Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 224Roof covering: tiles, slates and installation on battensChapter 10 of 10 in the section

Acceptance of a roof covering: alignment, laps and inspection from the ground

By the end of this chapter, you will be able to detect alignment or flatness defects in a roof covering from the very first inspection from the ground, check that critical laps on the roof comply, and methodically record each acceptable or non-compliant deviation in the minutes of a joint inspection record at acceptance.

Key takeaways

  • A visual check from the street immediately reveals waviness in the courses and verges.
  • The geometric tolerance of the finished work is assessed according to the rules of SIA 414.
  • Laps at valleys, hips and ridges require direct instrumental checking on the roof slopes.
  • The joint inspection record documents the deviations found before the acceptance minutes are formally signed.

Detecting geometric defects from the ground before going up on the roof

The examination of a roof covering always starts at ground level, standing back far enough to take in all the roof slopes. An experienced roofer immediately spots irregularities in the lines: a ridge that sags at a undersized ridge purlin, a verge with a visible step against the gable, or tile courses forming successive waves. These undulations often point to faulty setting-out on the battens, a poor distribution of the average exposed gauge, or a deformed roof structure that was not compensated for when the counter-battens were fitted.

  • Horizontal alignment of the courses: view from below at a steep angle to spot curved gauge lines and tiles tilting out of line.
  • Straightness of the starting and finishing verges: check the verge line against the face of the fascia boards or masonry.
  • Straightness of the ridge line and hips: detect sagging deflections or lateral deviations below the ridge line.
  • Regularity of the valley channels: visual check of the symmetry of the cuts and of the opening width of the drainage channel.

Checking special laps and formalising the joint inspection record

The close-up inspection on the roof complements the overall view gained from the street. It focuses primarily on the special points where the waterproofing transitions occur. The longitudinal and transverse laps of the tiles must strictly follow the manufacturer's recommendations according to the slope of the roof pitch and the wind exposure zone. Around penetrations, dormers and valley channels, the water head and the lap of the roofing material over the sheet-metal flashings determine the durability of the work against infiltration caused by powder snow or driving rain.

  1. Measuring the exposed gauge and gauge irregularitiesCheck the regularity of the lap over ten consecutive courses with a rule or tape measure to confirm that the adjustment ranges of the tile model are respected.
  2. Checking cuts at verges and around penetrationsCheck that mechanical fixings (screws, hooks) are present on every cut element, and measure the water drainage clearance against the flashings or metal valley channels.
  3. Examining the ventilated ridgeMake sure the ridge tiles interlock, the ventilated closure strip is continuous, and the fixing clips are correctly tightened without crushing the material.
  4. Recording non-conformitiesRecord on a plan or roof diagram the exact location of cracked pieces, poorly interlocked elements or defective laps.

The procedure ends with the joint inspection record drawn up on site in the presence of the site management and the contractor. This document sets out the exhaustive list of rectifications to be carried out: replacement of chipped tiles, realignment of a deviating verge, or correction of an insufficient lap over a metal flashing. Acceptance of the work, as provided for in art. 370 CO, discharges the contractor from liability for all defects that could have been found during a regular inspection, hence the crucial importance of an accurate inventory signed by both parties before the scaffolding is finally dismantled.

Inspection criteria at the joint acceptance of a roof covering
Element inspectedInspection pointVerification method
Tile courseRegularity of the exposed gauge and horizontal alignmentSighting along the axis from the street and sample measurement with a rule
Verge lineStraightness and even overhang above the fascia boardSide sighting and plumb check with a plumb line or string line
Hip and ridgeContinuity of the ridge line and fixing of the closure stripsDirect visual examination and gentle manual pull-off test
Valley and penetrationsMinimum water head and lap over the metal sheetDirect measurement of the head lap and the side lap

Geometric tolerances under SIA 414 and critical examination of alignments

A visual acceptance check begun from the public domain takes on contractual value as soon as the deviations found are measured against Swiss rules of the trade. A meandering verge or a curved ridge points either to an uncompensated deformation of the rafters of the roof structure, or to an inaccuracy in the initial setting-out of the battens. SIA 414 governs the permissible tolerances in building for judging the flatness and straightness of finished surfaces.

Geometric acceptance criteria during the joint inspection
Inspection pointVisible from the groundTechnical finding with rule / string lineFrequent structural origin
Ridge lineVertical waviness or deviation in planDeflection exceeding the SIA 414 tolerances over the total lengthSagging ridge purlin top or ridge batten not shimmed
Field tile coursesSaw-tooth pattern or oblique drift in alignmentVariable exposed gauge exceeding the interlocking clearance permitted by the manufacturerIrregular fixing of the battens or initial squareness defect of the roof slope
Verge lines (verge tiles)Wavering gap against the barge boardMeasurable lack of parallelism between the cut line and the verge rafterLeft or right verge rafter twisted without compensating shims
Hips and valleysAsymmetric skew of the metal axisNon-straight line, lead or zinc flashings pinched off-axisOff-axis board when the counter-battens were fitted

When an irregularity catches the eye from the street, the eye often perceives an accumulation of tolerances. If the carpenter left a deflection at the upper permissible limit and the fitter did not realign the first row of battens with a string line by shimming, the error becomes glaring. With large-format interlocking tiles, the longitudinal and transverse play of the exposed gauge makes it possible to take up several centimetres over a whole slope, on the strict condition that every course was marked out with a chalk line before laying.

Close-up checking of special laps and joint inspection minutes

As soon as the inspection leaves the ground and moves up onto the secured access platforms, the analysis focuses on the critical points where water is channelled or shed. Laps at penetrations (chimneys, dormers, roof windows) and along gutters must be measured individually. A geometric defect visible from below often conceals a forced waterproofing repair under the tile.

  1. Examining the water head at metal connectionsMeasure the lap between the shaped flashings (copper, zinc or powder-coated aluminium) and the roof covering. Check that the rear retaining clips are present, preventing water driven back by the wind from getting around the drip edges.
  2. Checking fixings at verges and ridgesMake sure that every verge tile and ridge tile is mechanically fixed (stainless steel screws with EPDM washer or dedicated hooks) according to the wind zone, with no broken hanging nib or split batten.
  3. Checking overhang lengths into the gutterCheck that the eaves overhang the gutter by at least one third of the diameter of the drainage outlet, with a continuous metal drip edge guaranteeing a hanging drip without water returning under the first batten.
  4. Drawing up the joint inspection recordRecord on the acceptance form all the appearance defects and waterproofing non-conformities found in the presence of the site management, distinguishing major defects from accepted tolerances.

The joint inspection record is the key document for closing out the roofing construction site. Article 367 CO specifies that the client must examine the state of the work as soon as it is reasonably possible and notify the contractor of any defects. Where SIA 118 is incorporated into the contract for work, acceptance is the subject of formal minutes. Acceptance with reservations triggers the remedying of the defects notified within the period set by the site management.

In the event of a dispute over the straightness of a slope, article 367 CO allows each party to request an examination by experts. The analysis will then cover the simultaneous compliance with functional watertightness against driving rain and the visual regularity requirements defined by SIA 414, excluding any aesthetic subjectivity not supported by an instrumented measurement.

Handling alignment disputes and formalising reservations

When a joint inspection record reveals straightness defects or non-compliant laps, methodical handling of the dispute is necessary to preserve the parties' rights. A roof covering with wavy tile courses or a misaligned verge immediately raises the question of the execution tolerance allowed in view of possible deformations of the underlying roof structure.

  1. Joint measurement of misalignmentsStretch the string line and the rigid rule across the disputed areas: gauge line deviations, hip curvature or verge misalignment. The deviations found are quantified in millimetres and recorded on a sketch.
  2. Checking special pointsCheck closely the minimum laps at the ridge, at metal valleys and against sheet-metal flashings at penetrations. An insufficient water head is a potential waterproofing defect, distinct from visual appearance alone.
  3. Detailed entry in the minutesEnter in the joint record the precise location of the faults, the reference to the applicable tolerances and the period allowed for remedial work or alignment corrections.

In accordance with art. 367 CO, the client examines the state of the work as soon as it is reasonably possible and notifies the contractor of any defects. In the event of persistent disagreement over the aesthetic or functional acceptability of an alignment, each party may request an examination by experts under that same legal provision, thus avoiding a unilateral blocking of acceptance.

Frequently asked questions

Is waviness visible from the street enough to refuse acceptance?

No. A visual assessment from the public road is a warning sign but has no direct contractual value. The joint inspection record requires going up onto the work to measure the deviations precisely with a rule or string line. If the measured defects exceed the tolerances set by SIA 414, the client may then serve a formal notice of defects and demand rectification.

Who is responsible for a deviating ridge caused by the ridge purlin?

The roofer is responsible for the final alignment of their ridge. If, during battening, they find that the ridge purlin of the roof structure has excessive deflection, they must report it immediately so as to shim their counter-battens accordingly. If they lay their ridge tiles on a deformed structure without prior reservation, the visual irregularity will be held against them at the joint inspection record at acceptance.

What recourse applies if a verge junction is skewed relative to the wall?

It must be checked whether the defect comes from the squareness of the masonry or from the laying of the verge tiles. Where a wall is out of square, the roofer adapts their lateral exposed gauges within the manufacturer's tolerances. If the offset results from an irregular cut or a poorly distributed interlocking clearance, the acceptance record will set a deadline for realigning the verge line.

How should an alignment disagreement be recorded in the acceptance minutes?

Both parties must sign the joint inspection record, stating their respective positions. The contractor details the SIA 414 tolerances they consider to have been met, while the site management records the measured deviations judged inadmissible. Each keeps a signed copy. If the disagreement blocks acceptance, a joint expert examination under the Code of Obligations (CO) makes it possible to decide the matter.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 414Dimensional tolerances in building
  • CO art. 367Examination of the work and notification of defects; examination by experts

In the same section