Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 224Roof covering: tiles, slates and installation on battensChapter 9 of 10 in the section

Snow guards: where to place them, how many rows, and what they are anchored to

A sheet of snow sliding off a roof is a mass of several tonnes capable of causing serious injury or the death of a pedestrian. This chapter details the calculation of snow loads according to geographical zone and altitude, the layout of the retention system on the slope and the mandatory anchoring technique into the load-bearing structure.

Key takeaways

  • The sizing of the devices depends directly on the snow load of the locality.
  • The length of the rafter run determines the number of snow guard rows to be installed.
  • Every anchor must be fixed into the rafters or the load-bearing battens, never onto the tile batten.
  • Reinforced protection is mandatory above entrances and circulation areas.

Load calculation and distribution of snow guard rows on the roof slope

The sizing of snow retention devices is not a matter of empirical judgement. In French-speaking Switzerland, the mass of snow accumulated on a roof slope can exceed several hundred kilograms per square metre depending on altitude and climatic region. The thrust exerted by the snow cover sliding along the tiles or slates generates very high shear and pull-out forces. Ignoring these forces exposes people at the roof edge to falling solid elements that are particularly dangerous.

To determine the quantity of retention elements (individual hooks, bars or snow guard grilles), the roofing plumber must analyse the characteristic load at the site. The steeper the roof pitch, the greater the force parallel to the roof covering. The length of the line of slope — the rafter run — requires multiple stop lines to break up the falling mass and avoid an internal avalanche effect.

Recommended layout of retention lines according to altitude and rafter run length
Construction site altitudeRafter run lengthMinimum number of rowsArrangement of the equipment
Up to 600 mLess than 5 metres1 rowAt the eaves above walkways
Up to 600 mMore than 5 metres2 rows1 row at the eaves, 1 middle row
From 600 m to 1000 m5 to 8 metres2 to 3 rowsStaggered or continuous arrangement
Above 1000 mMore than 6 metres3 rows or moreContinuous grilles and distributed hooks

Load-bearing anchoring technique and targeted protection of access zones

The classic roofing error is to fix the snow bar brackets or hooks directly onto the tile batten. A standard-section spruce batten is absolutely not sized to take transverse tensile forces. Under the thrust of the snow cover, the batten breaks or its nailing pulls out, taking the entire device and the adjacent tiles with it.

The retention brackets must be anchored into the load-bearing support of the roof structure: either directly into the rafter, or through the rigid boarding or counter-battens mechanically fixed into the main structure. The anchoring wood screws must have a sufficient diameter and embedment depth to withstand the pull-out load guaranteed by the manufacturer of the sheet-metal system.

  1. Locating the load-bearing elementsMark the position of the rafters through the underlay so that the fixing brackets are perfectly aligned.
  2. Notching or cutting of the roofing materialGrind or cut the exposed part of the underlying tile to allow the anchor bracket to lie flat without creating extra thickness or a point of water ingress.
  3. Mechanical fixing of the bracketScrew the retention bracket into the roof structure with structural screws in stainless steel or hot-dip galvanised steel, according to the system's recommendations.
  4. Fitting the bars and replacing the tilesInsert the bars or grille into the brackets, engage the safety locks and cover with the trimmed upper tile.

If there is doubt about the strength of the existing roof structure sections during a renovation, the roofing plumber must notify the site management. Under art. 365 CO, if the ground or the support designated by the client is defective, the contractor must immediately inform the client so that the fixings can be adapted and defective performance avoided.

Determining the snow load according to altitude and layout on the roof

On pitched roofs, snow accumulation generates significant static and dynamic thrusts along the rafter run. During a surface thaw, a sodden snow cover suddenly sliding can exert a pull-out force of several hundred kilograms per linear metre, creating a fatal risk for people at the bottom of the roof fall. The sizing of retention systems is based on the characteristic snow load of the site, calculated according to the altitude of the construction site, the roof pitch and wind exposure.

Indicative ground load values and theoretical snow density in French-speaking Switzerland
Site altitudeType of snowIndicative densityEstimated ground load
Less than 400 m (e.g. Rhône plain)Wet fresh snow100 to 200 kg/m³0.90 kN/m²
400 m to 800 m (e.g. Plateau / Jura foothills)Compacted / accumulated snow300 to 400 kg/m³1.20 to 1.85 kN/m²
800 m to 1200 m (e.g. Prealps / Jura)Dense or water-saturated snow400 to 600 kg/m³1.85 to 3.20 kN/m²
Above 1200 m (e.g. Valais Alps)Compact firn / ice600 to 800 kg/m³More than 3.20 kN/m²

To prevent failure of the retention elements or snow passing over the eaves edge, the distribution of hooks or snow bars must be planned in successive lines. On long rafter runs (exceeding 4 to 5 metres), a single row at the eaves suffers a destructive leverage effect under the weight of the snow cover above. The snow mass is therefore broken up by doubling or tripling the rows distributed over the height of the bay.

Anchoring to the load-bearing elements of the roof structure and securing access

The classic installation error is to fix the hooks or the snow guard tube supports directly onto the tile battens. Under a major shear force, the batten splits or tears away from the counter-batten, causing damage to the roof covering and the sudden fall of the snow slab. The force must absolutely be transmitted to the load-bearing structure of the roof.

  • Direct anchoring to the rafter: The fixing bracket of the retention hook or bar support passes through the double battening and is anchored directly into the roof timber using flat-head structural wood screws.
  • Fixing to a reinforced eaves board: Where there is continuous boarding, the fixing passes through the board and the counter-battens to reach the vertical load-bearing elements.
  • Watertightness at penetrations: Fitting a sealing gasket or a sealing sleeve under the fixing bracket prevents any water ingress at the level of the underlay.

The layout of snow guard systems is particularly critical above pedestrian circulation areas and building access points. Under art. 17 OTConst, measures must be taken at passageways and workplaces to prevent people being endangered by falling objects or materials. Above main entrances, garage access roads, pavements and parking areas, the system must be reinforced. In these priority zones, the roofer installs a combination of a high snow guard grille and hooks distributed per tile to block the extrusion of the lower layer of the snow cover.

Handling snow slide incidents: responsibilities and rework of anchors

When a mass of snow or ice detaches from a roof slope and falls into a circulation area, the risk of injury or damage is at its maximum. If an accident occurs or an anchor failure is found after a major snowfall, the roofing plumber must intervene immediately to secure the perimeter and analyse the causes of the failure. Under CP, a person who directs or carries out work in breach of the recognised rules of the trade and endangers the life or physical integrity of others is liable to criminal penalties. Defective sizing or fixing of snow guard hooks falls directly under this responsibility.

In accordance with the Code of Obligations, the client may hold the builder liable in the event of a defect. If the snow load exceeds the design value for the region or if an installation defect is identified, a strict remedial protocol must be applied.

  1. Immediate securing of access below the slopeSet up ground markings and prohibit passage under the potential fall zone. Manually clear the remaining accumulated snow using fall-protection equipment.
  2. Inspection of the anchors and load-bearing supportsRemove the tiles around the failure points to inspect the rafter. Check whether the timber has split, whether the wood screws have sheared or whether the hooks have deformed by exceeding the elastic limit.
  3. Recalculation of sizing and reinforcementRecalculate the snow surface load according to the altitude of the site in accordance with the SIA standards. Distribute the additional rows over the roof slope and increase the density of hooks per square metre.
  4. Direct anchoring to the rafters with structural screwsRefix galvanised steel or stainless steel supports directly into the roof structure using wood screws of at least 8 mm diameter, pre-drilled to avoid splitting the load-bearing timber.

Frequently asked questions

Why is it forbidden to fix snow guard hooks only onto the tile batten?

The batten is not a load-bearing roof structure element sized for the pull-out and shear forces caused by sliding snow. Under the thrust of the mass, the batten breaks or comes away from the counter-batten, causing the tiles and the complete system to fall. The fixing must pass through the counter-batten to be anchored into the load-bearing rafter.

How do you determine the number of snow guard rows needed on a roof?

The number of rows depends on the roof pitch, the length of the rafter run and the characteristic snow load of the site linked to altitude. A single row at the eaves is not enough on long rafter runs: the accumulated load risks crushing the first line. Intermediate rows distributed over the whole surface should be added to break up the snow slab.

What should be done above entrance doors and pedestrian access points?

Above passage zones, the density of snow guards must be reinforced. A system of grilles or double metal bars at the eaves edge is generally combined with a close distribution of hooks on the upper part of the slope. This combination prevents both the sliding of blocks of ice and the runoff of sodden snow above the access points.

Who is responsible in the event of an accident caused by snow falling from a roof?

The owner of the structure is liable for damage caused by construction defects or lack of maintenance. However, the roofing company that carried out the work may be held liable on the basis of CP if the system was incorrectly sized or installed in breach of the recognised rules of the trade, in particular in the case of defective anchoring to a non-load-bearing support.

Texts and standards cited

  • CPbreach of the recognised rules of construction

In the same section