Key takeaways
- The visual inspection is always carried out under the usual service lighting and without raking artificial light.
- The normal viewing distance for assessing an interior wall covering is between one and two metres.
- A slight joint shrinkage remains tolerated depending on the thickness, texture and material installed.
- The acceptance report records the nature of the touch-ups permitted and their deadline for rectification.
Setting the viewing conditions: stand-back distance and normal-use lighting
On a finishing-work construction site, the inspection of wall coverings regularly gives rise to unjustified disputes when site management or the client inspects the drops a few centimetres from the surface, sometimes armed with a torch or a site inspection lamp. The rules of the trade applied in Switzerland require the final appearance of a wallpaper, textile wall covering or vinyl covering to be assessed under the future conditions of use of the premises. A match is never judged with one's nose against the wall.
The visual assessment must be carried out under diffuse natural light or under the final artificial lighting of the room, as provided for in the architectural design. The use of halogen or LED floodlights directed obliquely at the partitions creates excessive cast shadows on the slightest excess thickness of material or on the natural bevel of the edges. This completely distorts the inspection. If the final light fittings are not yet installed at the time of the visit, the parties agree on substitute lighting that faithfully reproduces the planned lighting atmosphere, without raking light.
| Inspection criterion | Method accepted at acceptance | Inadmissible practice |
|---|---|---|
| Viewing distance | Stand-back distance between 1 m and 2 m, observer standing | Inspection at less than 50 cm or with a magnifying glass |
| Light source | Daylight without direct sun or final lighting | Site inspection lamp, smartphone torch, raking light |
| Viewing angle | Perpendicular to the wall or usual viewing angle | Looking along the surface at a raking angle |
| Drying time | After thermal stabilisation and complete drying of the adhesive | Immediate inspection on fresh or damp adhesive |
Joint tolerance, targeted reservations and lifting protocol
Installing a wall covering in drops inherently involves joints. A perfect joint in the sense of microscopic continuity does not exist in craft work, particularly on absorbent substrates or with high-weight materials such as textile wall coverings, grasscloth or heavy vinyls on non-woven backing. The residual opening of a joint must remain imperceptible at normal viewing distance, but a very slight gap or a microscopic technical overlap may result from the normal hygrometric shrinkage of the fibres as the paste water evaporates.
- Butt joint
- Joining of two adjacent drops without overlapping material and without visible gaping, made either by direct butting or by double cut with a cutter along a metal rule.
A distinction is made between accidental opening resulting from excessive pulling on the paper during smoothing down, which is an execution defect, and the structural visibility of the edge of a wallpaper tinted on the surface. In the latter case, the white edge of the paper may show against a dark background without any physical gap. To prevent this, the painter first tints the background at the future joints or uses suitable touch-up crayons on the edges.
- Joint inspection record of defectsWalk through the rooms with site management under conventional lighting. Identify each disputed area precisely without generalising to the whole wall section.
- Drawing up the acceptance reportRecord each reservation in a localised way (for example: joint gaping over 30 cm on drop number 3 of the south bedroom), setting a reasonable deadline for rectification.
- Technical rectification of the anomaliesInject a suitable adhesive to re-fix a lifted edge, reactivate a joint with a seam roller, or replace the whole drop if the shade of the original batch allows it.
- Formal lifting of reservationsArrange a follow-up visit on the points recorded. Have the reservation-lifting form signed, which confirms final acceptance of the work and starts the contractual warranty period.
Joint inspection procedure under SIA 118 and classification of joint defects
Checking a wallpaper, a non-woven covering or a textile wall hanging cannot be improvised in a site corridor. It follows the acceptance procedure of standard SIA 118, which prescribes a joint visit between site management and the painting contractor. During this inspection, each anomaly reported on the drops must be analysed against the viewing conditions agreed before installation began. If the client claims to identify a defect by holding a raking lamp against the partition or by looking at the match from twenty centimetres, the foreman must recall the reference basis: the visual assessment is carried out in diffuse natural light or under the final service lighting, from a distance of at least one metre to one and a half metres.
Standard SIA 118 classifies the shortcomings found at acceptance and triggers the start of the warranty periods. The appearance of an open joint or an overlap does not automatically constitute a serious defect justifying refusal of the work. The joint inspection procedure distinguishes the minor imperfection, invisible at the standard distance and inherent in the dimensional tolerances of the material, from the proven defect that breaks the harmony of the wall section or compromises the adhesion of the wall covering system.
| Joint inspection record | Inspection criterion | Contractual status | Acceptance decision |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joint perceptible only under raking artificial light | Invisible at 1.50 m in normal-use lighting, no gaping | Tolerance permitted | Work accepted without reservation |
| Joint opening of less than 0.3 mm on heavy vinyl | Pattern line preserved, background not visible by contrast | Dimensional tolerance | Acceptance with informative note |
| Continuous gap of more than 0.5 mm exposing the background | Clearly visible at 1.50 m in diffuse daylight | Execution defect | Localised reservation with deadline for touch-up |
| Unintended overlap of the edges | Creation of a raised ridge catching the light | Execution defect | Targeted reservation with redoing of the drop |
| Clear lifting of the edge with peeling | Local loss of adhesion, risk of mechanical damage | Technical defect | Reservation with order to re-glue |
At the end of the inspection round, site management and the team leader record their remarks in the acceptance report. To avoid any later dispute during the two-year period for giving notice of defects guaranteed by standard SIA 118, the reservations must be geographically targeted (room, wall section number, precise identification of the drop concerned) and accompanied by a realistic deadline for bringing the work into conformity.
Treating and lifting a reservation on joints: working methods and validation
Lifting a reservation on a defective joint requires measured actions. The first reflex of a qualified painter is to treat the anomaly without damaging the adjacent coverings. Depending on the nature of the fault (dry edge lifted, squeezed-out adhesive that has marked the surface, or excessive shrinkage), the rectification method ranges from simple precise re-gluing to replacement of the drop to the millimetre.
- Re-gluing a non-adhering edge: targeted injection of a special vinyl seam emulsion with a flat-tip syringe, controlled dampening of the back of the drop without soaking the substrate, immediate smoothing with a soft plastic conical roller and immediate wiping of the excess with a damp sponge.
- Reducing the visible background on an open joint: on a minimal shrinkage showing a light substrate under a dark paper, careful application of a touch of dry pastel chalk or watercolour with a fine brush to break the visual contrast, without staining the surface.
- Partial replacement by double cut: when an edge is chipped or torn, lay a strip of spare material from the same production batch overlapping, make a joint mitre cut with a steel rule and a new blade at 30 degrees, remove the lower offcut, re-glue and close up the lips of the joint.
- Preparing the work areaIsolate the portion of drop noted in the report. Check that residual adhesive has not soiled the adjacent pattern and prepare the precision tools: syringe, conical roller, blotting paper and suitable seam adhesive.
- Carrying out the touch-upTreat the reservation using the appropriate technique (injection, reactivation or double cut). Never stretch the material crosswise, otherwise a tension is created that will reopen the joint as it dries.
- Joint inspection record of liftingCall in site management after complete drying (twenty-four hours minimum). Re-examine the wall section at the normal stand-back distance of one and a half metres under the lighting provided for in the contract.
- Signing the addendum lifting the reservationHave the lifting certificate initialled on the original report. This signature records the final conformity of the work and formally closes the reservation entered at acceptance.
Where the touch-up cannot conceal the deviation beyond the tolerances permitted, complete replacement of the drop from ceiling to skirting becomes necessary. This last-resort measure requires drawing on the safety stock of rolls kept in dry storage, ensuring perfect consistency of batch and calibre with the surrounding surfaces.
Handling disputes at acceptance and technical arbitration
When site management refuses to sign the report or multiplies unfounded reservations, the conflict almost always stems from a biased inspection method. The most frequent error is to point an LED inspection lamp or a raking floodlight at the wall covering, or to judge a match from twenty centimetres from the substrate. Faced with such a situation, the team leader or works manager must immediately suspend the informal inspection and require strict application of the acceptance framework provided by standard SIA 118. The work must be assessed under future operating conditions, in diffuse natural light or under the final artificial lighting provided for in the design, keeping a stand-back distance of at least one and a half metres perpendicular to the wall.
- Putting the disagreement in writingRecord in the acceptance report the actual viewing conditions imposed by site management. Expressly mention the improper use of raking artificial light or of an inspection distance that does not comply with Swiss rules of the trade.
- Circumscribing and quantifying the reservationsRefuse any blanket entry such as "drops to be redone entirely". Require each disputed joint to be precisely marked on the installation plan, with the exact measurement of its gap using a rule or thickness gauge.
- Calling on a neutral technical expertIf the deadlock persists on the tolerance for the opening of a joint, seek the technical opinion of an expert from the Swiss umbrella association of the plastering and painting trade, or agree on a joint expert inspection record under standard SIA 118.
- Proposing targeted rectification or a financial arrangementFor a proven isolated defect that does not compromise the general appearance of the room, negotiate local repair limited to the drop concerned within an agreed rectification period, or a proportionate deduction avoiding complete removal.
Frequently asked questions
May site management use a raking floodlight at acceptance?
No. The inspection of a wallpaper or textile wall covering is carried out exclusively under the normal-use light of the room, whether natural or artificial. Using a raking artificial light source, such as a site floodlight or a torch, artificially alters the cast shadows at the matches and is not an admissible assessment method under the rules of the trade.
What is the minimum viewing distance for judging a wallpaper joint?
The visual assessment of a match is carried out at a normal viewing distance, usually set at at least one and a half metres from the wall for a living room or offices. Examining the drops with one's nose against the wall or with magnifying instruments is contrary to Swiss professional practice and cannot justify the notification of an execution defect.
What joint opening remains permissible between two consecutive drops?
For standard wallpapers hung butt-jointed, the drops must be tight together without overlap. A maximum tolerance of zero point five millimetre is generally accepted at very localised points, provided that the background does not show up in contrast and that the alignment of the printed patterns remains continuous when the whole is viewed at the standard inspection distance.
What deadline applies for lifting a reservation notified on a lifted drop?
The report drawn up under standard SIA 118 must set a reasonable deadline for rectification, agreed between the parties, generally ten to twenty working days. The tradesperson intervenes in a targeted way by local re-gluing with special seam adhesive or by replacing the drop concerned, then has the lifting of the entered reservation formally countersigned.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction works, governing the procedure for acceptance of the work, the notice of defects, the rectification deadlines and the warranty
