Key takeaways
- Any perforation of a finished slope without prior agreement releases the roofing contractor from its warranties.
- Site management must submit a written request specifying the exact location and dimensions.
- The original roofer carries out the opening of the roof build-up and the watertight connection of the duct itself.
- A joint inspection record drawn up before and after the operation attests to the conformity of the reworked structure.
Uncoordinated penetration: loss of legal cover and notification protocol
On pitched-roof construction sites, the late intervention of a plumber, electrician or heating installer to run a ventilation duct, a refrigerant line or solar cables is a major source of disputes. When a secondary trade, on its own initiative, cuts clay tiles, severs a counter-batten or pierces the underlay with a utility knife, the physical continuity of the protective envelope is broken. Such an initiative immediately deprives the client of its rights against the roofer-metal flasher for defects resulting from this alteration. By working directly on a completed roof build-up, the third party incurs its own civil liability and relieves the original tradesperson of water-ingress damage occurring in the modified area.
To avoid this break in the warranty, installing a penetration after the fact requires a strict administrative procedure. No physical work may be started without a written request issued by site management or the client. This document must define the technical characteristics of the opening: nominal diameter of the sleeve, nature of the fluid or cabling, bulk of the added thermal insulation, and precise coordinates on the roof slope in relation to the rafters and purlin lines. A minimum positioning tolerance must be observed so as not to interfere with existing saddle flashings, hips or recessed gutters.
- Submission of the technical data sheets for the duct and for the sealing collar specified by the manufacturer.
- Marking of the rafter spacing from the roof void to ensure that no trimmer needs to be created.
- Validation of the airflow and thermal feasibility by the lead designer before notification to the metal flasher.
- Issue of a daywork order or a supplementary quote for the opening and reinstatement work.
Sequential execution, rework by the roofer and inspection records
The fundamental rule on pitched roofs is that only the roofing and metal-flashing contractor holding the original lot is authorised to uncover the materials, cut the underlayers and make the final watertight connection. This exclusive competence ensures that the mechanical and chemical bonds applied to the underlay membrane and the vapour barrier remain compliant with the professional guidelines of the Swiss Association of Building Envelopes. If the roofer finds an unforeseen situation on site that risks compromising the proper performance of the roof, art. 365 CO, under its paragraph 3, requires the roofer to inform the client immediately of any circumstance compromising the proper execution of the work.
- Initial joint inspection recordJoint visual examination of the area with site management. Photographic survey of the tiles and the alignment of the battens, and confirmation that there is no pre-existing water ingress at all on the vapour barrier.
- Methodical removal by the rooferLocal uncovering of the rigid elements, removal of the ventilation battens and measured incision of the underlay in an envelope cut so as to preserve future water laps.
- Passage of the service ductInstallation of the duct by the installing trade, with no stray mechanical fixing to the roof battens, leaving sufficient clearance to absorb thermal expansion.
- Reinstatement of airtightness and watertightnessFitting of an elastomer collar bonded to the vapour barrier on the inside, bonded connection of the sleeve to the underlay with a bevelled deflector counter-batten, then refitting of a ventilation tile with socket or fabrication of a titanium-zinc metal flashing with flexible apron.
- Final joint inspection recordChecking, beneath the covering and on the surface, of the lap of the aprons and of the free drainage of water in the tile channel, and signing of the record attesting that the warranty is maintained.
| Technical operation | Executing trade | Critical check point | Contractual consequence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Removal of the roof covering | Roofer-metal flasher | Retention of the original tiles | Warranty preserved |
| Perforation of vapour barrier | Roofer-metal flasher | Continuous airtightness | Warranty preserved |
| Installation of duct or cable | HVAC installer / Electrician | Centring without mechanical stress | Third party's liability |
| Underlay connection | Roofer-metal flasher | Slope of the deflector drip | Warranty preserved |
| Undeclared penetration | Third party intervening | Unauthorised cutting of the envelope | Warranty void |
Technical processing of the prior written request and interface coordination
The unplanned opening of a finished roof slope is a direct attack on the integrity of the envelope. When a plumber, electrician or heating installer must run a service duct, a ventilation duct or solar cables through an existing roof build-up, the procedure can never be an isolated initiative. Piercing a batten layer, severing a counter-batten or cutting through a strip of underlay alters the condition of a work already delivered or in the course of acceptance. To preserve contractual responsibilities, any later intervention absolutely requires a prior written request addressed to site management and to the awarded roofing and metal-flashing contractor.
This prior written request documents the geometric and thermal constraints of the planned penetration. The notification form sent by the finishing trade states the exact outside diameter of the pipe or cable bundle, the nature of the fluid carried, the service temperature and the positioning coordinates on the roof plan. This location must be checked against the rafter spacing and the available trimmers, so as to rule out any damage to the load-bearing structure. It also allows the roofer to assess the feasibility of the connection according to the tile exposure, the break line or the proximity of a valley.
| Element examined | Critical parameter | Technical requirement for validation |
|---|---|---|
| Underlay | Loading class (extraordinary or normal) | Compatibility of the sealing collar with the bonded or welded sheet |
| Roof covering | Exposure and position relative to the interlocking exposure | Sufficient lap and careful cutting without weakening the neighbouring tiles |
| Thermal insulation | Continuity of the thermal resistance of the build-up | Airtight sealing without thermal bridge around the sleeve |
| Metal flashing | Girth of the apron or lead plate | Water drained forwards with no ponding or lateral backflow |
Approval of the prior request by site management formalises the variation order. It sets the schedule of the operation in two separate stages: on the one hand the coring or mechanical cutting of the substrate, and on the other the watertight reinstatement of the successive layers. Uncoordinated intervention by a third party releases the roofing contractor from its obligations for the resulting defects, in accordance with the principle of art. 369 CO, which provides for the exclusion of the client's rights in respect of defects in the work where the defective execution is personally attributable to the client.
Exclusive execution by the roofer-metal flasher and double joint inspection record
The fundamental rule on Swiss ventilated roofs is that the opening of the roof covering and the reinstatement of watertightness are reserved to the roofer and metal flasher. The finishing-work technician is authorised only to pass through the opening prepared and to install the pipe. Any repair of the underlay by makeshift adhesive bridging, mastic filling or polyurethane foam injection is strictly prohibited. Only the roofing tradesperson has the qualifications required to fit preformed heat-weldable EPDM sleeves or connection strips compatible with the material of the sheet.
- Initial joint inspection recordDrawing up of a visual record with photographic survey before any dismantling, attesting that the tile or slate is intact, that there is no water ingress on the underlay and that the counter-battens in the area concerned are in order.
- Selective removal and openingCareful clearing of the roof covering elements by the roofer, clean cutting of the battens and measured incision of the underlay according to the geometry of the trimmer.
- Passage of the service ductInstallation of the pipe by the third-party installer, fitting of its independent structural fixing collar and checking of the thermal insulation clearance.
- Watertight connection and closingFitting by the roofer of a water- and airtight sealing sleeve bonded or welded to the underlay sheet, incorporation of a water deflector upstream, reinstatement of the counter-battening, fitting of the made-to-measure lead or copper socket and refitting of the cut tiles.
- Final joint inspection recordJoint closing inspection signed by the three parties involved, attesting that the penetration is perfectly watertight and recording the lifting of all reservations.
In the event of a dispute following a leak, the absence of a written protocol exposes the client to a refusal of cover by the building insurance. If the third party has severed the dust barrier or the underlay without agreement, the roofer is entitled to decline all liability for moisture damage in the roof space. Rigorous keeping of the site diary and the countersigning of the rework records ensure traceability of the interfaces between tradespeople.
Disputes and covert penetrations: what to do
Discovering on the construction site a penetration made without prior consultation constitutes an immediate break in the chain of warranty. As soon as an unauthorised penetration is found — whether a ventilation service duct, a photovoltaic cable passage or a sanitary drop — the roofer-metal flasher must suspend all work on the area concerned. The roofer sends a reasoned written notice at once to site management and to the client, formalising the damage to the finished work and declining all liability for the resulting water ingress or thermal defects. This duty to inform rests on the Code of Obligations, which requires the contractor to report without delay any circumstance compromising the work, and on art. 369 CO, which excludes the client's rights in respect of defects where the defective execution is personally attributable to the client.
- Immediate compilation of a joint photographic file showing the penetration, the damage to the underlay and the cuts in the insulation or dust barrier.
- Written notification of warranty exclusion covering the whole slope or catchment area affected until the reinstatement has been accepted.
- Issue of a quote for complete reinstatement addressed to site management, including the local removal of the roof covering, the watertight connection of the underlay sheet and the supply of the appropriate sealing collar or sleeve.
- Execution of the corrective work exclusively by the roofing contractor awarded lot CFC 224, at the expense of the liable third party or of the client.
Once the rework has been carried out in accordance with the rules of the trade, the parties draw up a joint closing inspection record. This document records the conformity of the airtightness, the bonded underlay and the connection of the tiles or sheets. Only on signature of this record does the roofer reinstate the warranty for the remaining period originally provided under the SIA 118 standard. Without this rigorous procedure, any later water ingress occurring during a storm or snowmelt risks being wrongly attributed to the roofing contractor, weakening its position in insurance assessments.
Frequently asked questions
What does a plumber risk by piercing an underlay sheet without warning the roofer?
The tradesperson is liable to bear the full cost of reworking the roof as well as the repair of any consequential damage caused by water ingress. By piercing without authorisation, the tradesperson relieves the roofer of its contractual liability for the modified area. Site management will order complete reinstatement by the awarded roofer, invoiced directly to the company responsible for the unauthorised penetration or deducted from its payment certificates.
How should the prior request be formalised before passing through a finished roof?
The installer sends site management and the roofer a written notice stating the diameter of the duct, the nature of the pipe, its precise geometric position and the pitch of the slope. The roofer examines compatibility with the rafter spacing, the thickness of the ventilation under the covering and the position of the battens. The roofer validates feasibility, defines the connection accessories required and plans the coordinated opening of the roof covering.
What is the impact of an unauthorised penetration on the two-year warranty period of the SIA 118 standard?
Under the SIA 118 standard, the work is covered by a two-year period for notifying defects from its acceptance. If a secondary trade pierces the roof covering or the underlay without the involvement of the roofer, the warranty lapses immediately on the modified area. The client loses the right to demand free reinstatement of that area from the original roofer in the event of a later leak.
Why is the joint inspection record before and after the intervention mandatory?
The record before the work fixes the condition of the roof, attesting to the integrity of the tiles, metal flashings and membranes before the third party goes onto the roof. The record after rework validates the perfect reinstatement of the water- and airtight barrier by the metal flasher. These written documents legally protect both companies by delimiting their respective material responsibilities in the event of damage.
Texts and standards cited
- CO art. 369exclusion of the client's rights in respect of defects in the work where the defective execution is personally attributable to the client (instructions given contrary to the contractor's formal warnings or any other cause).
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work, governing in particular the periods for notifying defects and the acceptance of works.
