Key takeaways
- The horizontal push prescribed by SIA 358 determines the line load on the handrail.
- The spacing between posts multiplies the point load and directly governs the bending moment at the foot of the post.
- The maximum bending moment is concentrated at the fixed base, the critical failure point of metal railings.
- The wall thickness of the profile prevents local buckling under extreme tensile and compressive stresses.
Transmission of the horizontal push and calculation of the bending moment at the base
In building metalwork (CFC 274), the stability of a railing rests on a simple but unforgiving mechanical principle: every horizontal force applied to the top rail is fully converted into a bending moment concentrated at the very base of the post. SIA 358 sets the horizontal imposed loads to be taken into account according to the use of the premises, generally ranging from zero point eight kilonewtons per linear metre for individual housing to more than three kilonewtons per linear metre in areas open to the public or with large gatherings. This load transfer depends closely on the distance between two consecutive posts.
- Post spacing
- Axial distance measured between two consecutive load-bearing posts of a railing, which determines the width of the tributary area collecting the horizontal push transmitted to each base.
The spacing of the posts is not a mere aesthetic choice or a convenience of workshop layout. Each post takes half a bay on either side of its axis. For a line load q defined by SIA 358 and a spacing e between posts, the point horizontal force F taken at the head of the post is given by the relation F equals q multiplied by e. Excessive spacing concentrates a considerable push on a single vertical element. Going from a spacing of one metre to a spacing of one metre twenty immediately increases the transverse load by twenty per cent, overloading the fixing and the shaft of the post.
The base moment is calculated by treating the post as a vertical cantilever beam fixed at its base and free at its head. The height h represents the lever arm, measured from the fixing plane of the base plate or the embedded socket to the axis of application of the load on the handrail, usually between one metre and one metre ten. The bending moment at the base M is calculated as the product of the point force F and the height h, which corresponds to the formula M equals q multiplied by e multiplied by h. On a residential balcony with a load of one kilonewton per metre, a spacing of one metre twenty and a height of one metre ten, the bending moment reaches one point thirty-two kilonewton-metres at the base weld.
Choice of section and profile thickness with regard to the risk of pull-out
It is invariably at the foot of the post that railings fail during strength tests or real incidents. The failure modes observed on construction sites are consistent: yielding of the steel when the elastic limit is exceeded at the base plate junction, tearing of the material along the weld bead, or local buckling of the compressed face of a tubular profile that is too thin. To keep these stresses below the permissible limit of the metal, the metalworker must select a sufficient elastic section modulus Wel in the plane perpendicular to the railing.
| Profile section (mm) | Thickness (mm) | Modulus Wel (cm³) | Indicative maximum spacing (m) | Base sensitivity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Square tube 40x40 | 2.0 | 3.5 | 0.70 | High (risk of buckling) |
| Square tube 50x50 | 3.0 | 8.5 | 1.20 | Low (good balance) |
| Flat bar 50x12 | 12.0 | 5.0 | 0.80 | Medium (visible flexibility) |
| Flat bar 60x15 | 15.0 | 9.0 | 1.30 | Very low (high stiffness) |
| Round tube 42.4 | 2.6 | 3.0 | 0.65 | High (plastic deformation) |
Wall thickness is the decisive variable, all too often sacrificed for reasons of procurement cost. A forty-millimetre square tube with a thickness of one point five millimetres has an attractive theoretical moment of inertia, but its compressed wall risks local buckling well before the overall force reaches the calculated elastic limit. In light metalwork complying with Swiss good practice, a minimum thickness of three millimetres for hollow steel profiles is required as soon as the spacing exceeds one metre. For solid profiles, such as flat bars mounted on edge, the thickness must prevent lateral buckling under bending.
- Defining the usage categoryIdentify the horizontal imposed load according to SIA 358 depending on whether the area is publicly or privately accessible.
- Setting the geometric spacingMeasure the bay lengths and lay out the posts with a regular spacing generally between eight hundred and twelve hundred millimetres.
- Calculating the fixed-base momentMultiply the push by the spacing and by the height of the top rail to obtain the moment acting at floor level.
- Checking the section modulusCheck that the calculated maximum stress does not exceed the elastic limit of the selected steel, with the required safety margin.
Relationship between spacing, SIA push and loading on the post
In building metalwork, the spacing between posts directly governs the shear force and bending moment transmitted to each anchor point. According to SIA 358, combined with the load assumptions of SIA 261, the horizontal imposed push is applied to the handrail, generally at one metre above finished floor level. For a line load of 0.8 kN/m in multi-family housing or 1.6 kN/m in places of assembly, each post takes the load corresponding to its tributary width. Increasing the spacing increases the push at the head proportionally and accentuates overturning at the slab.
The base moment results from the product of the horizontal force taken and the lever arm to the anchor point. With a spacing of 1.00 m and a load of 0.8 kN/m at a height of 1.00 m, the unfactored nominal moment reaches 0.80 kNm. At the ultimate limit states, the factored value exceeds 1.10 kNm. If the handrail reaches 1.10 m or if the post runs down along a slab edge for a side-fixed installation with a 150 mm bracket, the free height reaches 1.25 m. The base moment then exceeds 1.50 kNm, which rules out thin tubes.
| Spacing | Force taken | Base moment | Indicative profile | Minimum thickness |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.80 m | 0.64 kN | 0.64 kNm | Square tube 40x40 | 3.0 mm |
| 1.00 m | 0.80 kN | 0.80 kNm | Square tube 50x50 or flat bar 60x12 | 3.2 mm / 12 mm |
| 1.20 m | 0.96 kN | 0.96 kNm | Rectangular tube 60x40 | 4.0 mm |
| 1.50 m | 1.20 kN | 1.20 kNm | Rectangular tube 80x40 or flat bar 70x15 | 4.0 mm / 15 mm |
Fixed base and mechanical transmission to the structural work
The fixity at the base is the critical point of the railing. A post rarely fails at mid-height: it deforms or breaks right at its fixing plate. Whether installed on top of the slab or fixed to its side, the base plate undergoes severe bending generated by the overturning couple. If its stiffness is insufficient, the plate bends, distorts the alignment of the anchor bolts and creates a parasitic prying effect that pulls the anchors out of the concrete. The stiffness of the base directly determines the effectiveness of the post.
- Stiffness of the base plateUse a steel plate at least 10 to 15 mm thick to neutralise any deformation of the plate itself under the tension line of the anchors and to ensure a uniform distribution of stresses into the concrete.
- Execution of the fillet weldBevel thick walls and lay a continuous bead around the entire perimeter of the post, with a sufficient throat and without edge undercut in the tension zone.
- Spacing of the drilled holesProvide a sufficient distance between the axis of the post and the fixings so as to obtain an effective internal lever arm, while keeping the prescribed edge distances in the slab for the anchors.
- Shimming and bedding under the plateAvoid isolated shims that leave a void under the metal; fill the bedding space with a non-shrink grout to eliminate any secondary bending of the studs.
Side mounting against the slab edge has a major mechanical advantage over installation on top of the slab. By spacing the anchor points vertically by 120 to 200 mm on a reinforced bracket, the internal lever arm between the compressed anchor and the tensioned anchor increases significantly, which reduces the pull-out force on the concrete in proportion. Whichever system is chosen, the metalworker coordinates the spacing between posts, the moment of inertia of the profile and the method of anchoring to form a uniform chain of resistance from the infill to the load-bearing structure.
Failure at the foot of a post: emergency diagnosis and corrective measures
During push tests or acceptance on the construction site, a residual deformation, an anchor pull-out or a sharp crack signals a break in the load path. It is invariably at the base of the post that mechanical failure begins: the bending moment concentrates there the entire overturning couple. Faced with a post that bends under the load required by SIA 358, the metalworker must immediately secure the edge zone to prevent any fall into the void, then carry out a methodical diagnosis without concealing the defect.
- Yielding of the profile wall: the tube crushes or wrinkles just above the weld bead. This reveals insufficient steel thickness for the base moment. The correction requires internal sleeving with a solid steel insert welded through, or the outright replacement of the post with a profile of greater section and moment of inertia.
- Excessive bending of the base plate: a plate that is too thin acts as a lever (prying effect) and multiplies the pull-out on the fixings. Fitting a triangular stiffener or welding side gussets stiffens the fixed base and reduces local bending of the base.
- Detachment of the concrete anchorage: a cone-shaped break-out of the concrete indicates an insufficient edge distance or an overestimated lever arm. If the substrate allows, the metalworker moves the fixing axis back or modifies the plate for anchoring into the face of the parapet using approved chemical resin.
- Disproportionate post spacing: when the handrail deflects too much and overloads the neighbouring post, adding an intermediate post halves the horizontal push taken by each post, bringing the bending moment back within the elastic limit of the original profile.
Frequently asked questions
How should the base moment be recalculated if the architect raises the railing height to 110 cm?
The bending moment equals the product of the horizontal push and the vertical lever arm. For a height raised to 110 cm and a line load from SIA 358 distributed over a spacing of 1.20 m, the lever arm increases by 10%. This increase requires recalculating the necessary section modulus of the post, which generally means increasing the tube thickness from 3 mm to 4 mm or enlarging its section.
Can a tubular profile that is too thin be compensated by filling it with poured concrete?
No, this empirical method is prohibited in building metalwork. Unreinforced concrete poured into a hollow tube provides no reliable bond and does not significantly improve bending resistance at the fixed-base zone. Moreover, residual water trapped in the shaft promotes internal corrosion of the post. Only the insertion of a solid steel sleeve, fitted and mechanically welded at the base, restores the required section modulus.
Why prefer a side fixing to an installation on top of the slab?
Installation against the slab edge increases the overall lever arm but removes the problem of penetrating the floor waterproofing. At the foot of the post, the pull-out forces are taken by a pair of anchors working mainly in shear and pure tension over an extended plate height. This avoids weakening the upper edge of the concrete slab with vertical drilling too close to the edge.
From what post spacing must the top rail be split?
The post spacing alone does not dictate the splitting, but the thermal expansion of the handrail requires a sliding sleeve every 6 to 8 linear metres. Between posts, if the spacing exceeds 1.50 m, the horizontal push concentrated at the foot of each post increases considerably according to SIA 358. Reducing the spacing to between 1.00 m and 1.20 m remains technically more economical than oversizing all the posts.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 358Railings: geometry requirements, useful heights, imposed loads and fall protection
- code des obligationsGeneral rules of the contract for work, notice of defects in the work and the contractor's obligations
