Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 274Anchors and fixings in concreteChapter 1 of 10 in the section

Cracked concrete: the approved anchor for this case, and why concrete is always cracked

In building metalwork, anchoring a railing base plate or a stair landing to a slab requires knowing how the substrate actually behaves. This chapter teaches you to identify tension zones, to decipher European Technical Assessments and to select certified anchors that keep their permissible load despite the opening of cracks in the concrete.

Key takeaways

  • Concrete in the tension zone undergoes inherent microcracking that greatly reduces the bond of fixings.
  • An anchor designed for non-cracked concrete loses about half of its mechanical resistance.
  • The European Technical Assessment explicitly states the suitability of a metal or chemical fixing in a cracked zone.
  • The metalworker working on a balcony or cantilever must systematically install anchors approved for cracked concrete.

Natural cracking of the tension zone at the slab edge

In light metalwork and locksmith work, most fixings are installed at the periphery of the structure: balcony nosings, slab heads, terraces or landings. Reinforced concrete works according to a fundamental structural principle: the steel reinforcement takes the tensile forces while the concrete matrix takes the compression. As soon as an element deflects under its own weight or under service loads, its tension side inevitably develops microcracks. These openings, commonly between one tenth and three tenths of a millimetre, are normal for the structure but radically change the behaviour of point anchors.

Tension zone of concrete
Part of a reinforced concrete element subjected to tensile stresses under the effect of loads. Unlike the compression zone, it contains discontinuities in the material that prevent clamping by simple passive friction.

A cantilevered balcony perfectly illustrates this situation. The cantilever rests on the façade and its upper face is put in tension by gravity. The surface where the metalworker installs the upper base plates of the railings is therefore right in the tension zone. Even if no crack is visible to the naked eye during drilling, the concrete will open under future climatic and mechanical stresses. If the drilled hole crosses the axis of an incipient crack, the wedging force exerted by a standard fixing disappears almost instantly.

Assuming that a substrate is non-cracked is a frequent error of judgement on construction sites. For a civil engineer, concrete is only classed as non-cracked in very rare configurations, such as massive raft slabs or columns working exclusively in pure compression. As soon as a rail, a cross-member or a metal post transmits an overturning moment to the ground, the metalworker must assume as an absolute rule that the anchor is working in a cracked substrate.

The ETA approval and the guarantee of permissible load

To certify that an anchor will withstand the cyclic opening of a crack without slipping, manufacturers submit their products to a European Technical Assessment, abbreviated ETA. This official document sets the real performance of the stud or chemical resin after rigorous tests simulating the opening of the concrete under load. A mechanical anchor approved for cracked concrete incorporates a specific follow-up expansion mechanism: when the crack opens, the inner cone penetrates further into the expansion sleeve under the tension of the connection, restoring the pressure against the walls of the hole.

Behaviour of anchor families according to the condition of the concrete
Anchoring technologyCracked concrete approvalHolding mechanismBehaviour in the crack
Standard expansion studNoFriction through simple tighteningSlips as soon as the crack opens
Follow-up expansion studYesAutomatic expansion under loadThe cone re-engages and compensates for the opening
Special concrete screwYes (according to ETA)Thread cut into the matrixDeep interlock resistant to movement
Qualified chemical anchorYes (according to ETA)Bond and form-fit lockingResin formulated to fill and follow the microcrack

The permissible load of an anchor depends directly on its approval status. Resistance tables systematically give two distinct values for the same diameter and the same embedment depth: tension in non-cracked concrete and tension in cracked concrete. The latter is significantly lower, often reduced by a third to a half. If a metalworker sizes railing posts with non-cracked concrete values while the actual structure cracks, the overall safety factor collapses, exposing users to a risk of overturning under crowd pressure.

During on-site installation, compliance with the installation procedure guarantees the effectiveness of the approval. Insufficient dust removal by blowing and brushing prevents friction of the expansion cone or destroys the chemical bond. Likewise, the use of a calibrated torque wrench is mandatory to apply the exact torque: under-tightening leaves the stud passive, while over-tightening destroys the concrete threads already weakened by the natural microcracks of the floor.

Criteria for selecting an anchoring system for a tension zone

On a metalwork construction site, the temptation is frequent to standardise fixings in the workshop to reduce the stock of consumables in the van. Installing an entry-level standard stud on a railing base plate mounted on the outside nevertheless constitutes a serious non-conformity as soon as the concrete works in tension. The product designation on the technical data sheet must explicitly mention a European Technical Assessment (ETA) covering cracked concrete, formerly designated as Option 1 of the ETAG guidelines or under the use categories according to the current European assessment documents.

The physical phenomenon is implacable: when a balcony slab deflects under its own weight and service loads, the upper edge and the slab nosing undergo tensile stresses. The concrete opens in the form of microcracks imperceptible to the naked eye, often 0.2 to 0.3 mm wide. A mechanical anchor designed only for non-cracked concrete bases its anchorage on constant radial pressure against the walls of the drilled hole. As soon as the crack crosses the hole, the tight contact disappears: the expansion cone relaxes, the anchor slides outwards and pull-out failure occurs at a tensile value far below the nominal load.

Residual expansion under displacement
Ability of a specific stud or sleeve to compensate for the progressive opening of a crack in the concrete substrate. When the metal is put in tension, the inner cone penetrates deeper into the expansion sleeve, restoring the contact pressure against the concrete without catastrophic slipping.

For the metalworker, three main families have references certified for cracked concrete: the high-performance torque-controlled expansion stud, the concrete screw with reinforced self-tapping thread, and the anchor rod set with injection resin certified for tension zones. Each responds to distinct geometric configurations at the slab edge.

Installing approved anchors and reducing permissible loads

Choosing an anchor approved for cracked concrete does not remove the need to adapt spacings and edge distances. The European Technical Assessment sets strict limit values. For the same anchor, the permissible load in pure tension in cracked concrete is systematically 30 to 45 % lower than for the same fixing installed in a compressed, non-cracked block. The installer must read the line corresponding to the actual concrete class of the construction site, generally C25/30 or C30/37 on recent structures in French-speaking Switzerland.

Behaviour of the anchor families common in light metalwork according to the approval case
Anchor familyMechanism in cracked concreteInstallation sensitivityTypical use in locksmith work
Anchor stud with ETA for cracked concreteRe-expansion of the cone under load when the crack opensMandatory control of the prescribed tightening torque with a torque wrenchRailing base plates installed on top of the balcony slab
Special concrete screw with ETA for cracked concreteForm-fit locking through the helical thread cut into the concreteCareful cleaning of the hole; direct screwing without excess torqueFixing at the slab nosing, narrow base plates, wall-mounted handrails
High-performance chemical anchor (epoxy or vinyl ester resin)Bond combined with a specific profiled rod for tension zonesBrushing and blowing according to the ETA procedure; curing timeTaking up heavy wind loads on glass barriers or open-work posts
  1. Record the geometric configuration of the base plateMeasure precisely the thickness of the metal element to be fixed and the actual distance between the drilling axis and the free edge of the concrete. A reduced slab edge often requires switching from a mechanical stud to a concrete screw or a resin to avoid early spalling of the concrete under expansion stress.
  2. Drill and remove all drilling dustUse a hammer drill fitted with an unworn carbide bit within the tolerance gauge. Carry out the prescribed cycles of blowing with a hand pump or compressed air and of brushing with a calibrated wire brush. Residual dust coating the wall prevents the expansion sleeve from working properly or blocks the thread cutting of the screw.
  3. Tighten to the torque prescribed by the manufacturerApply the exact installation torque using a calibrated torque wrench. Under-tightening prevents the onset of the expansion required to compensate for a crack; excessive tightening with an impact wrench destroys the thread or pulls the cone out of the hole before any loading.

Handling installation contingencies and reworking non-conforming anchors

On a construction site for railing installation or light metalwork, anchor incidents in tension zones occur mainly in three forms: the anchor spins freely without ever reaching its nominal tightening torque, the drilling meets a main reinforcing bar, or the concrete spalls under expansion stress at the free edge of the slab. In these critical situations, trying to force the tightening or to elongate the base plate holes with a grinder is a serious technical error. A metal or chemical anchor that does not reach its specified torque reveals insufficient dust removal, a hole drilled outside tolerance or the opening of a live crack. Under no circumstances will the element guarantee the permissible load stipulated in its ETA.

  1. Condemning the defective drill holeAny mechanical fixing that refuses to lock at the prescribed torque must be dismantled or ground flush with the substrate. Trying to inject repair grout or insert metal shims into a failed hole is pointless, as no certified holding capacity can result from it.
  2. Offsetting the position of the new holeThe new fixing hole must respect an offset distance at least equal to the effective embedment depth from the abandoned hole. This spacing ensures the independence of the failure cones in the mass of cracked concrete and prevents local collapse of the compression zone.
  3. Making an adapter plateIf the centre-to-centre distance of the original base plate does not tolerate this geometric offset, the metalworker must make in the workshop a wider load-distribution plate with offset holes, submitted to the site management for approval.

Faced with a damaged substrate, edge spalling or unforeseen dense reinforcement, the metalworker records the findings in the daily installation report. In accordance with the provisions of standard SIA 118, a written notice informs the site management of these facts so that it can decide on the method of repair. Any substitute anchor selected must imperatively have a valid ETA approval for cracked concrete in order to ensure the stability of the light structures.

Frequently asked questions

Why is a balcony slab considered cracked on its upper face?

The upper face of a cantilevered balcony works constantly in tension under the effect of self-weight and service loads. Since concrete has low tensile strength, microcracks inevitably open in this zone to mobilise the steel reinforcement. Even if invisible to the naked eye at installation, these cracks widen under the effect of temperature variations and wind loads, reducing the bond of a non-certified anchor.

What is the difference between an option 1 and an option 7 anchor according to the ETA?

The European Technical Assessment ETA historically classified anchors into several approval options. An anchor with option 1 approval was tested and approved for use in cracked and non-cracked concrete, guaranteeing its holding capacity as cracks open. Conversely, an anchor classified as option 7 is reserved exclusively for non-cracked concrete. Installing it on top of a balcony causes its resistance to drop by at least half.

Can a standard mechanical stud be installed in the fixing zone of a railing?

No, a standard mechanical anchor stud without approval for cracked concrete presents a high risk of slipping or premature pull-out. When a crack crosses the drill hole, friction grip disappears and the expansion sleeve loses its seating. To fix a railing to the face or on top of a slab, the metalworker must install specific expansion studs or concrete screws with an ETA validated for tension zones with crack opening.

What should be done if the edge reinforcement prevents the embedment depth from being respected?

Reinforcing bars must never be cut when drilling. The first solution is to use concrete screws approved for cracked concrete, whose required embedment depth is often shorter than that of expansion studs. The second solution relies on a chemical anchor with threaded rod, calculated for a reduced depth permitted by its ETA, or on modifying the base plate in the workshop to shift the fixing points.

Texts and standards cited

  • norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work

In the same section