Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 224Roof covering: tiles, slates and installation on battensChapter 8 of 10 in the section

Replacing a broken tile: moving about without breaking ten others

Replacing a single defective tile frequently causes a chain of breakages if the roofer's footing is poorly positioned. This chapter details the rules for safe access, finding support points directly on the battening, the use of the roofing ladder and the precise movements for unlocking the tile so that you can work effectively without damaging the rest of the roof slope.

Key takeaways

  • Always place your feet directly over the battens and the exposed tile area (lap-free section) to spread the loads.
  • Use a roofing ladder fixed to the ridge to avoid any direct contact with the roof covering.
  • Relieve the tiles above and beside the broken one with a wooden wedge before sliding the broken piece out.
  • Check that the whole course interlocks perfectly and that the exposed tile areas are aligned after the replacement.

Support positions and safe access on a sloping roof

Walking directly on a covering of fired-clay or concrete tiles demands absolute care in body positioning. A tile spanning the gap between battens at mid-span will not withstand the weight of a worker. To avoid accidental breakages, the foot must rest only on the lower part of the tile, at the exact point where it bears on the batten and interlocks with the tile below. Support is taken flat so as to spread the load over several tile noses, avoiding impacts on the longitudinal interlocking edges.

For targeted work or on steep slopes, the use of a roofing ladder (or roof ladder) relies on bracket hooks firmly anchored to the rafters or hooked over the ridge. The ladder spreads the worker's weight over several linear metres of battening while creating a walking surface that keeps the tiles from any direct contact with site boots.

  • Axial progression: always climb in line with the rafters, where the mechanical strength of the battening is greatest.
  • Load distribution: use compliant roof hooks or load-spreading plates to secure the ladder.
  • Prior cleaning: sweep away moss or deposits that hide the interlocks and make the surface slippery.

Mechanical unlocking, fitting the new tile and checking the course

Replacing a broken element requires freeing the tile without forcing the neighbouring tiles that overlap it. The tiles of the course above and of the adjacent column should be lifted gently using softwood wedges. This temporary lift breaks the lock of the lateral and head-lap interlocking play, making it possible to extract the broken pieces without causing impact cracks on the neighbouring interlocks.

  1. Relieving the interlocksInsert two wooden wedges under the exposed area of the course above and under the tile to the right to free the waterproofing ribs.
  2. Removing the debrisFree the broken shard by turning it slightly upwards to release the lug from the batten, then slide it downwards.
  3. Inserting the new elementPresent the replacement tile from below, engage it under the raised interlocks, then push it up until the lug hooks over the batten.
  4. Removing the wedgesCarefully lower the upper tiles and check that no dust or rubble has lodged in the interlocking groove.

Once the piece is in place, the roofer carries out a visual and manual check of the course. He checks the horizontal alignment of the tile noses and the continuity of the drainage channel. If the replacement model comes from a different batch, the interlocking play must be adjusted with a string line to adapt the variable exposed area and guarantee perfect watertightness.

Moving about on the roof and distributing support points

Replacing a single broken tile is a frequent job in renovation or after a weather event. It exposes the roofer to the risk of damaging neighbouring elements through incorrect load transfer. On a covering of interlocking or plain tiles, the worker's weight must never be applied directly to the centre of a tile's exposed area or on the interlocking edges, otherwise microcracks or outright breakage of the adjacent pieces will result.

To move across the slope without damage, the foot rests exclusively on the exposed area of the tile, directly over the batten beneath. The heel lines up with the nose of the tile above so that the vertical force is transmitted to the timber batten and the roof structure, and not to the body of the roofing material.

Using a roofing ladder (or roof ladder) laid out on the slope spreads the worker's load over several battens at once. The rungs, offset from the roof plane, provide continuous support, leaving the worker's hands free while avoiding point impacts on the materials.

Unlocking technique and checking course alignment

Removing a broken element requires progressively lifting the upper and side tiles to free the interlocks without breaking the hanging lugs. Using hardwood wedges or tinsmith's shims, the upper course is placed slightly under tension to create the play needed to remove the broken fragment.

  1. Fitting the lifting wedgesInsert two wooden wedges under the noses of the tiles in the course above to relieve the weight bearing on the tile to be replaced.
  2. Freeing the interlocksGently turn the defective tile upwards to unlock the side edge and release it from the batten.
  3. Inserting the new pieceEngage the lug of the new tile on the batten, adjust the lateral interlocking fit, then remove the lifting wedges.
  4. Visual check and alignmentCheck the continuity of the exposed area and the straightness of the setting-out line to guarantee watertightness against driving rain.
Equipment and support methods by roof type
Type of coveringSafe support pointSpecific unlocking tools
Machine-made tile (clay)Directly over the batten / tile noseWooden wedges / tile hook
Plain tileDouble thickness over the battenRoofer's spatula / pliers
Natural slateOn continuous boarding onlyNail puller / slater's hammer

Once the element has been replaced, the course check ensures that the vertical and horizontal interlocks fit together without mechanical stress. A badly seated tile creates a path for powder snow and risks being lifted by wind pressure. If doubts arise about the soundness of the framework or of existing supports discovered during the replacement, the contractor discharges his duty to inform the client.

Handling the unexpected and checking the underlay

Replacing a broken roofing element sometimes reveals underlying damage hidden by the exposed area. When the breakage is due to a one-off impact, the batten bearing generally withstands the work without damage. If, however, the broken tile has let rainwater infiltrate for several seasons, the water has accumulated at the batten and counter-batten, causing localised rotting of the timber or deterioration of the underlay sheet.

  1. Repairing the underlay membraneDry the damaged area of the membrane thoroughly. Apply a compatible sealing patch stuck down with an acrylic adhesive tape suitable for exterior use, with an overlap of at least 10 cm in the direction of the slope under the upper sheet.
  2. Replacing the damaged section of battenSaw the damaged batten off at the nearest counter-batten. Replace the segment with a treated batten of the same section (generally 24 x 48 mm or 30 x 50 mm) fixed by nailing or through-screwing to the roof structure.
  3. Checking the interlocking chainCheck the lateral and vertical play of the surrounding tiles. If several adjacent tiles show chipping on the lugs or the interlocking ribs, replace them immediately to avoid further breakage on tightening.

In accordance with the Code of Obligations (art. 365 CO), the roofer has a legal obligation to notify the client or his representative immediately of any defect found in the supports or of any situation likely to compromise the proper execution of the roof covering. If the timber structure is too deteriorated to anchor the tiles or if the area to be replaced extends over a large part of the slope, the work must be stopped while the condition is recorded and an addendum for the remedial work is validated.

Frequently asked questions

How should you proceed if the original battens do not respect the theoretical exposed area?

When replacing a tile on an old roof, the battening may show variations in the exposed area. A rigid new tile must not be forced into the interlock. The hanging lug should be carefully ground down or the play adjusted within the interlocking margin tolerated by the manufacturer, to avoid twisting the vertical course.

Can sealant be used to glue a cracked tile?

Gluing a broken tile with sealant is a temporary solution that does not comply with the rules of roofing practice. Thermal expansion and frost susceptibility break the joint within one or two seasons, causing invisible leaks. The only lasting treatment to guarantee watertightness remains removing and fully replacing the damaged element.

How can you avoid breaking the interlocks when removing a tile on a very dry roof?

On old clay roofs that have become brittle, use two soft packaging-wood wedges or two plastic shims to hold the upper course raised. This relieves the pressure exerted by the overlying tiles without creating a concentrated stress point on the sharp edges of the side ribs.

Where can you find a replacement tile of the exact model for an old building?

If the exact model is no longer manufactured, the roofer looks for a tile from the same manufacturer and the same period in the salvage stocks of the yard. Failing that, he replaces a visible tile with a compatible neighbouring model and moves the original tile to a discreet area or the edge of a valley.

Texts and standards cited

  • CO art. 365materials and ground: the contractor is responsible for the good quality of the materials he supplies; if the material supplied by the client or the ground designated by him is found to be defective, or if some other circumstance compromises the proper or timely execution of the work, he must inform the client immediately, failing which he bears the consequences (para. 3).
  • OTConst art. 41measures to be taken at roof edges: appropriate measures to prevent falls from a fall height of more than 2 m (roofer's catch platform and/or perimeter guardrail depending on the roof pitch); on roofs with a pitch of more than 60°, work only from scaffolding or a mobile elevating work platform (para. 3).

In the same section