Key takeaways
- Refusal of the occupancy permit blocks handover of the building because of non-compliance with safety rules.
- SIA 358 prohibits horizontal elements that facilitate climbing in areas accessible to children.
- Fitting a laminated glass screen neutralises the ladder effect without replacing the entire metal framework.
- The locksmith shares the financial burden with site management depending on how the duty to notify was exercised.
Municipal finding of ladder effect and technical compliance by glass screen
During the final inspection before the occupancy permit is issued, the municipal building control delegate systematically checks the balustrades of balconies and terraces. The most common textbook case concerns balustrades made of bars or horizontal rails creating a ladder effect. If the original design allows a young child to use the cross-rails as footholds to climb, the authority strictly applies SIA 358 and refuses the occupancy permit until the risk of falling is eliminated. The building then cannot be put into service, which puts immediate pressure on the firms to correct the work a few days before the keys are handed over.
- Ladder effect
- Arrangement of horizontal or inclined structural elements spaced so as to provide successive footholds or handholds, allowing a young child to climb a balustrade.
To neutralise this effect without having to cut off the posts or redo the anchor plates fixed to the finished slabs, the rescue solution is to double the bar infill with a continuous screen on the inside. The locksmith installs a rigid, smooth, vertical infill screen. Laminated safety glass made of two sheets of heat-strengthened or toughened glass with a polyvinyl butyral interlayer meets both the mechanical and aesthetic requirements. The screen must cover all horizontal rails located in the critical zone so as to prevent any footing up to the height required by the safety guidelines.
| Component | Technical specification | Safety objective under SIA 358 |
|---|---|---|
| Type of glazing | Laminated safety glass (VSG) | Residual retention and no sharp fragments on impact |
| Mechanical fixing | Stainless steel glass clamps with safety pin | Prevent the pane from slipping under horizontal thrust |
| Position | Inner face (balcony side) | Remove access to the rails serving as footholds |
| Perimeter gaps | Bottom gap of less than 20 mm | Prevent the passage of a test wedge or a child's foot |
Contractual responsibilities, duty to notify and allocation of remedial costs
The urgent intervention immediately raises the question of who bears the cost. Replacing or adapting a complete set of balustrades causes unforeseen costs for glass supply, machining of adapter brackets and installation labour. The burden depends directly on the application of SIA 118 and on the obligations of the Code of Obligations (CO) relating to the contract for work. Three situations generally arise on the construction site when settling the remediation invoice.
- Analysis of the original execution drawingsThe locksmith examines whether the horizontal bar infill appeared expressly in the tender drawings and in the architect's drawings approved with the note "approved for execution". If the architect drew a prohibited configuration while ignoring warnings, his professional liability is engaged.
- Checking the written duty to notifyThe contractor checks whether he formalised in writing his duty to notify site management before fabrication. The Code of Obligations (CO) requires the tradesperson to warn the client if he finds that the instructions received lead to work that does not comply with the rules of the art or with building regulations.
- Drawing up the financial settlement agreementWhere a formal notice has been recorded in writing, site management or its insurer bears the entire additional cost of the glass screen. Where the locksmith gave no warning, joint fault is found, resulting in a fair sharing of the expenses between the commissioned design office and the locksmith's workshop.
Operationally, the pricing of this remedial work must be covered by a daywork order or a clarified contractual addendum before the final intervention. The amounts committed for supplying the laminated glazing and urgent installation commonly run to several hundred francs per linear metre, not counting crane costs if the balconies are difficult to reach from the inside. For the precise preparation of bills of quantities and the daywork rates applicable to this type of catch-up work, refer to the specialised quote tools under /soumissions/.
Urgent installation of the glass screen on the existing bar structure
When the finding of non-compliance drawn up by the municipal building department blocks issue of the occupancy permit, the locksmith's intervention takes place under severe time pressure. Complete removal of the balustrade with horizontal rails is generally not feasible without damaging the waterproofing of the thresholds or the rendering of the surrounding facades. Fitting a solid screen on the balcony side is then the quickest and least invasive technical solution to permanently neutralise the ladder effect caused by the horizontal bars.
The modification consists of doubling the offending bar infill with laminated safety glass panels fixed on the usable, i.e. inner, face of the balcony. This arrangement prevents any footing on the intermediate metal rails. The panels are held by stainless steel glass clamps adapted to the vertical load-bearing posts. To avoid any risk of damaging thermal bridging or contact corrosion on a powder-coated steel structure, locksmiths must use synthetic spacer sleeves and EPDM elastomer gaskets.
| Component | Recommended specification | Critical check point | Consequence of a defect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Glass panel | Laminated safety glass (VSG) of suitable thickness | Matt ground edges, arrises eased in the workshop | Chipping under the clamps, spontaneous breakage from thermal shock |
| Clamps | A4 stainless steel with safety back pins | Tightening to the recommended torque with a torque wrench | Vertical slipping of the glazing towards the slab edge under vibration |
| Bearing gaskets | UV-resistant EPDM profiled seals | Total absence of direct steel-to-glass contact | Cracking of the panel under mechanical clamping |
| Fixing to the post | Self-tapping stainless screws or blind anchors with isolator | Tightening torque and thread sealing | Galvanic corrosion between stainless screw and carbon steel tube |
Lifting of reservations by the municipal authority and settlement of costs
Once installation of the protective screen is complete, site management must request an official re-inspection by the building control authority. To prove that the corrected work strictly meets the objectives of protection against falls, the metalworking firm submits a complete technical file. This document includes the certificate of origin of the laminated glazing, the data sheets of the approved clamps and a detail drawing showing the complete elimination of climbing footholds below the handrail.
- Joint inspection on the slabThe municipal inspector checks on site that there are no gaps larger than the SIA 358 gauges between the added glazing and the balcony slab, and that the smooth inner surface is continuous.
- Issue of the certificate of complianceThe local authority endorses the inspection report, lifts the suspensive reservation and validates the file for immediate granting of the occupancy permit by the municipality.
- Breakdown of intervention costsSite management, the locksmith and the client settle the financial account by separating the material added value brought to the building from the urgent additional costs attributable to the original design error.
Financially, the invoice for urgent compliance work cannot be passed in full to the metalwork contractor if the execution drawings supplied by the architect expressly prescribed the faulty horizontal bar infill. However, if the locksmith failed in his professional obligation to alert the designer to the obvious non-compliance of the drawing with SIA 358, he risks having to bear a substantial share of the cost of the conversion. Amicable settlement of the dispute commonly takes the form of a three-party agreement: the client funds the raw supply of the glass, which brings an aesthetic added value, while the architect and the locksmith share the added hardware, the remedial labour and the urgent coordination costs.
Crisis management and arbitration when the occupancy permit is blocked
Refusal of the occupancy permit by the municipal authority puts the construction site in a critical contractual and financial deadlock. When the building control authority finds that horizontal rails create a ladder effect contrary to the requirements of SIA 358, site management frequently seeks to pass the entire cost of corrective measures to the locksmith. Faced with a dispute over who bears the cost of a laminated glass screen fitted urgently, the firm must apply a rigorous method to unblock the technical situation without unduly bearing remedial costs.
- Formally record the authority's refusalDemand a written copy of the non-compliance report drawn up by the municipality. Simultaneously notify site management of a statement of the situation referencing the previously approved execution drawings.
- Submit the amended quote subject to reservationSubmit the technical offer for supply and installation of the laminated glazing with certified clamps, stating in writing that the order is placed as a protective measure to obtain the permit, without prejudice to the final settlement of responsibilities.
- Have the solution validated by the technical departmentSubmit the principle for fixing the laminated glass screen to the municipal inspector before installation on site, thus ensuring that the reservation is effectively lifted as soon as the intervention is complete.
- Isolate the disputed amountsIn accordance with the principles governing the contract for work in the Code of Obligations (CO) and the rules of SIA 118, isolate the remedial cost as a specific item in order to prevent any blocking of the balance of the original works.
In the event of persistent disagreement with the professional designer, the speed of execution of the metalwork avoids aggravation of the damage, in particular compensation owed for delays in tenants moving in. The final financial split between the designer who drew the non-compliant work and the locksmith bound by the duty to notify will be made at the final account, on the basis of the written exchanges and technical evidence from the construction site.
Frequently asked questions
Who bears the cost of the laminated glass if the architect's drawing provided for horizontal rails?
Financial responsibility is generally shared between the architect and the locksmith. The designer commits a fault by drawing work contrary to SIA 358. However, under the rules of the contract for work in the Code of Obligations (CO), the metalwork contractor has a professional duty to check the conformity of the drawings and to notify his principal in writing before fabrication. Failure to give this warning places part of the additional cost on him.
What type of laminated glass should be installed urgently to neutralise the ladder effect?
Laminated safety glazing is used, made of two sheets of glass joined by a polyvinyl butyral (PVB) interlayer. The thickness is determined by the panel area and wind loads, commonly a composition of two eight-millimetre sheets. The edges must be ground and polished. Fixing with mechanical metal clamps ensures the glass is held without creating new climbing points.
Can the municipality grant a provisional occupancy permit pending installation of the glazing?
This decision lies exclusively within the discretion of the municipal building control authority. The authority sometimes tolerates a temporary occupancy authorisation if a rigid temporary enclosure, such as a solid timber panel firmly bolted to the structure, neutralises any climbing risk. This exemption is always subject to a strict deadline for installing the final glass screen compliant with SIA 358 before the official re-inspection.
How can the glass clamps be fixed without destroying the anticorrosion treatment of the existing posts?
On-site drilling of powder-coated or galvanised metal posts must be done at reduced speed to avoid heating the paint. After careful deburring, immediately apply a zinc-rich touch-up primer to the bare steel. Always use stainless steel screws with synthetic bushes and washers providing dielectric insulation to prevent direct contact between dissimilar metals and the formation of galvanic corrosion.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 358Balustrades: dimensional characteristics and fall prevention
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction works
- code des obligationsRules applicable to the contract for work and liability for defects
