Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 224Roofer safety, snow and roof maintenanceChapter 3 of 10 in the section

Fragile materials on roofs: translucent sheets, fibre-cement and falls through the roof

This chapter details practical methods for securing circulation and roofing work in the immediate vicinity of translucent or fibre-cement materials. You will learn how to identify non-load-bearing elements on a roof slope, install collective protection on the underside and set up suitable circulation routes to prevent any element from breaking under load.

Key takeaways

  • Translucent sheets and aged fibre-cement offer no guaranteed resistance to direct foot traffic.
  • Visual identification and marking of non-load-bearing zones are carried out before any access to the roof slope.
  • Installing a net on the underside is the priority collective protection against falls through the roof.
  • A load-spreading walkway remains mandatory for any movement along rooflights.

Identifying non-load-bearing materials and planning collective protection

On sloping industrial or agricultural roofs, glass-fibre-reinforced polyester profiled sheets, polycarbonate or corrugated fibre-cement sheets represent a permanent risk of sudden failure. Under the effect of ultraviolet radiation, temperature swings and weather, these materials lose their original elasticity. A translucent sheet several years old becomes brittle as glass; it can no longer bear the concentrated weight of a roofer, a sheet-metal worker or their tools. The trap often lies in the layer of dust or moss that evens out the surface of the slope and hides the exact nature of the rooflight elements.

Before any work on the slope, the team carries out a precise survey from inside the building. This inspection from the underside makes it possible to locate each translucent bay, assess the spacing of the roof purlins and check the condition of the fixings. The Ordinance on Construction Work requires work stations to be organised so as to eliminate the risk of falling. Where work is carried out at the roof edge, art. 41 OTConst provides for appropriate measures to prevent falls from a fall height of more than 2 m. Within the slope itself, the risk of falling through a fragile roof covering likewise requires systematic preventive measures before anyone walks on the roof.

  • Surveying the layout of the clear sheets from inside the roof structure before climbing onto the roof.
  • Checking the surface condition of the profiled sheets to detect cracks, yellowing and degradation of the resins.
  • Checking for any original welded wire mesh beneath the translucent sheets.
  • Marking off access zones to prevent installers from straying onto the brittle areas.

Where the configuration of the building prevents a standard collective system from being installed on the roof, the Ordinance on Construction Work allows equivalent protective measures, set out in writing with the involvement of an occupational safety specialist. This safety-engineering approach defines the permissible anchorages, the working method and the movement restrictions.

Deploying underside nets and setting up circulation routes

The most effective safeguard against the collapse of a fragile material is to catch the fall from below, as close to the slope as possible. A safety net suspended from the roof structure provides continuous collective protection for all trades working on the roof. These synthetic net sheets are stretched beneath the bays containing rooflights or transparent sheets, respecting the permissible deflection and the clearance distances from fixed installations or machinery located in the hall.

  1. Anchoring nets under the roof structureFix the net tension ropes directly to the load-bearing members of the steel or timber roof structure, using an aerial work platform operating from the interior floor.
  2. Installing circulation walkwaysPlace aluminium working walkways or load-spreading planks at least fifty centimetres wide, bearing on two consecutive purlins and not resting on the corrugation of the fragile material.
  3. Anchoring and guiding mobile walkwaysMechanically secure the walkway to the roof purlins using hooks or clamps to prevent any sliding down the slope.
  4. Rigid marking of edge zonesInstall a free-standing temporary guardrail or a guide rail along the walking lane to delimit the authorised route.
Comparison of restraint and load-spreading systems on a fragile roof
Safety systemArea of actionInstallation principleTechnical limit
Underside netBeneath the translucent sheetsSuspended from the main roof beamsRequires sufficient clear height under the slope
Roofer's walkwayOn the slope where people moveDirect bridging on the load-bearing purlinsDoes not protect against a sideways misstep
Metal protective grilleOn the frame of the translucent elementScrewed to the kerb or the structureSuited to isolated individual rooflights

For laying edges, valleys or sheet-metal flashings near a translucent strip, craftsmen use interconnected plank walkways. This arrangement spreads the load of the worker and materials onto the underlying structure without placing any mechanical stress on the plastic or fibre-cement sheets. Where crossing the roof requires stepping transversely across a transparent strip, the bridging element must extend at least one metre beyond each side of the non-load-bearing zone. The rules of good practice rule out the use of light, unsecured roofer's ladders, which may slip or puncture the corrugation crests.

Circulation and crossing arrangements for fragile roof coverings

On pitched roofs fitted with ribbed sheeting or corrugated fibre-cement sheets, the sudden failure of a translucent element is a permanent hazard. Under the effect of weather, temperature differences and ultraviolet radiation, polyester or polycarbonate sheets lose their mechanical cohesion. Their degradation causes a brittleness that is invisible from the slope. The illusion of a load-bearing surface leads to the most frequent accident in the trade: the roofer steps on a panel that gives way instantly under their weight, with no plastic deformation and no warning noise.

Rigorous identification of fragile zones precedes any climb onto the roof. On industrial halls and agricultural buildings, fouling by soot, moss and lichen erases the contrast between the opaque roof covering and the rooflights. Before accessing the slope, the foreman locates the translucent bays from inside the roof space or beneath the roof structure, then marks the openings on the roof plan. On the slope, rigid barriers or firmly anchored marking chains delimit an impassable working lane along the non-load-bearing zones.

Load-spreading means for moving on fragile roofs
Crossing systemLoad transferAnchoring conditionRecommended use
Rigid aluminium walkway with anchoring battensContinuous span over at least two roof purlinsMechanical locking at the top against slipping down the slopeRegular movement parallel or perpendicular to the corrugations
Curved roofer's ladder with wheels and hookLoad spread onto the rafters via the ridgeHook locked onto the opposite ridge purlinOccasional access for ridge or hip sheet-metal work
Rigid non-slip load-spreading panelDirect support bridging the spans of the roof structureAnti-lift fixing with stop blocks for toolsStatic work station during flashing work

Moving and working near a translucent sheet requires the systematic installation of circulation walkways. These elements must be sufficiently wide and have non-slip surfaces. Using simple planks resting directly on the corrugations of the fragile material is prohibited: working loads must be transmitted directly to the load-bearing purlins or rafters. All movement on the slope takes place exclusively on these prepared routes, firmly secured at the top of the slope to prevent any longitudinal sliding.

Underside protection, edge restraint and specific provisions

Preventing a fall through the material remains the priority objective before starting work on the slope. The proven method consists of deploying catch nets on the underside of the roof. These textile collective protections, stretched under the roof structure before the roofing work begins, catch the worker if a translucent sheet or a fibre-cement panel fails unexpectedly. These nets are installed entirely from the ground or by means of a mobile elevating platform, without any technician stepping onto the unsecured roof covering.

Art. 41 OTConst provides for measures to be taken at roof edges to prevent falls from a fall height of more than 2 m. For the sheet-metal worker or roofer, a guardrail or a catch scaffold at the bottom of the slope stops a slide down the roof slope, but it provides no protection against going through a fragile sheet in the middle of the slope. Perimeter protection at the edge and catching on the underside are two complementary systems that are indispensable to ensure safety over the whole working volume.

Where structural technical constraints make it impossible to install underside nets or rigid roof walkways, the Ordinance on Construction Work allows equivalent protective measures, set out in writing with the involvement of an occupational safety specialist. This exceptional provision requires a formal protocol recording the sizing of the temporary lifelines, the assessment of the strength of the anchor points on the roof structure, the use of suitable personal fall-arrest equipment and the detailed organisation of a rescue arrangement in case of suspension in mid-air.

Incident management and emergency measures on fragile surfaces

When a translucent sheet or a corrugated fibre-cement sheet cracks under a foothold or under the impact of a tool, the risk of total failure is critical. On an industrial or agricultural pitched roof, these materials degrade rapidly under the effect of sun, frost and moss. The roofer has no warning signal: the material gives way in one piece without prior bending. As soon as a chip or a suspicious crack appears, the team must apply a methodical withdrawal protocol. The site manager orders the sector to be stopped and the surrounding area cleared without sudden movements, relying solely on the load-bearing purlins or on the circulation walkway.

  1. Making safe and withdrawing personnelThe craftsman calmly transfers their weight onto the circulation walkway or the line of nailing on the roof structure. Access to the slope is prohibited for all workers present on the construction site.
  2. Marking and closing off accessIdentifying fragile zones requires floor marking and the installation of prohibition barriers. The ground-floor area directly beneath the damaged sheet is also closed off to eliminate the risk of crushing or cutting.
  3. Checking collective protectionThe condition of the net or underside protection is examined from below. Any textile net that has absorbed a load or the fall of an element must be taken out of service and tagged out.
  4. Defining substitute measuresWhere it is impossible to reinstate the required guardrails or nets, an equivalent protective measure, set out in writing with an occupational safety specialist, must be drawn up before starting the repair.

Art. 41 OTConst provides for the measures to be taken at roof edges to prevent falls from a fall height of more than 2 m. Where a fractured translucent material creates a gaping opening, this perimeter protection is no longer sufficient on its own. The sheet-metal and roofing team must treat the breach as an open hatch in the roof slope. Before replacing the damaged sheet, a rigid covering protection or a compliant net must prevent any fall into the void. Work resumes only after the validated measures have been formally recorded in the safety plan.

Frequently asked questions

How can we make sure that an old translucent sheet can still bear the weight of a roofer?

As a rule, no translucent sheet, whether polyester or PVC, may be considered safe to walk on. Even if the material appears visually intact, chemical ageing under solar radiation removes all mechanical elasticity. One must never step on a sheet or directly beside it. To work on or inspect the area, the craftsman must absolutely lay a circulation walkway bearing on the underlying roof purlins.

Does wearing personal fall-arrest equipment remove the need for an underside net?

No. The safety rules give priority to collective protection over individual systems. The net or underside protection secures all workers permanently without depending on a clipping-on manoeuvre. Personal fall-arrest equipment is used only as a temporary supplement or under particular constraints. If the configuration of the building prevents the usual protections from being installed, an equivalent protective measure, set out in writing with an occupational safety specialist, must be formalised.

What identification of fragile zones should be put in place during a maintenance job on a construction site?

Identifying fragile zones begins with a roof plan displayed at the access to the slope, supplemented by visual marking directly on the roof covering. On roofs with rooflights or fibre-cement elements, painted marking battens, cones or rigid protective grilles are installed. The authorised circulation lanes must be delimited unambiguously to prevent any worker from straying while handling tools.

What are the minimum technical requirements for a temporary circulation walkway?

A circulation walkway on a fragile roof covering must be at least 50 centimetres wide and rest on two consecutive roof purlins to transmit the loads. It must have non-slip battens nailed at regular intervals and a mechanical device preventing it from sliding towards the gutter. If the roof pitch exceeds 20 degrees or if there is a risk of slipping, the walkway must be supplemented by a restraint line or a suitable guardrail.

Texts and standards cited

  • OTConst art. 41measures at roof edges: appropriate measures to prevent falls from a fall height of more than 2 m

In the same section