Key takeaways
- Rigorous sizing in accordance with standard SIA 384/1 avoids the pitfall of unnecessary reserve capacity.
- An oversized machine multiplies short cycles and places excessive stress on the mechanical components of the refrigeration compressor.
- Each compressor start generates a peak in electrical current and disrupts the lubricating oil film.
- Repeated transient phases cause the seasonal coefficient of performance to collapse by preventing optimal thermal operating conditions.
The mechanics of short cycling and the multiplication of starts
In the field, the temptation to "add a safety margin" or to choose the nominal output of the next model up remains a common reflex. For a building whose calculated heat load is 9 kW, installing a 14 kW generator on the pretext of guaranteeing comfort in severe cold is nevertheless a serious technical fault. The output required by a building only reaches its nominal value for a few hours a year, during the harshest outdoor temperatures set for the local climate station. For the rest of the heating season, the heat demand fluctuates between 20% and 50% of this maximum value.
The nominal heat load of a building or building zone must be determined room by room using the recognised calculation method, without adding flat-rate supplements that are not justified by transmission and ventilation heat losses.
norme SIA 384/1
When an oversized heat pump starts up in the mid-season, the minimum heat output fed into the hydraulic network far exceeds the instantaneous absorption capacity of the emitters. Even with Inverter technology, the modulation range has a lower limit, generally between 25% and 35% of the compressor's maximum speed. Below this technical threshold, the machine operates in on/off mode. The water flow setpoint is reached in only three to four minutes. The controller then switches off the compressor, before switching it back on as soon as the circuit water has released its heat into a volume of water that is often too small. This phenomenon is called short cycling.
| Operating criterion | Correctly sized machine (standard SIA 384/1) | Oversized machine (+40%) |
|---|---|---|
| Heat output delivered | Continuous modulation at 30% | Lower modulation limit exceeded |
| Average cycle duration | 45 to 90 minutes continuous | 4 to 8 minutes (on/off) |
| Starts per 24 hours | 10 to 20 starts | 80 to 150 starts |
| Water temperature stability | Linear operation matched to the heating curve | Sawtooth oscillations of 4 to 8 K |
Degraded COP, mechanical wear of the compressor and discomfort
The compressor of a heat pump is a precision component whose theoretical service life exceeds 15 to 20 years, provided it operates under steady-state conditions. At each start, the electric motor draws a high inrush current that heats the stator windings. From a tribological point of view, the bearings and scrolls undergo a phase of dry or mixed friction during the first seconds of rotation, until the oil pump has restored hydrodynamic pressure. At the same time, abrupt movements of liquid refrigerant can flush the crankcase and dilute the synthetic oil, accelerating abrasion of the mechanical bearing surfaces.
The degraded coefficient of performance is the direct energy penalty of this situation. The thermodynamic refrigeration cycle takes between six and ten minutes to balance its evaporation and condensation pressures, stabilise the superheat at the electronic expansion valve and reach its nominal efficiency. If the controller cuts the power after five minutes of operation, the machine spends all of its running time in an unstable transient state. The seasonal coefficient of performance collapses by 15% to 25% compared with the data certified on the test bench, generating direct excess electricity consumption for the end customer.
- Load throttling and transient operation
- Operating period following start-up during which the expansion valve and evaporator fail to establish a stable superheat, limiting the thermodynamic efficiency of the refrigerant.
Discomfort for the user completes this picture of degraded operation. Pulses of heat injected at high temperature into distribution networks designed for low temperature cause mechanical expansion knocking in the risers and emitters. In the rooms, the room control struggles to compensate for these periodic heat surges, producing setpoint overshoots followed by a feeling of cold walls. A well-chosen heat generator should run for as long as possible at moderate output, ensuring acoustic comfort and component longevity.
Hydraulic impacts in the plant room and limits of the compensating buffer volume
When a generator delivers a heat output far greater than the building's instantaneous heat losses, the imbalance is not confined to the refrigeration circuit. The distribution hydraulics immediately suffer the repercussions of this oversizing. To dissipate the minimum output of an over-powered compressor without reaching the cut-off temperature within a few minutes, the network has to carry a very high volumetric water flow. If the secondary network – made up of radiators or underfloor heating loops – regulates by progressively closing thermostatic valves or electrothermal actuators, the available flow collapses. The temperature rise between flow and return becomes abrupt, precipitating the machine's shutdown.
Faced with this phenomenon, the common reflex in the field is to insert a heating water accumulator, commonly called a buffer tank or hydraulic decoupling. While the accumulator artificially lengthens the compressor's running time by storing the surplus heat, it does not correct the root cause of the problem. Using a decoupling bottle or a four-connection tank with an over-powered generator frequently destroys thermal stratification: because the primary and secondary flows are unbalanced, the return to the heat pump warms up prematurely through internal mixing, which impairs the instantaneous efficiency.
| Operating criterion | Generator sized at 100% of heat losses | Generator oversized at 160% of heat losses |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum modulated output | Matched to actual needs from 25 to 30% load | Above actual needs down to 0 °C outdoors |
| Average cycle duration | More than 35 minutes of continuous operation | Less than 8 minutes without a large buffer tank |
| Flow temperature stability | Sliding water temperature in line with the heating curve | Recurrent setpoint overshoots of 3 to 6 K |
| Hydraulic behaviour | Stable flow, circulator modulated at nominal operating point | Throttling at the valves and whistling in the radiators |
| Auxiliary consumption | Circulators synchronised with the demanded output | Excess consumption due to high flow rates and closely spaced cycles |
Rational sizing in accordance with standard SIA 384/1 and choice of the bivalence point
The design of a durable thermal installation rests on strict application of standard SIA 384/1, which governs the calculation of the nominal heat load of buildings in Switzerland. This document requires a room-by-room calculation that includes transmission through opaque and glazed walls, geometric and structural thermal bridges, and heat losses through hygienic air renewal or infiltration. No arbitrary safety margin may be applied to the final result. The nominal heat output obtained corresponds to the peak requirement at the local reference outdoor temperature (for example -8 °C in Geneva, -10 °C in Lausanne or -11 °C in La Chaux-de-Fonds).
For an air-to-water heat pump, the anchor point of the sizing is not to cover the entire nominal load with the compressor alone under extreme conditions, but to determine the bivalence point judiciously. In French-speaking Switzerland's climatic conditions, selecting a thermodynamic output covering 90 to 100% of the load calculated in accordance with standard SIA 384/1 without a back-up ensures stable operation throughout the winter. A staged electric back-up or a bivalent integration with an existing boiler takes care of the few days below the design temperature, avoiding paying for a disproportionate compressor that will spend 98% of its time at critical part load.
- Drawing up the heat load calculation in accordance with standard SIA 384/1 without any blanket comfort surcharge.
- Checking the compressor's minimum modulation range at +7 °C outdoors against the building's part load.
- Checking the water content of the installation to guarantee defrost times without a thermal drop in the network.
- Precise adjustment of the slope and offset of the heating curve on the weather-compensated controller.
- Hydraulic balancing of the risers and distribution loops to ensure the nominal flow through the heat exchanger.
Corrective measures and technical decision-making on an oversized installation
In a plant room where an oversized heat pump is already in service, the team leader or technician must stabilise operation to halt premature compressor wear. The first step is to extract the data from the controller: note the ratio between running hours and the number of starts. A healthy machine makes fewer than three starts per hour in the mid-season. If the counter shows more than six to ten starts per hour, the diagnosis of short cycling is confirmed.
The immediate action concerns the electronic load management. For an inverter machine, the parameter setting consists in limiting the compressor's maximum frequency in heating mode in order to cap the peak output. On on/off generators or inverter units controlled by a thermal loop, the switching hysteresis should be increased or the degree-minutes threshold on the heating curve widened. This setting forces a longer off time and lengthens the running time of each cycle, avoiding repeated shocks to the scroll mechanism.
If the software limitation proves insufficient to absorb the excess heat output, hydraulic adaptation becomes unavoidable. Adding a heat accumulator in series on the return or as a decoupling bottle increases the overall inertia of the circuit. The useful water volume must then be recalculated to guarantee a minimum running time of ten to fifteen minutes per cycle, even with the thermostatic valves of the distribution network closed by two thirds.
When operating faults cause continuous high-pressure trips or a degraded coefficient of performance that cannot be recovered, responsibility for the design is engaged. The heat output must be recalculated rigorously in accordance with standard SIA 384/1 to quantify the deviation from the actual requirement. Under art. 368 CO, the client may assert the rights attached to defects, which notably open the way to rectification of the installation or a reduction in price if the generator does not meet the intended operating requirements.
Frequently asked questions
How do you identify abnormal short cycling during a call-out in a plant room?
Consult the controller history. Divide the compressor's total running time by its number of starts. If the average cycle duration falls below ten minutes during moderate heating periods, the unit is short cycling. In the field, a machine that starts, rises abruptly to its setpoint temperature in four minutes and then stops for twenty minutes is delivering a minimum output greater than the building's current heat losses.
Does an inverter compressor completely eliminate the risk of oversizing?
No. Even with a modulating compressor, the minimum modulation range is generally between 20% and 30% of the maximum nominal output. If an 18 kW heat pump is installed for an actual need of 8 kW, its floor output hardly drops below 4.5 kW. When the building demands only 2 kW in the mid-season, the machine modulates to its minimum and is then forced into frequent stops and restarts.
Why does the degradation of the coefficient of performance increase the electricity bill?
At each start, the compressor draws a large inrush current and must establish the necessary pressure differences in the refrigeration circuit. During the first three minutes of a cycle, the refrigerant does not reach its nominal thermodynamic state and the heat exchanger runs at low efficiency. The multiplication of these transient phases lowers the overall seasonal coefficient of performance, which causes direct excess electricity consumption for a reduced heating service.
Can an over-powered heat pump be compensated by increasing the circulator flow rate?
Increasing the primary flow at the circulator avoids safety cut-outs by the high-pressure switch by dissipating the output more quickly into the circuit. However, this practice increases the flow velocity, upsets the hydraulic balancing of the radiators or underfloor heating and generates acoustic whistling at the valve bodies. Moreover, it does not solve the overall excess of energy: the water volume rises too quickly in temperature and the compressor cuts out anyway.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 384/1Heating installations in buildings - Calculation of the nominal heat load
- CO art. 368client's rights in the event of defects in the work: refusal, price reduction, rectification, damages; any clause agreed in advance that restricts or excludes the right to rectification of defects is void if the defect concerns a construction (para. 2bis, since 1 January 2026)
