Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 224Tinsmithing: shaping, junctions and thermal expansionChapter 1 of 10 in the section

Zinc, copper, stainless steel or aluminium: metal compatibility and runoff water

This chapter details the rules for combining metals in sheet-metal roofing work to avoid premature galvanic corrosion. You will learn to respect the order in which runoff water flows over the roof covering, to insulate metals properly where they contact treated timber or fresh concrete, and to ensure optimum service life of fabricated components.

Key takeaways

  • Runoff water from copper perforates zinc through galvanic corrosion within a few years.
  • Titanium-zinc and aluminium must always be installed upstream of copper elements.
  • Fresh concrete and salt-treated timber chemically attack metals unless a watertight separation is provided.
  • Stainless steel remains the transition metal that is universally compatible with all roof materials.

Galvanic couple and metal sequence on a pitched slope

In sheet-metal and roofing work, combining different metals on the same pitched roof is governed by strict physical rules. When a nobler metal (such as copper) lies upstream of a less noble metal (such as zinc or galvanised steel), runoff water laden with metal ions causes accelerated galvanic corrosion of the metal downstream. This phenomenon attacks the material in depth and causes the zinc to perforate in just a few years.

To avoid this degradation, the sheet-metal worker must strictly respect the electrochemical potential of the materials by arranging the metals in the strict order of water flow. Less noble metals are always placed upstream of nobler metals, or isolated by a neutral strip.

Compatibility and runoff water flow direction between sheet-metal roofing metals
Upstream metal (top of roof)Downstream metal (bottom of roof)Runoff compatibilityCorrective measure required
CopperZinc (titanium-zinc)Prohibited (rapid corrosion)Replace the zinc with stainless steel or insert a neutral separation
Zinc (titanium-zinc)CopperCompatibleNone (natural order of potentials)
AluminiumCopperCompatibleNone (runoff towards copper is harmless)
CopperStainless steelCompatibleNone (stainless steel resists cupric ions perfectly)

Aggressive substrate contacts and durability of fabricated metals

Metal compatibility does not concern rainwater alone, but extends to the substrate materials. Direct contact of zinc or aluminium with fresh alkaline concrete or mortar causes immediate chemical corrosion during the setting phase. Likewise, structural timber treated with metal salts or fire-retardant additives releases corrosive agents under the effect of residual moisture.

  • Mandatory installation of a neutral separation layer (synthetic membrane, decoupling felt or flexible waterproofing sheet) under titanium-zinc sheets laid over timber structures.
  • Protection of gutters and metal linings with a bituminous primer coat or a separation screen when pouring concrete or carrying out adjacent masonry work.
  • Exclusive use of brackets, hooks and screws in A2 or A4 stainless steel for the fabrication and installation of linings, to avoid any galvanic couple under the fixing head.
  • Application of the duty to inspect and inform under the Code of Obligations (art. 365 CO) if the substrate supplied or the treated timber risks damaging the planned sheet-metal work.
Decoupling felt
Structured synthetic mat installed under titanium-zinc strips and valleys on solid boarding, ensuring ventilation of the underside of the metal and eliminating direct contact with any timber preservation treatments.

The expected service life of a correctly dimensioned sheet-metal component free of galvanic corrosion commonly exceeds 40 to 60 years for titanium-zinc and more than 80 years for copper and stainless steel. Conversely, omitting a separation sheet or making a galvanic assembly error can reduce the roof's longevity to less than 5 years. The contractor is liable for the good quality of the material and of the work carried out under art. 364 CO and art. 365 CO.

Galvanic corrosion by runoff and incompatibility of metal couples

In pitched-roof sheet-metal work, premature degradation of metal components frequently results from a poor arrangement of materials along the water flow line. When a nobler metal located upstream comes into contact with rainwater, the water becomes laden with oxidising metal ions. As it runs downstream over a less noble metal, this electrolytic fluid causes accelerated electrochemical corrosion. This phenomenon, called runoff corrosion, attacks the matrix of the receiving metal until it is completely perforated.

The fundamental installation rule requires scrupulous respect of the electrochemical potential difference of the metals on the same roof slope. Copper has a high noble potential; runoff water from a copper roof covering, gutter or upper drip edge dissolves cupric ions. If this water flows directly onto titanium-zinc or Magnelis, the zinc suffers deep pitting that destroys the fabricated work within a few seasons of weathering.

Direct and runoff-water compatibility matrix between sheet-metal roofing metals
Upstream metal (water source)Downstream metal (receiver)Direct contactRunoff compatibility
CopperTitanium-zincProhibitedIncompatible (rapid perforation)
CopperGalvanised steel / MagnelisProhibitedIncompatible (severe corrosion)
Titanium-zincCopperCompatibleCompatible
Uginox stainless steel / 316LTitanium-zincCompatible with reservationCompatible
Lacquered aluminiumTitanium-zincCompatibleCompatible

Protection against treated timber, fresh concrete and durability of fabricated components

Besides incompatibility between metals, the sheet-metal worker must deal with attacks from substrate materials. Direct contact between a metal flashing and fresh concrete or mortar causes violent alkaline attack. Free lime and cement damage titanium-zinc and aluminium, forming whitish stains and disintegration pits as the masonry sets.

  • Installation of a decoupling strip or neutral separation felt under gutters and valleys.
  • Use of protective bituminous varnish on the hidden face of zinc sheets coming into contact with concrete or mortar.
  • Systematic mechanical isolation of fixing brackets and clips from timber impregnation products.
  • Choice of A2 or A4 stainless steel for the fabrication of components buried or embedded in masonry connections.

Solid or glulam timber roof structures treated with copper salts or fungicidal preservatives cause chemical corrosion equivalent to that of a galvanic couple. Moisture retained in the boarding releases salts that attack the sheets from the underside. It is essential to interpose a breathable underlay or a synthetic drainage mat under the sheet-metal work.

Underside corrosion
Deterioration of the metal caused by condensation of water vapour trapped between the solid substrate (boarding, panel) and the metal lining, reacting with timber acids or treatment products.

According to the rules of building practice and the principles of work execution, sheet-metal work that is correctly dimensioned and protected from electrochemical reactions has a high longevity. Pleated stainless steel or copper reach more than 80 years of service, while titanium-zinc reaches 40 to 60 years, provided no aggressive runoff alters the material's natural patina.

Managing incompatibilities on the construction site and corrective measures

When an error in combining metals or premature degradation due to runoff is discovered on a pitched roof, the sheet-metal worker must intervene without waiting for the perforation of the component to damage the sub-roof and the roof structure. If copper has been installed upstream of titanium-zinc strips or gutters, the release of cupric ions under the effect of rainwater causes rapid galvanic attack of the zinc below. Where a component is already damaged or there is an imminent risk of perforation, repair of the corroded element and replacement of the incompatible components are necessary to guarantee watertightness and preserve the service life of the roof covering.

The choice of fabricated materials must scrupulously respect the order of flow on the slope: lacquered aluminium or zinc upstream, stainless steel or copper downstream. Where replacing an upstream copper element proves impossible during partial refurbishment, the sheet-metal worker must install gutters or connections made entirely of austenitic stainless steel or copper, removing all zinc or aluminium from the water path.

If the construction site reveals a risk of defective work linked to the architect's choices or to the condition of the substrate, the contractor must immediately notify the client in writing. In accordance with the contractor's obligations set out in the Code of Obligations (CO), reporting a defective substrate or a material incompatibility avoids liability for consequential damage. The expected longevity of well-designed sheet-metal work exceeds 40 years for zinc and 50 years for copper or stainless steel.

Frequently asked questions

Why does a zinc gutter corrode below a dormer covered in copper?

Rainwater running over the dormer's copper becomes laden with cupric ions. As it flows onto the zinc gutter below, this acidic water creates a microscopic galvanic cell. This runoff corrosion phenomenon attacks the titanium-zinc at the surface and then perforates it completely within only a few years.

How can zinc be protected from direct contact with a concrete drip edge?

Fresh concrete and mortars contain alkaline slags that attack zinc by chemical corrosion in the presence of moisture. To prevent this degradation, a synthetic separation membrane or bituminous felt should be laid under the sheet-metal piece before it is anchored to the mineral substrate.

Which metal should be used to replace a gutter located below a copper roof covering?

A gutter located below copper must be fabricated in copper or austenitic stainless steel. Zinc, pre-patinated zinc and lacquered aluminium are strictly prohibited downstream of copper, as they would suffer rapid galvanic attack destroying the rainwater drainage component.

Do treated roof-structure timbers pose a danger to aluminium sheets?

Yes. Timber preservatives often contain copper salts or active metallic substances. Under the action of condensation or water infiltration, these salts migrate to the aluminium sheet and trigger irreversible pitting corrosion. A watertight decoupling strip is essential between the timber and the metal.

Texts and standards cited

  • Code des obligations art. 365material and ground: immediate notice to the client if the material or the ground is defective

In the same section