Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 221External windows and doors: installation and junctionsChapter 9 of 10 in the section

Replacing a window in renovation: full removal or retained frame

Window replacement in renovation confronts the installer with two technical choices: retaining the existing frame or carrying out a full removal. This chapter details the objective decision criteria, the preliminary mechanical diagnosis of the timber frame, the impact on the daylight opening and the residual thermal bridge, and the complete reconstruction of the reveals.

Key takeaways

  • Installation on a retained frame reduces the daylight opening and locks in a perimeter thermal bridge.
  • Mechanical probing of the existing frame determines the technical feasibility of reusing it.
  • Full removal guarantees thermal alignment but requires the masonry reveals to be reworked.
  • The internal airtightness connection must be continuous on the stripped structural work.

Choosing between retained frame and full removal according to building physics

In the renovation of external joinery, retaining the old window frame is often considered in order to limit work on interior finishes and reduce the time spent per opening. However, this approach places a new profile on top of an old joinery unit. The combined thickness of the jambs and rails systematically reduces the glazed area, causing a loss of daylight opening that frequently reaches 10 to 15 % per opening. In small or poorly oriented rooms, this reduction in light transmission directly affects visual comfort and passive solar gains.

From a thermal point of view, leaving the old frame in place creates a discontinuity between the insulation plane of the façade and the new joinery. Even when fitted with high-performance triple glazing, the window rests on an original timber-masonry interface that has no air- and vapour-tight barrier. This linear perimeter thermal bridge lowers the surface temperature at the interior junction, promoting the dew point and the appearance of mould under the finishing cover strips. According to standard SIA 118, the contractor is responsible for the conformity of the connections it carries out.

Technical comparison of installation methods in renovation
Technical criterionInstallation on retained frame (renovation)Full removal of the frame
Impact on daylight openingLoss of 60 to 120 mm around the glazed perimeterGlazed area preserved or increased
Overall thermal performanceThermal bridge persists at the old frameInsulation continuous against the new frame
Reworking of the revealsLimited to fitting added cover stripsComplete reconstruction of the plaster or masonry
Air and water tightnessTransferred to a timber substrate of unknown ageTreated directly on sound masonry (3 barriers)

Diagnosing the existing substrate and reconstructing the masonry reveals

Retaining the existing frame is technically acceptable only if it retains perfect mechanical integrity. The team leader carries out localised destructive probing using a square-pointed awl or a wood drill bit. The critical areas are the bottom rail, which is particularly exposed to historical driving-rain infiltration, and the bottoms of the jambs. The timber must show no rot, no fungal attack and no separation of the mortise-and-tenon joints. The anchoring of this frame in the masonry must also be checked by applying a horizontal pushing force to the intermediate jambs.

  1. Probing and clearing the old frameRemoval of the sashes, cutting off of the drip rails and milling of obstructing rebates. Application of a fungicidal treatment if the frame is approved, or complete removal of the frames in case of structural deterioration.
  2. Stripping and reprofiling of the revealIn full removal, elimination of the old tow or degraded foam sealing. Dust removal and levelling of the reveals with non-shrink mortar to obtain a flat, compliant bearing surface.
  3. Mechanical fixing and thermal packingPositioning of the new frame according to the prescribed sealing plane, direct fixing into the masonry using frame screws without plugs, observing the rigid bearing packers.
  4. Reconstruction of the three barriersInstallation of an impregnated pre-compressed tape on the outside against driving rain, controlled injection of flexible insulation into the installation joint, and bonding of a continuous vapour barrier membrane on the inside.

When full removal is chosen, reworking the interior reveals and the exterior jambs requires rigorous coordination. The window returns must be sized taking into account the thickness of the future lining or of the smoothing plaster coat. If the work is limited to window replacement without complete refurbishment of the façade, fitting a compensating sub-frame or a folded aluminium sheet connection profile ensures a watertight transition with the existing render. In the case of full removal, the cost of plasterwork and interior painting repairs often represents a substantial share of the operation, in the order of CHF 250 to 450 per opening, to be included from the planning phase.

Thermal impact and reduction of the daylight opening in renovation on an existing frame

Retaining the timber frame of an existing joinery unit limits heavy interior work, but this choice imposes major physical constraints on the opening. Inserting a new profile inside the old rebate results in a superposition of frames. This double thickness directly reduces the glazed area and alters the thermal geometry of the reveal connection, shifting the isotherm towards the interior.

The loss of glazed area depends directly on the width of the adaptation profiles and of the metal or PVC overlaps. On a narrow opening 80 cm wide, a perimeter loss of 50 to 70 mm on each jamb considerably reduces passive solar gain and alters the interior appearance of the reveals, particularly in period buildings where mouldings and plaster splays limit the returns.

Technical and building-physics comparison between full removal and retained frame
Evaluation criterionInstallation on retained frame (renovation)Full removal (complete refurbishment)
Daylight openingMarked reduction due to stacking of frame sectionsGross glazed area preserved or increased
Continuity of insulationResidual thermal bridge at the old hollow frameDirect connection to the structural work and continuity of the thermal plane
Airtightness barrierComplex interior joint to be guaranteed on a deformed old buildingContinuous airtight membrane bonded to sound masonry
Management of driving rainTotal reliance on the old flashing or folded adaptation sheetNew flashing with watertight side upstands according to SIA standards
Unit working timeVery short (2 to 4 hours per opening)Medium to long (1 to 2 days including plasterwork and painting)

Installation methodology: probing the frame, reworking the reveals and managing the construction site

The choice between retention and total removal is not based solely on time criteria. It requires a careful check of the mechanical stability of the existing frame. The old frame can serve as an anchoring substrate only if it is perfectly sound and firmly bonded to the masonry. At the same time, safety obligations must be anticipated from the planning of façade work in accordance with art. 3 OTConst.

  1. Mechanical and biological probing of the frameCheck the hardness of the timber by pricking with a screwdriver or square-pointed awl, particularly on the bottom sill piece, the lower corners and the areas near the drip rails. Any fibrous or softened timber, or timber showing signs of active moisture, rules out renovation on the existing frame.
  2. Checking the fixings in the masonryCheck the rigidity of the jambs by manual pulling and level checking. The original anchor lugs must show no play. If the frame moves under pressure, direct through-fixing into the stone or concrete is mandatory before any installation.
  3. Reworking the reveals in case of full removalRemove old debonded mortars and residual sealants. Reconstruct the edges of the reveal with a rapid-setting repair mortar to create a flat, dust-free surface, which is an absolute prerequisite for the adhesion of the sealing tapes.
  4. Connecting the three sealing barriersApply a pre-compressed tape or a breathable rain-screen membrane on the outside, thermal insulation injected or packed into the installation gap, and a continuous vapour barrier tape on the interior side to neutralise vapour transfer towards the wall.

In case of full removal, reworking the reveals often requires the plasterer to repair the reveals damaged by the extraction of the anchor lugs. This step generates fine mineral dust. To protect the health of installers during demolition, sanding or chiselling work, the employer is required to apply the general prevention measures provided for in art. 82 LAA, in particular by providing suitable respiratory protective masks and dust extraction devices.

Managing unforeseen events and disputes when replacing joinery

On a renovation construction site, the discovery of a rotten existing frame, friable masonry under the splays or traces of hidden condensation immediately changes the course of operations. When the retained-frame method proves inapplicable after the claddings have been removed, the installer must suspend the fixing of the new unit and record the actual condition of the substrate. According to CO, if the material supplied by the client or the ground designated by him is found to be defective, or if another circumstance compromises the proper or timely execution of the work, the contractor informs the client immediately, failing which he bears the consequences.

The forced switch from renovation on a retained frame to full removal generates additional intervention costs and changes the quantities of the profiles ordered. Reworking the reveals then requires chipping off the old plasters, applying a rapid-setting levelling mortar compatible with the sealing tapes, and reconstructing a rigid bearing seat. If suspect substances such as asbestos-containing sealants or lead-based paints appear during removal, work stops so that the analyses required by the ordinance on construction work can be carried out.

To protect the contractor's financial rights in the face of these demolition uncertainties, the traceability of joint findings is decisive. In case of technical deadlock or disagreement over the invoicing of unforeseen masonry work, CO specifies that after delivery, the client checks the condition of the work as soon as he can and notifies the contractor of any defects, each party being entitled to request an examination by experts. Drawing up work-stoppage records and formally notifying technical reservations protect the tradesperson's liability before mechanical fixings are resumed in the structural work.

Frequently asked questions

How should you react if the existing frame proves worm-eaten when drilling for the fixing screws?

Installation on the retained frame must be stopped immediately. No compliant mechanical anchorage can be guaranteed in degraded timber, which compromises wind stability and user safety. You must notify the client of the stoppage and propose switching to full removal. The masonry reveals will have to be stripped bare, levelled with mortar and refitted with sub-frames or direct fixings into the sound structural work.

What solution should be applied if full removal tears away part of the external wall insulation?

The edge of the reveal must be reconstructed before installing the new joinery to guarantee watertightness. Cut the damaged insulation cleanly with a hand saw to reach a sound section. Insert a strip of insulation of the same type, bonded and plugged, then rework the reinforced render with an overlapping glass mesh. The external pre-compressed tape will be applied only on this dry, continuous substrate, trued without any residual irregularities.

How can the significant loss of daylight opening imposed by a retained frame be compensated?

Choosing new profiles with a concealed sash or a very narrow central meeting stile makes it possible to regain several centimetres of glazing. If the room already suffers from low light input, the client must be guided towards full removal before manufacture. Retaining the old frame reduces the glazed area by 10 to 15 %, while creating a massive interior shoulder that accentuates the dark funnel effect around the opening.

What should be done if the thermal bridge of the retained frame generates mould on the cover strips?

The phenomenon indicates an interior airtightness defect combined with too low a surface temperature on the old timber. Remove the interior claddings, inject a stable fibrous insulation into the accessible cavities, and fit a vapour barrier membrane bonded continuously between the new frame and the masonry. Replace the cover strips with insulated profiles or profiles lined with a closed-cell foam strip to push back the dew point.

Texts and standards cited

  • COmaterial and ground: the contractor is responsible for the good quality of the material he supplies; if the material supplied by the client or the ground designated by him is found to be defective, or if another circumstance compromises the proper or timely execution of the work, he informs the client immediately, failing which he bears the consequences (para. 3).
  • COafter delivery, the client checks the condition of the work as soon as he can and notifies the contractor of any defects; for a building work, he has 60 days to notify them and a shorter contractual period is void (para. 1bis, in force since 1 January 2026); each party may request an examination by experts (para. 2).

In the same section