Key takeaways
- MoPEC sets the minimum insulation thickness according to the outside diameter of the distribution pipes.
- A single uninsulated DN 50 valve loses as much heat as one metre of bare pipe.
- Preformed boxes and removable thermal jackets allow quick maintenance without destroying the insulation.
- Pipe supports require rigid intermediate shells to stop the metallic thermal bridge.
MoPEC requirements and statutory thicknesses in boiler rooms
In heating distribution, a boiler room or an unheated basement suffers permanent heat losses if the pipework is not fully insulated. The Model Energy Provisions of the Cantons (MoPEC) impose strict requirements limiting heat losses for any new installation or thermal renovation. The aim is to prevent the plant room from becoming an uncontrolled passive radiator, to the detriment of the overall efficiency of the heat generator.
| Nominal diameter (DN) | Outside pipe diameter (mm) | Minimum insulation thickness (mm) |
|---|---|---|
| DN 10 to DN 15 | ≤ 22 mm | 30 mm |
| DN 20 to DN 32 | 23 to 35 mm | 40 mm |
| DN 40 to DN 50 | 36 to 60 mm | 50 mm |
| DN 65 to DN 80 | 61 to 90 mm | 60 mm |
| DN 100 to DN 150 | 91 to 168 mm | 80 mm |
| > DN 150 | > 168 mm | 100 mm |
These thicknesses apply to black steel, stainless steel or copper pipes running through unheated rooms. If the selected insulation has a higher thermal conductivity than the reference value of 0.035 W/(m·K), the installed thickness must be recalculated and increased to achieve an equivalent thermal resistance. In practice, on central heating construction sites, rigid rock wool shells with a cross-hatched aluminium vapour barrier or closed-cell elastomer foam sleeves are mostly used.
For pipe fixing, supports with a pre-integrated hard shell make it possible to keep the nominal insulation thickness along the entire underside of the pipe. The peripheral joint between the support shell and the straight sleeve must be closed with a pure reinforced aluminium adhesive to ensure continuous mechanical and thermal sealing.
Insulating flanges, valves and penetrations: treating the singular points
The finding on operating central heating installations is recurrent: metres of straight pipe are carefully insulated under sheet metal or aluminium, while isolating valves, non-return valves, strainers and flanges remain completely bare. These massive components in grey cast iron, brass or steel act as genuine cooling fins by convection and radiation.
- Equivalent loss length
- Ratio expressing the heat loss of a singular point (valve, flange, pump) converted into metres of uninsulated straight pipe of the same diameter.
An uninsulated DN 50 flanged valve operating on a water temperature of 70 °C gives off a heat output equivalent to that of about 1.5 metres of bare pipe of the same diameter. Compared with a pipe insulated according to MoPEC requirements, leaving a single valve bare causes as much annual heat loss as twenty to thirty linear metres of perfectly insulated network. On a distribution manifold comprising about ten valves, mixing valves and coupling flanges, the losses amount to several hundred watts continuously dissipated for no purpose.
- Allow space for dismantling when installing the pipesMaintain a minimum clearance of 80 mm between the outsides of adjacent pipes so that the shells can be slipped on and the valve insulation boxes closed.
- Fit removable boxes or flexible jacketsFit on each valve body or strainer a rigid preformed polyurethane shell with a protective casing, or a flexible thermal insulating jacket closed with hook-and-loop strips and straps.
- Insulate the connection flangesWrap all pairs of flanges of meters or air separators in suitable insulating covers to avoid a break in thickness at the bolted joints.
- Treat the passage of operating spindlesCut the insulation as closely as possible around the valve neck without blocking the handwheel or covering the stuffing boxes and pressure measuring points.
The use of made-to-measure flexible jackets or removable modular boxes allows the operator and the technician to check stuffing boxes, bleed or service strainers without damaging the insulation. From acceptance of the work, the thermal compliance check covers the complete closure of the network, with no exposed metal zone between the generator and the zone branches.
Surface losses of bare components: the real balance of a boiler room
On a boiler room construction site, it is common to finish insulating the straight pipes while postponing the cladding of the valves and fittings. This difference in execution seriously degrades the overall efficiency of the network. Because of its complex geometry and large metal mass, a valve body, a strainer or a pair of flanges works like a finned heat exchanger. Its contact surface with the ambient air is far greater than that of a tubular section of the same length.
In an unheated boiler room inadvertently kept above 25 °C by the radiation of manifolds and valves, the wasted energy contributes nothing to the comfort of the occupied rooms. According to the MoPEC modules adopted in cantonal energy legislation, distribution components, valves and fittings, pumps and flanges must be insulated in the same way as straight pipes. Leaving these elements bare turns the plant room into an overheated volume and cancels a substantial part of the gains obtained by replacing a heat generator.
| Nominal diameter (DN) | Straight pipe 100 % insulated to MoPEC (W/m) | Bare pair of flanges (W) | Bare control or isolating valve (W) | Linear equivalence in insulated pipe |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DN 32 (1" 1/4) | 11 | 38 | 55 | 5.0 m of insulated pipe |
| DN 50 (2") | 13 | 58 | 85 | 6.5 m of insulated pipe |
| DN 65 (2" 1/2) | 15 | 76 | 115 | 7.6 m of insulated pipe |
| DN 80 (3") | 17 | 95 | 145 | 8.5 m of insulated pipe |
| DN 100 (4") | 20 | 130 | 195 | 9.7 m of insulated pipe |
To guarantee the accessibility required during maintenance, bleeding or gasket replacement, the insulation of valves and fittings cannot be sealed in a destructive manner. Use rigid preformed shells in expanded polypropylene (EPP), pre-insulated aluminium sheet boxes lined with mineral wool, or quilted flexible covers fitted with hook-and-loop strips and tightening straps. These devices allow removal without a sharp tool and immediate refitting by the service fitter.
Supports, clamps and wall penetrations: treating the thermal bridge break
The effectiveness of insulation relies on the perfect continuity of the insulating barrier. The most common execution error in boiler rooms is to fix a metal clamp directly onto the steel or copper pipe, then butt the insulation on either side of this clamp. The threaded rod anchored to the ceiling or fixed to a steel section bracket then forms a continuous conductive thermal fin, dissipating the heat of the heat transfer fluid straight into the supporting structure of the building.
To eliminate these repeated localised losses along the distribution networks, the heating fitter must insert clamps fitted with insulating load-bearing shells. These rigid rings, made of high-density polyurethane foam or cellular glass insensitive to compression, support the weight of the water-filled pipework without crushing the insulation. The main insulating lining is then connected tightly against the load-bearing shell, ensuring an uninterrupted jacket.
- Selecting rigid insulating clampsChoose load-bearing blocks that are vapour-diffusion tight, sized to take the linear load of the water-filled pipe according to its nominal diameter, while maintaining an insulation thickness compliant with MoPEC requirements.
- Fitting and bonding on the pipeworkPosition the half support shells at the threaded rods. Make the joint with the adjacent insulating sleeve by bonding with elastomer adhesive or by reinforced aluminised taping, leaving no air gap.
- Treating penetrations through slabs and wallsPass the thermal insulation through the opening without reducing its cross-section. Where the wall requires fire resistance according to AEAI directives, combine the thermal sleeve with an approved fire-stopping system compatible with the nature of the insulation.
- Checking hydraulic expansionCheck that the guide points and fixed points do not exert any mechanical tearing on the insulating jacket during the cycles of rising and falling heating water temperature.
Treating partition penetrations requires careful coordination between the heating installer and the fire-stopping applicator. All too often, the thermal insulation is interrupted flush with the concrete so that the annular space can be filled with standard mortar or sealant, recreating a massive thermal bridge. The insulating sleeve must pass right through the building element. Smoke tightness and fire resistance are then ensured by non-combustible mineral shells or intumescent collars suited to the actual outside diameter of the insulated pipe.
Acceptance, non-conformities and remedying singular points in boiler rooms
During the acceptance inspection of a boiler room, the absence of insulation on isolating components, strainers or bolted joints is a frequent non-conformity with regard to MoPEC. An uninsulated DN 65 flange loses as much energy as one linear metre of bare pipe, cancelling the effectiveness of the standard insulation. The project manager or site foreman must act methodically when these shortcomings are noted by site management or the appointed agent.
- Reporting geometric obstructionsIf the layout imposed by the plans does not allow the required insulation thickness to be installed around the flanges or on the valve handles, notify the situation in writing to site management. Under art. 365 para. 3 CO, the contractor immediately informs the client of any circumstance that jeopardises the proper execution of the work.
- Treating clamps and supports without breaksFor direct supports creating a thermal bridge, replace bare metal clamps with rigid polyurethane or high-density rock wool shells with a load-distribution shell, ensuring the continuity of the insulating jacket without crushing the material.
- Implementing removable solutionsOn valves, non-return valves and circulators requiring maintenance access, fit quilted flexible covers closed with straps or removable aluminium sheet insulation boxes fitted with toggle latches, adjusting the cut-outs for the spindle stems.
- Recording rectifications and checksCarry out a joint check of each fitted component with the technical manager, then record the clearing of the reservations in the site diary before the official commissioning of the installation.
Do not tolerate any thermal bridge at wall penetrations or metal brackets. Where the standard thicknesses do not fit, the use of compact high-thermal-performance insulating composites avoids rebuilding the pipework while achieving the equivalent thermal resistance required by cantonal energy regulations.
Frequently asked questions
How do you insulate a butterfly valve between flanges when space is lacking?
When the clearance between flanges and walls is too narrow for a rigid shell, apply made-to-measure flexible insulating jackets lined with mineral wool or microporous aerogel strips fixed with staples. This method makes it possible to meet the thermal resistance requirement without blocking the lever linkage or the motorised actuator. Make sure the spindle remains fully operable.
What insulation thickness should be fitted on a flange according to MoPEC?
The MoPEC requirements impose insulating valves, flanges and fittings with a thermal efficiency identical to that of the adjacent pipe. If the pipe requires an insulation thickness of forty to sixty millimetres depending on its diameter, the removable box or removable jacket covering the flange must have an equivalent thermal resistance over its entire peripheral surface.
Is a support clamp welded onto the pipe admissible in a boiler room?
No, a flat bar welded directly onto the hot fluid pipe passes through the insulation and forms a continuous cooling fin towards the framework or the wall. MoPEC and the recognised rules prohibit this practice. The fixing requires a clamp mounted on a rigid insulating sleeve with a thermal break, transferring the mechanical loads to the support without piercing the insulating barrier.
What should be done if fire-rated wall penetrations prevent continuous insulation?
At a fire-rated wall penetration, conventional thermal insulation cannot always pass through the separating element. An approved fire-stopping system compatible with the pipe diameter should be used, completed by certified collars. The heating insulation is then tightly connected on either side of the partition without leaving any bare steel.
Texts and standards cited
- CO art. 365material and land: the contractor is responsible for the good quality of the material he supplies; if the material supplied by the client or the land designated by him is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work, he must immediately inform the client, failing which he bears the consequences (para. 3).
