Key takeaways
- The single-unit trench box suits straight, shallow trenches with no crossing of underground pipes in service.
- Sliding-rail shoring allows the depth to be adjusted up to seven metres while limiting settlement of neighbouring properties.
- Steel sheet piles are required in soft, submerged ground or to bypass transverse pipes by means of adjusted embedment lengths.
- Shoring removal must always be carried out in coordinated stages with backfilling and compaction in successive layers.
Choose the support system according to the depth of the excavation and the available footprint
Under art. 68 OTConst, excavations deeper than 1 m 50 that are not propped or shored must be battered or secured by other adequate measures. Where the road geometry or the adjoining structure prevents opening a stable slope, the choice between a prefabricated trench box, sliding-rail shoring or a sheet pile wall depends directly on the excavation height and the geotechnical nature of the subsoil.
The self-supporting trench box, made of two steel panels joined by rigid struts, is the fastest solution down to 3 m 50 in depth. It requires sufficient lateral space so that the excavator can lower it in one piece. When the trench reaches 4 to 7 metres, or where the ground has poor bearing capacity with a risk of decompression under the carriageway, sliding-rail shoring on single or double rail posts takes over. Its panels are lowered independently in vertical rails, maintaining continuous pressure against the excavated walls. Double-rail sliding shoring allows the vertical spacing of the struts to be adjusted, freeing a usable clearance height for laying large-diameter concrete pipes. The steel sheet pile wall, driven by vibration or hammering before excavation, is required as soon as the water table calls for a watertight cofferdam or differential settlement threatens adjacent foundations.
| System | Optimum depth | Site footprint | Geotechnical limits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rigid trench box | Less than 4 m | Bucket width + 40 cm | Homogeneous ground, no water table |
| Sliding-rail shoring | From 3 m to 7 m | Bucket width + 60 cm | Soft soils with high earth pressure |
| Sheet piles | Beyond 4 m | Strict alignment of the piles | Water-bearing ground or compact rock |
Dealing with crossing services and sequencing installation and removal
The presence of underground utility services in operation determines the shoring equipment. Steel trench boxes form a solid, indivisible panel: they cannot cross any transverse pipe without a destructive cut or an abrupt stop of the run. If drinking water, gas or electricity services cut across the excavation axis, the site foreman turns to adjustable sliding-rail shoring fitted with short boxes with horizontal sheeting, or to a sheet pile wall. Driven sheet piles allow a window to be left open: the elements at the pipe are stopped higher up, while the neighbouring piles go down below the excavation bottom. The lower gap is wedged progressively with strutting timber fitted under the underside of the pipe, located beforehand by trial hole.
- Starting excavation and guidingExcavate to a depth of one metre with the backhoe bucket, keeping to the exact axis of the trench. Place the base element or the sliding posts and check verticality with a spirit level.
- Driving in stages and excavationLower the panels by pressing alternately on the uprights with the back of the bucket, then excavate the soil below the level of the cutting edges, never undercutting the ground by more than 50 centimetres.
- Securing the excavation bottomAdjust the lower strut jacks as soon as the design level is reached, place the gravel bedding layer and lay the pipe.
- Backfilling and removal of shoring in stagesBackfill the trench in successive 30 cm layers, carefully compacted. Raise the panels by an equivalent height at each stage to avoid any lateral decompression of the ground.
The order of removal is the critical point for the stability of adjacent infrastructure. Abruptly pulling out shoring over its full height before compaction releases the thrust stresses in the soil, creating lateral voids that cause delayed settlement of road surfacing or kerbs. The jacks and struts must only be loosened as the load-bearing backfill level compensates for the earth pressure.
Earth pressure and surface loads: designing the shoring
Under art. 68 OTConst, excavations, shafts and earthworks must be arranged so that falling or collapsing material endangers no worker, and those deeper than 1 m 50 that are not propped or shored must be battered or secured by other adequate measures. Thrust increases with the reduced cohesion of soft soils, the presence of pore water and the depth of excavation. The choice between prefabricated trench boxes, double-rail sliding shoring or a sheet pile wall therefore depends directly on the system's ability to balance this earth pressure without harmful deformation for the construction site.
According to art. 77 OTConst, props and shoring must withstand the foreseeable loads and forces, be built in accordance with the recognised rules of the trade and be designed taking additional loads into account, such as vehicles, machines and stored materials. At the top of the excavation, the movement of an excavator or the storage of gravel generates a decisive lateral thrust. While a standard single-unit trench box suits ordinary trenches up to three metres, sliding-rail shoring stiffens the wall thanks to its guide posts and adjustable cross-members. Steel sheet piles are required whenever hydrostatic pressure is added to earth pressure in saturated ground.
| Retaining system | Behaviour under earth pressure | Resistance to surcharges at the edge | Recommended depth range |
|---|---|---|---|
| Standard steel trench box | Load carried by fixed struts; risk of decompression during lowering | Moderate permissible surcharge; heavy traffic to be kept away from the edge | Excavations of 1.50 m to 3.50 m in stable soft ground |
| Double-rail sliding shoring | Plates guided by vertical posts; active limitation of settlement | Excellent resistance to surcharges thanks to adjustable cross-members | Excavations of 3.00 m to 6.50 m in constrained urban areas |
| Steel sheet pile wall | Pile toe embedded below the excavation bottom; watertightness and blocking of thrust | Very high resistance with walings and steel props | Deep trenches from 4.00 m or in a water table |
Execution phasing: crossing services and order of installation and removal
Installing shoring in a congested subsoil requires a precise analysis of the existing infrastructure. The crossing of buried services (gas, electricity, drinking water or sewers) is the first technical criterion excluding the closed trench box. The rigid walls of a single-unit trench box prevent a transverse pipe from passing through without breaking the continuity of the shoring. In this situation, sliding-rail shoring with modular plates or light manual sheet piles make it possible to slide the steel elements in on each side of the existing service, while the pipe is suspended by slings fixed to the upper strutting frames.
- Starting excavation and locatingPre-trench excavation to a maximum of one metre to locate transverse pipes visually. Position the guide posts or lower the first trench box level, checking plumb.
- Driving in by excavating under the shoringRemove the spoil by shovel in stages of fifty centimetres. Push alternately on the steel uprights to drive the system down progressively without decompressing the ground.
- Wedging and crossing servicesAdjust the sliding panels above and below the crossing pipes. Install the intermediate struts and prepare the bedding for the new pipe.
- Order of removal and staged compactionBackfill in thirty-centimetre layers compacted with a roller or vibrating plate. Raise the panels progressively by an equivalent height to prevent any void behind the shoring.
Removing shoring from a sheet pile wall requires similar management of deformations. Extraction with a vibratory driver can cause a rearrangement of fine sands or saturated silts, exposing road kerbs to settlement. Earthworks crews plan for immediate filling of the extraction void by injecting a bentonite-cement grout or a lean mortar. This methodical filling fixes the soil mass, prevents erosion of the excavation bottom and guarantees the integrity of neighbouring pipes after the support has been removed.
Handling construction site contingencies: jamming, decompression and unrecorded services
On the construction site, shoring incidents occur mainly when the ground proves unexpectedly heterogeneous or when water inflows change suddenly. Under art. 68 OTConst, excavations deeper than 1 m 50 that are not propped or shored must be battered or secured by other adequate measures. As soon as abnormal deformation of the walls appears, or when the trench box refuses to go down by simple excavation, the crew stops digging. Forcing it down with the excavator bucket is a mistake: it distorts the sliding uprights, warps the steel panels and jams later removal. When faced with a blockage on an erratic boulder or old masonry, clearing is done carefully in short stages under the lower cutting edge, never excavating hollow beneath the structure.
When an unrecorded underground service crosses the trench, the single-unit trench box becomes unusable without risk of rupturing the pipe. The remedy is to replace the system with individually driven sheet piles or with sliding-rail shoring allowing independent adjustment of the walings and struts. In accordance with art. 77 OTConst, shoring must withstand the foreseeable loads and forces, be built in accordance with the recognised rules of the trade and be designed taking additional loads into account, such as site machinery and stored materials. If scouring occurs in the presence of water, adding draining gravel and laying a geotextile blocks backward erosion under the cutting edges before any resumption of digging.
When disturbance extends to neighbouring structures, millimetre reference marks on adjacent façades and optical targets indicate structural movement. The appearance of a crack in the road surface near the excavation requires the struts to be readjusted and the surroundings to be relieved by removing spoil stored at the edge. In soft, waterlogged soils, if the shoring shows abnormal tilt, the civil engineer prescribes temporary wedging to restore equilibrium before the pipes are laid.
Frequently asked questions
How do you cross a gas pipe or a perpendicular electric cable with excavation shoring?
The standard trench box does not allow a transverse service to be crossed directly without creating a dangerous breach. Where a perpendicular cable or pipe is present, use sliding-rail shoring with vertical posts and adjustable cross-members, or drive short steel sheet piles on each side of the obstacle. The exposed service is suspended from an upper steel beam using flat textile straps to prevent any sagging or rupture.
When should sheet piles be preferred to sliding-rail shoring for a trench?
Sheet piles are required as soon as the excavation bottom goes below the water table or into unstable non-cohesive soils. Their interlocking joints provide relative watertightness and limit scouring by hydraulic piping. They are also essential when the surface footprint is extremely limited against adjoining façades, or if the depth exceeds six metres. Conversely, in dry, open ground, sliding-rail shoring offers a significantly higher output.
What method should be used to remove a shoring trench box without destabilising the excavation?
Shoring removal is always carried out in coordination with the backfilling of the trench. Backfill the area in horizontal compacted layers not exceeding 30 to 40 cm in thickness. Once the backfill height has stabilised against the panels, raise the trench box in regular vertical steps using the excavator's slings, without diagonal pull. This technique prevents lateral decompression of the soil and protects the laid pipes from sudden stresses.
Why does a shoring trench box sometimes refuse to go down during excavation?
This jamming most often results from excessive friction of the soil on the outer walls or from meeting a rock obstacle under the lower cutting edge. An asymmetric pushing force applied by the excavator may distort the steel uprights. To restore progress, clear the material under the bevelled cutting edge with a pick or a narrow bucket, then resume regular alternating driving without forcing.
Texts and standards cited
- OTConst art. 68arrangement of excavations, shafts and earthworks: protection against collapse and obligation to batter, prop or shore beyond 1 m 50
- OTConst art. 77requirements for props and shoring: resistance to foreseeable loads, compliance with the recognised rules of the trade and allowance for surcharges
