Key takeaways
- A waterproof resin blocks evaporation and causes immediate blistering if the screed is damp.
- SIA 251 sets distinct moisture thresholds for cement and calcium sulphate.
- Only the destructive calcium carbide measurement is authoritative in an adversarial inspection.
- Systematic recording of the values in a report is a condition for the actual start of resin application.
Comply with the SIA 251 moisture thresholds according to the type of binder
Applying a synthetic resin floor covering, whether an epoxy or a polyurethane system, creates a barrier that is almost impervious to water vapour transfer. When the screed still contains excess free water at the time of application, this trapped moisture can no longer escape to the ambient air. Under the effect of temperature variations and osmotic pressures, the water migrates beneath the polymer film, dissolves mineral salts and generates blisters filled with alkaline liquid. The phenomenon destroys the mechanical and chemical adhesion of the primer. The resulting damage requires complete stripping of the covering, mechanical planing of the substrate and a full redo at the expense of the company that applied it without prior verification.
| Type of mineral binder | Without underfloor heating | With integrated underfloor heating |
|---|---|---|
| Cement-based bonded screed (CT) | ≤ 2.3 % CM | ≤ 1.5 % CM |
| Calcium sulphate flowing or traditional screed (CA/CAF) | ≤ 0.5 % CM | ≤ 0.3 % CM |
The difference in threshold between binders follows directly from their chemical kinetics. A cement screed continues to consume a small fraction of its mixing water through hydration over the weeks. It tolerates a maximum residual moisture of 2.3 % measured by calcium carbide for application without heating, a threshold that most resin manufacturers recommend lowering even further to 2.0 % as a technical safety margin. Calcium sulphate, by contrast, is critically sensitive to water: above 0.5 % CM, residual water dissolves the gypsum matrix beneath the resin, causing the bonding zone to crumble into powder. Where the floor incorporates embedded heating, SIA 251 tightens these criteria drastically. Prior heating-up is an indispensable prerequisite to drive out deep water before the decisive test.
Master the calcium carbide test and formally record the result
For the applicator of painted or poured floors, the calcium carbide measurement is the only assessment method recognised contractually and judicially in Switzerland. This destructive chemical test consists of bringing the water present in a mortar sample into contact with calcium carbide grains inside a sealed chamber. The reaction produces acetylene gas, whose pressure rise is directly proportional to the amount of free water. Unlike indirect methods, this test extracts the water from the deep capillary network.
- Location and deep samplingIdentify the most vulnerable areas of the room: dark corners, thick sections, door thresholds and areas far from openings. On heated floors, require the precise layout drawing of the circuits so as not to cut a pipe. Chisel out a representative sample over the full thickness or specifically in the lower third of the screed.
- Crushing and weighing the sampleQuickly crush the fragments in a metal mortar to obtain a fine grind, without using an electric grinder, which generates heat that would vaporise the water. Weigh exactly the required quantity with the precision balance: 20 grams for a cement screed or 50 to 100 grams for a calcium sulphate screed.
- Introducing the reagents and sealingSlide the weighed sample into the steel bottle with four hardened steel balls. Then carefully introduce the glass calcium carbide ampoule without breaking it before closing. Immediately screw on the measuring head fitted with its pressure gauge and a clean, undeformed seal.
- Mechanical shaking and pressure readingShake the flask vigorously with circular and vertical movements so that the balls crush the ampoule and mix the powder intimately. Repeat the shaking after five and ten minutes. The pressure rises gradually. Read the stabilised value on the dial after fifteen minutes and convert the pressure into a CM percentage using the calibration table.
The painter's task is not to accept the screeder's work, but the painter bears full responsibility for their bonding system as soon as the impregnation primer is applied. Drawing up an adversarial measurement report before any application is a fundamental professional act. This document must record the date, the time, the exact location of the sampling point, the ambient temperature, the substrate temperature, the air humidity and the exact value in CM percentage obtained. If the measured value exceeds the threshold set by SIA 251 or by the polymer manufacturer's data sheet, the applicator must formalise in writing their refusal to proceed to the site management and wait for complete drying.
Failure mechanisms under waterproof resin: the risk of osmotic blistering
Applying a poured floor covering based on synthetic resin (epoxy or polyurethane) creates a membrane impervious to water vapour. When this system is applied to a cement or calcium sulphate screed whose moisture exceeds the permissible thresholds, the thermo-hygrometric balance of the build-up is broken. Under the effect of temperature variations, sun through glazing or heating-up, the residual water trapped in the pores migrates towards the upper interface. Blocked beneath the airtight film, this moisture generates upward hydrostatic pressure. This stress quickly exceeds the tensile strength of the mortar and the adhesion of the epoxy primer, generally required to be at least 1.5 N/mm².
Osmotic blistering is the most costly damage for the resin-applying painter. The trapped moisture dissolves the soluble mineral salts of the binder and forms pockets of concentrated water beneath the film. Through osmosis, water continues to be drawn towards these inclusions, constantly increasing the internal pressure. The defects appear as domed blisters filled with a brownish alkaline liquid, followed by detachment of the system. On cement screed, the failure tears off the first few millimetres of the mortar. On anhydrite calcium sulphate screed, the trapped water transforms the gypsum and breaks down the contact zone into a crumbly paste. Remediation requires complete mechanical diamond planing, prolonged drying and full renewal of the covering, generating costs out of all proportion to the initial quote.
| Binder type | SIA 251 critical threshold | Physical phenomenon under the resin | Defect observed in the long term |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cement screed without heating | > 2.3 % CM | Migration of free water and formation of osmotic cells under the film | Blisters full of alkaline liquid, film-like detachment of the primer |
| Cement screed with heating | > 1.5 % CM | Hydrostatic pressure accelerated by heating cycles | Cracking of the rigid epoxy film, sheet detachment along the heating coils |
| Calcium sulphate without heating | > 0.5 % CM | Continued residual hydration and softening of the gypsum matrix | Powdery disintegration under the primer, total mechanical tear-off |
| Calcium sulphate with heating | > 0.3 % CM | Thermal confinement of residual water causing debonding | Total loss of adhesion at the interface, spontaneous lifting of the layers |
Recording the reading, refusing application and transfer of risk
The boundary of the painter's trade is clear here: the craftsman does not pour the screed, does not choose its admixtures and does not manage its drying programme. However, the painter bears full responsibility for their synthetic covering as soon as the impregnation primer is applied. If the calcium carbide test reveals a water content above the tolerances set by SIA 251, the painter must formally refuse the substrate. Improvised application of a pore-sealing primer without prior written approval from both the site management and the resin manufacturer deprives the company of any recourse and engages its civil liability.
- Carrying out the check in an adversarial mannerChisel out the mortar chips from the lower third of the screed together with the site management. Note the weighed mass and monitor the pressure after ten minutes of shaking.
- Drawing up the measurement recordEnter on the daily report the date, the room, the type of binder, the mass tested, the pressure read and the rate calculated in per cent CM. Photograph the dial with a timestamp.
- Written notification of refusalSend a written notice to the site management without delay. Recall the SIA 251 thresholds and confirm the immediate halt of the resin system application.
- Conditions for resuming workMake resumption subject to a new compliant carbide test. On heated screed, require certification of the complete heating-up protocol before taking a new sample.
Written traceability of the check protects the craftsman under the general rules of the Code of Obligations (CO) on the duty to notify in the presence of a defective substrate. Given the demanding pace of finishing work, refusing to apply on a screed that is too damp is an elementary act of professional diligence: waiting a few days for drying to be completed avoids a widespread tear-off whose financial and legal repercussions would be catastrophic for the company.
Crisis management: what to do in case of confirmed blistering
The discovery of blisters, craters or widespread detachment on a resin floor is the most dreaded damage for the floor painter. Faced with this defect, any hasty spot repair worsens the technical and financial situation. The first measure on the construction site is to immediately stop all mechanical loading of the covering and to document the condition exhaustively. The team leader photographs the phenomenon under raking light, marks the position of the swollen areas and records the ambient temperature and the humidity of the room.
Surgically opening two or three test blisters makes it possible to characterise the nature of the failure. If a brownish, alkaline liquid flows out under pressure when the film is cut, the diagnosis of osmotic blistering is made with near certainty. If the resin film separates cleanly from its bonding primer without any trace of free water, the defect stems from surface contamination or from exceeding the overcoating time. If, on the other hand, the resin tears off the surface skin of a friable screed, the cohesion of the substrate is at issue. In every case, the painter must immediately retrieve the calcium carbide measurement record drawn up before application.
Repairing a blistered floor requires complete removal of the synthetic build-up by planing or heavy shot blasting, until sound concrete or mortar is reached. Mere superficial scarifying retains the trapped water and dooms the future repair. Once the substrate is bared, a new drying phase is indispensable, often accelerated by installing condensation dehumidifiers under sealed enclosure. If programme constraints prevent waiting for the residual moisture to fall below the permissible thresholds, the specifier must order a specific system with a moisture-tolerant epoxy vapour barrier, accompanied by a contractual addendum approved by the client.
Frequently asked questions
Is an electronic capacitive tester enough to approve the application of a resin?
No. Electronic dielectric or capacitive devices only give indicative values without a binding standardised calibration. They serve only the team leader to map a room quickly and identify the dampest areas. Only the calcium carbide test, carried out in accordance with SIA 251 by sampling in the lower third of the mortar, constitutes the official physical measurement recognised in Switzerland in a judicial expert assessment.
Can a vapour-permeable resin be applied to get around a damp screed?
Some water-based epoxy systems or polyurethane-cement systems offer greater water vapour permeability than conventional resins. However, this permeability remains limited and never allows the dryness requirements of the substrate to be disregarded. A calcium sulphate screed holding too much water disintegrates under the primer, causing mechanical failure of the floor. Compliance with the SIA 251 thresholds remains imperative before any work.
Why do moisture thresholds differ between cement screed and anhydrite screed?
Cement screed generally tolerates a maximum residual moisture of two per cent by carbide, because the remaining water is slowly absorbed into the hydration of the binder. Conversely, calcium sulphate or anhydrite screed imperatively requires a level below zero point five per cent. With water trapped under a waterproof resin, the gypsum breaks down chemically through secondary ettringite, reducing the surface layer to a mud with no strength.
Who commissions and pays for the calcium carbide measurements?
Preparation and drying of the screed are the screeder's responsibility. The painter applying the waterproof resin, however, has the professional obligation to check the dryness of the substrate in order to decide whether to apply or to refuse it. According to Swiss practice and the works contract, the preliminary acceptance tests fall to the resin applicator or are the subject of a specific item invoiced to the site management according to the measured quantities.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 251Swiss standard for floating and bonded screeds inside buildings, defining in particular the residual moisture criteria for the application of impervious coverings.
