Key takeaways
- The SIA 251 standard sets the maximum permissible residual moisture for receiving a synthetic floor resin.
- The absence of a check measurement before application directly engages the technical liability of the applicator painter.
- Coring with calcium carbide measurement is the only destructive diagnosis that cannot be disputed in the event of a dispute.
- Renovation requires complete stripping of the blistered film and the application of a specific vapour-barrier primer.
Identify the osmotic origin of the blistering and document the moisture of the screed
Blisters and delamination on a floor poured in epoxy or polyurethane resin generally appear a few weeks to several months after acceptance. In the recurrent case of application on a recent cement screed, the defect almost always results from osmotic pressure or from the build-up of water vapour tension trapped under a waterproof film. When the binder has been applied to a substrate with a moisture content close to 5%, the rising capillary migration meets the waterproof layer, causing a loss of mechanical adhesion at the screed-resin interface.
- Osmotic pressure under resin
- Physical phenomenon in which the moisture trapped in the porosity of the screed dissolves mineral salts or soluble components of the poorly cross-linked resin, creating a pocket of concentrated liquid whose osmotic tension swells the surface film until it forms a permanent blister.
The initial visual diagnosis is not enough to close the investigation: piercing a blister often releases a highly alkaline liquid with a very high pH. The professional must then have material evidence of the condition of the substrate established through adversarial destructive investigations in the presence of site management and the screed layer.
- Non-destructive indicative surveyGrid survey of the surface using a capacitive or dielectric moisture meter to map the zones of moisture accumulation and identify critical areas.
- Coring of the screed and coveringSampling over the full thickness of the screed using a diamond core drill operating dry so as not to distort the internal water content of the concrete.
- Calcium carbide measurement (CM bomb)Crushing of the specimen taken from the lower third of the screed, precise weighing and reaction with the carbide in the pressure vessel according to the standardised method.
- Examination of the underside of the filmVisual and chemical analysis of the residues stuck under the torn-off film in order to confirm a cohesive failure of the screed or a lack of adhesion of the primer.
Establishing financial liability for the damage and carrying out the renovation
On construction sites subject to the SIA 118 standard and to the Code of Obligations, the question of who bears the cost rests on the traceability of execution checks. While the screed layer is required to deliver a compliant substrate, the applicator painter bears full liability for the damage if he applied the resin without first checking the residual moisture content of the substrate. Without a measurement record countersigned by site management before work started, the painter cannot rely on a hidden defect in the screed.
| Situation found | Classification of the defect | Financial responsibility |
|---|---|---|
| No CM moisture reading before resin application | Failure by the applicator to examine the substrate | Applicator painter (100%) |
| Compliant CM measurement documented, then external water ingress | Unforeseeable event or third-party waterproofing defect | Client or responsible trade |
| Formal written notice refusing the substrate, application ordered | Transfer of risk following written instruction | Client or site management |
| No waterproofing barrier under slab on ground | Design error in the structure | Shared according to expert report (engineering office / site management) |
Where the contractor's liability is confirmed, partial repair by patching is ruled out because of differential stresses and the risk of immediate recurrence around the repaired areas. Full renovation is required, following a strict protocol. The cost estimate for such remediation can reach very heavy amounts, often of the order of two to three times the original price of the painting package, because it combines waste disposal and rebuilding of the barrier.
- Complete mechanical strippingHeavy milling or planing of the whole surface to remove all of the delaminated resin as well as the laitance or the upper part of the screed contaminated by salts.
- Steel shot blastingPass of the shot blasting machine under continuous extraction to open the mineral porosity and obtain a suitable roughness, without residual dust.
- Application of a moisture barrierApplication of a specific epoxy primer tolerant of water-saturated substrates, applied in two crossed coats with broadcasting of oven-dried quartz sand to create the mechanical key.
- Pouring of the new finishing systemApplication of the new self-levelling or film-forming covering after the system blocking the residual moisture has fully cured.
Post-damage coring and consequences of the absence of a prior reading
The most frequent expert-assessment scenario with interior floor resin involves the appearance of osmotic blisters six to eighteen months after acceptance of the work. On opening a blister, the technician finds a brackish liquid under pressure and a clean adhesive failure at the level of the cement substrate. To establish the cause of the defect formally and beyond dispute between the parties on the construction site, the court or insurance expert does not rely on a surface capacitive moisture meter. The evidentiary procedure requires a destructive diagnosis by coring and direct measurement.
- Sampling by dry coringScreed cores are drilled dry, without cooling water, so as not to distort the water content of the material. Drilling is carried out immediately around the blistered areas and in areas believed to be sound for comparison. The core also allows the presence or absence of a stop barrier under the resin to be observed.
- Measurement of residual moisture by the Darr method or with carbideThe fragments taken from the lower third and the upper third of the screed are crushed and then analysed by oven drying at one hundred and five degrees (Darr gravimetric method) or with the calcium carbide flask. The SIA 251 standard sets the requirements for substrates of poured floor coverings. A measured value of between four and five per cent mass moisture in the body of a cement screed proves that no equilibrium state had been reached when the application work was carried out.
- Looking for the moisture barrier in the stratigraphic sectionMicroscopic analysis of the section of resin taken makes it possible to characterise the primer applied. The absence of a specific moisture-tolerant epoxy primer or of a multilayer vapour barrier confirms that the system applied was a standard waterproof covering, entirely vulnerable to osmotic pressure.
The decisive element of the expert assessment lies in consulting the site diary and the applicator's self-inspection sheets. If the application company cannot produce any written moisture measurement record from before application, its technical liability becomes indefensible. The SIA 251 and SIA 118 standards require the contractor to check the suitability of the substrate before any intervention. Applying a film-forming resin on an unmeasured screed amounts to tacitly accepting the substrate as it is.
Full renovation protocol and allocation of the cost of the damage
Once the moisture incompatibility is proven, no local repair by injection or patching guarantees the durability of the floor: the osmotic liquid migrates laterally and bursts the edges of the repaired areas. The renovation must be total. Work must restart from exposing the bare screed through to rebuilding a build-up certified as resistant to osmotic pressure, or be postponed until the concrete has dried completely.
| Renovation protocol step | Technical operations required | Allocation of financial burden | Contractual and normative basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Complete stripping of the resin | Heavy milling or planing, removal of the delaminated film and of the concrete contaminated by salts | Application company (painter-resin installer) | Obligation to remedy defects under the Code of Obligations and the SIA 118 standard |
| Diagnosis of the stripped substrate | Roughness check, control coring and new carbide moisture measurements | Application company (or shared with the civil liability insurer) | Mandatory prior check under the SIA 251 standard |
| Installation of the vapour barrier | Application of a special epoxy barrier for damp substrates or a cement-epoxy system | Application company (full corrective work) | Failure to give initial advice and breach of the prior duty to notify |
| Finishing coat and surfacing | Pouring of the new self-levelling compound and polyurethane sealing coat | Application company | Restoration in accordance with the original order at no extra cost to the client |
The direct cost of this damage includes mechanical planing under industrial extraction, removal of waste through an approved channel, application of a special stop barrier for saturated damp substrates, and complete reapplication of the resin system. To these amounts are frequently added compensation for loss of use of the building or for the forced relocation of users, as provided for in the works contract.
Crisis management, liability and full renovation
When osmotic blisters break through a covering poured in synthetic resin, the appearance of an alkaline liquid under high tension reveals residual moisture trapped in the mineral substrate. On a cement screed showing nearly five per cent mass moisture, the premature application of a waterproof epoxy system without a vapour barrier blocks the normal evaporation of the mortar. The trapped water dissolves the soluble compounds of the cement binder, generating a saline concentration that draws in moisture by osmosis and bursts the surface film. Having failed to record an adversarial calcium carbide reading before the work, the applicator has no technical defence against the client.
- Mechanical stripping and purging of the substrateComplete milling or shot blasting of the blistered cured film, careful removal of the delaminated mortar layers and industrial dust removal to open the pores of the cement.
- Check measurement and vapour barrierChecking of the surface cohesion followed by the mandatory application of a specific epoxy moisture-barrier primer compatible with damp substrates, before the self-levelling finishing system is reapplied.
The financial responsibility for this full rework lies entirely with the resin applicator. This damage covers the milling costs, the transport of residues, the rebuilding of the build-up and the losses linked to the premises being out of use. In accordance with the Code of Obligations, the craftsman bears the remedying of defects resulting from a manifest omission in the preparatory phase. Only the presentation of a formal notice drawn up before the work, pointing out the critical moisture level and the need for a dedicated barrier, would relieve the company. Failing such notification, the complete renovation is carried out at the sole expense of the resin installer, and its cost must be quantified according to the usual rules for tenders.
Frequently asked questions
Who commissions and pays for the post-damage destructive coring?
The coring diagnosis is generally commissioned by the client or its technical insurer to identify the origin of the defect. The investigation costs are initially advanced by the claimant. As soon as the measurements show that the blistering results from application on a screed that was too damp without a suitable barrier, these expert and laboratory costs are charged back in full to the applicator responsible for the initial failure to check.
Why does a screed at five per cent moisture cause blisters?
At five per cent mass moisture, a cement screed contains a significant quantity of free, uncombined water. The resin forms a completely impermeable film that blocks gas exchange. The residual water migrates towards the surface under the effect of temperature variations and dissolves mineral salts. A concentrated saline solution forms, which draws in water by osmosis, developing a hydraulic pressure greater than the adhesion of the resin.
Can the applicator blame the screed layer who delivered the floor?
No. The screed layer delivers a work subject to natural drying times that vary with the ambient humidity. Before applying a waterproof covering, the painter or resin installer has the strict duty to check the suitability of the substrate. The SIA 251 standard requires him to measure the residual moisture. If he applies his build-up on a screed that is not dry without warning site management, he bears full liability for the resulting damage.
Can only the visible blisters be repaired without redoing the whole floor?
A spot repair is bound to fail. The residual moisture remains present under the entire surface and the osmotic pressure will simply migrate to the adjacent areas that are still bonded. In addition, the liquid under the blisters chemically contaminates the surface mortar. The only lasting solution is to plane off the defective covering completely, remediate the screed and apply an approved vapour barrier before applying a new system.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 251Poured floor coverings
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work
