Key takeaways
- The painter accepts an agreed surface grade without correcting, free of charge, the shortcomings of the plastering trade.
- Any first coat applied amounts to tacit acceptance of the condition of the substrate and a full transfer of responsibility.
- The filling primer makes the background opaque but never replaces a complete levelling skim coat over defective surfaces.
- The written joint inspection record and the supplementary offer must precede the start of any corrective work.
The joint inspection record at acceptance: refusing the transfer of burden between trades
On a building construction site, the painter works immediately after the plastering crews. Under standard SIA 257, the painting company accepts a substrate in order to apply a system of primer, intermediate coat and finish, or a wall covering. It must on no account make good, free of charge, the shortcomings of the preceding tradesperson. The surface quality grade of the substrate is set by the contractual documents of the contract. When the delivered surface does not match the agreed technical specifications, site management sometimes tries to force the painter to compensate for local unevenness and smoothing defects through unpaid preparatory work.
- Quality grade agreed in the contract
- Finish level prescribed in the specification to define the fine flatness and surface appearance of the raw substrate before any painting.
The acceptance check is carried out by eye and in raking light before any painting equipment is unpacked. Plaster smears, rounded edges, hollows along the reinforcement tapes or coarse sanding scratches in the plaster must be recorded without delay. If the painters try to remove these defects by intensive unpaid sanding, they damage the protective paper of the plasterboard, create fibrous fluff and wrongly take on work that fell to the plastering trade.
Tacitly accepting a defective substrate engages the painter's civil and professional liability. As soon as the first primer coat is applied, the tradesperson is legally deemed to have approved the substrate. Texture defects, missing material or shadows revealed at acceptance of the work will be irrevocably attributed to them, with no possibility of recourse against the plasterer. Hours spent making up for a third party's shortcomings without prior financial agreement remain solely at the painting company's expense.
| Defect observed | Technical classification | Contractual allocation |
|---|---|---|
| Loose residual dust | Ordinary preparation under standard SIA 257 | At the painter's expense (CFC 272) |
| Board joints perceptible to the touch | Substrate levelling defect | To be redone by the plasterer (CFC 271) |
| Widespread micro-relief across the wall | Contractual grade not achieved | Extra cost for skim coat or remedial work CFC 271 |
Corrective skim coat and filling primer: formalise the extra cost before intervening
The technical distinction between a filling primer and a full-surface skim coat must remain perfectly clear to everyone involved. The filling primer, applied with a medium-pile roller or by mechanised spraying, regulates the porosity of the background and seals only the micro-pores of the substrate. It compensates neither for marked hollows nor for float waviness. A full skim coat consists of continuously surfacing the wall with a blade or stainless-steel trowel using a fine film-forming filler. This operation redefines the surface micro-texture and is a service distinct from ordinary painting work.
- Full-surface skim coat
- Continuous application of a film-forming filler with a blade over an entire substrate to correct its micro-relief before the finish is applied.
- Immediate joint inspection recordInspect the walls under raking light with site management and the plasterer before starting work on the construction site.
- Traceability of defectsDraw up a precise joint record stating the rooms, the surface quantities in square metres and the deviations found from the contract.
- Issuing the extra-cost notificationSubmit a priced supplementary offer for the full skim coat, detailing the unit cost and the direct impact on the delivery times of the work.
- Obtaining formal approvalSuspend painting until the change order or day-work slip has been signed by the client.
Before starting painting work, the contractor checks the condition of the substrates and reports without delay any defects that prevent flawless execution of their services.
norme SIA 257
A full-surface skim coat heavily alters the operational schedule of the finishing work. Complete application of filler with a blade requires a drying time of at least twenty-four hours before mechanical sanding with a pole sander under continuous extraction. Under standard SIA 118, any service not provided for in the original contract requires prior written notification to give entitlement to payment. The contractor draws up their quote per square metre or applies their day-work rates before starting the filler passes. If site management refuses the extra cost, it must instruct the plasterer to complete their work. Skim coating without a formal order amounts to paying out of your own pocket for the saving made by another trade.
Normal preparation under standard SIA 257 and full-surface skim coat
The opening of the painting work on the construction site often confronts the applicator with a recurring misunderstanding: confusing the ordinary preparatory work included in the unit prices of the tender with full remedial operations. Standard SIA 257 precisely defines the limits of the painter's basic services. These comprise dusting, light scraping, primer coat and spot filling of small isolated damage or minor fixing holes. In no case do these ordinary contractual services cover the generalised correction of smoothing defects or missing material left by the plasterer.
As soon as a substrate shows repeated edge misalignments, deep sanding scratches over large areas or a general relief incompatible with the satin or matt finish ordered, applying a simple filling primer by roller or airless pump is no longer enough. A filling primer is formulated to even out the absorption of the background and unify the micro-texture; it cannot make up for a lack of material thickness or the absence of continuous skim coating. Requiring the painter to compensate for these shortcomings without an addendum amounts to making them carry out, at their own expense, a finishing pass that originally belonged to the plastering trade.
| Operation on the construction site | Contractual classification | Allocation of the service | Technical means used |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spot filling of isolated chipped edges | Basic service (standard SIA 257) | Included in the painter's unit price | Filling knife, quick-setting filler paste |
| Application of a primer or filling primer | Contractual primer system | Included in the painter's specification | Textured polyamide roller or airless spray gun |
| Continuous skim coat on plasterboard | Variation work / extra cost | Invoiced separately or charged to the upstream trade | Wide smoothing blade (60 to 80 cm), fluid paste filler |
| Heavy sanding to level protruding joints | Remedial work on a defective work | Rejection of the substrate or approved day-work slip | Orbital long-reach sander, class M industrial extraction |
Notifying reservations and obtaining the addendum before execution
As soon as the painter applies their first impregnating or primer coat on a deficient substrate, they are deemed to have accepted the substrate as it stands. The client and site management can then rely on the absence of prior objection to make them solely responsible for all final visual imperfections. To neutralise this mechanism, the non-conformity finding must absolutely be made before the finishing materials are unpacked and must give rise to a detailed written notice, in accordance with the general rules of standard SIA 118.
- Visual inspection and recording of defectsInspect the walls under raking light similar to the future lighting conditions of the work. Note the precise extent of the areas where the surfacing work does not match the quality grade agreed in the contract. Document with clear photographs with millimetre reference marks.
- Drawing up the written list of reservationsWrite without delay a report addressed to site management. Describe the defect technically without passing value judgements: absence of continuous skim coating, widespread micro-porosity, protruding tape ghosting, incompatibility with the finish required under standard SIA 257.
- Producing a joint reference sample areaMark out a representative area on the construction site. Apply the system provided for in the contract on one half and the corrective skim coat followed by the paint system on the other half, to show the technical extra cost visually in the presence of site management.
- Issuing the variation quote and awaiting the written orderSubmit the supplementary offer stating the exact quantities and the description of the additional filler passes. Start the general skim coating only after the day-work slip or the addendum has been formally signed by site management or the client.
Handling the dispute: refusal of addendum and blockage on the construction site
When site management rejects the written notification of an extra cost and orders the painter to apply the first coat, the financial risk shifts entirely onto the tradesperson. The recurring argument of keeping to the schedule often masks an attempt to pass the cost of plastering rework onto the finishing work. Agreeing to proceed without written agreement means tacitly validating the substrate received and taking on responsibility for the final result, including tape ghosting, bubbles or surface roughness.
Faced with a refusal of an addendum for skim coating a substrate that does not meet the grade agreed in the contract, the foreman must formalise the situation unequivocally. Under the rules of standard SIA 257, the painter carries out only routine preparation, not corrective skim coating to make up for structural shortcomings. The procedure requires immediately halting the start of painting on the disputed walls and sending a detailed written finding to site management, accompanied by a precise photographic file taken under raking light.
- Record the stoppage of painting work on the affected areas in the daily site report.
- Send a reasoned notice stating the technical impossibility of achieving the contractual result without a prior skim coat.
- Call an urgent joint meeting on site with site management and the plasterer concerned.
- Demand a formal, approved service order before starting any application of filling primer or filler.
If site management demands painting despite the defects found and refuses the extra cost of skim coating, the company must formally disclaim any warranty as to flatness and final appearance, in accordance with the rules of the Code of Obligations (CO) and standard SIA 118. When the client orders additional skim coating work, this service is covered by a signed day-work slip or a priced addendum before the first pass of the blade. Failing written agreement, the painting trade remains suspended on the disputed surfaces until formal arbitration by site management.
Frequently asked questions
Can the painter hide the plasterer's defects with a simple filling primer?
The filling primer has a dry-film thickness that is insufficient to fill hollows, the sharp edges of reinforcement tapes or the missing material left by the plasterer. This product evens out the absorption of the background and softens slight crazing, but never corrects a geometric defect. Trying to build up a primer with a roller leads to unsightly excess thickness, runs and tensions that end up cracking under the finishing coats.
What does the painting company risk if it applies its first coat on a defective substrate?
By applying the primer coat without issuing prior written reservations, the painter tacitly accepts the substrate as it stands. From that moment, they relieve the plasterer of their contractual responsibility. If the client later disputes the flatness or visual appearance of the finished paint, the costs of sanding, full skim coating and complete redoing of the system will fall exclusively on the painting company, with no possible recourse against the upstream trades.
How should a skim coat made necessary by an insufficient quality grade be quantified and priced?
The painter measures the actual non-compliant surfaces during a joint survey. The pricing includes the initial mechanical sanding, dust removal, application of a fixative, skim coating with film-forming filler in crossed passes, then final finishing sanding. The estimate is made per square metre or in day-work hours according to Romandy practice, then forms the subject of a supplementary quote subject to a purchase order before any work starts.
Who must bear the cost of the corrective skim coat when the substrate is accepted?
The financial burden depends on the decision of site management. Either the plasterer comes back to redo their surfaces at their own expense to achieve the quality grade agreed in the contract, or the painter is commissioned by addendum to carry out this additional skim coat as an extra cost. In the latter case, site management generally charges the expense to the account of the plasterer at fault, without the painter having to suffer any deduction.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 257Painting, varnishing and interior and exterior wall coverings
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work
