Key takeaways
- A colour-chart swatch reproduces neither the absorption of the substrate nor the actual light in the room.
- The reference area must measure at least two square metres and receive the complete specified system.
- Visual assessment is carried out exclusively under the natural light of the location and the final artificial lighting provided for.
- Joint signature on the substrate or on a record blocks any later dispute on aesthetic grounds.
Apply the trial area on site to reveal the colour under its final lighting
Choosing a colour from an NCS swatch strip or a card fan deck under the fluorescent lighting of an office is the main cause of colour disputes on construction sites. Metamerism radically changes how a colour is perceived as soon as the light sources change: a shade seen as a neutral grey in a workshop can turn olive green or violet under low-energy luminaires or facing a north-facing glazed opening. In addition, reflections cast by an oiled parquet floor, floor tiles or a neighbouring façade alter the final appearance in a way that cannot be controlled from a distance.
The reference area must be applied in the room concerned, directly on the prepared substrate. Treating a loose sample card is not suitable, because the surface texture, porosity and thermal warming of the masonry do not match actual conditions. To be representative, the area must cover a sufficient continuous zone, ideally located where a shaded zone meets a zone receiving direct light.
The painter applies to this area the entire system given in the specification: primer or substrate-regulating fixative, intermediate coat and finishing coat. If the overall application is planned with a twelve-millimetre polyamide textured roller or with an airless spray gun, the trial sample must be applied with that same equipment, without changing the dilution rates recommended in the manufacturer's data sheet. Applying a sample with a flat brush to save time changes the orientation of the mineral fillers and distorts the opacity and the film tension.
Recording the texture, sealing the agreement and preserving the colour references
The appearance of a paint is not limited to its colour formulation: the level of specular gloss (deep matt, velvet or satin) and the structure of the roller texture define the final look as much as the pigments. Two paints formulated to the exact same NCS reference will look different if one has a gloss of two per cent at a sixty-degree angle while the other reaches ten per cent. The reference area allows the client to be confronted with this material reality before the overall quantity measurement begins.
- Complete drying of the filmWait until the system is dry right through, i.e. a minimum of twenty-four to forty-eight hours depending on ambient humidity, because water-based paints darken markedly as the binders coalesce.
- Joint visual inspectionInspect the surface from a distance of at least one metre fifty, facing the wall and under several lighting angles, in the presence of site management or the client.
- Signature and markingMark out the chosen area with precision masking tape or with an indelible marker in the margin, then affix the signatures directly on the sampling record.
- Archiving the formulationRecord the code of the tinted formula, the manufacturer's batch number, the base reference and the exact manufacturing date printed on the tin.
The approved reference area remains protected on site and must not be repainted before the general application phase in the room. It serves as the direct standard for checking the texture, opacity and tension of the film during inspection rounds. In addition, the painter keeps in reserve a wet sample taken from the same original drum, tightly closed in a labelled glass jar, together with a dried rigid reference board signed on the back. This precaution puts an end to any dispute in the event of a product re-order or a localised repair during the final touch-ups at the end of the construction site.
Examination protocol under actual lighting and metamerism on site
Assessing a colour on a fan-deck swatch of a few square centimetres, often leafed through under the fluorescent lighting of an office or the harsh light of a workshop, systematically misleads. Metamerism radically changes the perception of pigments as soon as the paint film is exposed to the natural light of the site or to the artificial sources provided for in the fit-out design. To eliminate any difference of judgement with the client or site management, applying a reference area directly in the destination room is the only technically convincing means.
The reference area must not be applied in the middle of a wall without a reference point, but preferably on a zone including an internal corner or a transition with a glazed opening. This position allows the colour to be viewed both under direct light and under raking light. The assessment must absolutely be made on a film that has completed its full drying time right through, i.e. a minimum of twenty-four to forty-eight hours depending on ambient humidity and the nature of the binder (acrylic dispersion, alkyd emulsion or silicate).
- Check under natural light at the two critical moments of the day: at its peak for saturation and in the late afternoon for colour shift under raking light.
- Check under the final artificial lighting: temporary commissioning of the specified luminaires (actual colour temperature in kelvins and colour rendering index; never under temporary yellow LED site lighting or an improvised halogen floodlight).
- Examination of the cast-shadow effect in internal corners to assess the visual darkening caused by mutual reflections between adjacent walls.
Formalising the surface appearance and securing the formulation
Colour can never be separated from the texture and the degree of gloss of the dry film. A deep matt off-white does not have the same visual presence or the same light absorption as a satin emulsion applied with the same recipe number. The on-site sample makes it possible to fix all of these variables: depth of the matt, fineness of the pile of the roller used (micro-fine or textured), absence of mottling or roller marks in the cutting-in.
| Criterion observed | On-site examination method | Point of attention for the team |
|---|---|---|
| Degree of gloss (matt, velvet, satin) | Observation under raking light at 60° and 85° angles | Uniformity of the film with no zones of differential absorption due to primer touch-ups |
| Structure of the finish texture | Visual check at a perpendicular distance of two metres | Strict use of roller sleeves with the agreed pile height (e.g. 8 mm or 12 mm) |
| Colour accuracy | Comparison with the standard sample card | Complete drying of the two-coat system before signing the record |
| Appearance of the cutting-in | Inspection of the junctions with ceiling, skirting boards and door frames | No excess thickness or excess sheen caused by pressing the brush too hard |
Once agreement has been reached between the painter, site management and the final client, the decision must be recorded in writing immediately by means of a reference area approval form. This document records the exact location of the reference zone in the building, the commercial designation of the paint, the complete application system (type of primer and number of finishing coats), and the reference of the tinting machine formula or the industrial batch number. Two mobile rigid boards of forty by sixty centimetres, treated with the same coats and the same tools as the reference wall, are signed at the same time: one board is kept on file in the contractor's site hut, the other is handed to site management.
The reference of the chosen colour must be recorded in the site diary with the exact date of mixing. If supplies arrive in several successive deliveries, the workshop must order the bases from the same manufacturer and ensure that the colorants come from the same calibration cycle. If a batch variation occurs during the application of the large volumes, a new match must be tested discreetly behind a door before any application on a continuous wall, ensuring perfect continuity with the original reference area.
Handling differences and appearance disputes after application
When the client or site management disputes the final result, claiming that the colour applied over the full area does not match the initial choice, the approach relies exclusively on the documents agreed by both parties before the start of the construction site. The paper colour chart or an on-screen display is in no case an enforceable contractual reference. Only the reference area kept on site or the sealed and countersigned sample board is authoritative before the parties.
- Joint examination under service lightingOrganise an inspection visit immediately in the presence of site management. The disputed wall and the reference area are observed strictly under the final lighting provided for in the project, from a distance of at least two metres and at a perpendicular viewing angle, in accordance with the Swiss professional recommendations of the trade.
- Checking the application parametersIf a visual difference appears between the approved area and the rest of the room, check without delay the batch numbers on the remaining drums, the dilution rate applied on site, the type of roller used and strict compliance with the number of coats prescribed in the chosen finishing system.
- Checking the light sourcesCheck the colour rendering index and the colour temperature of the luminaires installed by the electrician. An unforeseen change from warm lamps to cold luminous panels completely changes the perception of the same pigment formula.
- Contractual closure of the disagreementIf the paint film applied matches the signed reference area, the work is deemed to comply with the agreements made. Any change of shade demanded by the client then constitutes a change to the order subject to a financial addendum, in accordance with the general rules of the SIA 118 standard. In the event of a proven deviation attributable to the application, the company repaints the walls at its own expense.
Frequently asked questions
What should be done if site management refuses to sign the approval record for the reference area?
Never start painting the rooms in full without written agreement. Notify site management formally by email or letter that drying is complete and that the lack of approval is blocking the continuation of the work. State that the contractual deadlines are suspended under the SIA 118 standard as long as the shade and the degree of gloss have not been expressly confirmed by the client.
The electrician changed the colour temperature of the luminaires after the painting was done: who pays for the repainting?
If the change of lighting takes place after the reference area was signed under the initial specifications, the painting company is entirely relieved of any responsibility. The metamerism caused by a change of light sources results from poor coordination by site management. Applying a new colour formula necessarily gives rise to the issuing of a daywork order or an additional quote accepted before work begins.
The client disputes the roller texture or the gloss on a large section of wall: how is it to be settled?
Hold the countersigned reference board against the disputed surface. Observation is never made under artificial raking light at ten centimetres from the substrate, but under the normal conditions of use of the room. If the roller texture and the degree of gloss measured with a reflectometer match the characteristics of the reference area, the complaint is unfounded and the work must be accepted without any financial retention.
How long must the physical reference and the samples be kept after acceptance?
Keep the sealed reference boards and the formulation sheets throughout the warranty period for defects provided for by the contract for work or by the SIA 118 standard. These physical items are your essential supporting documents in the event of a later dispute concerning ageing of the binder, a local repair following metalwork or locksmith work, or touch-ups demanded when the accounts are closed.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work, handling of change orders and acceptance of works.
- code des obligationsGeneral rules on the contract for work and the contractor's liability.
