Key takeaways
- Rigid mortar bedding blocks the air flow and cracks under thermal expansion.
- The ventilation opening under the ridge must strictly comply with the requirements of standard SIA 232/1.
- The ventilated ridge closer combines air outlet under the ridge with complete weather-tightness against driving snow.
- Refurbishing a mortar-bedded ridge requires complete removal of the old mortar before a raised ridge batten is fitted.
Abandoning mortar for dry fixing with a ventilated ridge closer
On pitched roofs in western Switzerland and in the Alpine valleys, the traditional fixing of ridge tiles with cement mortar or hydraulic lime mortar quickly shows its physical limits. The masonry forms a rigid connection between clay or concrete elements that are subject to constant thermal and mechanical movement. Under freeze-thaw cycles, the mortar bead cracks, allowing direct capillary infiltration. Moreover, this filling completely blocks the upper outlet of the counter-batten system, trapping rising water vapour in the thickness of the insulation and rotting the tops of the rafters.
Roof ventilation must be ensured over the full length of the slopes up to the ridge. The air outlet openings at the high point of the roof must guarantee continuous air flow through the underlay zone, in order to prevent any build-up of moisture and to regulate the summer temperature beneath the discontinuous roofing elements.
norme SIA 232/1
Dry fixing solves these problems by separating the role of mechanical protection against the weather from the roof ventilation function. The system relies on a flexible or semi-rigid ventilated ridge closer fitted onto a raised ridge batten. This technical roll combines an air-permeable central part — made of a micro-perforated metal grille or a tear-resistant synthetic geotextile — and two weather-tight side wings. These pleated aluminium or malleable copper flashings, coated on the underside with beads of cold-applied butyl, closely follow the profile of Roman, corrugated or flat tiles.
| Criterion | Mortar-bedded ridge | Dry-fixed ridge on ventilated closer |
|---|---|---|
| Air outlet | Completely blocked by the mortar fillet | Complies with the sections required by SIA 232/1 |
| Expansion and shrinkage | Cracking of the bead is unavoidable | Tiles free to move thermally |
| Frost sensitivity | Spalling due to water retention | Unaffected, direct drainage of condensate |
| Future maintenance | Complete demolition with a chisel | Dismantling element by element without breakage |
The air extracted from the counter-batten network thus escapes freely under the dome of the ridge tiles, without powder snow or driving rain entering under the roofing. The side wings create a baffle that gusts cannot get past, while immediately draining run-off water towards the lower part of the roof slope.
Mechanical fixing of the elements and method for reworking an old ridge
Assembly begins with the installation of adjustable metal risers, plugged or screwed onto the ridge framing. These supports receive the pressure-treated timber ridge batten, sized to the camber of the chosen tiles. The ventilated ridge closer is then unrolled and stapled onto the upper edge of this timber. After the peel-off film has been removed, the pleated flashings are carefully pressed down by hand and then with a rubber roller into the bottom of the roofing profile to activate the butyl. A dust-free substrate is essential to guarantee continuous adhesion.
- Careful removal and demolitionRemove the existing ridge tiles with a flat crowbar, taking care not to damage the last courses of field tiles. Break up the mortar with a hand chisel or a light breaker fitted with a flat blade, directing the blows upwards.
- Cleaning and checking the substrateSweep away the rubble thoroughly and vacuum up the fine mineral dust. Check that the ridge timber is straight and check the condition of the underlay strip at the ridge junction.
- Packing out the new ridge battenFix the metal riser brackets every sixty centimetres in line with the rafters. Position the batten so that the ridge tiles rest on the ridge closer without bearing on the timber.
- Pressing down and tightening the clipsUnroll the ridge closer, bond the adhesive strips to the clean roofing and lay the ridge tiles, securing each one individually with nailed or screwed stainless steel hooks.
The fixing of the ridge tiles must in no case depend on the dead weight of the clay. Each element is secured by a specific hook in pre-lacquered aluminium or 1.4301 stainless steel. These clips engage on the heel of the preceding ridge tile and are screwed directly into the central batten with wood screws of a minimum diameter of four and a half millimetres, fitted with a neoprene sealing washer.
Ridge ventilation requirements according to SIA 232/1
The durability of the thermal insulation and of the roof structure depends directly on the free circulation of air in the space beneath the roofing. A traditional bedding mortar blocks the space under the ridge tiles and neutralises the upward thermal draught. In accordance with standard SIA 232/1, a continuous air outlet at the ridge line is essential to remove residual moisture from heated rooms or accidental water ingress.
The ventilation space under the tiles must communicate directly with the outside without any risk of blockage by dust deposits, insect nests or drifted snow. Metal or composite ridge closers fitted with perforated grilles and pleated flashings provide this continuous ventilation section while blocking water driven by gusts of wind or winter powder snow.
| Type of ridge construction | Vapour removal | Freeze-thaw resistance | Mechanical wind resistance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full bedding in cement mortar | None (zone entirely airtight) | Poor (cracking under thermal stress) | Rigid but brittle with ageing |
| Flexible aluminium/ventilated fabric closer | Excellent (continuous air passage along the ridge) | Unaffected (no hydraulic binder) | Elastic thanks to the mechanical fixings |
| Rigid closer with ventilation combs | Very high (large geometric sections) | Very good (frost-insensitive materials) | Durable if anchored to a stable ridge batten |
Demolition of mortar-bedded ridges and integration of the dry ridge closer
When refurbishing a pitched roof, converting a mortar-bedded ridge to a dry solution requires methodical removal of the old fillets. Violent impacts on the upper courses of tiles cause chipping of the noses of the clay elements being kept, or destabilise the underlying roof structure. The work is carried out with a light chisel hammer or a point chisel to detach the mortar without shaking the ridge purlin.
- Removing the old ridge tilesCarefully cut through the mortar between the joints without striking the underlying tiles directly. Recover the elements in good condition if reuse is stipulated in the specifications, then remove the mineral debris.
- Fitting the brackets and adjusting the riserFix the metal ridge brackets directly onto the roof structure with suitable wood screws. Adjust the height of the ridge batten (usual section 30 x 50 mm or 40 x 60 mm) to provide the necessary clearance under the ridge tiles.
- Unrolling and pressing down the ridge closerNail or staple the ridge closer to the top batten at regular intervals. Remove the protective film from the butyl strips and press the pleated profile by hand into the troughs of the tiles to create a barrier tight against powder snow.
- Mechanical fixing of the ridge elementsLay the new or cleaned ridge tiles with the overlap oriented according to the prevailing winds. Lock each unit with specific hooks screwed into the ridge batten, avoiding any rigid cement joint.
For end pieces or the junction with hips, prefabricated special pieces or made-to-measure lead or zinc flashings ensure mechanical weather-tightness. The use of ridge tile hooks in powder-coated aluminium or stainless steel guarantees excellent resistance to pull-out under wind suction, while allowing the clay tiles to expand without restraint during summer thermal shocks.
Handling unforeseen problems and refurbishing a non-compliant ridge
During refurbishment, removing a mortar-bedded ridge often reveals hidden defects on the ridge purlin or at the ends of the hips: superficial rot in the timber, excessive deflection under residual mortar loads, or the absence of continuous support to anchor the ridge risers. If the load-bearing structure is compromised, the roofer-plumber must stop installing the ventilated system. In accordance with CO, the contractor informs the client when circumstances compromise the proper or timely execution of the work.
| Defect found | Impact on the ventilated ridge | Corrective measure on site |
|---|---|---|
| Spongy or rotten ridge support | Batten brackets cannot be screwed down | Replacement or doubling of the purlin by the carpenters |
| Level difference > 15 mm between rafters | Misalignment of the batten and the ridge tiles | Individual packing under adjustable metal brackets |
| Underlay closed at the top | Total blockage of the thermal flow under the tiles | Longitudinal cutting of the membrane and weather-tight reinstatement |
| Marked asymmetric pitch | Ridge closer flashings too short on one side | Use of an asymmetric ridge closer or double flashing |
Another frequent technical problem is the unsuitability of the ventilated ridge closer flashing for tiles with a very pronounced profile. When the butyl adhesive does not press into the troughs, the wing lifts under the action of the wind and lets powder snow in. It is forbidden to compensate for this defect with mortar under the ridge tile. The height of the ridge batten must be adjusted to the millimetre before pressing down. Work at the upper edge requires attention to collective fall protection in accordance with OTConst.
Frequently asked questions
How can a ventilated ridge closer be adapted to old tiles with a very irregular profile?
On old hand-made or heavily distorted tiles, ordinary pleated flashings leave gaps. A flexible ridge closer with a high stretch coefficient and wide strips of reinforced butyl should be used. Before bonding, the tiles must be dry-brushed. Careful manual pre-forming into each trough prevents mechanical tension in the strip, guaranteeing continuous bonding and tightness against drifting snow.
What should be done if the ridge batten is fixed too low relative to the ridge tiles?
If the batten is too low, the ridge tile hooks do not press the clay elements down properly and the ridge closer risks being crushed under the weight of the ridge tiles, thereby blocking the ventilation sections required by standard SIA 232/1. The metal fixing brackets must be raised, or a calibrated counter-batten screwed into the structure must be inserted, to restore the necessary air clearance.
Can the old mortar-bedded ridge tiles be reused for dry re-laying?
Reuse is possible provided that all residual mortar adhering to the ridge tiles is removed without cracking the clay. Residues prevent precise centring and clipping of the aluminium or stainless steel fixing hooks. If the ridge tiles show frost damage, spalling, or if their interlock has been damaged by chiselling, they must be replaced entirely with compatible new elements.
How can the air outlet under the ridge be guaranteed if the underlay is continuous?
On a ventilated ridge, the underlay membrane must not hermetically enclose the ridge tile if it is not permeable to water vapour. The membrane must be interrupted about five centimetres below the ridge line on each side to allow warm air to escape from the space under the roofing, then a protective ventilated cap must be fitted to divert infiltrating water towards the lower counter-battens.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 232/1Pitched roofs
- COmaterial and ground: the contractor is responsible for the good quality of the material he supplies; if the material supplied by the client or the ground designated by him is found to be defective, or if any other circumstance compromises the proper or timely execution of the work, he must inform the client immediately, failing which he bears the consequences (para. 3)
- OTConstuse of the perimeter guardrail: installed in unprotected places where the fall height exceeds 2 m, on embankments more than 2 m high and with a slope of more than 45°, and near bodies of water and watercourses (para. 1)
