Key takeaways
- Systematic probing of the battens and rafters determines whether the roof can be retained without stripping it.
- The absence of an underlay directly exposes the roof space to critical infiltration of winter powder snow.
- Three solutions exist: spot maintenance with reservations, an underlay fitted from the inside, or a complete ventilated re-roofing.
- Written information to the client releases the contractor from defects attributable to the client's choices.
Diagnosis of the substrate and assessment of infiltration in the absence of an underlay
Throughout Switzerland, many traditional buildings still have clay or cement tile roofs laid directly on the original battens, without an underlay membrane. This old design relies on a precise physical balance: a steeply pitched roof above a ventilated, unheated roof space. Outside air constantly sweeps the underside of the tiles, allowing accidental infiltration water or morning condensation to evaporate. This balance disappears as soon as the use of the roof space changes, or when weather loads exceed the tile's capacity to shed water by gravity.
| Element inspected | Findings on site | Direct risk to the roof |
|---|---|---|
| Battens and counter-battens | Visible sagging, brown rot, repeated traces of moisture | Deformation of the laying plane, risk of failure under snow load |
| Nailing of the battens | Advanced corrosion of nails, heads torn off, eaten-away section | Lifting of tile courses under wind suction |
| Underside of the tiles | Chalking of the concrete, whitish efflorescence, run-off marks | Increased frost susceptibility of the material and continuous dripping into the roof space |
| Rafter ends | Fungal attack at the wall plate, superficial or deep woodworm damage | Unstable substrate, impossible to anchor durable counter-battening |
The battens are inspected from inside the roof space and by opening up external sample areas in several zones of the roof. The foreman uses a metal awl to check the firmness of the timber at the core of the battens and at the nailing points on the rafters. Without an underlay, the most destructive risk under the Swiss climate comes from powder snow. Driven by strong gusts or the winter bise wind, powder snow infiltrates under the side interlocks and tile heads. It penetrates deep into the roof space, forming drifts that cannot be seen from the ground. During a thaw, or under the effect of heat radiated from the rooms below, this snow melts, damaging ceilings, floors and load-bearing elements.
Possible levels of intervention and the legal formalities of the duty to notify
A roofer faced with a roof lacking an underlay must determine the technical boundary between simple maintenance and structural refurbishment. He must not leave the client under the illusion that re-laying the tiles provides modern watertightness. Occupational safety requirements mean that edge protection must be adapted to the pitch and the fall height in accordance with the Construction Work Ordinance. The decision depends on the future use of the roof space and the mechanical condition of the battens.
- Level 1: Like-for-like conservation maintenanceSpot replacement of broken tiles, wedging of sagging battens and removal of moss without changing the construction system. This level applies to ventilated, uninsulated, unused roof spaces, after the client has agreed in writing that the risk of snow infiltration remains.
- Level 2: Underlay stretched from the insideFitting of a vapour-permeable sheet fixed under the rafters with clamping battens, with leakage water guided towards the eaves. This stopgap solution is difficult to make continuous at valleys, hips and flashing penetrations.
- Level 3: Complete strip-out and ventilated re-roofingComplete removal of the covering and the worn-out battens, inspection of the rafters, fitting of a continuous underlay, ventilated counter-battening of at least 50 mm and new treated battens. This level is the lasting solution that secures the work.
The duty to notify is the practitioner's legal protection. Art. 365 CO provides that if the material supplied by the client or the ground designated by him is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance compromises the proper or timely execution of the work, the contractor must inform the client. The absence of an underlay is a technical circumstance that compromises watertightness in severe weather. The information is given in writing before the construction site opens. Under art. 369 CO, the client's rights in respect of defects in the work are excluded where the defective execution is personally attributable to him, in particular through instructions given contrary to the contractor's notices.
Technical trade-off between monitored retention, bay-by-bay refurbishment and complete strip-out
On traditional roofs in French-speaking Switzerland, the historical absence of an underlay becomes a serious problem as soon as the roof space changes use or climatic exposure increases the loads. The initial diagnosis must lead to a rigorous choice between three courses of action: keeping the configuration without an underlay under monitoring, partial remedial work from the inside between the rafters, and complete removal of the covering to fit a standard underlay in accordance with good practice.
| Configuration observed | Level of powder snow and condensation risk | Technical option chosen | Expected durability |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ventilated unused roof space, sound battens, hardwood not sagging | Low to medium: occasional infiltration dried by natural draught | Retention with monitoring and local repair of chipped tiles | 10 to 15 years without changing the thermal envelope |
| Converted roof space without external access, sound rafters, aged battens | High: water accumulating on the insulation, hidden rotting of the timber | Partial remedial work from the inside (membrane stretched in a cradle with counter-batten) | Palliative solution (10 to 20 years), dependent on the watertightness of the joints |
| Warped battens, fungal attack on rafters, insulation project planned | Very high: damage virtually certain in frost or powder snow zones | Complete strip-out, restoration of the roof structure, continuous underlay and counter-battening | Lasting (> 40 years), compliant with current thermal and climatic requirements |
Partial work carried out from the inside, although attractive for limiting sheet-metal and scaffolding costs, involves critical details. It consists of stretching a vapour-permeable membrane in a cradle between each pair of rafters, held in place by retaining battens of at least 24 mm section. This arrangement drains snowmelt towards the middle of the bay but does not solve the protection of the rafter ends or the watertightness at valleys and hips. Moreover, it guarantees no ventilation under the existing tiles if the original battens rest directly on the roof structure.
Coordination with the sheet-metal work and formalising the duty to notify
Creating a new underlay during a complete strip-out changes the overall geometry of the roof slope. The addition of boarding or underlay panels, combined with the 45 to 50 mm ventilation counter-battening and the new roofing battens, raises the tile plane by 70 to 100 mm. This extra thickness requires complete reconstruction of the perimeter sheet-metal work. The plumber-roofer must replace the verge flashings, raise the handrails, adapt the dormers and rebuild the chimney flashings with watertight aprons connected to the underlay.
- Survey of eaves levelsCheck the position of the existing gutter. Raising the covering generally means lowering or moving forward the gutter line and fitting a copper or zinc eaves apron connected to the underlay.
- Integrating the underlay at penetrationsBond the underlay membrane to the collars of chimney passages, soil-pipe vents and roof windows using compatible adhesive sealing tapes.
- Treatment of valleysFit a specific waterproofing under-layer beneath the metal valley gutter before nailing the diagonal counter-battens.
When the client refuses a complete strip-out for budgetary reasons and demands that a covering without an underlay be retained, or a purely superficial refurbishment of the battens, the contractor takes on liability if he stays silent. Damage caused by powder snow or condensation cannot be classed as unforeseeable events in the Swiss climate. The professional must draw up a formal notification setting out the problems inherent in the absence of a second waterproofing layer.
In practice, the descriptive quote must explicitly include the technical reservations if the contract is limited to reworking the existing battens. The cost estimate for a complete standard underlay with readjusted sheet-metal work must be offered as a priced alternative, in order to prove that the owner chose the economical option in full knowledge of the residual risk.
Handling critical unforeseen findings and disagreement over remediation
During rework or partial opening of a ventilated roof space, the discovery of roof structure elements attacked by wood-boring insect larvae, brown rot or disintegrated battens calls the initial visual diagnosis into question. When timber sections lose their load-bearing capacity because of earlier recurring infiltration, simply replacing a few courses of tiles becomes illusory. The impossibility of mechanically fixing an underlay continuously and taut on a heterogeneous substrate means the overall intervention strategy must be reconsidered to preserve the stability of the roof.
The main disagreement arises when the owner insists on keeping the roof without a complete underlay despite a major risk of infiltration from powder snow. During bise episodes or swirls of cold air, fine crystals pass through the interlocks of old tiles and accumulate directly on the floor or the insulation. Faced with a refusal to carry out the complete strip-out essential for fitting a ventilated underlay that complies with good practice, the roofer must put his disagreement on record. Under art. 369 CO, the client's rights in respect of defects are excluded where the defective execution is personally attributable to him, in particular through instructions given contrary to the contractor's formal notices.
- Temporary weatherproofingFitting of a temporary reinforced tarpaulin fixed with nailed counter-battens to ensure interim watertightness without damaging the remaining sound timber.
- Joint survey of the defectsPreparation of a precise photographic inventory documenting the sag of the rafters, the residual moisture of the battens and the condition of the verge edges.
- Drafting the formal noticeSending a detailed letter summarising the risks of snow infiltration, the absence of eaves ventilation and the refusal of the complete refurbishment work.
- Waiting for a decision to be confirmedSuspension of the final work until receipt of the written order defining the limits of liability accepted by the client.
Accepting a makeshift or undersized patch-up without written reservations would engage the roofer's professional liability for any subsequent water damage. If the client maintains his refusal of a complete strip-out, only an explicit release agreement with unambiguous technical reservations allows emergency securing work to be completed without assuming the consequences of the defects inherent in a structure lacking an underlay.
Frequently asked questions
How can you identify with certainty the penetration of powder snow in an uninsulated roof space?
Powder snow infiltrates under the effect of wind through the clearances of the interlocks and the overlaps of old tiles lacking an underlay. In the unheated roof space, it forms localised drifts on the floor or at the foot of the rafters before melting at the first thaw. Whitish run marks on the timber, dried moisture rings and rust on the batten fixing nails confirm these recurring penetrations during winter episodes.
Can an underlay be fitted from the inside between the existing rafters?
This stopgap solution is not recommended by professional roofing rules. Fitting underlay sheets stretched between rafters from the inside does not allow infiltration water to be drained to the gutter at the eaves without piercing or saturating the timber. The rafters remain exposed to moisture trapped behind the membrane, which promotes mould growth and slow rotting of the load-bearing frame in the absence of continuous counter-battening creating a sufficient ventilation air gap.
Which technical criteria require complete removal of the roof instead of partial refurbishment?
Complete removal is required as soon as more than a quarter of the batten timbers show loss of section, active rot or excessive sag incompatible with the alignment of the tiles. It is also mandatory when the building undergoes conversion of the roof space into heated rooms. Creating thermal insulation absolutely requires a ventilated underlay continuous from eaves to ridge, with counter-battening of at least 50 mm, which cannot be achieved by spot interventions on isolated bays.
What is the legal value of a simple email for formalising the duty to notify?
An email is an admissible written means of proof if it clearly demonstrates notification of the defects found and the risks incurred. However, to ensure indisputable evidential weight against the client, the notice should be backed up by a registered letter or recorded in countersigned site minutes. The document must state the absence of an underlay, the proven risk of water damage from powder snow and the owner's refusal to carry out the necessary work.
Texts and standards cited
- CO art. 369exclusion of the client's rights in respect of defects in the work where the defective execution is personally attributable to him (instructions given contrary to the contractor's formal notices or any other cause)
