Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 274Metal stairs and handrailsChapter 2 of 10 in the section

The vibrating staircase: natural frequency, a stringer that is too flexible and remedial measures

A steel staircase can satisfy all mechanical strength requirements and still sway unpleasantly under users' footsteps. By the end of this chapter, you will be able to identify the dynamic origin of these vibrations, measure the influence of the span and implement three workshop or on-site remedial measures to stiffen the structure permanently.

Key takeaways

  • Resonance occurs when the human stride matches the natural frequency of the structure.
  • A verified static calculation never guarantees the absence of bounce or dynamic discomfort.
  • The SIA 358 standard requires a level of user comfort that excludes any feeling of insecurity when using the staircase.
  • Three solutions exist after the fact: an intermediate support, boxing-in of the stringer and coupling of the guardrail.

Understanding the oscillation phenomenon between the human stride and the stiffness of the stringer

On a finishing-work construction site, the finding is a classic one: a straight steel staircase shows no permanent deformation and its anchorages withstand the prescribed loads, yet every passage produces an unpleasant spring effect. This oscillating behaviour immediately causes apprehension in the user. In building metalwork, a structure designed for the ultimate limit state and compliant with static deflection criteria can nevertheless fail the test of everyday walking if its dynamic response was neglected during the execution phase.

Natural frequency
The natural rate of free oscillation of an undamped steel structure, expressed in hertz (Hz). It depends directly on the ratio between the flexural stiffness of the structure and its carried mass.

The cadence of a pedestrian going up or down stairs generally lies between 1.4 Hz and 2.4 Hz, i.e. roughly one to two steps per second. Each heel strike produces a periodic vertical force accompanied by higher-order harmonics reaching 3 to 5 Hz. When the stringer has a fundamental natural frequency within this critical range, resonance amplifies the amplitude of the movement with each consecutive step. Even if the residual stresses remain far below the yield strength of the steel, the user perceives an unacceptable sensation of instability.

Guardrails and access elements must ensure operational safety and provide a sufficient feeling of security to avoid panic or vertigo reactions in users.

norme SIA 358

The primary cause of this excessive flexibility lies in the ratio between the stringer's moment of inertia and its free span. A stringer made of a simple cut flat bar or a slender U-section suffers a drastic loss of stiffness as soon as the length spanned exceeds three to four metres without intermediate support. Vertical inertia plays the leading role, but the lack of torsional stiffness also favours combined deformation modes in which the treads tilt sideways, further disturbing the walker's trajectory.

Dynamic behaviour of steel stringers according to their geometric profile
Type of stringerTorsional stiffnessVibration sensitivityPreventive action in the workshop
Simple steel flat bar (thickness 10 to 15 mm)Very lowCritical from 3 m spanProhibit thin flat bars without bracing
Open rolled section (UPN or UPE)Low to moderateMedium with rigid treadsConnect the risers rigidly
Hollow rectangular tube or boxed sectionExcellentLow over a standard spanFavour closed sections for long spans

Three proven technical methods to stabilise a flexible stringer after installation

When a lightweight steel staircase vibrates after its final installation, complete dismantling is economically and technically unthinkable. The metalworker must then intervene on site to modify the dynamics of the flight. The objective is always to raise the natural frequency above the threshold of human sensitivity by increasing the overall stiffness, reducing the active span or dissipating the kinetic energy.

  1. Solution 1: Create an intermediate supportInstalling a tubular post under the stringer at mid-span is the most direct response. By halving the span, the fundamental natural frequency is multiplied by a factor of about four. If floor space constraints rule out a load-bearing post, the alternative is to hang the landing or the central stringer from the concrete slab above using a solid steel cylindrical tie rod fixed by through-anchoring.
  2. Solution 2: Rebuild a boxed section with a stiffenerTo preserve the existing outline without adding a support column, the section of the existing stringer is reinforced. The method consists of welding or bolting a continuous flat bar to the underside, or closing the hollow of a UPE with a closing plate 4 to 6 mm thick. This boxing-in blocks torsion and multiplies the vertical moment of inertia without excessively increasing the dead weight.
  3. Solution 3: Structurally couple the handrail and the treadsTurning the guardrail into a participating truss girder radically changes the vibrational behaviour. The tubular top rail is made integral with the stringers by reinforced posts welded or bolted with thick backing plates. The handrail then acts as a compressed top chord, giving the whole flight a multiplied structural depth.

The choice of remedial measure depends on operating constraints and on the appearance agreed with site management. In administrative renovations or villas where the space beneath remains free for circulation, boxing-in under the stringer and mechanical coupling of the balustrade remain the two most discreet approaches. After on-site reinforcement welding, it is the metalworker's responsibility to carefully clean the weld beads and apply anti-rust touch-up paint compatible with the workshop finishes.

On-site implementation of reinforcements: intermediate supports and stringer stiffeners

When a straight or quarter-turn steel staircase shows excessive flexibility after assembly, the metalworker works within a constrained geometric framework. The stringer, generally made of a rolled UPE section, a rectangular tube or a thick flat bar, deflects dynamically under the alternating impact of walking. The objective on the construction site is not to take up a failure load already covered by the static calculation note, but to block the oscillation amplitude by shifting the vibration antinodes.

Comparison of post-installation reinforcement measures according to stringer type
Reinforcement techniqueImplementation on the construction siteImpact on frequencyArchitectural constraint
Intermediate tubular postBase plate welded under the stringer and anchored into the concrete floorDoubles the overall stiffness, eliminates the first modeFloor space taken up beneath the flight
Longitudinal stiffener under the flangeIntermittent weld of a flat bar or T-section under the profileIncrease in vertical inertia of 30% to 50%Change to the visual depth of the stringer
Tie rod hung from the underside of the slabHigh fixing to the concrete slab and tensioning sleeveRaises the frequency beyond the walking rangeVisible cable or solid round bar in the stairwell opening
Connection to the guardrailStructural bolting of the posts to the stringer flangeParticipating box effect according to SIA 358Low if the infill is pure laminated glass

Installing an intermediate post is the most radical remedy: halving the free span of the stringer divides its theoretical deflection by eight and significantly increases its natural frequency. If the clearance under the staircase must remain completely free for a passage or a fit-out, added stiffeners become necessary. Welding a continuous steel flat bar or an inverted L-angle to the underside of the stringer makes it possible to rebuild a section with a high moment of inertia. The welder alternates the weld runs to limit the thermal shrinkage that would distort the straight alignment of the treads.

Dynamic check, comfort thresholds and acceptance of the work

The standard cadence of human walking lies between 1.5 Hz and 2.5 Hz, i.e. between one and a half and two and a half steps per second. Each stride also generates secondary load harmonics between 3.0 Hz and 5.0 Hz. If the natural frequency of a steel staircase flight falls below this critical threshold of 5 Hz, the structure goes into resonance when an ordinary user passes. Even if the steel works far below its elastic limit and the mechanical strength is beyond doubt, the perceived pumping movement creates a serious sense of insecurity for the user.

  1. Empirical measurement on siteCarry out a jump or sharp impact test at the centre of the flight, instrumented with a portable accelerometer, in order to plot the damping and identify the dominant frequency of the stringer.
  2. Calculation of the residual dynamic deflectionCheck the instantaneous deformation under the passage of a person of standard build; the measured vertical amplitude should not exceed one millimetre in order to guarantee psycho-physiological comfort.
  3. Adjustment of the end connectionsCheck that there is no play in the arrival and departure base plates. A support that rocks by a few tenths of a millimetre on its anchors turns a fixed-end stringer into a simply supported one and immediately lowers its natural frequency.
  4. Joint inspection record at acceptanceDraw up the record with site management and the client, confirming the absence of perceptible resonance and functional compliance in accordance with the recognised rules of the trade under the Code of Obligations (CO).

In building metalwork, a successful acceptance does not boil down to proving that a stringer carries the imposed load without breaking. As soon as vibration disturbs the grip on a guardrail or makes an adjacent glass element oscillate, the work suffers an immediate loss of usability. Anticipating the maximum unsupported span in the workshop drawings makes it possible to size the web depth of the stringer with vibrational comfort in mind, thus avoiding remedial work after powder-coated finishing, which is often costly and complex to carry out.

Handling disagreements and remedial protocol in a vibration dispute

When a client or site management refuses acceptance of a steel staircase on the grounds of a feeling of insecurity caused by oscillations, the steel contractor or metalworker faces a delicate balancing act. Very often the structure scrupulously meets the mechanical strength requirements for service loads and the guardrail fulfils all the geometric safety criteria prescribed by the SIA 358 standard. Yet the residual flexibility of the stringers produces an elastic behaviour judged unacceptable by the user: the natural frequency of the flight then coincides with the rhythm of human walking, creating a resonance that is perceptible at every stride.

To resolve the dispute without getting bogged down in sterile argument under the Code of Obligations (CO), the person in charge of the works organises a joint inspection record with the contractor's representative. Measuring the oscillation frequency and the displacement amplitude at mid-span makes it possible to objectify the dynamic behaviour under real walking loads. Once the nuisance is established, the metalwork company submits a costed technical proposal to stabilise the work permanently.

  • Propose a stiffening arrangement suited to the spatial constraints: grouting in an intermediate column, mechanically fixing a continuous stiffener flat bar under the existing profile to increase the bending inertia, or incorporating rigid connections to a load-bearing partition.
  • Formalise a contractual addendum clarifying responsibilities and the allocation of costs, depending on whether or not the original specifications prescribed particular dynamic requirements.
  • Install the stiffeners under slight preloading to eliminate play tolerances, then carry out the powder-coating or anti-corrosion paint touch-ups to the recognised rules of the trade so that the intervention is invisible.

Frequently asked questions

Why does a steel staircase vibrate even though it carries the test loads perfectly?

Load-bearing capacity is a matter of ultimate mechanical strength, whereas vibration concerns the serviceability limit state and structural dynamics. A stringer made of folded sheet or hollow section can carry the regulatory weight without failing and still lack inertia against the human step. As soon as the natural frequency of the staircase drops below the five-hertz threshold, the rhythmic stride goes into resonance with the structure, generating amplitudes perceived as uncomfortable.

Does the SIA 358 standard set natural frequency criteria for steel staircases?

The SIA 358 standard deals with the safety of guardrails and railings, imposing protection heights and strict geometries to prevent falls. It does not directly define a threshold value for the vibration frequency of staircase stringers. Aspects of dynamics and limiting deflection under moving loads refer to the general standards for steel structures. However, excessive vibration can compromise the fixing of the rails and unsettle the user.

Which stiffening solution should be preferred when a floor-standing post is refused on architectural grounds?

If the architect rejects an intermediate vertical support on the floor, the solution is to increase the moment of inertia of the existing stringer. The tradesperson welds or bolts a thick flat bar or a U-section under the bottom chord. An effective alternative is to anchor the stringer transversely against a solid reinforced concrete wall using rigid concealed brackets, which blocks the torsion mode and drastically reduces the free vibrating span.

How do you achieve a clean paint touch-up after welding a stiffener on site?

After on-site welding, the heat-affected zone must be thoroughly cleaned by careful grinding and mechanical brushing to remove mill scale and spatter. The metalworker applies a high-zinc anti-corrosion bonding primer compatible with the original coating. The finish is applied with a lacquer roller or by sprayed touch-up in a colour-matched shade from the exact RAL chart, feathering the repair to blur the visual demarcation on the stringer.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 358Guardrail - Constructional and dimensional provisions for user safety

In the same section