Key takeaways
- The temperature range on a roof reaches one hundred kelvins and causes several millimetres of movement per metre.
- A gutter without a dividing joint inevitably suffers shearing of its welds and soldered joints.
- The fixing must always alternate a central fixed zone with sliding clips towards the ends.
- The vulcanised expansion joint ensures continuous watertightness without blocking contraction movements.
Calculate thermal elongation and respect the maximum length for each metal
On a pitched roof in French-speaking Switzerland, a box gutter or hanging gutter undergoes severe temperature ranges. Exposed to solar radiation in summer, the metal can rise above 80 °C, whereas a winter night at altitude commonly brings it below -20 °C. This temperature variation of 100 K requires the sheet-metal worker to take rigorous account of the linear thermal expansion coefficient specific to each alloy. Installing a twenty-metre gutter in one piece without any thermal compensation device inevitably leads to buckling of the sheet in summer, then to tearing of the metal or pulling apart of the soldered joints during winter contraction.
- Linear thermal expansion coefficient (α)
- Physical value expressing the elongation or shortening, in millimetres per metre of sheet, for a temperature change of one kelvin (or one degree Celsius). It determines the free mechanical travel required on the supports.
| Metal used | Coefficient α (mm/m·K) | Expansion over 10 m (mm) | Maximum length without joint (m) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Titanium-zinc | 0,022 | 22 | 6 to 8 |
| Copper | 0,017 | 17 | 8 to 10 |
| Aluminium | 0,024 | 24 | 6 to 8 |
| Stainless steel (austenitic) | 0,016 | 16 | 10 to 12 |
| Galvanised steel | 0,012 | 12 | 10 to 12 |
To comply with the recognised rules of the trade and the requirements of the contract for work and services set out in art. 364 CO, the contractor is liable for the proper execution of the work and must size the sections so as to limit continuous lengths. If the developed width of the profile exceeds 500 mm, as is the case for box gutters receiving large roof-slope areas, the increased transverse stiffness raises the risk of buckling fatigue. The maximum length of rigid sections without a joint must then be reduced to 6 metres for zinc and aluminium, and to 8 metres for copper.
Incorporate watertight joints and guide the movement with fixed and sliding clips
Absorbing expansion movements requires a clear separation between watertightness and the mechanical guidance of the formed piece. In a continuous gutter, the key technical element is the watertight expansion joint. It consists of a central elastomer strip, generally of vulcanised EPDM or UV-resistant neoprene, edged by two metal strips compatible with the gutter metal (copper, zinc or aluminium). This prefabricated joint is welded or tin-soldered on each side of the interrupted profile, ensuring perfect hydraulic continuity while absorbing a compression and tension travel of at least 20 to 30 mm.
- Cutting and preparing the profileInterrupt the gutter, leaving a gap of at least 30 mm between the two gutter ends at an ambient temperature of 15 °C. Carefully clean the joint areas mechanically and chemically.
- Positioning and welding the elastomer jointCentre the flexible rubber strip on the axis of the cut. Make an overlap of at least 15 mm between the metal strip of the joint and the gutter, then solder or weld fully without burning the elastomer.
- Fitting the bridging strip or joint coverFit a protective shim or a loose joint cover above the rubber to prevent puncturing by ice or abrasion by roof debris.
- Checking the outletsMake sure a downpipe outlet stub is never blocked by the joint: the outlet must have its own sliding clearance or be placed at the neutral point.
Managing expansion also depends on the system used to attach to the roof substrate. A gutter must never be nailed or screwed directly into the roof boarding along its whole length. Fixing is done with metal clips formed from a compatible strip. Two categories of clips are essential:
- The fixed clip: nailed firmly to the boarding and folded into the hem or fold of the gutter over a restricted zone of one to two metres, generally located at the centre of the section or at the downpipe outlet.
- The sliding clip: made in two interlocking parts or as a slide-type clip, fixed to the timber substrate while leaving the profile free to slide lengthwise during temperature changes.
- The neutral point: a fixed anchor point that forces the metal to expand equally and predictably on each side towards the end joints.
- The seam clearance: folding the edges with a gap of at least 5 mm in the folds to avoid mechanical binding in case of oblique expansion.
Pathology of continuous failure and thermal behaviour of metals
Installing a twenty-metre box gutter or hanging gutter in one piece without a compensating joint inevitably leads to mechanical failure of the work within a few seasons. Exposed to direct radiation on a pitched roof slope, the sheet undergoes extreme temperature ranges, frequently swinging between a night frost at -20 °C and summer heating above +80 °C in full sun, i.e. a conventional working temperature difference of 100 K. If the metal profile is restrained by rigid fixings or welded without interruption, the alternating axial tensile and compressive stresses exceed the elastic limit of the metal. The result first appears as local buckling of the walls, followed by low-cycle fatigue that tears the gutter bottom at the edge of the welds or abruptly shears the rivets of the heels and outlets.
Each alloy used in Swiss sheet-metal roofing work reacts according to its own expansion. Titanium-zinc and aluminium show the most severe variations, requiring rigorous division into sections to avoid tearing of the base. Copper shows intermediate stability but tolerates no local restraint, otherwise its nailed clips will be pulled out. Austenitic stainless steel, although more stable, generates considerable thrust forces on the seam heads because of its high modulus of elasticity.
| Sheet-metal roofing metal | Expansion coefficient (mm/m·K) | Movement over 20 m (ΔT = 100 K) | Maximum length without joint | Typical failure mode |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Titanium-zinc | 0,022 | 44,0 mm | 6,0 to 8,0 m | Transverse cracking of the soldered joint or of the heat-affected zone |
| Copper | 0,017 | 34,0 mm | 8,0 to 10,0 m | Pulling out of the clips and fatigue failure at the fold of the gutter bottom |
| Aluminium | 0,024 | 48,0 mm | 8,0 to 10,0 m | Elongation of the fixing holes, shearing of rivets and buckling |
| Austenitic stainless steel | 0,016 | 32,0 mm | 10,0 to 12,0 m | Wavy deformation of the edges and tearing of the spot welds |
| Galvanised steel | 0,012 | 24,0 mm | 10,0 to 12,0 m | Failure of the soft tin solder under winter tension |
Design of watertight joints and kinematics of the fixings
To guarantee the watertightness of a box gutter or hanging gutter while absorbing axial movements, the sheet-metal worker has two technical solutions: the vulcanised elastomer membrane joint and the raised mechanical stepped joint. The industrial compensating profile combines a central strip of flexible EPDM elastomer or neoprene with two metal edges identical to the gutter (zinc, copper or stainless steel). The elastomer strip is connected on each side by a soldered or seamed-welded overlap on the rigid sections. For works with a large hydraulic cross-section or subject to blockage, the stepped system with a water-diverting flashing remains the most durable traditional solution, provided a minimum rise of 60 mm above the general water line is created.
- Vulcanised membrane expansion joint
- Prefabricated watertight element consisting of a central elastomer body able to withstand repeated deformation in tension and compression, edged by two metal strip edges compatible with forming and workshop soldering on the gutter segments.
- Determining the fixed anchor pointPlace a fixed clip or a watertight riveted strap at the geometric centre of the section or at the rainwater outlet pipe, to force symmetrical expansion towards the free ends.
- Fitting the sliding guide clipsFix the sliding clips to the roof boarding or the gutter brackets at a regular spacing of 400 to 500 mm. The slide must grip the bead or the hem fold with a lateral clearance of 1 to 2 mm, without any mechanical pinching of the sheet.
- Adjusting the installation gap according to the ambient temperatureSet the width of the elastomer gap at the time of welding: bring the edges closer together if installation takes place in great heat (+30 °C), or open the gap if the work is carried out in cold weather (+5 °C), to allow for future summer expansion.
- Welding and continuity checkMake the soft solder or sealing bead on the metal edges, protecting the elastomer from the flame with a heat shield or a damp cloth, then check that no screw passes mechanically through the joint.
Procedure for repairing a torn gutter and managing defects
The failure of a twenty-metre gutter installed in one piece results directly from mechanical restraint against daily thermal cycles. On a pitched roof exposed to direct solar radiation, the annual temperature range commonly reaches eighty to one hundred degrees between winter night frosts and summer heating. This variation requires an expansion travel of several tens of millimetres which, if blocked by rigid nailing, generates shear stresses exceeding the elastic limit of the metal. The appearance of a clean tear, generally starting at a drainage outlet stub or a weakened solder bead, requires an overall structural repair of the water collection system.
- Cutting and segmenting the developed lengthCut the existing metal profile cleanly with a thin disc cutter or a nibbler to split the continuous twenty-metre length into two independent ten-metre elements. This operation immediately releases the residual tensile stresses trapped in the metal.
- Removing restraints and fitting sliding clipsRemove all the nails or through-screws that have locked the work to the roof boarding. Fit made-to-measure folded sliding clips at the edge and bottom, spaced every forty centimetres, ensuring freedom of axial movement of at least fifteen millimetres without damaging friction.
- Incorporating a vulcanised expansion jointInsert between the two separated sections a prefabricated watertight expansion joint, made of a central flexible elastomer bellows vulcanised onto two metal edges identical to the original metal. Make the end connections by double welding or tin-lead seaming in accordance with the recognised rules of the trade.
- Creating a central fixed pointCreate a fixed clip nailed firmly at the exact middle of each ten-metre element. This arrangement balances the thermal movement: half of the elongation moves freely towards the elastic joint, the other half towards the free end or the downpipe.
As regards contractual liability, CO governs the client's rights in the event of defects in the work, allowing the client in particular to demand the repair of the defective sheet-metal work. Bringing the work into compliance with the suissetec guidelines and standard SIA 232/1 guarantees lasting watertightness of the gutter without risk of a new failure.
Frequently asked questions
Why does a continuous 20 m zinc gutter eventually tear?
Zinc has a high thermal expansion coefficient of 0,022 millimetre per metre per kelvin. Over a length of twenty metres exposed to a temperature gradient of 80 kelvins, the element undergoes a theoretical dimensional change of about thirty-five millimetres. If the gutter is rigidly fixed without an expansion joint, the cyclic stresses of summer compression and winter tension cause localised work hardening, inevitably leading to fatigue failure of the metal at the weakest point.
How should the fixed clip be positioned in relation to the expansion joint?
The fixed clip must be placed at the geometric centre of the gutter section concerned, never directly next to the expansion joint. This symmetrical positioning halves the thermal expansion travel. Thus, on a ten-metre section, five metres of metal expand freely towards the flexible expansion joint, while the other five metres lengthen towards the roof end or the overflow outlet, guided by the intermediate sliding clips.
What difference in thermal movement is observed between copper and aluminium?
For a fifteen-metre element exposed to a temperature difference of 80 kelvins, aluminium expands noticeably more than copper. With a coefficient of 0,024 millimetre per metre per kelvin, aluminium lengthens by about 28,8 millimetres, compared with 20,4 millimetres for copper, whose coefficient is 0,017. Aluminium therefore requires more generous sliding clearances and watertight expansion joints sized to absorb a greater range of movement.
Can an expansion crack be repaired with a tin-soldered splice plate?
Soldering a metal splice plate over the tear does nothing to address the mechanical cause of the defect. Tin solder has a lower tensile strength than the base zinc or copper sheet. Under the repeated action of thermal contraction, the metal will tear again at the immediate edge of the solder. The only lasting remedy is to cut through the work and insert a manufactured watertight expansion joint made of vulcanised elastomer.
Texts and standards cited
- COclient's rights in the event of defects in the work: refusal, price reduction, repair, damages; any clause agreed in advance that restricts or excludes the right to have defects remedied is void if the defect concerns a construction (para. 2bis, since 1 January 2026)
- SIA 232/1Pitched roofs
