Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 224Sarking, ventilation and underlay membraneChapter 4 of 10 in the section

Insulating between rafters or over rafters: what each solution means for the roofer

This chapter details the practical consequences of the choice of insulation for the roofer and sheet-metal worker. You will be able to anticipate the geometric constraints of sarking at the verges, eaves and junctions, size the roof ventilation according to SIA 180, ensure the continuity of the thermal insulation and coordinate the construction site interfaces without causing moisture damage.

Key takeaways

  • Laying over the rafters eliminates thermal bridges but raises the entire level of the roof covering.
  • Insulation between rafters keeps the existing profile but restricts the usable thickness and the ventilation cross-section.
  • SIA 180 requires strict continuity of the thermal barrier to prevent condensation.
  • Sarking requires all sheet-metal developed lengths at the verge, eaves and penetrations to be adapted.

Geometric impact of sarking on sheet-metal work and roof junctions

External thermal insulation over the rafters, commonly called sarking, consists of laying a continuous rigid insulation board directly on the rafters or on a load-bearing board sheathing. This method eliminates the thermal bridges created by the timber framing members. In return, it raises the whole roof plane by the thickness of the insulation plus that of the counter-battens. For insulation meeting current thermal requirements, this vertical offset commonly reaches 140 to 200 mm. This change profoundly alters the positioning of the sheet-metal components and requires the interfaces to be anticipated from the preparatory phase.

  • Eaves line: the fascia, the drip edge and the position of the gutter all rise, requiring rigid support to withstand the weight of snow.
  • Side verges: the developed length of the verge flashings (wind boards, linings) increases to cover the full additional thickness up to the soffit.
  • Roof penetrations: chimney stacks, dormers and ventilation ducts must be extended to guarantee the upstand heights.
  • Ridge: the height of the hip and ridge junction requires flashings or metal connection pieces adapted to the new roof covering plane.
Technical comparison: sarking versus insulation between rafters
Technical criterionInsulation between raftersSarking (over rafters)
Treatment of thermal bridgesDiscontinuous (linear thermal bridge at each rafter)Continuous (boards laid with tight joints over the entire slope)
Roof profile and vergesUnchanged (the build-up stays within the roof structure)Raised by 140 to 200 mm (impact on verges, eaves and windows)
Space for ventilationOften constrained by the remaining rafter depthFully preserved above the underlay thanks to the counter-battens
Cladding sheet-metal workStandard developed lengths according to existing profilesWide, made-to-measure developed lengths to cover the insulation

Ventilation under the roof covering and continuity of the envelope according to SIA 180

The management of air and water vapour flows is the central requirement governed by SIA 180 (Thermal protection and moisture protection in buildings). In a between-rafters configuration, the fibrous insulation must never come into contact with the underside of the roof covering. Where the underlay is not highly vapour-permeable or where there is no continuous ventilated board sheathing, a ventilated air space under the rafters remains necessary. Conversely, if the rafter depth is entirely filled by the insulation, the counter-battening must absolutely guarantee a free ventilation cross-section of at least 40 to 50 mm above the water-tight underlay.

In a sarking system, the continuous insulation layer forms a homogeneous thermal barrier. The roof ventilation is located exclusively between the underlay laid on the insulation and the tile or metal roof covering. The counter-batten guides the air from the eaves inlet to the ridge outlet. The sheet-metal worker must ensure that the eaves ventilation grilles and ventilated closers are not obstructed by the metal cladding pieces or by the compression of the insulation during fixing.

  1. Checking continuity at the vergeEnsure that the sarking insulation meets the head of the façade or the ventilated cladding without any gap, in order to avoid any edge thermal bridge.
  2. Laying the underlayRoll out the underlay membrane directly onto the thermal insulation or the rigid support board, respecting the prescribed overlaps.
  3. Fixing the counter-batteningFix the counter-battens through the insulation into the rafters using double-thread screws sized for the wind and snow loads.
  4. Installing the eaves components and ventilationInstall the eaves flashing and the rodent protection grille, and check the required free air inlet cross-section.

Insulation between rafters: thickness constraints and management of thermal bridges

Placing an insulation batt within the depth of the rafters means a permanent compromise between thermal resistance and ventilation space. Where the structural depth of the timbers limits the permissible thickness, completely filling the bay prevents any air circulation under the roof covering support. The sheet-metal worker and the roofer must then ensure that a continuous air space absolutely remains above the water-tight underlay to preserve the drying of the roof structure and remove residual moisture.

The retained timber frame creates a break in thermal homogeneity. Each rafter forms a linear thermal bridge repeated every 60 to 80 centimetres. To meet the requirements of interior comfort and protection against condensation prescribed by SIA 180, insulation between rafters frequently requires an additional cross layer. This overlay changes the overall thickness under the rafters or forces the upper edge to be raised by means of battens.

Technical comparison of installation for the roofer-sheet-metal worker
Execution criterionInsulation between raftersInsulation over rafters (sarking)
Continuity of the insulationInterrupted by each rafter; regular thermal bridges to compensate for.Total and continuous above the roof structure; thermal bridges eliminated.
Raising of the verges and eavesNone or limited to the thickness of a reinforced counter-battening.Major: 120 to 220 mm of insulation to be made up at the overhangs and gutters.
Ventilation under the roof coveringRequires careful counter-battening over the underlay, without crushing the material.Ventilation retained above the insulation board by added battening.
Sheet-metal junctionsStandard verge profiles and penetration flashings.Widened eaves fascias, deep wind boards and modified sheet developed lengths.

Construction site coordination and sheet-metal adaptations linked to sarking

The sarking technique lays a rigid, uninterrupted envelope directly on the decking or the rafters. Although it radically eliminates linear heat losses at the timbers, it changes the entire height profile of the roof. This systematic raising forces the sheet-metal worker to redefine all the geometries of the eaves, the stack base flashings and the verge heads. The laying plane cannot be aligned with the levels of the old masonry or of the bare roof structure.

  1. Setting out the ventilation counter-batteningFix the counter-battens through the rigid insulation into the load-bearing rafter by means of inclined double-thread screws, calibrating the thicknesses to maintain the air circulation space.
  2. Supporting the foot of the slope and raising the eavesInstall a timber stop plate or a reinforced metal profile to take up the thrust of the rigid boards and support the gutter brackets at the new height.
  3. Adjusting the verges and eaves connectionsForm wind boards and drip edges adapted to the new developed length, incorporating lining strips to close off the visible edge of the insulation against the weather.
  4. Connecting penetrations and openingsRaise the frames of dormers, chimney ducts and roof windows in order to connect the sheet-metal waterproofing while respecting the water-protection heights.

Logistical anticipation determines the success of the work. According to art. 3 OTConst, construction work must be planned so that the risk of accident or harm to health is kept as low as possible. This requirement applies particularly during the handling of very thick boards and when screwing at an angle on steep slopes. The tradesperson also adjusts the schedule with the carpenter so that the underlay and the through-fixings are completed before any prolonged exposure to rain.

Managing flatness deviations, repair of junctions and disputes over additional thickness

On major renovation construction sites with pitched roofs, installing insulation over the rafters frequently reveals structural deformations that the original decking concealed. Where the rigid boards create unevenness at leaning or warped rafters, the counter-battening is subjected to bending stresses that degrade the alignment of the roofing battens. According to SIA 180, thermal insulation and moisture protection require perfect continuity without any break in the thermal plane, which prohibits any isolated shimming that lets cold air circulate under the insulation boards.

If the overall additional thickness requires a raising of the verges and eaves greater than anticipated in the tender drawings, the sheet-metal worker is faced with verge strips, chimney flashings or roof-window curbs that have become too short. The continuity of the insulation must nevertheless be guaranteed against the masonry and the penetrations, while maintaining the ventilation retained above the underlay. Any lack of coordination leads to the sheet-metal work being stopped to avoid non-watertight junctions.

Where the geometric deviation compromises the stability of the work or the timber substrate shows excessive deflection, art. 365 CO applies: the contractor must immediately inform the client if the supplied substrate or the circumstances jeopardise the proper or timely execution of the work. In parallel, art. 3 OTConst requires the work to be planned so that the risk of accident or harm to health is as low as possible, in particular given the increased fall risks caused by the sudden raising of the working planes at the roof edge. The remedial work requires the installation of trapezoidal furring pieces under the insulation boards or the replacement of the metal flashings to adjust the seam folds to the new ridge lines.

Frequently asked questions

How should the eaves be treated when there is a significant raising with sarking?

The additional thickness requires an adapted eaves board to be rebuilt in order to fix the gutter brackets at the new height. The sheet-metal worker installs a continuous metal flashing ensuring drainage into the gutter, while preserving a free air inlet cross-section under the roof covering. The thickness of the insulation must be coordinated with the drainage slope in order to avoid any mechanical choking of the ventilated air space above the underlay.

Can insulation between rafters and insulation over rafters be combined?

This mixed solution reduces the total raising height of the roof while limiting structural thermal bridges. It nevertheless requires the position of the dew point to be checked in accordance with the criteria of SIA 180. The continuous outer layer limits linear heat losses, while the added counter-battening ensures the ventilation retained above the flexible underlay, without excessively changing the eaves lines and the dormer fronts.

What should be done if the existing dormers prevent the insulation from being raised?

Insulation over the rafters butts up against the cheeks and valleys of unmodified dormers. The sheet-metal worker must remove the old metal gutters and adapt the curbs to absorb the height difference. If the height below the window sill is insufficient, the insulation should be locally thinned using a rigid material with high thermal performance, while scrupulously maintaining the airtight connection and the water-tightness.

How can the wind resistance of the verges be ensured after the roof has been raised?

Raising the verge rafter requires reinforced through-fixings anchored in the primary roof structure to resist suction. The sheet-metal worker forms a made-to-measure verge strip, with a clear drip edge and a rigid hooking fold. The spacing of the fixing brackets and double-thread screws must compensate for the compressible insulation thickness interposed, preventing any tearing off during gusts in exposed zones.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 180Thermal insulation and moisture protection in buildings
  • CO art. 365materials and ground: the contractor is responsible for the good quality of the materials he supplies; if the materials supplied by the client or the ground designated by him are found to be defective, or if any other circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work, he must immediately inform the client, failing which he bears the consequences (para. 3).
  • OTConst art. 3planning of construction work: the work is planned so that the risk of occupational accident, occupational disease or harm to health is as low as possible (para. 1); if the presence of asbestos or PCB is suspected, the employer identifies and assesses the hazards and plans the necessary measures (para. 2); the employer who wishes to undertake as contractor under a contract for work examines, before concluding the contract, the measures necessary to ensure occupational safety and health protection (para. 3); the measures specific to the construction site are regulated in the contract for work (para. 5).

In the same section