Key takeaways
- Any blistering on a mineral screed is presumed to result from excess moisture trapped under the impermeable film.
- The absence of a prior moisture measurement deprives the tradesperson of any recourse against the screed layer.
- The SIA 118 standard requires full rework of the surface as soon as a loss of adhesion is found.
- An immediate written notice reporting that the admissible threshold has been exceeded formally releases the painter from all liability.
The physics of blistering and the trap of contractual liability
Applying a film-forming coating or a resin on a mineral floor creates an almost impermeable barrier to water vapour diffusion. When the concrete or flowing screed substrate retains a fraction of free water above the tolerances permitted by the paint manufacturer, thermal gradients cause moisture to migrate towards the interface. This trapped water builds up pressure, dissolves residual mineral salts and generates osmotic or gas pressure. The film lifts, forming blisters under tension that eventually burst under foot traffic or the passage of trolleys.
The contractor is liable for the quality of the work. If the work has defects that make it unfit for its intended use or significantly reduce its value, the client may demand its rectification free of charge, as well as compensation for the consequential damage.
Norme SIA 118
In legal and contractual terms, the building painter's task is neither to produce the screed nor to judge its mix, which are the screed layer's responsibilities. However, the painter applies the finish on a substrate that he has a professional obligation to check. Under the general principles of the Code of Obligations and the SIA 118 standard, a tradesperson who starts work without formal reservations is deemed to have accepted the substrate as it stands. If blistering occurs three weeks after acceptance, the appointed experts systematically conclude that there was an adhesion defect due to moisture incompatibility. Without written evidence predating the work, the painter bears the entire damage.
The duty to notify is not a mere formality. It is the technical act that proves the tradesperson exercised professional diligence. Faced with a compressed schedule, the painter who finds a screed that is still too fresh must suspend his work and immediately warn site management. Failing such notification, the SIA 118 standard puts the tradesperson at fault: he applied an impermeable system on an unstabilised substrate, causing the failure of his own work.
The moisture-reading protocol and the extent of rework at the painter's expense
To protect against a destructive loss, the team leader or foreman must build the moisture reading into the routine for opening a construction site. The measurement takes only two minutes when carried out with a surface capacitive moisture meter for the initial survey, supplemented if necessary by a dielectric probe or a carbide measurement carried out in coordination with the screed layer. This reading must be recorded on a dated self-inspection sheet countersigned by site management.
- Checking the technical thresholdsConsult the technical data sheet of the floor primer. Epoxy or polyurethane systems generally require a residual moisture content below 4 % by mass on concrete or cement screed, and below 0.5 % on anhydrite screed.
- Joint measurement at critical areasTest at least three points per fifty square metres, focusing on the thickest areas, cold corners and the surroundings of floor drains.
- Drawing up the recordEnter the raw measured values, the ambient temperature, the dew point and the substrate temperature on the self-inspection form. Have the foreman or site management sign it.
- Serving the notice of non-compliant substrateIf the values exceed the supplier's tolerances, refuse to apply by official letter or email to the site supervisor, specifying the risks of blistering and total loss of adhesion.
| Situation on the construction site | Substrate status | Allocation of rework under the SIA 118 standard |
|---|---|---|
| Compliant reading recorded and countersigned | Substrate validated jointly | Warranty shared or shifted to a later, unforeseeable ingress of water. |
| Reading above threshold with written notice of refusal | Substrate declared non-compliant | Full release of the tradesperson; rework at the client's expense if he forced the application. |
| No written reading before painting | Substrate presumed unchecked | Full liability of the painter for the entire loss. |
When blistering becomes widespread, rework is never limited to a local touch-up. On a floor paint, a spot repair remains visible and presents a permanent weakness in mechanical anchorage. Site management therefore requires the blistered film to be stripped completely by shot blasting or mechanical planing, the residues to be fully vacuumed, a reinforced moisture barrier to be laid and a complete new system to be applied. The tradesperson at fault bears not only these heavy operations, but also the ancillary costs of handling equipment, any relocation of activities and the downtime of the premises.
Formal notification for a damp substrate: put the notice in writing before applying
As soon as the measuring instrument shows a value incompatible with the planned resin or paint system, the construction site must stop. Continuing the application in the hope of spontaneous evaporation through the film is a direct technical fault. Under the duty to notify that falls on the painter under the Code of Obligations, any anomaly found in the condition of the slab or screed must be reported in writing to the client or to site management.
A simple oral remark made during a visit to the construction site has no legal value in the event of later damage. The joint document must be drawn up immediately on site, completed with the raw measured values, the precise location of the test points and the signature of both parties. If site management nevertheless orders the painting to be carried out to keep to the handover schedule, that written order formally releases the tradesperson from the consequences of the blistering.
| File item | Construction site without joint moisture reading | Construction site with dated protocol and formal notice |
|---|---|---|
| Proof of substrate compliance | None. The substrate is deemed to have been accepted by the painter without reservation. | Documented. The measured values and the initial condition are recorded and countersigned. |
| Classification of the blistering | Execution defect attributed to the painting company (poor preparation or unsuitable choice). | Defect inherent in the structural work or insufficient drying of the screed, attributable to another trade. |
| Responsibility for rework | Entirely the painter's: sanding, chemical stripping or shot blasting and a new coat at his expense. | Released if a written order to paint was issued, or suspended until drying is confirmed. |
| Handling of the interruption | Potential delay penalties and work performed at a loss. | Legitimate extension of time recorded in the site minutes. |
- Mark the readings on the planNote the moisture percentages measured at critical points, particularly along buried walls, at cold corners and near floor drain traps.
- Draft the notice of anomalyState the manufacturer's data sheet, the maximum tolerated threshold for the bonding primer and the technical refusal to apply without prior drying.
- Have the inspection sheet countersignedObtain the endorsement of site management on the daily report, or send the document by registered mail with a time-stamped electronic copy.
Warranty, acceptance and allocation of costs under the SIA 118 standard
The management of warranties and contractual liability is governed by the SIA 118 standard. At the acceptance of the work, the client examines the condition of the floors. However, the osmotic phenomenon and the pressure of water vapour trapped under an epoxy resin or a polyurethane often take several months to cause blistering delamination. The defect therefore often appears during the period for notifying defects, giving rise to a right to free rectification for the client if the applicator is at fault.
When the expert report concludes that there was excess moisture in the concrete at the time of application, the absence of an initial protocol puts the painter on the front line. In construction law, the tradesperson is presumed responsible for the substrate on which he lays his finish, unless he proves he carried out all the usual checks. The extent of rework is never limited to a spot repair of the burst blisters. The presence of interstitial water implies the failure of the entire floor build-up.
Case law and the practice of arbitral tribunals under the SIA 118 standard confirm that a contractor cannot exonerate himself by claiming that the site supervisor knew the moisture content of the slab. Checking the compatibility between the coating and its substrate falls within the painter's specific area of competence. Only material proof of a compliant prior measurement, or the service of a notice of interruption formally overridden by a written order from site management, allows the financial responsibility for demolition and rework to be avoided.
Loss declared: managing the dispute and limiting the rework
When blistering appears after handover, site management immediately invokes the warranty governed by the SIA 118 standard. The demand follows: strip the entire floor covering and redo everything at the painter's sole expense. Faced with this claim, panic often leads to urgent intervention without prior analysis, which amounts to an implicit admission of liability for the entire loss.
- Immediate joint inspection recordSummon site management to the site before any mechanical intervention. Document precisely the shape of the blisters, their exact location and the possible presence of liquid under the film. Take pieces of resin to check the failure plane: a cohesive failure tearing out concrete proves a degraded substrate, whereas a clean delamination points to osmotic pressure or residual moisture underneath.
- Gathering the documented evidenceRetrieve the dated and signed moisture reading taken before application and recorded in the site diary. If a written notice of non-compliant substrate was served under the Code of Obligations before application, your position is legally supported. This document shows that the client or his representative maintained the order to apply while formally aware of the risk of later defects.
- Defining the extent of reworkContest the reprofiling of sound surfaces. The extent of rework at your expense must be limited to the areas that have actually delaminated and their direct perimeter of compromised adhesion. If the absence of waterproofing under the slab is established, laying a vapour barrier falls under the structural work or the screed, and not under a standard painting service owed without payment.
With no prior joint reading at all, the painter's contractual position becomes very hard to defend. He then bears the complete restoration of the floor, including mechanical sanding, industrial vacuuming and reapplication. The only lever left is technical negotiation to limit the treatment to the affected bays and to avoid replacement of the entire surface without compensation.
Frequently asked questions
What should you do if the client refuses to sign the moisture reading before application?
If site management refuses to sign the joint reading, immediately record the measured values, the date, the time and the method used in the daily site report. Send this document the same day by email with acknowledgement of receipt or by registered mail, stating that the values exceed the admissible threshold. Suspend the floor painting work until a formal written order to proceed has been served on you.
Who bears the cost of sanding to strip a blistered floor paint?
If the painter applied the product without carrying out or recording a prior moisture measurement, the costs of heavy sanding, planing and waste removal fall entirely on him under the warranty according to the SIA 118 standard. On the other hand, if a written notice of non-compliant substrate was sent and validated before the work, these preparatory operations can be invoiced as additional work to the client or to the package responsible for the screed.
Does a sealed plastic sheet test have legal value in a dispute?
The test with a polyethylene sheet taped down for twenty-four hours is an indicative method recognised on construction sites in French-speaking Switzerland for detecting surface condensation. However, in the event of a court-appointed expert opinion or arbitration under the SIA 118 standard, only a quantitative measurement by the destructive carbide method or by a relative-humidity probe sealed in the concrete provides indisputable probative evidence to release the painting company from liability in the face of a residual moisture problem.
Can premises downtime costs be claimed during rework for blistering?
The client may try to charge loss of operations or relocation costs linked to the downtime of the floor area to be reworked. However, within the contractual framework of the SIA 118 standard, the contractor's primary obligation is to rectify the defective work within a reasonable time. Indirect consequential damages are generally not admitted at the tradesperson's expense without proof of a serious fault distinct from a mere material or substrate defect.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work, acceptance of the work and warranty for defects
- COGeneral provisions on the contract for work, contractor's obligations and the duty to notify of defects in the substrate
