Key takeaways
- Untreated raw water scales plate heat exchangers and accelerates corrosion of metal components.
- On-site analysis of pH, hardness and conductivity determines the treatment required.
- The magnetic sludge separator protects high-efficiency circulators against abrasive magnetite.
- The mandatory recording of make-up volumes makes it possible to detect micro-leaks before the network oxidises.
Characterising raw water and conditioning the filling according to the technical rules
Recent heat generators, in particular heat pumps fitted with compact plate heat exchangers and condensing boilers with narrow channels, impose strict requirements on the heat-transfer fluid. Mains water considered drinkable frequently has a mineral content incompatible with this equipment. As soon as heating starts, calcium and magnesium ions precipitate as scale on the hottest walls, drastically reducing heat transfer and causing severe mechanical stresses. In addition, there is a risk of galvanic corrosion when several metals, such as copper, steel and aluminium, coexist in the same closed loop.
Before injecting a single litre of water into a distribution pipework, the heating fitter must carry out a complete analysis of the local supply water. This is not limited to a visual estimate. The check must cover three parameters: total hardness (expressed in French degrees °fH), electrical conductivity (in microsiemens per centimetre) and hydrogen potential (pH). The guidelines of the Suissetec trade association and the recommendations of the Swiss Society of Engineers and Architects set precise target values depending on the total installed heating output and the specific volume of the circuit.
| Parameter measured | Construction site test tool | Usual technical requirement | Consequence of non-compliance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total hardness | Colorimetric reagent titration kit | Less than 1 to 15 °fH depending on specific volume | Heavy scaling of exchangers and loss of efficiency |
| Electrical conductivity | Calibrated electronic conductivity meter | Below 100 µS/cm with demineralisation | Acceleration of galvanic currents and bimetallic corrosion |
| pH value (stabilised) | Digital tester or pH test strips | Between 8.2 and 9.5 (8.2 to 8.5 for aluminium) | Acid attack on steels or alkaline dissolution of aluminium |
To reach these tolerances, two main processes are used during filling: softening by ion exchange and full demineralisation on a disposable or regenerable mixed-bed resin. Softening replaces calcium ions with sodium, which prevents scale but retains a high conductivity favourable to corrosion. Demineralisation removes almost all dissolved salts, lowering the conductivity to a harmless level. This second process is generally recommended for modern low-temperature installations. The mobile treatment equipment is temporarily connected between the supply point and the heating network, respecting the physical separation required by the sanitary guidelines.
Capturing magnetite and documenting make-up water in operation
Even in a correctly conditioned circuit, residual dissolved oxygen reacts with the ferrous elements of pipes, buffer tanks and radiators to form black magnetic iron oxide, magnetite. These very hard microscopic particles circulate in suspension in the fluid. Modern high-efficiency circulators use synchronous motors with a permanent-magnet rotor. Without targeted mechanical protection, these magnets immediately attract metal debris into the motor air gap, causing mechanical blocking of the impeller, overheating of the winding and premature wear of the seals.
Installing a sludge separator combined with a powerful magnetic rod is an essential component on the main return to the heat generator. Positioned just upstream of the heat pump or boiler, the device slows the flow velocity of the fluid to allow gravity sedimentation of heavy matter, while the magnetic field captures all ferrous filings and oxides. This component is maintained with the magnetic field switched off, by withdrawing the magnet from its sleeve before opening the drain valve to discharge the accumulated sludge without draining the network.
- Cleaning and initial flushing of the networkFlush each distribution loop thoroughly with clean water before the final connection of the generators, to remove solder residues, jointing paste and cutting sawdust.
- Controlled filling and air purgingFill the circuit at a moderate flow rate through the water treatment station, methodically venting the air at the high points to limit the intake of gaseous oxygen.
- Commissioning the magnetic sludge potInsert the magnetic rod into its housing on the return line, isolate the discharge valves and check the tightness of the connections under test pressure.
- Installing and reading the make-up meterFit a dedicated volumetric water meter on the fixed filling line and record the starting reading in the boiler-room log.
Managing water quality does not end with the acceptance of the work. Repeatedly adding untreated raw water to compensate for pressure drops is the main cause of recontamination of a healthy network. Each addition brings a new load of limescale and corrosive oxygen. Fitting a dedicated water meter and displaying a maintenance log in the boiler room are required by the professional rules of the trade. The operator or technician must record in it the date, the exact volume injected and the pressure reached at each top-up.
On-site analysis protocols and application of the Suissetec guidelines
Direct injection of mains water into a modern thermal network is a major cause of premature failure. Current generators, whether heat pumps fitted with copper-brazed stainless steel plate exchangers or condensing boilers with aluminium-silicon alloy heating bodies, have millimetre-sized water passages and very high heat flux densities. Raw water supplied by municipal networks in French-speaking Switzerland frequently shows a hardness above 25 °fH and a high conductivity. Under the temperature rise in contact with the heating walls, calcium and magnesium ions instantly precipitate as limescale. A scale layer of only 1 mm on the exchange surfaces reduces heat transfer by nearly 10 %, causing local overheating, thermally induced stresses and cracking of the exchangers.
To protect installations against this damage, the Suissetec guidelines on heating water quality require a systematic characterisation of the water source before any filling. The installer must carry out the analysis of the filling water directly at the draw-off point using a calibrated field test kit. The mandatory measurements cover total hardness expressed in French degrees (°fH), electrical conductivity in microsiemens per centimetre (µS/cm) and hydrogen potential (pH). If the hardness exceeds the permissible thresholds defined according to the installed output and the specific volume of the installation (often set at 20 or 50 litres per kilowatt), preparatory treatment is absolutely required. Using a mixed-bed resin demineralisation cartridge is the reference solution to simultaneously lower the hardness to less than 0.1 °fH and remove the chlorides and sulphates responsible for crevice corrosion.
| Parameter analysed | Usual raw water (Swiss Plateau) | Target value after demineralisation | Consequence of non-compliance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total hardness (°fH) | 15 to 35 °fH | < 0.5 °fH (low salinity) | Scaling of the primary exchanger, loss of thermal efficiency |
| Electrical conductivity | 300 to 700 µS/cm | < 100 µS/cm | Acceleration of galvanic cells and under-deposit corrosion |
| pH value (standard materials) | 7.0 to 8.0 | 8.2 to 9.5 (self-alkalinisation) | Acid corrosion of black steels if pH is below 8.2 |
| pH value (with aluminium components) | 7.0 to 8.0 | 8.2 to 8.5 (narrow range) | Dissolution of the passive alumina layer if pH exceeds 8.5 |
Magnetic sludge capture and metrological monitoring of make-up water
Even in a circuit carefully degassed and demineralised at commissioning, residual oxygen and the permeability of synthetic materials (in particular underfloor heating pipes without an effective oxygen barrier or poorly maintained expansion vessels) feed the formation of magnetite (Fe3O4). This black ferromagnetic oxide sludge has a very fine grain size that bypasses conventional filter screens. Attracted by the permanent magnetic fields of high-efficiency electronic circulators, magnetite accumulates in the motor air gap, causes mechanical blocking of the rotors and fouls the micro-channels of the heat exchangers.
Installing a magnetic sludge and particle separator is essential for the long-term life of the system. The device is mounted on the main distribution return, immediately before the connection to the heat generator or the hydraulic separator, on a straight section respecting the nominal pipe diameters. The device combines a hydrodynamic flow reducer to settle heavy mineral matter and a high-power neodymium magnetic rod immersed in the flow. During periodic maintenance, the site foreman withdraws the magnetic rod from its dry sleeve, which instantly releases the retained iron particles; it is then enough to open the lower drain valve under circuit pressure to discharge the oxides into a transparent container without draining the installation.
The last part of the protocol concerns the recording of make-up volumes. Each addition of fresh water reintroduces dissolved oxygen and corrosive minerals. The installer must fit, upstream of the disconnector, a sub-meter dedicated to the filling line. Every litre injected must be recorded in the boiler-room operating log, with the date, the exact volume, the circuit pressure and the operator's signature. Under art. 364 CO, the contractor is liable for the proper and faithful performance of their work. A make-up exceeding 5 % of the total circuit volume over one year reveals a loss of tightness or a malfunction of the expansion vessel. If the operator carries out repeated top-ups without informing the installer, the meter reading provides material proof of defective operation, relieving the heating contractor of responsibility.
Handling sludge-fouling damage and remediation protocol
In the event of a drop in thermal efficiency on a plate heat exchanger or recurrent blocking of an electronic circulator by magnetite, the operator often questions the reliability of the generator. Yet the first technical step is to take a sample bottle of water from the circuit before any purging. If the network was filled with mains water without softening or demineralisation, the manufacturer will refuse the contractual warranty. The expert assessment will confirm an excessive conductivity or an unsuitable pH, engaging the provisions of art. 368 CO on the client's rights in case of defects in the work.
- Isolation and physico-chemical characterisationIsolate the generator and take a sample at the low point. Measure the pH, total hardness and electrical conductivity on site using calibrated instruments. Note the smell and colour of the fluid to detect any bacterial growth.
- Mechanical flushing and hydrodynamic desludgingConnect a pulsed air/water flushing unit to the distribution manifolds. Clean the network loop by loop until perfectly clear water is obtained. Do not use aggressive acids, which attack stainless steel exchangers and destroy the protective passivation films.
- Technical upgrade of the boiler roomInstall on the main return a sludge separator fitted with a removable neodymium magnetic rod. Connect a volumetric water meter on the filling line to accurately trace the volumes added.
- Reconditioning and commissioning recordFill the circuit with demineralised water complying with the requirements of the Suissetec guidelines, with minimal residual conductivity. Record the pH and conductivity values and the meter reading in the maintenance log before signature by both parties.
When sludge deposits cause the thermal failure of a compact exchanger, the absence of initial records puts the installer at technical fault. Only the systematic recording of filling analyses and the monitoring of make-up water can prove that the installation was delivered and maintained according to the rules of the trade.
Frequently asked questions
What are the risks of filling a heating system with raw drinking water?
Filling a closed circuit with mains water without prior treatment causes two major kinds of damage. Firstly, limescale precipitates under the effect of heat on the thin walls of the exchanger, forming a thermal insulator that degrades efficiency. Secondly, dissolved oxygen and minerals trigger rapid electrochemical corrosion of ferrous metals, generating abrasive magnetite sludge that blocks the circulation pumps.
Why install a magnetic separator rather than a strainer filter?
A standard strainer filter retains only coarse particles and clogs quickly, creating critical pressure losses without stopping microparticles. The magnetic sludge separator uses the slowing of the water stream to settle heavy sludge and captures microscopic iron oxides thanks to a powerful magnetic rod. Maintenance takes a few minutes without draining the circuit, simply by withdrawing the magnet and opening the flush valve.
Should softening or demineralisation of the circuit water be preferred?
The technical choice depends on the installed output, the water volume and the Suissetec guidelines. Softening replaces limescale with sodium without lowering the overall mineral salt content: conductivity stays high and promotes corrosion. Demineralisation removes all dissolved minerals, neutralising the electrical conductivity of the water. It is recommended for modern multi-metal installations fitted with heat pumps and compact exchangers.
Why systematically record make-up water volumes?
Fitting a sub-meter on the filling disconnector makes it possible to verify the tightness of the closed circuit. Any make-up above a few percent of the total volume per year signals an anomaly: pressure loss in the expansion vessel or a micro-leak in the network. Recording these volumes in the boiler-room log relieves the installer of responsibility by demonstrating abnormal operation in the event of a technical dispute with the client.
Texts and standards cited
- CO art. 368client's rights in case of defects in the work
