Key takeaways
- Securing the surrounding area and the workers must always come before any repair work on the roof.
- Emergency tarping is carried out by clamping the tarp under counter-battens screwed into the roof structure, without loose ballast.
- A complete photographic record of the slope is made before any protective tarp is fitted.
- The emergency invoice for making the roof watertight remains strictly separate from the quote for the final repair.
Securing the perimeter and stabilising the slope before tarping
Work following a storm begins in the context of active damage. Displaced roofing elements, loosened ridge tiles or torn-off verges turn the pitched roof into an unstable zone. The absolute priority is to eliminate immediate hazards, both for occupants at ground level and for the sheet-metal workers and roofers sent to the site. In accordance with art. 82 LAA, the employer must take all measures that experience has shown to be necessary, that are feasible according to the state of the art and that are appropriate to the given conditions in order to prevent occupational accidents and diseases; the workers assist the employer in this.
- Marking out an exclusion zone at ground level with construction site barriers below the work area and the damaged verges.
- Visual inspection from an aerial work platform or the roof space to identify cracked rafters and broken battens.
- Systematic removal of loose elements that could slide off when climbing onto the slope.
- Installing a proven structural anchor point for the personal fall arrest system.
As soon as access to the slope is secured, making the roof watertight requires a reinforced tarp of at least 200 g/m², waterproof and tear-resistant. The sheet must never simply be nailed through its perimeter eyelets, which tear out in a moderate breeze. The fundamental principle is to clamp the tarp between the substrate and hardwood battens with a minimum cross-section of 24 x 48 mm, firmly screwed through the existing battening into the load-bearing rafters. The screws go through the clamping batten every 40 to 50 cm, using suitable threaded wood screws.
- Tucking under the intact upper edgeSlide the head of the tarp 30 cm under the intact row of tiles above the breach, or run it over the ridge and secure it on the opposite slope.
- Mechanical tension and intermediate batteningPull the sheet taut towards the gutter to eliminate water pockets. Press intermediate battens down in the direction of the slope, aligned with the rafters, to guide rainwater runoff without obstruction.
- Bottom fixing and eaves drainageFold the lower end into the gutter or hanging gutter, maintaining a continuous screwed clamp on the last tilting board.
Recording the damage for the insurer and splitting the work quote
The haste to cover the breach often destroys the evidence essential for the building insurer to settle the claim. In French-speaking Switzerland, whether the building is covered by a cantonal fire and natural hazards insurance institution or by a private company, the burden of material proof lies with the owner. The response team must set aside ten minutes to make an accurate visual record before covering the area with the tarp.
| View scale | Subject to frame | Purpose for the assessor |
|---|---|---|
| Overview | Whole façade and the affected roof slope | Prove the exposure to the prevailing wind and the context |
| Medium view | Breach, eaves lines and exposed hips | Delimit the area directly affected by the torn-off materials |
| Close-up | Sheared nails, bent hooks, underlay | Demonstrate the violence of the storm as opposed to wear |
Handling the finances of the storm damage requires splitting the operation into two strictly independent commercial files. The emergency work comprises making safe, removing dangerous materials, supplying the tarps, the holding-down battening and immediate labour on a time-and-materials basis. This first service is invoiced without delay, on the basis of the work report signed by the client, so that the client can obtain quick reimbursement as rescue costs.
The full repair of the slope is the subject of a separate estimate quote, drawn up calmly after an exhaustive measured survey. This document details the replacement of broken battens, the repair of the underlay, the relaying of new tiles or slates compatible with the original model, and the repair of the sheet-metal elements creased by the squall. Under the ordinance on construction work, where collective fall protection measures cannot be installed immediately, the tradesperson plans the appropriate scaffolding for this second, lasting phase of the construction site.
Work protocol in bad weather and evidence record for the insurer
Work following a storm confronts the team of sheet-metal workers and roofers with severe residual weather conditions: persistent gusts, slippery surfaces and unstable roofing elements. The absolute rule on site is to carry out the operations in a strict sequence: secure access and workstations, record the state of the damage on a joint basis, then fit the temporary protection. No repair or reinforcement must be attempted before the risks of falling from the pitched roof have been neutralised.
- Marking out and securing at ground levelImmediately mark out a fall zone at the foot of the slope using barriers or warning tape. Displaced tiles, torn-off verge elements or ripped sheet-metal flashings may slide off at any moment because of the wind.
- Anchoring and secure access to the slopeSet up the access equipment without resting on weakened battens or deformed gutters. Workers wear personal fall protection equipment connected to verified structural anchor points on the slope.
- Methodical photographic recordPhotograph the entire slope from the ground and from the aerial work platform, then take close-up shots of the damaged key points: wind-blown ridge, valleys clogged with debris, loose metal flashings or broken slates. These photos are the evidence of the initial condition for the building insurer's assessor.
- Fitting the temporary tarpRoll out a reinforced tarp of high mechanical strength from the ridge towards the eaves. Fixing must be done using screwed wooden battens passing through the sheet into the load-bearing rafters, to prevent the wind catching the free edges.
The employer applies art. 82 LAA: the employer must take all measures that experience has shown to be necessary, that are feasible according to the state of the art and that are appropriate to the given conditions in order to prevent occupational accidents and diseases; the workers assist the employer in this. In violent winds or residual hail, if mechanical restraint cannot be guaranteed or if gusts exceed the operating limits of the temporary access equipment, immediate withdrawal is mandatory until conditions calm.
Administrative and technical separation: emergency securing versus repair
In contractual and administrative terms, the frequent confusion between emergency protective measures and the final restoration work gives rise to serious disputes with cantonal insurance institutions or private companies. The emergency work is an immediate stopgap intended to stop water infiltration into the roof space from getting worse. It gives rise to a specific time-and-materials slip or a statement of time spent and materials used, signed by the owner or their representative on site.
| Operational criterion | Phase 1: Emergency measures and tarping | Phase 2: Final repair of the slope |
|---|---|---|
| Main objective | Temporary watertightness and elimination of the risk of falling materials | Lasting restoration of the roof covering, sheet-metal work and underlay |
| Means of access to the roof | Mobile elevating work platform or occasional access from inside using a harness | Continuous façade scaffolding and mandatory collective protection |
| Materials used | Reinforced tarps, temporary wedging counter-battens, wood screws | Compliant replacement tiles or slates, custom-folded flashing strips |
| Contractual framework | Emergency order, time-and-materials invoicing of hours and supplies | Detailed quote based on a joint measured survey after the assessor's visit |
| Prior approval | Direct instruction from the owner to limit further damage | Formal confirmation of cover by the insurer before execution |
The final repair requires methodical dismantling of the affected areas, checking the integrity of the underlying roof structure and replacing distorted sheet-metal elements: torn-off downpipes, deformed verge strips or dented valleys. The sheet-metal and roofing company draws up a separate complete quote, including removal of the emergency measures, clearance of debris, the ground-supported scaffolding essential for long-duration work and the fitting of the final materials.
Handling disputes, repeat storms and insurance complications
On a pitched roof damaged by gusts, the situation can deteriorate despite the first measures: a new squall tears off the temporary sheet, residual infiltration damages interior finishes, or the insurer's assessor disputes the time-and-materials hours spent on securing. The work is carried out under heavy weather constraints, but the method remains strict: first secure access and falling elements, then photograph all the damage, repair afterwards.
If the wind strengthens to the point that moving on the battens or the underlay becomes impracticable, withdrawal is required without delay. In accordance with art. 82 LAA, the employer must take all measures that experience has shown to be necessary, that are feasible according to the state of the art and that are appropriate to the given conditions in order to prevent occupational accidents and diseases. No tarping justifies endangering the team on a wet slope battered by wind.
- Failure of the temporary protection: if a drip edge tears or an emergency counter-batten is torn out, evacuate the ground area threatened by falling tiles or battens, record the exact time of the deterioration in the weather and call the client back before any new climb.
- Discovery of structural damage: if a rafter shows a clean break under the weight of a fallen tree or if the ridge purlin has moved, immediately record the stoppage of the roofing work. Under art. 365 CO, if another circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work, the contractor must inform the client immediately, failing which the contractor bears the consequences.
- Financial disagreement with the insurer: categorically refuse to merge the rescue work and the full repair into a single invoice. Emergency securing falls under essential protective measures, whereas the lasting replacement of tiles, hips and sheet-metal valleys is covered by a separate itemised quote.
Frequently asked questions
How should you react if the wind tears off the emergency tarp the night after it was fitted?
Never go back onto the roof at night or in the middle of a storm. Wait for the major gusts to end and for daylight before working safely. Take dated photographs of the damage before touching anything. Have the client sign a new work order for this re-tarping, then reinforce the mechanical hold-down by screwing clamping battens directly into the rafters through the sheet.
Can the insurer refuse to pay for emergency tarping if the photos are missing?
The insurer's assessor requires material evidence to confirm that the rescue measures were essential. If you cover the breach straight away without prior photographs, the insurer may argue that the original damage was minor and dispute the number of hours invoiced. Always photograph the blown-off elements, the water penetration and the precise state of the battening before rolling out the reinforced polythene or heavy tarp.
Can a few broken tiles be replaced during the emergency securing phase?
Yes, if these one-off replacements ensure immediate watertightness without requiring heavy dismantling. However, these actions must appear separately on the emergency time-and-materials report, stating the emergency supplies used. Complete reworking of the slope, recalibration of the sheet-metal work or straightening of the valleys falls exclusively under the final repair quote, drawn up later after drying and a joint assessment.
What should you do if the underlying roof structure has sagged under the impact of a fallen tree?
Stop all roofing work on that bay immediately. Secure only the ground-level perimeter against residual falling materials and notify the client in writing straight away. The stability of the timber frame is a matter for the carpenter. Do not fit any ballast or tarp under tension on a weakened structure: wait for the propping or prior reinforcement of the roof structure by the specialist company.
Texts and standards cited
- LAA art. 82general prevention rules: the employer must take all measures that experience has shown to be necessary, that are feasible according to the state of the art and that are appropriate to the given conditions in order to prevent occupational accidents and diseases; the workers assist the employer in this (in particular by using personal protective equipment).
- CO art. 365material and site: the contractor is responsible for the good quality of the material it supplies; if the material supplied by the client or the site designated by the client is found to be defective, or if another circumstance jeopardises the proper or timely execution of the work, the contractor must inform the client immediately, failing which the contractor bears the consequences (para. 3).
