Key takeaways
- SIA 180 requires permeance that increases from the inside to the outside of the build-up.
- The condensation plane forms where the vapour pressure meets saturation.
- Summer drying requires effective removal of residual moisture towards the ventilated cavity.
- Any substitution of the dust barrier or vapour barrier absolutely requires a recalculation by the building physics office.
Glaser physics translated onto the scaffolding: the rule of decreasing Sd
On the execution drawings of a ventilated façade or a joinery lining, the order of the layers sometimes appears arbitrary to the installation crews. Yet the building physicist sizes each component using the method prescribed by SIA 180. This analysis compares two curves through the wall in winter conditions: the actual vapour pressure generated by indoor human activity and the saturation pressure, directly linked to the temperature drop within the insulation. As soon as the actual pressure curve touches the saturation curve, the water vapour changes state: liquid water appears in the heart of the insulation or against the bracing board. This critical point is called the condensation plane.
- Sd value (equivalent air layer thickness)
- A quantity expressed in metres that measures a material's resistance to water vapour diffusion. The higher the Sd, the more the material slows the passage of gaseous moisture.
To prevent this destructive physical phenomenon, the designer applies a strict rule: the resistance to diffusion must decrease from the warm interior to the cold exterior. On the interior side, the vapour retarder or vapour barrier has a high Sd value, often between 2 m and more than 20 m depending on the rooms. On the exterior side, in front of the mineral wool thermal insulation, the rain-barrier membrane of a ventilated façade has an extremely low Sd value, generally below 0.2 m. This hierarchy ensures that the small quantity of vapour able to pass the interior barrier can escape freely towards the ventilated air cavity without meeting an impermeable obstacle.
| Position | Functional layer | Vapour behaviour | Indicative Sd value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Interior | Continuous vapour retarder | Slows diffusion, blocks warm air | 2.0 m to 15.0 m |
| Centre | Mineral wool (panels) | Highly permeable, ensures the thermal gradient | 0.1 m to 0.2 m |
| Exterior | Façade membrane / rain barrier | Highly permeable, watertight against liquid water | 0.02 m to 0.10 m |
| Façade | Ventilated air cavity | Removes vapour to the outside | Free ventilation |
The summer drying cycle and the ban on changing the specified products
A building envelope never stays perfectly dry at all times: minor infiltration during the structural work phase, the residual moisture of concrete or winter micro-diffusion introduce water into the build-up. The durability of the façade rests entirely on its drying capacity. In summer, the flow reverses. Solar radiation heats the cladding and the air in the cavity, creating a thermal gradient directed towards the inside of the building. The materials must then allow this moisture to escape in both directions without condensing behind the interior linings.
Building elements must be designed so as to avoid any accumulation of moisture from one year to the next. The quantity of water condensed during the heating period must be able to evaporate entirely during the drying period.
norme SIA 180
On the construction site, there is a frequent temptation to replace a missing material with another one available in the van: replacing a humidity-variable vapour retarder with a standard polyethylene sheet, or bonding a bituminous sealing strip around a metal pre-frame instead of a vapour-permeable tape. This initiative breaks the balance established during the thermal sizing. A fully impermeable sheet will prevent drying towards the inside during summer heatwaves, trapping water in the frames or at the base of the lining.
Where a discontinuity or a geometric constraint requires the installation to be adapted at a joinery connection, the foreman must demand an official technical data sheet for the substitute product and submit it to site management. In accordance with the rules of the art of building referred to in art. 229 CP, the arbitrary modification of an insulation build-up that endangers the soundness of the structure constitutes a serious breach of the façade installer's professional responsibilities.
Hygrothermal calculation according to SIA 180 and the reality of installation
The sizing of a ventilated façade build-up or a window reveal is not a matter of site intuition. The building physics engineer models the behaviour of the wall according to the requirements of SIA 180 (Thermal insulation and moisture protection in buildings). The calculation evaluates the saturation vapour pressure at every point of the section, from the heated interior environment to the exterior ventilated air cavity. As soon as the partial vapour pressure exceeds the saturation pressure, the dew point is reached: liquid water condenses in the very heart of the insulation or against a cold face.
- Permeance and Sd value
- The Sd value represents the air layer thickness equivalent to a material's resistance to water vapour diffusion, expressed in metres. The higher the Sd value, the more the material resists the passage of vapour. Permeance directly measures the quantity of vapour passing through a given surface per unit of time and pressure difference.
For the installer of cladding or exterior joinery, the direct issue lies at the airtightness line. If a vapour retarder has a two-millimetre tear at a framing fixing bracket, or if an adhesive tape peels off at a window reveal, warm air laden with moisture infiltrates by convection. This concentrated air flow brings up to one hundred times more water into the wall than simple diffusion through a continuous membrane. The theoretical calculation of SIA 180 then becomes void, because it assumes continuous airtightness, perfectly sealed all around the openings.
| Position | Functional layer | Vapour behaviour | Consequence of a reversal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Interior side (warm) | Connected vapour retarder or vapour barrier | High Sd (impermeable or regulating) | Massive entry of vapour into the insulation in cold weather |
| Wall core | Thermal insulation (e.g. mineral wool) | Highly vapour-permeable | Loss of thermal performance if dampened |
| Exterior side (cold) | Vapour-permeable rain barrier | Low Sd (very open to diffusion) | Interstitial condensation blocked behind the screen |
| Rear face of cladding | Ventilated air cavity | Free convective removal | Summer and winter drying of the façade impossible |
Summer drying dynamics and management of material changes
A well-designed wall sometimes accumulates a tiny, admissible quantity of moisture during periods of intense cold in winter. The compliance of the structure rests on the fact that this moisture must evaporate completely during the warm months: this is the summer drying capacity. In summer, solar radiation intensely heats the façade cladding and the air cavity. This warming reverses the thermal gradient: the vapour then tends to migrate from the outside towards the inside of the building, or to escape vigorously through the ventilated air cavity.
Any unstudied modification on the construction site irreparably disrupts this hygrothermal balance. Replacing a mineral fibre insulation with a rigid board without recalculation, changing the brand of a humidity-variable vapour retarder, or substituting a breathable rain barrier with an impermeable bituminous membrane blocks the evaporation flow. By reducing the exterior permeance, the water remains confined against the timber framing or the reveal uprights. Biological degradation of the timber, corrosion of fixings and rotting of the interior linings occur silently over two to three heating seasons.
- Checking data sheets before orderingScrupulously compare the Sd value, the permeance and the reaction-to-fire class of the delivered material with the exact designations of the CFC 221 tender.
- Checking the ventilation conditionsGuarantee the air inlet sections at the base of the cladding and the outlet sections under the flashing or parapet to ensure the thermal draught essential for drying.
- Formal reporting in case of inconsistencyIf the execution details impose a non-vapour-permeable material on the outer face, draw up a written notice before installation in accordance with art. 365 CO.
Managing installation deviations and blocking unvalidated modifications
On an envelope construction site, reversing two components or substituting a membrane with a stock product ruins the hygrothermal balance defined by the engineer according to SIA 180. The permeance rule requires an Sd value that decreases from the inside to the outside in order to discharge winter moisture towards the ventilated cavity. If an installation error is found, such as a vapour retarder applied on the outer side of the insulation or a rain barrier replaced by a bituminous felt that is impermeable to diffusion, water inevitably accumulates at the condensation plane without being able to escape during the summer drying cycle.
- Stopping the area and joint inspection recordImmediately stop the installation of the cladding or facing in the affected area. Note the exact references of the membranes installed and record the non-conformity in writing to site management.
- Formal notification according to the contractThe contractor applies the duty to inform provided for in art. 365 CO: if a circumstance compromises the proper execution of the work, they inform the client. No membrane change is decided verbally.
- Instruction from the building physicistWait for the recalculation of the balance according to SIA 180. If the summer drying capacity is compromised, remove the build-up without technical compromise until the prescribed order is restored.
Any change of brand, insulation thickness or type of film modifies the thermal resistance and the overall permeance of the wall. If a dust barrier is rolled out instead of the prescribed humidity-variable vapour retarder, the uptake of interior moisture in winter exceeds the summer drying capacity. Only formal validation by the engineering office authorises re-fixing. Art. 364 CO subjects the contractor's liability to the same rules as that of the employee: fidelity to the plans and specifications remains the only guarantee against hidden interstitial defects.
Frequently asked questions
Can a humidity-variable vapour barrier be replaced by ordinary polyethylene film?
No. Polyethylene film blocks water vapour completely, with its fixed and high Sd value. The building physicist specifies a humidity-variable membrane to allow summer drying of the wall towards the inside of the building when the vapour migrates in the opposite direction under the effect of the summer sun. Removing this drying capacity locks moisture into the heart of the board or insulation, causing mould.
What should be done if a roll of rain barrier without clear marking is delivered to the construction site?
Refuse to install it and check the data sheet with the supplier. A rain barrier for ventilated cladding must meet strict vapour permeability requirements under SIA 180. If the delivered material has too high a resistance to diffusion, the water condensed within the thickness of the façade insulation will never be able to evaporate towards the ventilated air cavity.
Why is the layer order rule stricter at altitude in French-speaking Switzerland?
At altitude, winter outdoor temperatures are very low and prolonged, which accentuates the vapour pressure drop through the wall. The dew point is quickly reached within the insulation. The layer order ensures that interior moisture does not enter faster than it escapes to the outside. Failure to respect permeance leads to destructive internal icing.
Can site management verbally authorise the change of a membrane?
No, a verbal agreement never protects the company in the event of a subsequent hygrothermal loss. The composition of the façade depends on a validated thermal calculation note. Any product change requires a prior recalculation of the vapour discharge capacity according to SIA 180 and a written change order, signed by the designer before installation on the profiles.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 180Thermal protection, moisture protection and indoor climate in buildings
- COObligations of the contractor: liability subject to the same rules as that of the employee; execution of the work in person or under their personal direction
- CO art. 365Material and ground: the contractor is responsible for the material supplied; if a circumstance compromises regular or timely execution, they must inform the client immediately (para. 3)
