Key takeaways
- Any building constructed before 1991 requires an asbestos diagnosis before work on the old render.
- Chiselling or sanding an asbestos-containing render releases large quantities of invisible, highly pathogenic fibres.
- Art. 3 OTConst requires the contractor to assess the risks and plan the necessary protective measures.
- Art. 32 OTConst requires work to be stopped and the client to be informed in the event of a discovery.
The pre-work asbestos diagnosis determines the preparation of substrates
Before applying an external thermal insulation composite system (ETICS) to an existing masonry wall, surface preparation often requires probing, chipping, stripping or sanding old mineral and organic renders. On Swiss buildings constructed before the asbestos ban in 1990, these exterior coatings are frequent sources of chrysotile fibres. Float-finished or sprayed finishing renders, facade levelling coats, textured paints and cladding adhesives commonly contained between 0.1% and 5% asbestos to improve workability and weather resistance.
According to art. 3 OTConst, work is planned so that the risk of harm to health is as low as possible, and the employer identifies and assesses the hazards and then plans the necessary measures where the presence of asbestos is suspected. For the facade contractor, this means requesting the pre-work diagnosis report before sending the teams onto the scaffolding deck. The investigation must explicitly cover the external envelope, with core samples taken through all paint and mortar layers down to the load-bearing substrate.
| Facade material | Typical period | Risk during ETICS preparation | Diagnostic precautions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mineral and synthetic renders | 1960 to 1990 | Chiselling, sanding, thermal stripping | Sampling through the full thickness down to the substrate |
| Levelling coats and screeding mortars | 1950 to 1985 | Drilling for insulation fixings | Analysis of the intermediate levelling layers |
| Joinery sealing mastics | 1960 to 1990 | Tearing out when replacing or insulating reveals | Testing of each type of elastomeric mastic |
| Panels under lintels and soffits | 1950 to 1990 | Mechanical fixing of plinth profiles | Check for asbestos cement or lightweight panels |
If the report drawn up by the building pollutant diagnostician concludes that asbestos is present in the render or adhesive, removing the coating is not part of the facade contractor's routine operations. Work releasing significant quantities of fibres must be entrusted to a specialist remediation company before the insulation installation teams intervene. Where the report certifies the absence of asbestos, the analysis reports must be kept in the construction site safety file.
Stopping work and reporting when an unexpected discovery is made on the render
Old facades often undergo successive localised repairs over the decades. An initial diagnosis based on spot sampling may miss a repair area, an old paint hidden under a recent levelling coat or a bituminous mastic under a window sill. The installation team must remain alert to any visual inconsistency in the render or the appearance of sub-layers not described in the initial report.
If a substance particularly hazardous to health is found unexpectedly, work must be stopped and the client or their representative informed.
art. 32 OTConst
As soon as a worker notices a doubtful layer, the on-site reaction must prevent any fibres from becoming airborne. The foreman stops operations in the area concerned without delay. Power tools not connected to class H industrial vacuum cleaners are unplugged, and the area is cordoned off to prevent other trades working on the scaffolding from passing through.
- Suspension of mechanical operationsImmediately stop all chiselling, drilling or sanding on the suspect facade. If necessary, lightly dampen residual dust with water to bind volatile particles.
- Cordoning off and closing the work areaProhibit access to the section of scaffolding concerned. Put up a danger warning sign and block access from the service ladders.
- Written notification to site managementFormally notify the client or their representative by means of a notice of work stoppage stating the condition of the area, the location of the zone and the suspected risk.
- Sampling and analysis by a specialistThe client appoints a certified diagnostician to take representative samples and have them analysed by electron microscopy in an accredited laboratory.
- Resuming work or reorganising the phasingWait for the formal results. If the result is negative, record the lifting of the reservation. If the presence of asbestos is confirmed, adjust the schedule for the duration of the remediation.
Procedures for working on deteriorated render and technical extraction measures
Before applying an external thermal insulation composite system to an old facade, the mechanical condition of the substrate calls for preparation operations such as hammer sounding, chipping out non-adherent areas, brushing or removing chalking finishing layers. Where the building was erected before the general ban on hazardous mineral binders and synthetic fibres, every superficial mechanical intervention carries a risk of particle dispersion into the immediate environment. Old float-finished mineral renders, synthetic renovation renders or thick textured paints applied to facades frequently incorporated fibrous silicates to improve impact resistance and prevent cracking.
Treating a render containing fibres cannot be equated with ordinary facade refurbishment. The facade contractor must under no circumstances use free-disc sanders, renovation milling machines without dedicated extraction, or pressure washers above the pressures permitted for asbestos-containing substrates. Very high-pressure water breaks down the organic or mineral matrix and disperses particles into the run-off sludge, polluting the ground at the foot of the scaffolding and the surface water drainage networks.
| Facade operation | Mechanical effect on the render | Required technical measure | Treatment route |
|---|---|---|---|
| Localised chipping of hollow-sounding areas | Fracturing and spot removal | Hand tools with constant wetting, local extraction | Sealed packaging for compliant disposal |
| Surface levelling sanding | High-speed surface abrasion | Rotary machines connected to a certified vacuum cleaner with absolute filter | Sealed waste bags labelled for pollutants |
| Thermal or chemical stripping | Softening of the binder without percussion | Hand scraper, collection of pasty residues on a waterproof sheet | Disposal at a landfill of the appropriate type according to analysis |
| Surface washing before bonding insulation | Washing and rinsing at moderate pressure | Full recovery of wash water via watertight channels | Filtration of sediments before discharge or controlled disposal |
For bonded-and-dowelled installation of expanded polystyrene or mineral wool boards, the flatness of the old substrate must meet the requirements of the render manufacturers' application guides and standard SIA 243. If complete removal of the contaminated render proves technically disproportionate to the risks involved and pull-off tests confirm the residual cohesion of the substrate, a suitable mechanical fixing may pass through the existing render. In this configuration, each fixing hole requires drilling equipment fitted with an annular extraction nozzle pressed against the facade to contain the dust generated at source.
Coordination of parties, notification obligations and resumption of installation
According to art. 3 OTConst, work is planned so that the risk of occupational accident, occupational disease or harm to health is as low as possible, and if the presence of asbestos or PCB is suspected, the employer identifies and assesses the hazards and plans the necessary measures. A contractor entering into a works contract examines, before signing, the measures necessary for health and safety. Art. 32 OTConst provides that if a substance particularly hazardous to health is found unexpectedly, work must be stopped and the client or their representative informed.
The information given to the client must be clear and detailed. The site manager notifies in writing the partial or total stoppage of the substrate preparation tasks, citing the appearance of a material not listed in the initial pre-work diagnosis report. This contractual step protects the facade company against financial claims linked to schedule delays, since the risk of discovering unknown pollutants is part of the uncertainties of an existing structure.
- Report without delay to the works supervisor the presence of any suspect, friable or fibrous binder uncovered during chipping.
- Blocking off the scaffolding access serving the bays concerned and cleaning the landings with a filtering vacuum cleaner.
- Checking the construction site's technical safety file to adapt the respiratory protective equipment of the personnel present.
- Waiting for the results of microscopic analyses from a specialist laboratory before any restart of remediation or insulation installation work.
- Coordination with the asbestos removal company recognised by SUVA when the emission level requires remediation under containment.
Once remediation has been carried out by specialists or the negative diagnosis confirmed by the analysis laboratory, work resumes on a surface that has been remediated, dedusted and declared clean. The facade contractor then applies the primer coat or bonding bridge recommended by the manufacturer of the thermal insulation system. Scrupulous compliance with this chain of decisions guarantees the safety of the fitters, prevents contamination of the neighbourhood and ensures the mechanical durability of the insulation board fixed to a remediated substrate.
Emergency protocol and dispute management in the event of an unexpected discovery
On a thermal renovation construction site, the unexpected discovery of a fibre-containing render or a doubtful levelling coat during substrate preparation interrupts the planned sequence of work. A bituminous sub-layer hidden under the mineral render, a reveal mastic or a tile adhesive not listed in the initial report are frequent examples of such incidents. In this situation, the installation team must under no circumstances attempt to remove, sweep or sand the disputed area by its own means.
- Stopping the work stationStop all mechanical scraping, drilling or chiselling in the area concerned. Close off the scaffolding at that location and prohibit the passage of personnel without protective equipment.
- Fixing and local containmentNever vacuum with an ordinary site vacuum cleaner. Lightly dampen the flaking area or lay a sealed plastic sheet secured with adhesive tape to prevent airborne fibres.
- Formal notice to site managementReport the finding to the foreman and to site management. Draw up a written notice describing the exact location and visual nature of the suspected material.
- Expert assessment and samplingSite management appoints a certified diagnostician to take a sample and have it analysed in a laboratory in accordance with SUVA guidelines.
According to art. 32 OTConst, if such a substance is found unexpectedly, work must be stopped and the client or their representative informed. The employer also ensures that employees are protected from any exposure. For its part, art. 3 OTConst provides that if the presence of asbestos or PCB is suspected, the employer identifies and assesses the hazards and plans the necessary measures.
From a contractual standpoint, this temporary suspension is the subject of a formal notice of stoppage addressed to site management in accordance with the Code of Obligations (CO). This document records the date of stoppage, the scaffolding bays put out of use and the foreseeable impact on the external insulation installation schedule, thereby preserving the company's rights against late-completion penalties.
Frequently asked questions
What should be done if the client refuses to provide a pollutant diagnosis before the start of the construction site?
In the absence of a diagnosis for a building constructed before 1990, the contractor must not begin destructive substrate preparation work. They send a written notice recalling that occupational safety legislation makes the start of work conditional on the prior identification of risks. Operations remain suspended without penalty as long as the client has not had the required assessment carried out by an accredited professional.
Can a facade contractor take samples from a suspect render themselves?
No, sampling of suspect exterior renders falls exclusively to a qualified diagnostician with recognised competence. Sampling involves strict technical procedures to prevent the dispersion of fibres: prior wetting, cutting under extraction with an appropriate filter, sealed packaging and standardised labelling. A facade contractor who took a fragment themselves would risk contamination and would unduly incur liability in the event of a dispute over the representativeness of the sample.
Can insulation boards be bonded directly onto an old render containing asbestos without stripping it?
Covering an asbestos-containing render without prior stripping is only conceivable if the substrate has sufficient mechanical cohesion and if the cantonal authority permits it. However, dowelling through insulation boards remains an emissive operation requiring heavy precautions: certified source extraction, specific drill bits and suitable personal protective equipment. If the render sounds hollow or chalks, its complete remediation by a specialist company becomes unavoidable before the insulation is installed.
How should the scaffolding be closed off when work is stopped because of an asbestos discovery?
As soon as operations are interrupted, the site manager physically blocks access to the scaffolding levels alongside the facade concerned. Explicit signage prohibits entry by any unauthorised person by means of barriers and standardised warning signs. This closing-off is recorded in the site diary and notified in writing to the client, in order to certify that the work area remains secured against any risk of secondary contamination until the analysis results are available.
Texts and standards cited
- OTConst art. 3planning of construction work: work is planned so that the risk of occupational accident, occupational disease or harm to health is as low as possible; if the presence of asbestos or PCB is suspected, the employer identifies and assesses the hazards and plans the necessary measures
- OTConst art. 32substances particularly hazardous to health (asbestos, PCB): if their presence is suspected, the employer identifies and assesses the hazards, plans the necessary measures and informs the workers of the diagnostic results; if such a substance is found unexpectedly, work must be stopped and the client or their representative informed
