Key takeaways
- Excavations deeper than 1 m 50 require shoring or a suitably designed slope.
- The maximum permissible slope varies from 3:1 in sound rock to 1:2 in unstable backfill.
- A horizontal berm or freeboard of at least one metre remains mandatory at the crest of the slope.
- Run-off water and the storage of materials drastically reduce the stability of excavated slopes.
Defining the permissible slope according to the actual cohesion of the excavated ground
Opening an excavation without shoring means replacing the mechanical strength of a trench box with the inherent stability of the natural ground. Under art. 68 OTConst, excavations deeper than 1 m 50 that are not propped or shored must be sloped or secured by other adequate measures. Below this threshold, a vertical wall may be tolerated only if the ground has sufficient cohesion and is not subject to any vibration from machinery. As soon as the excavator goes beyond this excavation depth, the site manager and the foreman must adapt the cross-section to the ground actually uncovered in the skip.
The ground is not identified from the cab, but by visual and tactile examination of the excavated spoil. In accordance with art. 75 OTConst, the slope of the walls of excavations and earthworks must be adapted to the strength of the ground, and appropriate measures must be taken if it is compromised by heavy rainfall, thaw, loads or vibrations. Sound, unfractured rock allows almost vertical walls, with a height-to-base ratio of up to 3:1 (approximately 70° to 80°), provided that loose scales and unstable blocks are systematically scaled off along the working face.
| Ground type encountered | Theoretical ratio (H:B) | Indicative maximum angle | Behaviour during excavation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Massive, sound, non-deleterious rock | 3:1 to 2:1 | 70° to 63° | Very steep slopes possible, scaling of blocks mandatory |
| Compact gravels and well-graded alluvium | 1:1 | 45° | Good mechanical stability if the fines are not washed out |
| Fine sands, compact silts and moraines | 2:3 | 34° | Very high sensitivity to moisture and impacts |
| Soft clays, recent uncompacted backfill | 1:2 | 26° | Frequent circular slips, very flat sloping required |
In the clean alluvium of the Swiss Plateau, made up of dense moraine gravels and sands, the standard slope commonly applied by machine operators is 1:1, i.e. an angle of 45°. However, this geometry requires a complete absence of free water. If the trench passes through silts, glacial silts or non-cohesive fine sands, the internal friction angle drops sharply: the slope must then be flattened to 2:3 (approximately 34°), or even 1:2 (26°) in heterogeneous uncompacted backfill. Where the space available at the edge of the plot does not allow this geometric setback, open excavation becomes unworkable and the use of prefabricated shoring or a nailed wall is contractually required.
Managing crest surcharges, water ingress and safety berms
A slope angle calculated for ground at rest no longer holds once an external load is applied at the top of the slope. The pressure exerted by a twenty-tonne backhoe, a concrete mixer truck manoeuvring or a stockpile of excavated material generates a lateral stress that pushes the mass of earth towards the void. The standard requires a horizontal clear zone: the upper edge of the excavation must remain entirely free of any deposit or load over a minimum width of one metre. This safety strip also serves as a walkway for visual monitoring of the edge and maintenance of the surface-water drains.
- Locating machinery haul roads at a distance greater than the total depth of the excavation.
- Immediate removal of excavated material to a dedicated storage area set back from the crest.
- Installing a rigid barrier or a wheel stop to prevent any vehicle from approaching the unstable edge.
- Creating intermediate berms at least 1 m wide as soon as the excavation height exceeds 4 m.
Water is the most destructive collapse factor on an earthworks construction site. Pore water adds weight to the soil while cancelling the friction between grains through hydrostatic pressure. Under the ordinance on construction work, a proof of slope safety prepared by a specialist engineer or a geotechnical engineer is required in particular if the slope height is more than 4 m, if the planned depth-to-horizontal-setback ratios are not observed, or in the event of additional loads or water ingress. On site, the appearance of seepage or infiltration in the middle of the wall requires work to stop so that the area can be drained using fascines, filter gravel or well points connected to a pump.
For high excavations in loose ground, continuous excavation in a single slope carries a high risk of overall circular failure. The method of execution in line with good practice consists of dividing the height difference into successive benches. Each bench must not exceed three to four metres in vertical height and must be separated from the next by a horizontal berm of at least one metre fifty. This berm breaks the energy of surface run-off, retains small rockfalls and provides a base for laying a network of collection channels leading to soakaways or the site oil separator.
Replacing shoring with sloping: technical feasibility and regulatory framework
The choice of excavating with an open slope rather than installing shoring depends first of all on the geometry of the plot. If the absence of adjoining structures and the width of the available footprint make this profile possible, this method eliminates the handling of steel trench boxes and eases bucket manoeuvres. On the other hand, the volume of spoil increases markedly with depth. For site supervision, this solution requires a large footprint at the crest, increased haulage to approved disposal sites and regular checks on the stability of the exposed walls.
Under art. 68 OTConst, excavations, shafts and earthworks must be arranged so that falling or collapsing material endangers no worker; those deeper than 1 m 50 that are not propped or shored must be sloped or secured by other adequate measures. Below 1.50 m, a vertical wall may be maintained in compact loose ground without groundwater ingress. As soon as the excavation bottom goes beyond this depth, supervision must choose between installing certified shoring and opening a secured slope complying with the horizontal setback prescribed by good practice.
The stresses exerted at the crest of the excavation directly alter the equilibrium of the excavated ground. The movement of dumpers and mixer trucks and deposits of unscreened aggregate generate loads that promote landslides. A horizontal safety zone at least 1 m wide, kept free of any spoil or equipment, must run along the top of the slope. For the passage of heavy machinery, this clear strip must be widened to transfer the pressures beyond the theoretical failure plane.
Permissible slopes by ground type: rock, gravel, silt and backfill
The profiling of the excavation depends on the ground classification identified during stripping. The ordinance on construction work specifies that the slope of the walls of excavations and earthworks is adapted to the strength of the ground, and that appropriate measures must be taken if this strength is compromised by heavy rainfall, thaw, loads or vibrations. The foreman therefore adapts the slope as soon as the machine moves from compact moraine to vulnerable silty pockets.
| Ground encountered | Indicative maximum slope | Mechanical behaviour | Execution provisions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sound compact rock | Up to 3:1 (approximately 70° to 80°) | High cohesion, risk from decompressed blocks | Careful scaling of the wall and analysis of the dip of the strata |
| Moraine and compact gravels | 1:1 (45°) to 2:1 (approximately 60°) | High internal friction, adequate stability when dry | Intermediate berm from 3 m and a clear crest maintained |
| Silts and stiff clays | 1:1 (45°) to 2:3 (approximately 34°) | High sensitivity to water, risk of rapid collapse | Flattening of the slope, upstream drainage and sheeting |
| Backfill and reworked soils | 1:2 (approximately 26°) to 2:3 (approximately 34°) | Practically no cohesion, instability under load | Very flat slope, no storage at the crest and monitoring |
- Analyse the geological stratification and dipFrom the first excavation passes, check the stability of the working faces. Look for fluid sandy lenses, unstable backfilled areas or rock faults dipping towards the excavation.
- Adapt the profile as soon as water appearsWhen seepage or resurgences appear on the slope, reduce the excavation slope. Pore water pressure destroys the cohesion of silts and fluidises the fine materials of the face.
- Provide horizontal bermsAs soon as the slope height exceeds 3 m in loose ground, provide berms at least 1 m wide. These steps break the energy of run-off and prevent regressive erosion of the wall.
Control of rainwater and groundwater determines the stability of the slope throughout the works. During storms or thaw, saturated fine ground loses its cohesion under the effect of pore pressures. Laying polyethylene sheeting or weighted geotextiles prevents surface gullying of the excavation face. At the toe of the slope, a ditch collecting surface water towards a dewatering sump protects the base against scouring and keeps the excavation bottom dry.
Emergency measures and stabilisation in the event of failure or unexpected behaviour of the slope
On the construction site, the appearance of tension cracks at the crest, unexpected water seepage in the slope or bulging at the toe of the slope signals imminent failure. The first action is to evacuate the excavation bottom and secure the surrounding area. The backhoe clears the working zone at the top of the slope to remove any rolling load or spoil deposit.
- Unloading the crest and scalingRemove the soil stored at the edge and scale off the masses loosened from the surface using a suitable backhoe, without putting any personnel at the bottom.
- Creating a toe buttressSpread free-draining fill material or rock armour blocks at the toe of the slope to rebuild a counterweight and block the slip circle.
- Channelling water ingressLay a land drain or a gravel-filled drainage trench to divert surface water and intercept seepage before it saturates the mass.
- Waterproof sheeting of the wallDeploy reinforced sheets weighted down with sand sausages to preserve the cohesion of the soil against gullying and bad weather.
Under art. 68 OTConst, excavations deeper than 1 m 50 that are not propped or shored must be sloped or secured by other adequate measures. If the initial sloping no longer holds because of thaw or poor mechanical behaviour, resuming the excavation requires a change of method. Art. 76 OTConst provides for a proof of slope safety, prepared by a specialist engineer or a geotechnical engineer in particular in the event of additional loads or water ingress. Work resumes after formal agreement on the new slope geometry or the installation of appropriate shoring.
Frequently asked questions
How should you react when a pocket of pressurised water bursts out in the lower third of a slope?
Personnel must be evacuated from the excavation bottom. The water degrades internal cohesion and triggers piping or mudflows. A draining buttress is built at the toe using untreated coarse gravel, combined with relief pumping. The contractor informs the site management and calls in the geotechnical engineer to define a dewatering system or a flattening of the angle before excavation resumes.
Can you excavate vertically for 1.50 m and then start sloping above it?
This mixed method is only acceptable in stable rock or very compact ground without water ingress. If the soil has a loose or silty grading, the lower vertical section of 1.50 m risks collapsing under the weight of the upper soil. A horizontal berm at least 1 m wide must be provided between the shored vertical part and the toe of the unpropped upper slope.
What distance must be kept when driving a 10 t dumper at the crest of an excavation?
A clear strip of at least 1 m is mandatory at the crest of the slope for persons, but heavy machinery traffic requires a much greater setback. The load of a 10 t dumper acts directly on the failure prism. As a general rule, a haul lane at least 2 m from the edge is applied, increased by the depth of the excavation if no calculated shoring takes up the dynamic thrust.
What should be done if the plot boundary prevents the sloping angle required by the ground from being achieved?
Sloping is no longer applicable once the footprint extends beyond the property boundary without a validated encroachment agreement. The contractor must give up unsupported open excavation and install vertical support suited to the subsoil conditions: trench boxes, sheet pile walls, soldier pile walls or secant piles. This option requires a contractual adjustment and a structural design calculation prepared by a specialist civil engineer.
Texts and standards cited
- OTConst art. 68Excavations, shafts and earthworks deeper than 1 m 50 arranged so that falling or collapsing material endangers no worker.
- OTConstProof of slope safety prepared by a specialist engineer or a geotechnical engineer in particular if the height exceeds 4 m, or in the event of additional loads or water ingress.
