Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 272Substrate acceptance and diagnosis before paintingChapter 10 of 10 in the section

Refusing a substrate: the record, the letter, and what happens if you apply anyway

This chapter gives you the method to document the non-conformities of a substrate before any painting. You will be able to take indisputable measurements, record defects in writing and issue a reasoned refusal according to professional rules. Finally, you will understand why applying paint to an unprepared substrate shifts the entire financial burden of damage onto your company.

Key takeaways

  • The SIA 257 standard governs the criteria for accepting and refusing substrates in painting.
  • A valid refusal must rest on measured physical values and dated, probative photographs.
  • The notice of defects must be served in writing on the site management before any work is carried out.
  • Applying a system despite a non-conformity releases the preceding trades and engages your warranty.

Recording the non-conformities and drafting the reasoned refusal according to SIA 257

A painter working on a construction site in French-speaking Switzerland takes over a finished substrate produced by the mason, the plasterer or the screed layer. In accordance with the SIA 257 standard, the craftsman is responsible for visually and mechanically examining the condition of the surfaces before starting preparatory coats or finishes. If the substrate shows insufficient cohesion, greasy contamination, salt efflorescence, excessive moisture content or marked chalking, the painter must suspend work. This examination does not concern general flatness or plaster skim tolerances, which are matters for the smoothing specialists, but the physical and chemical suitability of the substrate to receive the specified primer and paint films.

  1. Physical and chemical diagnosisMeasure residual moisture using a carbide hygrometer or a calibrated capacitive device. Test surface cohesion by cross-hatching with a cutter and pulling off standardised adhesive tape. Assess surface resistance by scratching with a steel stylus and check porosity using the water-drop test.
  2. Recording the evidenceDocument each anomaly with a survey sheet stating the exact room, the location on the wall, the measured value in figures and the ambient temperature. Pair each critical point with a sharp photograph including a tape measure and a contrast chart to record the condition on site.
  3. Drafting the joint inspection recordState in writing the deviations found against the tolerances of the SIA 257 standard. Describe the failures factually without passing judgement on the work of other trades, specifying that the substrate does not allow durable adhesion of the prescribed system.
  4. Formal notification to the site managementSend your reasoned refusal letter by registered mail or with formal acknowledgement of receipt to the site management and the client. This step falls within the general contractual framework set by the SIA 118 standard, whose basic rules on the duty to notify are detailed in the structural work material.
Substrate assessment parameters according to SIA 257
Defect foundTest methodAlert or refusal thresholdStatement in the refusal letter
Moisture content by massCalcium carbide bombValue above the technical data sheetsImmediate risk of blistering and detachment
Surface chalkingRubbing with a dark gloveDense white dust depositNo mechanical anchorage of the primer
Excessive alkalinitypH paper on dampened substratepH above 10 on fresh concreteRisk of saponification of organic binders
Mechanical strengthCross-scratch with a steel nailCrumbling of edges under the toolSubstrate unable to bear the system

Consequences of painting despite an unsuitable substrate

Applying a blocking primer, a primer or a lacquer on a non-compliant substrate amounts to tacit acceptance of the substrate by the painter. Under pressure from the site schedule or to avoid a crew stoppage, the craftsman often makes the mistake of attempting a remedy with strong fixatives without first notifying his reservations. By doing so, the painting company takes on full technical responsibility for the defects to come. Under the general principles of the Code of Obligations (CO) governing the works contract, a professional who carries out the work without immediately warning the client of a defect noted in the material or the ground supplied loses all recourse against the preceding contractors.

Pathologies resulting from application on a damp or powdery substrate generally appear a few weeks to several months after handover. Trapped water migrates under the effect of interior heating, creating a vapour pressure that lifts the paint film through continuous blistering. In the case of dead or burnt plaster, the paint film comes away in whole sheets, taking with it a thin layer of disintegrated plaster. The court-appointed expert will systematically demonstrate that the painter, as a certified or CFC-qualified professional, had a professional obligation to detect this anomaly through simple preliminary tests.

  • Full transfer of the financial burden of repairs onto your company's civil liability insurance alone.
  • Obligation to carry out, at your own expense, thermal, chemical or mechanical stripping of all the incompatible coats.
  • Exclusion of recourse against the plasterer or the mason, who are released by your physical covering of their work.
  • Loss of the right to additional payments for the remedial work required before repainting.

To validly release your company, the refusal letter must expressly make the resumption of work conditional on the complete remediation of the substrate by the responsible trade. If the site management nevertheless demands application of the system by signing a written site instruction, that document must state that the risks of detachment or aesthetic deterioration are formally transferred to the client, thereby excluding the painter's liability for defects attributable to that imprudent order.

Joint protocol and instrumented traceability of surface checks

A defect recorded unilaterally by the painter offers only precarious protection before a sceptical site management or one pressed by the delivery schedule. As soon as a substrate shows a clear non-conformity making the surface unfit to receive the system provided for in the specification, the record must rest on indisputable physical readings. The SIA 257 standard requires checking the dryness, cohesion, absorption and cleanliness of the substrate before any application of primer or paint. Turning this technical obligation into a legal shield requires reproducible measurements, recorded in writing and backed by indexed photographs.

Each reading must link a precise location in the building to a numerical value or a standardised test result. A simple handwritten note saying a screed is damp or a wall is dusty has no probative value in a later court expert assessment. The painter marks the test area on the substrate with a grease crayon or masking tape, places a millimetre rule next to the measuring point, and photographs the whole in a wide shot to locate the room and then in a close-up of the dial of the measuring device.

Painter's instrumented checks, acceptance criteria and method of proof
Parameter checkedSite tool or methodImmediate refusal criterionProbative recording method
Moisture of mineral substratesDielectric moisture meter or carbide bombWater content above the limits accepted by the product manufacturerPhoto of the dial with level marker and room number
Alkalinity of the substratepH indicator strips on a surface dampened with demineralised waterpH above 10 for a standard synthetic dispersionMacro photo of the colour change with the reference scale
Surface cohesionStandardised cutter cross-hatching and pull-off with reinforced adhesive tapeDelamination or crumbling of the cut edgesAdhesive sample stuck on a card with date and signature
Temperature and condensationThermo-hygrometer coupled with an infrared contact probeSurface temperature less than 3 °C above the dew pointTime-stamped device report recording relative humidity and air temperature

The self-inspection sheet resulting from this measurement campaign forms the essential technical annex of the file. Drawn up in duplicate, it must be sent without delay to the site management with an invitation to attend a joint counter-assessment within forty-eight hours if the measured findings are disputed on the construction site.

Order to proceed and full transfer of the risks of defective work

A critical situation frequently arises when the site management refuses to stop the work, citing non-negotiable delivery deadlines or late-completion penalties owed to the other trades. Faced with the painter's reasoned refusal, the client or their representative sometimes tries to force immediate application of the primer coat, claiming that drying will finish under the paint film. Yielding verbally to this pressure is the major professional fault that cancels the protective effect of the duty to notify provided for by the Code of Obligations (CO) and by the SIA 118 standard.

  1. Notification of the reasoned refusal by registered mailSend the formal refusal letter together with the joint record of measurements, specifying the unavoidable technical defects (blisters, mould, powdering, flaking) if the work continues.
  2. Demand for prior remediation of the substrateGive the client formal notice to have the substrate treated by the responsible trade (dehumidification of the ambient air, sanding of cement laitance, chemical neutralisation).
  3. Requirement for a written order to proceed with a discharge clauseIf the client demands that the paint coats continue despite the unfavourable technical opinion, make the resumption of coats conditional on a written site instruction stating that the client assumes the financial risk of blistering or detachment.
  4. Protective stoppage of the painting crewIn the absence of a written order releasing the company or of remediation of the substrate, suspend services in the rooms concerned and record the stoppage to prevent any invoicing of late-completion penalties.

When the formal written order is issued by the client in accordance with the rules of the works contract, the technical risk linked to the expressly announced defects is transferred to the client. The painter nevertheless remains bound to respect the rules of the trade for the operations he controls: correct dilution of binders, observance of recoating times between coats and chemical compatibility of the coats applied. In the event of a claim, the documentary evidence established from the moment the substrate was received is the only means of avoiding the obligation to redo everything at his own expense.

Dispute over the condition of the substrate: stoppage procedure and handling of orders

When the site management refuses to sign the joint inspection record and maintains schedule pressure to force application on a damp, powdery or chalking substrate, the foreman must immediately freeze the disputed area. Any tacit continuation of operations amounts to unreserved acceptance of the substrate. The fundamental principle laid down by the SIA 257 standard and the Code of Obligations (CO) requires the painter to stop work as soon as the substrate compromises the performance of the system. The painter records the technical readings with calibrated instruments, takes high-resolution photographs with metric reference marks and leaves the disputed area.

  1. Sending the written formal noticeSend the same day a reasoned notice by time-stamped email and registered letter to the site management and the client. The letter recalls the technical impossibility of painting in accordance with the recognised rules of the profession, details the measured values outside tolerance and sets a deadline for the responsible trade to restore the substrate.
  2. Organising the crew's relocationSwitch the applicators to a compliant work front in order to minimise waiting costs. Notify the site management that the unproductive hours caused by the blocking of the defective area will be charged on a daywork basis for unforeseen standing time.
  3. Handling the formal orderIf the site management orders in writing to paint despite the refusal notified, require a formal written order expressly assuming full responsibility for the foreseeable defects (detachment, blistering, ghosting). Without this unambiguous discharge, categorically refuse any base or primer coat.
  4. Recourse to technical expert assessmentIn the event of persistent disagreement, promptly call on an independent technical expert or the arbitration service of the French-Swiss umbrella association for plastering and painting. The joint on-site examination permanently fixes the material evidence before any alteration of the substrate.

The fatal mistake is to seek an oral compromise on site to preserve relations with the architect. Painting on a defective substrate with the idea of "sorting things out" makes the painter bear all the costs of stripping, heavy sanding and complete redoing of the system. Only instrumented proof backed by an unassailable written notification guarantees the company's financial and legal security.

Frequently asked questions

What should be done if the site management refuses to sign the refusal protocol?

If the site management's representative refuses to countersign the joint record, the painter must not insist on site. He immediately notes this refusal to sign on the original document, then sends the record the same day by registered mail with a time-stamped digital copy. This formal notification is legally sufficient to prove the warning and releases the applicator from any liability for delays caused by the impossibility of starting the painting work.

Can the client impose the application of paint by written order?

Yes, the client or their agent retains the prerogative to impose execution of the work by a formal written order. Under the Code of Obligations (CO) and the SIA 118 standard, if the painter has previously issued a reasoned notice detailing the risks of blistering or poor adhesion, this written order releases the contractor from any warranty obligation. The company then paints at the sole risk of the specifier.

Does a partial application to test the substrate cancel the written refusal?

Yes, applying a test coat over a large area without formal written agreement considerably weakens the applicator's position. If a test area is essential to assess cohesion or absorbency, it must be the subject of a written agreement limiting the sample to an agreed restricted area. Applying extensively amounts, in the eyes of the courts, to accepting the substrate and cancels the protection offered by the refusal letter.

Who bears the cost of waiting days caused by a non-compliant substrate?

When the painter is forced to interrupt work because of an out-of-tolerance substrate supplied by another trade, the standing costs of labour and equipment fall on the client. To obtain compensation, the contractor must report the obstruction in writing without delay, reorganise his crew if possible on another front of the building and keep a log of unproductive hours valued at the daywork rates in force.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 257Painting, varnishing and wall coverings: rules for checking substrates, execution and acceptance of work
  • SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work: duty to notify, interruption for a defective substrate and the client's order
  • Code des obligationsWorks contract: immediate notification of defects in the material supplied by the client and discharge of liability in the case of express instructions

In the same section