Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 272Substrate acceptance and diagnosis before paintingChapter 3 of 10 in the section

Repainting over old paint: identifying the existing film, compatibility and stripping

Applying a water-based dispersion paint over an old glossy alkyd lacquer often leads to widespread peeling due to lack of adhesion. This chapter sets out the method prescribed by standard SIA 257 for identifying the binder in place, testing adhesion on a test area and defining the cases where complete stripping is required before any repainting.

Key takeaways

  • The solvent test immediately identifies a hard alkyd binder as opposed to a reversible acrylic dispersion.
  • Applying a dispersion paint directly over varnish or glossy alkyd paint causes adhesion failure through tension.
  • The test area with cross-hatch pattern according to standard SIA 257 validates adhesion before application.
  • A non-adherent paint film requires chemical stripping or complete sanding under controlled extraction.

Identifying the binder in place and diagnosing adhesion failure

On a renovation construction site, new paint falling off in continuous sheets almost always betrays an attempt to apply a water-based dispersion directly onto an alkyd enamel or glossy alkyd paint without any substrate preparation. Oil-based or alkyd lacquer polymerises into a dense, smooth, hydrophobic film with very little porosity. Conversely, as the acrylic dispersion dries it undergoes a volumetric shrinkage that creates strong internal mechanical stresses. With no mechanical key on the vitrified surface, the pulling stresses shear the interface and the film peels off in whole sections.

The condition and nature of the primer coats and of the existing paints must be examined before work begins. If doubts remain about the compatibility of the planned system with the old substrates, preliminary tests are required.

Standard SIA 257 (Painting, plaster and applied coatings)

Before starting the repair work, the painter must determine the exact chemical nature of the original paint film. The two main families encountered in older buildings react differently to chemical reagents and workshop solvents. A visual diagnosis remains misleading: only a methodical white-cloth protocol allows a formal determination of the film's composition.

  1. Solubility test with methylated spiritsRub the surface vigorously with a clean cloth soaked in denatured alcohol or ethanol for about twenty seconds. If the film softens, becomes tacky or transfers material onto the cloth, it is a vinyl or acrylic dispersion. If the film remains intact, hard and unmarked, it is a cross-linked binder of the alkyd, polyurethane or oil type.
  2. Strong solvent test (acetone or cellulose thinner)On the area unaffected by alcohol, rub with a pad soaked in acetone. An old alkyd paint (glycerophthalic) resists or dulls only very superficially without its structure dissolving, whereas a thermoplastic resin melts instantly under the action of the solvent.
  3. Checking compactness by scrapingScore the film with a painter's knife or a utility knife. An old, heavily oxidised oil paint fractures into brittle flakes, whereas a dispersion produces flexible shavings.

Compatibility test on a test area and execution of stripping

Where an old alkyd lacquer is sound and firmly adherent, applying a specific bonding primer is a technical alternative to complete stripping, provided the surface is sanded to remove the gloss and validated formally on a test area. Standard SIA 257 requires glossy surfaces to be fully matted and any trace of grease removed before painting.

Decision matrix according to the condition of the existing film
Condition of existing substratePreparation requiredRecommended systemValidation
Glossy alkyd paint, intact and adherentAbrade with P120 grit, careful dust removalBonding primer, water-based or solvent-based1 m² test area and cross-hatch test
Flaking or chalking alkyd paintRemoval of non-adherent parts, mechanical sandingSubstrate fixative, then intermediate coatTape pull-off check
Blistered dispersion over old lacquerComplete stripping of the dispersion and the unstable substrateBaring of the original substrate, renewal of the complete systemAcceptance of the substrate according to SIA 257

The test area is carried out on a representative area of one square metre. After abrading and applying the bonding primer followed by a finishing coat of dispersion, allow the full drying time (three to five days depending on ambient humidity). Then carry out the cross-hatch test with a utility knife, with six crossing cuts spaced two millimetres apart, followed by the standardised adhesive tape pull-off. If the film lifts, complete stripping becomes mandatory.

  1. Chemical stripping with emulsion or gel free of chlorinated solventsApply the stripping gel with a brush in a thick coat of two millimetres. Leave to act according to the manufacturer's data sheet (from thirty minutes to several hours under polyethylene film to prevent evaporation). Scrape off the softened material with a scraper knife. Then neutralise the substrate by washing with clean water and brushing to stop any residual action that would attack the new paint.
  2. Mechanical stripping under industrial extractionUse a variable-speed eccentric rotary sander or a renovation milling tool connected to a vacuum cleaner certified for fine dust. Work with P40 to P80 corundum abrasives to remove the hard coats, then finish with P120 grit to even out the substrate without gouging the support.

Diagnosis of incompatibility and identification of binders according to standard SIA 257

Peeling in sheets of a water-based dispersion paint applied directly over an old glossy glycerophthalic lacquer is a classic failure in interior renovation. This adhesion failure results from a critical stress differential: during coalescence, the physical shrinkage of the acrylic resin generates a shear force that exceeds the interfacial adhesion on a hard, smooth, non-porous film. Without mechanical matting by sanding or the interposition of a suitable primer, the new film has no mechanical key and ends up detaching in large strips under the effect of thermal stresses or humidity variations. In accordance with standard SIA 257, thorough examination of the substrate and precise chemical identification of the binder in place are the painter's responsibility before any decision to overcoat.

  • Visual and tactile examination to spot cohesion defects and the gloss of the old lacquer.
  • Solubility test by solvent rubbing to identify the chemical nature of the binder.
  • Standardised cross-hatch test according to standard SIA 257 to measure the residual adhesion of the film.
  • Measurement of substrate moisture by the dielectric method to rule out a moisture problem.
Method for identifying binders by solvent solubility test
Test solventObserved reactionNature of the binderRisk of direct overcoating
Methylated spirits (ethanol)Rapid softening and colour transfer onto the clothWater-based acrylic or vinyl dispersionLow if the existing film is cohesive
Acetone or cellulose solventVery slow softening or no visible alterationAlkyd resin (glycerophthalic) or cross-linked urethaneHigh: peeling without prior sanding
White spiritTotal chemical inertness, lacquer remaining hard and intactBoiled-oil paint or traditional enamelCritical: total incompatibility without a suitable primer

The compatibility test on a test area validates the technical choices in situ. The painter marks out a representative area of at least half a square metre. The old lacquer is degreased, rinsed with clean water and then sanded with P100 grit to create a micro-roughness for adhesion. The complete system is then applied: one water-thinnable adhesion primer coat followed by two finishing coats of dispersion. The pull-off test by lattice incision and standardised adhesive tape allows the actual adhesion to be checked after complete drying.

Stripping methods and remediation of failing substrates

When the dispersion peels in sheets or when the cross-hatch test on the old lacquer reveals widespread adhesion failure, complete removal of the unstable build-up becomes essential. Standard SIA 257 reminds us that no new finishing coat can compensate for the lack of adhesion or poor cohesion of the underlying coats. The painter must then choose between mechanical and chemical stripping depending on the fragility of the substrate, the presence of mouldings and the need to capture dust in occupied premises.

  1. Mechanical and thermal strippingOn solid substrates and flat surfaces, stripping is carried out with a rotary sander using P60 to P80 corundum abrasives, which must be connected to a class M dust extractor to capture particles. On moulded woodwork, a regulated hot-air or infrared heat stripper softens the glycerophthalic film without burning the substrate, allowing precise scraping with a steel knife.
  2. Chemical stripping with paste free of chlorinated solventsOn fragile plaster or delicate ornaments, a thixotropic stripper free of methylene chloride is required. Applied in a thick coat of 1 to 2 millimetres under polyethylene film to limit evaporation, it dissolves the alkyd resins. The sludge is scraped off and packed airtight for disposal via a special waste stream.
  3. Washing, neutralisation and preparationAfter stripping, the surface is thoroughly cleaned with clean water or the appropriate thinner to remove any saponification agent or waxy residue. The painter checks the neutrality of the substrate with pH paper before carrying out mechanical abrading with P120 grit to even out the dry substrate.

Once the substrate has been bared, remediated and dried, the painter applies the renewal system in accordance with standard SIA 257. On bare plaster, an acrylic impregnating primer regulates the absorption of the substrate. On residues of old lacquer that have remained unaltered and perfectly adherent, applying a bonding primer based on water-based epoxy resin or modified acrylic ensures the adhesion bridge required before the finishing dispersion is applied.

Handling the adhesion failure and full rework protocol

When the dispersion film freshly applied over an old glossy glycerophthalic lacquer starts to blister or comes off in whole skins, the interface failure has occurred. The internal stresses caused by cross-linking and evaporation of the water phase exceed the nil adhesion strength of an unmatted substrate. Attempting to re-anchor the film with a new coat or to hide the edges with filler is a major technical fault that worsens the defect.

  1. Joint inspection record and notice of defectsStop the work and formally notify the situation to site management in accordance with the provisions of standard SIA 118 and the Code of Obligations (CO). Record the incompatibility by means of a documented cross-hatch test on a test area.
  2. Dry peeling of the unstable dispersionRemove the new dispersion using a rigid-blade painter's knife or a pull scraper. Where there is no adhesion at all on the satin or glossy substrate, the film can generally be removed in large continuous strips.
  3. Mechanical or chemical stripping of the substrateIf the old alkyd lacquer is itself crazed or chalking, remove it completely by thermal or chemical stripping under film. If the alkyd film remains perfectly cohesive with the original plaster, carry out abrasive abrading with 80 grit under slaved extraction to completely remove the gloss and create the roughness required by standard SIA 257.
  4. Reconstitution of the paint systemRemove dust meticulously by the wet method. Then apply a specific adhesion-promoting primer for closed substrates before applying the intermediate coat and the chosen dispersion finish.

The disposal of solid residues and stripping sludge must comply with the requirements of the Ordinance on Waste (OLED). Sludge loaded with solvents or originating from old substrates containing lead pigments is special waste and must be handed over exclusively to an approved recycling company.

Frequently asked questions

How can an old alkyd be distinguished from an acrylic on the construction site?

Soak a white cloth in methylated spirits or acetone and rub the existing film vigorously for about thirty seconds. If the resin softens, becomes tacky or clearly bleeds onto the fabric, it is a water-based dispersion. If the solvent evaporates without altering the gloss or softening the hard film, you are dealing with a solvent-based lacquer of the glycerophthalic or polyurethane type.

Why can a dispersion peel several days after application?

During application, moisture keeps the film somewhat flexible. It is during the final phase of water evaporation and polymer coalescence that mechanical shrinkage increases. If the old glossy lacquer has not been sanded to provide a mechanical key, the internal tension stresses eventually shear the smooth interface, causing delayed lifting in whole sheets.

Is it possible to sand the dispersion that is peeling off the alkyd directly?

No. Running an orbital sander over a poorly adherent elastic film generates heat that immediately clogs the abrasive discs. Moreover, the rotary vibration tears off strips without cleaning the substrate. Removal must be carried out by hand with a scraper or metal blade before mechanical abrading of the underlying lacquered substrate is undertaken.

Which stripper should be chosen indoors without breaching occupational safety?

Avoid volatile strippers based on methylene chloride. Choose gel formulations based on dibasic esters or biodegradable solvents free of chlorinated solvents. These products are applied in a thick coat and stay confined under a polyethylene sheet for several hours. They limit harmful evaporation in the premises and allow the coats to be softened without uncontrolled toxic fumes.

Texts and standards cited

  • norme SIA 257Painting, varnishing and interior wall coverings: preparation of substrates and compatibility of systems
  • norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work: notice of defects and handling of non-conformities
  • OLEDOrdinance on the limitation and disposal of waste: management of construction waste and special waste streams

In the same section