Key takeaways
- Any corrugated sheet laid before the ban on asbestos is presumed to contain hazardous fibres.
- Grinding, sawing, drilling or brushing fibre-cement sheets is strictly prohibited.
- In the event of an unexpected discovery, the construction site is suspended and site management is informed.
- The removal of highly emissive materials is reserved for asbestos removal companies recognised by Suva.
Identifying suspected asbestos in corrugated sheets without damaging the materials
In pitched roofing, the refurbishment of industrial halls, agricultural sheds or annexes built before 1990 regularly exposes sheet-metal and roofing crews to asbestos-containing composite materials. Large-format corrugated fibre-cement sheets are the most common element. These elements contain a variable proportion of asbestos strongly bound into the cement, most often chrysotile, used to mechanically reinforce the sheet and ensure its weather resistance.
Climatic ageing degrades the surface matrix: moss and lichen colonise the material, rain erosion exposes asbestos fibres and the composite becomes brittle under freeze-thaw cycles. The material thus loses its original integrity. The slightest aggressive handling releases an invisible cloud of inhalable microfibres, extremely toxic to the lungs. Before any physical intervention on an old roof, a review of the building's archives and a reading of the manufacturing markings make it possible to determine the composition of the product.
The employer must anticipate these risks from the work assessment phase. Under the Ordinance on Construction Work, when the presence of asbestos is suspected, the employer identifies and assesses the hazards, then plans the necessary measures before committing the crew. No dismantling quote may be carried out blindly without a prior pollutant diagnosis, commissioned by the client or their representative. This expert document records the sampling, the analytical method used and the precise toxicity classification of the sheets concerned.
- Absolute ban on cutting or sawing corrugated sheets with dry rotary tools.
- Strict prohibition of mechanical cleaning of roofs by wire brushing or high-pressure water jet.
- Refusal to break the overlap corners or to force rusted lag screws with a hammer.
- Obligation to access the roof slope only via walkways that spread the loads over the roof structure.
The golden rule on the roof is to preserve the static state. Fibres trapped in the matrix do not disperse into the air as long as the sheet remains intact and free from violent friction. Breaking a sheet to speed up its removal turns a situation of moderate risk into critical respiratory contamination for all the trades working within the work perimeter.
Stopping work and organising the specialist intervention
Interrupting a roofing task upon an unexpected discovery follows directly from the requirements of the Ordinance on Construction Work. According to art. 32 OTConst, if such a substance is found unexpectedly, work must be interrupted and the client or their representative informed. The crew on the slope stops manual handling, puts away its tools without raising dust and withdraws from the critical zone.
- Suspension of the technical operationStop all loosening of fixings and any attempt to lift the sheets. Leave the elements in place to prevent the edges from crumbling.
- Closing off accessCordon off the foot of the façade and the access hatch to the attic. Display a warning sign prohibiting passage by other workers.
- Formal notification of managementImmediate transmission of the finding to the foreman or the company manager. Drafting of a notice of interruption addressed to site management and the owner.
- Weather protectionTemporary protection against rain infiltration by light tarpaulin secured without mechanical perforation of the substrate.
In parallel with securing the perimeter, walking on fibre-cement sheets demands extreme caution. This material is inherently fragile and its breaking strength is unpredictable, made worse by decades of sun exposure. Unexpectedly falling through a corrugated slope is one of the most frequent causes of fatal accidents among roofers. Any movement during the inspections must be made exclusively on flat roofing ladders or board walkways spreading the worker's weight over at least two underlying purlins.
| Project stakeholder | Main task | Scope of intervention |
|---|---|---|
| Client | Funding and commissioning of the pollutant diagnosis | Before any award or as soon as a stoppage is reported |
| Certified diagnostician | Sampling and analysis in an approved laboratory | Preliminary assignment or emergency expert assessment |
| Roofer CFC 224 | Stopping work, protecting the roof slope and formal notice | As soon as a material that has not been diagnosed is visually suspected |
| Recognised company | Contained removal, packaging and disposal of waste | Execution of major asbestos removal under Suva approval |
When the degraded state of the sheets requires complete removal releasing significant quantities of fibres, the task goes beyond the ordinary skills of the roofer. The Ordinance on Construction Work expressly reserves these operations for asbestos removal companies recognised by Suva. This qualification guarantees mastery of decontamination airlocks, absolute-filtration extraction, packaging in labelled sealed wrapping and transport of the waste to a type B landfill for inert materials in accordance with Swiss environmental directives.
Securing the roof slope and fall-arrest measures on fragile roofs
Replacing old corrugated sheet roofs requires particular vigilance regarding the residual load-bearing capacity of the material. Widely installed before 1990, these fibre-cement sheets suffer over the decades a degradation of their mineral matrix. Under the combined action of freeze cycles, moisture and moss, the sheet loses its original elasticity and becomes brittle. A roofer must under no circumstances regard an old corrugated roof as a work surface that can be walked on directly. The risk of sudden breakage and falling through the roof is one of the most serious dangers of the trade during the survey or preparation phases of the construction site.
For work at the edges of the roof slope, art. 41 OTConst provides for appropriate measures to prevent falls from a fall height of more than 2 m. Depending on the pitch of the slope and the configuration of the building, crews install roofers' brackets or perimeter edge guardrails. However, these external installations do not protect against the specific risk of falling through the corrugated material itself. Protection must therefore be provided continuously over the entire surface on which workers advance.
- Systematically lay temporary walkways, such as load-spreading boards or roofing ladders bearing directly on the purlins of the roof structure.
- Install safety nets under the roof before any work on the pitch, to guard against a local failure of the roofing during operations.
- Prohibit any brushing, grinding or high-pressure cleaning likely to erode the material and disperse mineral residues into the working environment.
- Use mobile elevating work platforms for one-off access whenever the terrain configuration and the height of the building allow.
If doubt remains during the preliminary checks or if unidentified sheets appear under a lining, art. 32 OTConst requires that work be interrupted and the client or their representative informed. The team leader suspends activity in the area concerned, prohibits access to the attic and records the facts in the daily report so that the necessary technical investigations can take place.
Intervention by recognised companies and disposal routes
When the diagnosis confirms the presence of asbestos in the corrugated sheets, asbestos removal requires specific skills. According to the Ordinance on Construction Work, operations releasing significant quantities of asbestos fibres hazardous to health are strictly reserved for asbestos removal companies recognised by Suva. Sheet-metal or roofing staff must not carry out forced manual dismantling, pull out fixings with a crowbar or break up the sheets, as these mechanical actions break the cement and release respirable dust into the air.
| Construction site phase | Qualified party | Technical measures | Required document |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stoppage on suspicion | Roofer of the company CFC 224 | Interruption of work, cordoning off the perimeter without fracturing the material | Notice of interruption to the client |
| Expert assessment and sampling | Building pollutant diagnostician | Sampling according to protocol, analyses in an accredited laboratory | Asbestos survey report |
| Removal and packaging | Recognised asbestos removal company | Controlled unscrewing, sealed packaging under closed film, regulatory labelling | Asbestos removal plan and tracking slip |
| Resumption of the roofing | Roofing company | Inspection of the cleaned attic, installation of battens and the new roofing build-up | Minutes of resumption of work |
The disposal of removed elements is governed by the requirements of the ordinance on the avoidance and disposal of waste. Dismantled corrugated sheets must remain intact and be stored on strapped pallets under a sealed tarpaulin to prevent any dust from being blown away. They are transported to type B landfills or to routes approved by the cantonal environmental protection services. Fly-tipping or reusing these old materials for other rural structures is strictly prohibited.
Crisis management on the construction site: unexpected discovery and remedies
The accidental discovery of suspect elements on the roof halts the roofer's activity. Degraded corrugated sheets, ventilation ducts or friable underlayers laid before the 1990 ban require protective securing measures. Any mechanical action, drilling or brushing is prohibited to avoid the airborne dispersal of harmful dust.
According to art. 32 OTConst, if such a substance is found unexpectedly, work must be interrupted and the client or their representative informed. The crew then freezes the technical situation. It comes down from the slope without fracturing the sheets and prohibits access under the roof structure to protect the other trades from any contamination.
- Joint inspection recordThe foreman writes a formal notice in the site diary, supplemented by detailed photographs of the unaltered suspect material.
- Notice of interruptionTransmission of a written notification to site management and the client, stating the technical impossibility of continuing without an official diagnosis.
- Coordinated resumptionWaiting for the survey conclusions before any resumption of activity or transfer of the file to an asbestos removal company approved by Suva.
In contractual terms, the provisions of the Code of Obligations (CO) governing the contract for work protect the professional: the duty to notify the client immediately of a circumstance jeopardising the work relieves the contractor of the resulting delays. The Ordinance on Construction Work then requires that the treatment of materials releasing fibres be entrusted exclusively to trained professionals, ensuring the protection of employees and neighbours.
Frequently asked questions
What to do if site management disputes the risk and demands removal?
The team leader maintains the stoppage of the workstation. The employer confirms in writing the refusal to carry out destructive work without laboratory analysis. The Code of Obligations (CO) relieves the contractor when they report a manifest danger. Continuing would expose the workers to toxic fibres and would engage criminal liability for the construction site under the rules on occupational safety.
How to fit an emergency tarpaulin on cracked corrugated asbestos sheets?
Mechanical fixing with screws or through-nails is ruled out because it releases dust. The roofer deploys a heavy reinforced tarpaulin secured to the ridge or to sound elements of the roof structure. It is held down with sand sausages or flat lashing straps around the perimeter, taking care not to crush the fragile corrugations of the material.
Can a sheet-metal company dispose of the dismantled sheets itself?
No. The transport and landfilling of asbestos waste require sealed packaging in a closed, labelled double wrapping. In accordance with the ordinance on waste, the disposal of asbestos materials requires tracking slips for special waste and the use of authorised routes, which goes beyond the ordinary scope of work of a roofer without specific certification.
Who bears the costs of the diagnosis and the delay resulting from the stoppage?
The costs of sampling, laboratory analysis and specialist intervention fall entirely on the client, who is responsible for the condition of their building. As the interruption is an unforeseeable event not attributable to the contractor, the latter is entitled to an extension of the contractual execution deadlines and to compensation for the protective securing measures undertaken on the roof slope.
Texts and standards cited
- OTConst art. 32substances particularly hazardous to health (asbestos, PCB): if their presence is suspected, the employer identifies and assesses the hazards, plans the necessary measures and informs the workers of the diagnosis results (para. 2); if such a substance is found unexpectedly, work must be interrupted and the client or their representative informed (para. 3).
- OTConst art. 41measures to be taken at roof edges: appropriate measures to prevent falls from a fall height of more than 2 m (roofers' bracket and/or perimeter guardrail depending on the roof pitch); on roofs with a pitch of more than 60°, work only from scaffolding or a mobile elevating work platform (para. 3).
