Key takeaways
- The wind drives powder snow through the side and head laps of the tiles.
- Ventilated eaves combs and ventilated closures let fine crystals through but prevent critical accumulations.
- The underlay is the real watertight line of defence against the melting of powder snow.
- Direct exposure to the prevailing winds requires the watertightness of the underlay to be upgraded at altitude.
Infiltration mechanisms under wind action and limits of roofing accessories
Alpine powder snow is characterised by fine, cold, cohesionless crystals, often less than one millimetre in diameter. When a storm front hits a slope, the dynamic pressure of the wind creates overpressure on the windward side and suction on the leeward side. This pressure difference forces the crystal-laden air through the gaps between the small roofing elements. The interlocks of clay or concrete tiles, designed to act as a barrier against downward driving rain, prove permeable to these turbulent airflows.
- Direct penetration through the side interlocks and the tile exposure under the effect of differential pressure.
- Suction at the break lines, hips and ventilated ridges through the Venturi effect.
- Turbulence around roof penetrations, such as chimneys, dormers or roof windows.
- Low-level infiltration at the eaves when the eaves ventilation inlets are not protected.
On the construction site, the classic mistake is to believe that mechanical accessories in plastic or metal are enough to make the roof covering snow-tight. An eaves comb keeps out birds and rodents, but its spacing lets powder snow through with no resistance at all. Likewise, flexible ventilated ridge closures are fitted with perforations or woven fabric: while these openings stop the heavy, wet flakes of low altitudes, they quickly clog with dry snow in strong gusts, before letting it creep under the ridge by suction.
Synthetic foam fillers placed at the eaves or in the valleys are another frequent trap. Soaked with water after the first thaw, they freeze into a rigid block that blocks drainage at the eaves bed and lifts the adjacent tiles, increasing the water paths during later thaws.
Design of the underlay at altitude and management of melting infiltrations
Since the discontinuous roof covering is not a barrier against air and fine snow, the alpine technical rule requires the underlay to be treated as the true collecting barrier. Powder snow deposited on the membrane inevitably melts under the residual heat flow escaping from the insulation or as soon as the first solar radiation warms the tiles. The system must guide this meltwater to the gutter or the drip edge without contact with the timber or the thermal insulation.
| Loading level | Exposure conditions | Underlay requirements | Treatment of perforations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Normal loading | Altitude below 800 m, slope sheltered from the wind | Taut flexible membrane, free or simple bonded laps | Nailing sealing strips recommended under counter-battens |
| High loading | Altitude between 800 and 1200 m, frequent prevailing wind | Welded or bonded membrane on continuous boarding, rain-tight class | Systematic nailing sealing strips under battens |
| Extraordinary loading | Altitude above 1200 m, exposed ridges, heavy snow squalls | Watertight underlay, welded bituminous or synthetic strips | Counter-battens coated or embedded in the sealing |
For mountain construction sites, the professional guidelines for pitched roofs require an underlay for extraordinary loading as soon as the pitch is low or the building is directly exposed to ridge winds. The membrane must absolutely rest on a continuous rigid substrate, made of rough-sawn board sheathing or wood-based panels complying with the construction standards in force.
The site manager must carefully check the execution of the details at the singular points: upstands of at least 150 mm along dormer cheeks, welded flashings around flues and specific treatment under the hips. In accordance with art. 365 CO, the contractor notifies the client of any specification in the file providing for a standard underlay in an area known for its winter drifts.
Actual effectiveness of roof accessories against powder snow
On construction sites at altitude or exposed to strong bise conditions, powder snow driven by the dynamic pressure of the wind penetrates through the slightest gap in the roof covering. Dry snow grains, often less than 0.2 mm in diameter, bypass the side interlocks and the exposure of clay or concrete tiles. For sheet-metal workers and roofers, it is essential to distinguish between devices intended to keep out birds and those that prove totally ineffective against fine deposits.
| Verge or ridge device | Main function | Behaviour against powder snow | Consequence for the underlay |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flexible or rigid eaves comb | Keeps out birds and rodents | Ineffective (spacing too wide) | Lets the snow front through under the gutter |
| Ventilated roll ridge closure with pleated flashing | Ridge ventilation and rain barrier | Permeable to fine grains under strong pressure | Drifts build up on the top strip |
| Perforated rigid metal closure | Mechanical ridge ventilation | Ineffective against the bise | Direct passage of snow crystals |
| Watertight ridge bridging on the underlay strip | Continuity of the watertight membrane | Total stop under the roof covering | The underlay drains the meltwater at thaw |
The eaves comb and perforated closures ensure the minimum ventilation cross-section of the air gap, but they are in no way an airtight and snow-tight barrier. In a violent wind event, the overpressure on the exposed side and the suction on the leeward side force the crystal-laden air through the perforations of the accessories. Trying to seal these openings tightly with compact foams is a serious mistake: it blocks the upward ventilation flow, promotes condensation under the roof covering and causes the roof structure to become waterlogged at the first thaw.
Exposure to the prevailing wind and installation details of the underlay
As soon as the structure is located in a prevailing wind corridor or above the regional altitude reference levels set by the standards, the roof must be designed on the assumption that powder snow will systematically get through the roof covering. The whole execution effort rests on the continuity of the underlay. According to standard SIA 232/1, extraordinary loading requires a higher underlay class, with laps welded or bonded hot or cold, able to withstand the prolonged stagnation of a snow layer.
- Choice of underlay classMove from an execution for normal loading to one for high or extraordinary loading. Flexible membranes simply stretched with free laps are excluded; the use of strips laid on closed boarding or rigid underlay panels with sealed joints becomes mandatory.
- Treatment of laps and counter-battensBond the longitudinal and transverse laps using the integrated adhesive strips or specific solvent-based adhesives. Systematically lay sealing tapes under the counter-battens before nailing to prevent any infiltration of meltwater through the nail or screw holes.
- Connection of penetrations and vergesTurn the underlay strips up onto the kerbs of dormers, chimneys and roof windows up to the upper level of the roof battens. Form diverter flashings upstream of the penetrating elements so that the meltwater from infiltrated snow is not diverted under the rain barrier.
- Execution of the eaves lineEnsure the underlay water is discharged directly into the gutter or onto a ventilated eaves flashing. Do not stop the strip short of the wall plate, which would saturate the eaves with moisture when the drifts accumulated under the tiles melt.
On slopes directly exposed to the prevailing wind, the counter-slope created by a local sag of the underlay substrate is the most destructive defect. The infiltrated powder snow melts slowly under the thermal action of the building or during fair spells; the released water then stagnates against the counter-battens if the alignment is not strictly straight. Compliance with these construction details determines the durability of the roof timbers and of the thermal insulation beneath.
Management of damage caused by powder snow infiltration and corrective measures
During a bise or alpine blizzard, fine snow passes through the tile interlocks and accumulates on the underlay. When this layer melts under the effect of heat loss or a thaw, damage occurs if the build-up has weaknesses in watertightness or drainage. The first emergency action is to locate the water path in the roof space or the insulation in order to prevent rot of the rafters and deterioration of the interior linings.
As soon as water damage resulting from the melt is found, the client checks the condition of the work and notifies the defects according to the usual rules. In accordance with art. 367 CO, for a building work, the client has 60 days to notify the contractor of defects. For the sheet-metal roofer, this step requires an immediate expert assessment of the damaged area: checking the counter-battens, verifying the nailing strips and examining the perforations.
| Finding of infiltration | Technical origin | Corrective action required |
|---|---|---|
| Droplets at nail penetrations | No sealing tape under counter-battens | Remove the battens, install nailing sealing strips. |
| Build-up and overflow at the eaves | Underlay closed off in the gutter or blocked | Rework the flashing for free drainage towards the front. |
| Penetration at the leeward ridge | Ventilated closure saturated or comb torn off | Replace with a double-deflection ridge. |
| Waterlogging at the side verge | Insufficient strip upstand against the bargeboard | Raise the hot-welded strip against the verge rafter. |
If the dispute concerns a design defect in relation to alpine loading, the statutory warranty applies. Art. 371 CO provides for a limitation period of five years for defects in a building work against the contractor. At altitude, a major refurbishment often requires converting an underlay for normal loading into a membrane for high or extraordinary loading, with continuous substrate and welded strips.
Frequently asked questions
Can polyurethane foam be injected under the ridge tiles to block powder snow?
No, this intervention is prohibited on a ventilated roof covering. Polyurethane foam forms a rigid barrier that traps meltwater and blocks the escape of water vapour from the roof space. Quickly degraded by temperature variations and ultraviolet light, the foam crumbles and clogs the underlay ventilation channel. A suitable ventilated metal closure or a ventilated double ridge without expanding foam should be used.
How should the roof eaves be treated to prevent powder snow from forming an ice dam?
The eaves must provide two separate drainage paths: that of the roof covering via the tiles and that of the underlay via a metal flashing. The underlay must not discharge directly into the main gutter, which freezes first, but drain freely into open air or onto a dedicated flashing. A rigid perforated grille advantageously replaces the standard plastic comb to withstand the pressure of ice at the foot of the slope.
Why does powder snow pass through flexible ventilated ridge closures?
Flexible ventilated closures have side openings calibrated for air circulation. Driven by strong gusts, powder snow has an extremely fine grain size that passes through these perforations like an aerosol. Once under the ridge, it settles in the ventilation channel. Against the prevailing winds at altitude, only a metal ridge with an inverted-profile wind baffle or a sealed sub-ridge ensures an effective mechanical stop for powder snow.
Which underlay class should be used on an alpine slope highly exposed to the bise?
For altitude zones subject to blizzards, an underlay for normal loading with a simple lap is insufficient. The professional guidelines require a class for high or extraordinary loading. This requires a rigid underlay, generally on continuous timber boarding, with strips heat-welded or cold-vulcanised at the joints and upstands. The counter-battens must be laid with systematic nailing sealing tape to stop infiltration under pressure.
Texts and standards cited
- CO art. 367after delivery, the client checks the condition of the work as soon as it is able to and notifies the contractor of defects; for a building work, it has 60 days to notify them and a shorter contractual period is void (para. 1bis, in force since 1 January 2026); each party may request an examination by experts (para. 2).
- COlimitation period of the client's rights in respect of defects: two years from acceptance of the work (para. 1); five years for defects in a building work against the contractor, the architect or the engineer (para. 2) and for defects in a movable work incorporated into a building work (para. 1); the five-year period cannot be modified to the client's detriment (para. 3).
