Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 272Substrate acceptance and diagnosis before paintingChapter 7 of 10 in the section

Cracks: opening, reinforcing, filling, and those that are not treated

Filling an active crack with a rigid filler guarantees it will quickly reappear under the finishing film. This chapter details the method for identifying whether a crack is stabilised or live, installing a monitoring tell-tale and applying the V-opening protocol with reinforcement. You will know exactly which defects to treat and which to refuse until the structural work has been consolidated.

Key takeaways

  • The SIA 257 standard requires identifying whether each crack in the substrate is stabilised or still moving.
  • A live crack requires a monitoring tell-tale to be fitted beforehand to measure its residual activity.
  • Treating a dead crack requires a continuous V-opening and the incorporation of a reinforcement.
  • Active structural cracks are a matter for masonry and must never receive a rigid filler.

Distinguishing the stabilised crack from the active crack on the substrate

Before applying any primer coat or picking up a filling knife, the house painter must make a precise diagnosis of every linear defect. The SIA 257 standard requires a methodical acceptance of substrates: the painter checks the cohesion, cleanliness, dryness and mechanical stability of the surfaces. A crack is never a mere visual surface defect; it reveals a break in continuity caused either by internal stresses in the material during setting, or by mechanical forces transmitted by the building structure.

Stabilised crack (dead)
Linear defect whose opening no longer changes over time. It results from a completed phenomenon, such as hydraulic shrinkage of a mineral binder, old desiccation or slight initial deflection after formwork removal.
Active crack (live)
Defect whose edges continue to move, opening, closing or shearing. This permanent movement stems from differential settlement of foundations, cyclic thermal expansion or excessive deflection of load-bearing slabs.

Filling an active crack with a rigid filling compound leads to immediate technical failure: the filler, lacking sufficient elasticity, will break at the next thermal cycle or with seasonal humidity variations. To determine the activity state of a suspect gap before starting the finishing work, fitting a monitoring tell-tale before the works is essential.

On-site analysis criteria according to crack behaviour
CharacteristicStabilised crack (dead)Active crack (live)
Main originDrying shrinkage of plaster, surface crazing, initial hydraulic shrinkage of concrete.Differential settlement, structural thermal expansion, vibration, mechanical overload.
Dimensional variationNone over an observation period of several weeks.Measurable opening, closing or offset depending on temperature or load.
Tell-tale behaviourThe plaster tell-tale or millimetre gauge remains perfectly intact.Clean break of the plaster pad or visible slip on the millimetre vernier.
Limit of intervention CFC 272Direct treatment by the painter: mechanical opening, priming and reinforced filling.Refusal of rigid filling; notification to the architect/project manager and possible flexible sealing.

V-opening protocol, reinforced bridging and limits of intervention

Once monitoring confirms that the crack is dead, the painter carries out a permanent repair. Surface filling without mechanical preparation is prohibited: it creates no key for the product and leaves friable edges that detach under the paint.

  1. Mechanical V-openingUsing a rigid triangular scraper, a sharp rasp or a plasterer's gouge, hollow out the crack edges along its entire length, giving it a flared V profile. The depth must reach the sound base of the substrate without creating square shoulders that trap air.
  2. Dust removal and consolidation of the baseBrush the groove vigorously with a hard bristle brush to remove all loose particles, then vacuum the residual dust. Apply a suitable fixative or fluid bonding primer to bind porous substrates and ensure adhesion.
  3. Initial filling and fitting the reinforcementFill the groove with a filling knife using a non-shrinking synthetic or mineral filling compound. Immediately embed in the fresh material a non-woven polyester reinforcing strip or a fibreglass tape, centred on the axis of the crack, without forming any fold or air pocket.
  4. Pressing and smoothing the finishCover the reinforcement with a second pass of smoothing compound, then press the blade firmly to restore an even plane flush with the adjacent surface of the substrate, with no visible excess thickness before light sanding.

Where a crack is recognised as active after tell-tale readings, the painter must on no account treat it with a rigid surfacing compound. If the tender specification requires a finish on this substrate without remedial structural work, the painter's intervention is strictly limited to creating a flexible sealing joint: clean opening with a blade, fitting a closed-cell polyethylene foam backing rod and injecting an elastomeric or polyurethane sealant compatible with water-based paints. Where the movement exceeds the elongation capacity of standard sealants, the defect is a matter for the load-bearing structure; the painter immediately records written reservations to site management and suspends the finishing work.

Instrumented monitoring: fitting and reading tell-tales before intervention

The initial visual examination and mechanical probing with a rasp are not always enough to determine whether a gap has finished stabilising or is still subject to residual stresses. Faced with a straight defect running through the plaster or along a junction of load-bearing elements, premature application of a repair mortar exposes the work to rapid failure of the finishing film. When an immediate diagnosis is uncertain, fitting a monitoring tell-tale before the works is required to measure the micrometric behaviour of the crack edges over a representative period.

  1. Preparing the tell-tale's baseClear the substrate of any flexible covering, wallpaper or flaking paint over a clean area of about ten square centimetres on either side of the crack. Dust the area with a dry brush and check that the mineral base has sufficient cohesion to anchor the measuring device without risk of surface tearing.
  2. Fitting the millimetre gauge or the plaster padFix a vernier monitoring gauge or bond a tell-tale of pure modelling plaster with a calibrated thickness of five millimetres, thinned at its centre. For a measuring gauge, plug or bond the two plates with a structural adhesive with no elastic recovery, so that the entire movement of the substrate is transferred to the reading grid.
  3. Initial reading and entry in the site diaryNote the date of fixing, the ambient temperature, the relative humidity of the room and the original vernier zero. Write these references directly next to the measuring device with an indelible marker to avoid any loss of traceability between two inspection visits.
  4. Interpreting the movement cyclesTake readings at regular intervals over a period of several weeks. A plaster tell-tale broken cleanly or a vernier variation exceeding two tenths of a millimetre confirms a live crack. A crack with no change in readings after the building has been heated again attests to a stabilised crack, ready to be cut out in a V and bridged.

The thermal factor plays a major role on recent structures or transition slabs. An active crack reacts to seasonal expansion differences or to the building's service loads. If the readings show a continuous alternation of openings and closings over the weeks, any rigid treatment with filler or standard calico tape will be sheared at the next cycle, causing the decorative system to detach.

Acceptance of the substrate under SIA 257 and transfer of responsibility

The contractor checks whether the substrate is clean, dry, grease-free and free of cracks that would compromise the performance of the coatings. If he finds anomalies or movements incompatible with carrying out the painting work, he informs site management in writing before starting application.

Norme SIA 257

The SIA 257 standard clearly sets the scope of action of the painter. The CFC 272 professional accepts plaster or masonry surfaces in order to apply a protective and aesthetic system; he is in no way authorised to correct defects belonging to the structural work or to structural connections. Blindly filling a live separation without formal notification transfers responsibility for future damage to the painter at the time of acceptance of the work.

Classification of cracks and limits of the painter's intervention
Tell-tale findingNature of the defectApplicable treatmentResponsible trade
Zero variation observed after a full cycleDead shrinkage crack or crazingV-cutting, dust removal, non-woven reinforced bridging and surfacing compoundPainter (CFC 272)
Low-amplitude cyclic variationControl joint or limited thermal movementElastomeric bridging sealant with elastic decoupling stripPainter (CFC 272) on written instruction
Progressive widening or flatness offsetActive structural crack or foundation settlementRefusal to fill, mechanical consolidation or prior staplingStructural work, plasterer (CFC 271) or civil engineer
Shear at partition-to-ceiling junctionsSlab deflection or absence of a decoupling jointCreation of a clean recessed joint or flexible painted jointDry-lining plasterer (CFC 271)

As soon as a monitoring tell-tale shows uncontrollable dynamic behaviour at the scale of a paint system, the foreman suspends operations in the affected area. A reasoned notice is sent to site management, recording the millimetre values observed and requesting the intervention of the civil engineer or the plastering contractor to stabilise the base before the primers are resumed.

Managing defects: remedies and protective measures for unforeseen reopening

When a crack reappears through a fresh paint film or a reinforced strip, the painter is facing a deep mechanical failure that smoothing products cannot arrest. If this defect appears during the work or during drying shrinkage, the foreman suspends the work on the bay concerned. Masking the opening with a heavy-bodied finishing coat or hasty filling aggravates the damage: the continuous movement of the substrate will inevitably tear the mineral or organic film.

The procedure calls for a joint inspection record to be drawn up with site management and the client's representative. The foreman records his reservations in writing, specifying the exact location, the orientation of the crack edge and the progressive nature of the break, in accordance with the rules of the SIA 118 standard and the provisions of the Code of Obligations. The notification requires the intervention of the plasterer for lightweight partition defects or of a civil engineer if the load-bearing masonry shows signs of shear.

  • Taking close-up photographs with a millimetre reference and measuring the moisture content of the substrate.
  • Sealing in a glass tell-tale or a graduated vernier gauge to objectively record the amplitude of lateral and vertical movements.
  • Formal stoppage of the finishing work on the cracked element until written instructions are received from the agent.

If site management nevertheless orders the finishing coats to continue without the structure being reinforced by the masonry or plastering contractors, the painter disclaims any warranty as to the durability of the film. Any treatment by elastic bridging or fibreglass tissue carried out under these conditions is a temporary masking solution, ordered under the sole responsibility of the principal.

Frequently asked questions

How should you react when a bridged crack reappears while the paint is drying?

The painter stops application on the wall concerned and informs site management. This early reappearance indicates that the substrate is subject to dynamic stresses exceeding the elasticity of the non-woven strip or the filler. The condition of the film should be photographed, the humidity checked and a monitoring tell-tale fitted. No closing coat must be reapplied before the formal opinion of the agent, in order to protect the contractor's rights.

Can the painter be held responsible for a recurring crack on plaster?

No, if the painter complied with the SIA 257 standard when accepting the substrate. Structural movements are a matter for the structural work or plastering trades. However, if the contractor filled an active crack without prior notification or without fitting a compliant reinforcement, his contractual liability may be engaged for lack of diligence. Issuing written reservations before carrying out the finishing system is his only legal protection against the client.

What is the minimum period required to monitor a doubtful crack?

A plaster tell-tale or a measuring gauge is ideally observed over several weeks in order to take in the building's thermal expansion cycles and humidity variations. On new construction sites, shrinkage movements of the concrete sometimes require extended monitoring. If the contractual programme requires a quick intervention, the painter states his reservations in writing: without sufficient time to qualify the crack as dead, the durability of the bridging cannot be certified.

Why prohibit traditional plaster filler on a through-crack?

Pure plaster has rigid mechanical strength with no residual elasticity. When it fills a through-crack subject to shear or settlement stresses, it fails brittly at the first micro-movement. Unlike fibre-reinforced synthetic filling compounds or plastic-elastic acrylic sealants, plaster absorbs no dynamic deformation. The fracture line is therefore instantly transmitted to the paint, ruining the appearance and the continuity of the substrate.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 257Painting, varnishing and wallpapering: requirements for acceptance of substrates, inspection of surfaces and conditions of application.
  • SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work: handling of notices of defects, notification of reservations and contractual liability.

In the same section