or conductivity exceeds the thresholds prescribed by the Swiss guideline for heating water.
Air separators at the high point and degassing of networks
The presence of air in a distribution network is not limited to a hissing sound in a thermostatic valve or a lukewarm top of a radiator. While manual bleeding removes the stationary pockets trapped in the floor radiators, it does not deal with the dissolved gases carried by the heat-transfer fluid. As soon as the water is heated by the generator, the solubility of gases drops sharply according to Henry's law, releasing a multitude of microbubbles at the point of maximum temperature. These microbubbles circulate at high speed, cause cavitation in the circulators and feed the oxidation of ferrous components. Treating air therefore requires combining air vents at the geometric high points with a microbubble separator placed on the hot flow in the boiler room.
The highest points of each riser must absolutely be fitted with a bleed bottle or a static air separator equipped with an automatic float air vent, preceded by a ball isolating valve. The isolating valve allows the air vent to be shut off after the initial commissioning phase: an automatic air vent left permanently open eventually leaks because of limescale deposits or, worse, draws in air in the event of a local reversal of hydrodynamic pressure. In complex installations or tall office buildings, a cyclic vacuum degasser completes the arrangement to extract the dissolved nitrogen that simple buoyancy cannot separate.
| Equipment | Location in the network | Main function | Operating constraint |
|---|---|---|---|
| Manual radiator air vent | Top plug opposite the valve | Release of static air pockets during initial balancing | Requires a bleed key and protection of floor coverings |
| Float degassing bottle | Top of risers and high points of distribution | Removal of free air volumes risen by gravity | Mandatory isolation by quarter-turn valve after initial degassing |
| Microbubble separator | Boiler room flow, immediately after the heat generator | Continuous capture of microbubbles released at high temperature | Pressure drop to be included in the pump head calculation |
| Magnetic sludge separator | Main return upstream of the circulators and the generator | Trapping of ferrous oxides and sediments by magnetic field | Periodic draining of the settling chamber at operating pressure |
Mechanical sludge removal and top-up with stabilised technical water
Confusing a sludge problem with a hydraulic imbalance or simple air presence leads to ineffective interventions. A radiator clogged with magnetite remains cold in its lower and central part, because the passage of the heat-transfer fluid is obstructed there. Opening the upper bleed screw solves nothing: heavy particles do not rise and never escape through a two-millimetre venting orifice. To remove these oxidation and bacterial degradation residues, mechanical action under controlled flow is required, network by network and loop by loop.
- Isolating the generator and connecting the flushing unitClose the isolating valves of the heat pump or boiler to protect the heat exchangers. Connect the hoses of the sludge-removal pump to the drain and fill valves of the main manifold or of the circuit concerned.
- Hydrodynamic flushing loop by loop in reverse flowIsolate all radiators or floor coils except one. Inject clear water pulsed by compressed-air impulses to shear the sediments. Reverse the direction of circulation to dislodge the compact deposits lodged in the regulating elbows and in the lower pipework.
- Visual check of the discharge and filtration of residuesPass the flushing water through a fine-mesh transparent filter until the effluent is completely clear. Repeat the operation methodically on each emitter before reopening the next loop.
- Filling under pressure and protective conditioningDrain the raw flushing water and inject the compliant technical water, supplemented by a corrosion inhibitor and a dispersant suited to the mixed metallurgy of the installation.
The water top-up following sludge removal must under no circumstances be carried out with raw drinking water from the distribution network. Repeated addition of hard water reintroduces dissolved oxygen and mineral salts that precipitate as limescale on the hottest surfaces. The final filling requires passing through a mixed-bed demineralisation cartridge to guarantee very low electrical conductivity, thus limiting any risk of a galvanic cell between the steel of the radiators, the copper of the risers and the aluminium-silicon of the heat exchangers. A sub-meter dedicated to the filling disconnector allows each subsequent top-up volume to be traced precisely and recorded in the boiler room technical log.
Managing persistent blockages, hydraulic faults and acceptance disputes
When methodical bottom-to-top bleeding and the initial flushing do not restore thermal balance, the heating fitter must refrain from continuously refilling with water. Each uncontrolled top-up introduces dissolved oxygen, accelerates the formation of magnetite and degrades the heating surfaces. An emitter that remains cold at the top after degassing, or an underfloor heating loop that is completely inert, often reveals a structural hydraulic fault, heavy fouling of the regulating components or a malfunction of the pressure control.
- Isolation and hydraulic load testIsolate the healthy circuits on the manifold in order to direct the full pump head of the circulator towards the problem area. Checking the differential pressure makes it possible to determine whether the absence of circulation results from a compact sediment plug or a blocked balancing valve.
- Hydrodynamic flushing in reverse flowConnect a sludge-removal pump equipped with a magnetic rod directly to the emitter or loop concerned. Dynamic flushing by reversing the flow direction and sending air impulses dislodges compact sludge deposits without spreading abrasive particles towards the heat exchangers of the boiler or heat pump.
- Water reconditioning and final bleedingInject demineralised or stabilised top-up water complying with the recognised technical requirements, accompanied if necessary by a corrosion inhibitor. Carry out a final degassing at the automatic air separator located at the high point of the riser, then check the setting of the safety valve and the pressure of the expansion vessel.
When the faults result from a prior defect, such as the absence of an oxygen barrier on old pipes or a faulty hydraulic sizing, the installer applies art. 365 al. 3 CO if a circumstance compromises the proper execution of the work by informing the client. A formal notice records these technical obstacles in order to document the situation before heavy work is undertaken.
Frequently asked questions
Why does a radiator remain cold at the bottom while the top is hot?
A radiator that is hot at the top and cold at the bottom does not need air bleeding, because air always accumulates at the top of the radiator body. This thermal gradient comes either from insufficient water flow, due to an undersized circulator or poor setting of the return elbow, or from an accumulation of sludge and ferrous oxides in the lower part. These dense sediments block the passage of hot water and require targeted mechanical flushing.
Why must radiators absolutely be bled from the bottom to the top of the building?
Dissolved air migrates naturally towards the high points by differential gravity as soon as circulation stops. By bleeding the lower floors first, the heating engineer stabilises the static pressure of the network and avoids driving new bubbles towards the radiators on the upper floors. This rigorous sequence, combined with maintaining a minimum pressure on the boiler room pressure gauge, prevents the formation of secondary air pockets in the risers and secures the installation before it is put back into service.
Where should the automatic air separator be installed to ensure its effectiveness?
The automatic air separator is installed primarily on the hot flow in the boiler room, directly after the heat generator, where the water temperature is highest and its gas solubility lowest. In addition, an air vent or microbubble separator must be fitted at each geometric high point of the distribution risers. This double arrangement captures the gases released on heating and prevents their accumulation in the emitters furthest from the generator in the building.
Can a heating installation be filled directly with water from the distribution network?
Direct filling with raw drinking water is to be avoided without prior analysis. Water that is too hard generates limescale on the heat exchangers, while water that is too aggressive promotes internal corrosion of radiators and steel pipework. The top-up water must comply with the target values for hardness, conductivity and pH recommended for closed-circuit installations, which requires the use of a mobile softening or demineralisation unit at each intervention.
Texts and standards cited
- CO art. 365material and ground: contractor's liability for the material supplied; informing the client if the ground or the material is defective or if another circumstance compromises the proper or timely execution of the work (para. 3)
