Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 274Balustrades: height, infill and complianceChapter 6 of 10 in the section

Non-compliant existing structures: upgrade obligation, triggering works and written notice

On an existing building, working on a dilapidated balustrade directly engages the metalworker. This chapter details the alteration thresholds that require compliance under standard SIA 358, the method for written notification to the client, and how to protect your civil or criminal liability in the event of a later accident.

Key takeaways

  • A simple one-off repair never exempts you from warning the owner about major geometric non-compliances.
  • Replacing base plates or balusters often triggers the formal obligation to meet current standards.
  • The reasoned written notice is the only exonerating proof under the requirements of the Swiss Code of Obligations (CO).
  • Recording the client's refusals allows the company to be cleared of criminal liability for negligence.

Identify the triggering works and the scope of standard SIA 358 on existing structures

In the Swiss building stock, many balustrades from before the 1990s have heights of 90 cm, horizontal rails forming a ladder, or gaps between upper balusters greater than 12 cm. As long as no work is undertaken, the owner benefits from a tolerance linked to the period of construction, subject to the general safety of the structure. However, as soon as the metalworker intervenes on the metal structure, this tolerance no longer protects the tradesperson who modifies or restores the structure without reservation.

A distinction must be made between preservation maintenance and substantial alteration. Retightening anchor bolts, locally treating surface rust or repairing a broken weld point fall under the metalworker's technical maintenance without changing the geometry of the structure. By contrast, complete replacement of the handrail, changing the posts, modifying the balusters or raising the finished floor level (such as installing thermal insulation on a roof terrace or tiles on pedestals) constitute triggering works.

Types of metalwork interventions and adaptation requirements
Nature of the metalwork interventionImpact on the existing guardrailTechnical requirement
One-off re-welding of a defective postStructure kept without change of shapeReinforcement permitted; duty to give written warning of existing dimensional defects
Complete replacement of the handrail or railsChange to the holding geometryObligation to adjust the total height to 100 cm under standard SIA 358
Raising of the floor by another trade (waterproofing, screed)Reduction of the remaining usable height below 100 cmMandatory raising of the metal balusters or full replacement
Replacement of solid panels with open balustersChange in the type of fall protectionStrict application of the 12 cm gauge and removal of any climbing support

If the finished exterior level is raised by several centimetres during a balcony renovation, the original balustrade becomes a deadly trap by losing its required height. The metalworker cannot simply carry out a blind order for paint or reinforcement without checking the remaining dimension between the top of the walkable floor and the top of the upper profile.

Drafting the written notice to the client and managing the legal risk

The contractor's silence is the most destructive trap in the event of an accident. Under the Code of Obligations (CO), the tradesperson bears a clear duty to inform and warn the client as soon as they identify an anomaly in the material supplied or in the safety of the structure entrusted to them. Quietly repairing a non-compliant guardrail amounts to tacitly validating its ability to hold people, in the eyes of its users.

  1. Dimensional survey and visual examination of non-compliancesMeasure the actual height from the walkable floor, check the gaps between posts with a 120 mm gauge and identify any elements that facilitate climbing before any pricing or dismantling.
  2. Formal wording of the notice of defects to the ownerSend a formal notice by registered letter or against a signed receipt, setting out precisely the deviations found from standard SIA 358 and the fall hazards involved.
  3. Proposal of technical compliance optionsSubmit a quote including the welded height extension, the addition of an offset handrail, the fitting of perforated backing sheets or the total replacement of the whole unit.
  4. Notification of the consequences of a refusal to upgradeIf the client refuses the safety works, require a countersigned written discharge or suspend work on the dangerous parts.

In a dispute following the failure of a guardrail that had recently been worked on, court-appointed experts examine whether the metalworker's work may have given occupants a false impression of safety. A freshly painted or reinforced guardrail that is still only 85 cm high with widely spaced horizontal rails misleads the user. The written notice must state unequivocally that the one-off repairs carried out do not cancel the original defects of geometric design.

Where the owner expressly refuses to bring the structure up to standard for financial or aesthetic reasons, the metalworker must have this refusal entered in the construction site minutes. In the event of obvious and imminent danger, such as completely corroded anchorages in crumbling concrete, the tradesperson must refuse to carry out the work and notify the client in writing that access to the balcony is prohibited.

Execution protocols and palliative adaptations when replacement is refused

On a renovation construction site, the metalworker frequently encounters the client's refusal to fully replace a dilapidated guardrail. The client often asks only for a reinforcing weld on a corroded post or the retightening of a loose fixing. Working on an isolated element without correcting the major geometric non-compliances prescribed by standard SIA 358 directly engages the professional. As soon as filler metal touches the structure or an anchor is replaced, the metalworker implicitly validates the overall mechanical strength of the element if they do not frame their action with a rigorous palliative technical solution.

If full replacement of the barrier is rejected for budgetary or heritage reasons, two technical interventions can correct the most critical risks without altering the façade: raising the rail and internal backing. The mechanical height extension is carried out by internal sleeving into the existing hollow posts or by welded brackets receiving an offset handrail in 42.4 mm round tube. To neutralise horizontal balusters that encourage climbing or vertical gaps larger than the permitted gauge, fixing a solid or micro-perforated screen on the inner side is the safest workshop solution.

Comparison of securing solutions on an existing metal guardrail
Existing configurationNon-compliance under standard SIA 358Corrective technical adaptationMechanical limit of the intervention
Historic riveted guardrail (height 85 cm)Insufficient protective heightAdded height extension using angles and a bolted tubular handrailIncreased lever arm on the existing slab fixings
Horizontal rails forming a ladderEasy climbing by young childrenInternal fitting of a perforated aluminium sheet (holes max. 10 mm) or laminated glassIncreased wind load requiring verification of post stiffness
Spacing between balusters of 140 mmRisk of a child's body passing throughInsertion of welded intermediate round bars or screwed flat sectionsLocal alteration of the original metallisation or powder coating
Floor base plate loosened by frostInsufficient resistance to horizontal thrustRemoval of mortar, offset drilling and core drilling for stainless steel chemical anchoringAdhesion dependent on the condition of the reinforced concrete slab edge

Documentary traceability and transfer of responsibilities after the intervention

The contractual handling of a defective guardrail rests on the strict application of the rules of the contract for work defined by the Code of Obligations (CO). The metalworker is bound by a duty of care and an unequivocal duty to warn. In the event of personal injury following a failure of the barrier, the courts examine the causal chain: if the tradesperson repaired a post without notifying that the height of 90 cm constituted a risk of crushing or tipping over, their civil liability, and even criminal liability under the Criminal Code (CP) for endangering others, may be pursued jointly with that of the owner of the structure.

  1. Initial joint inspection record with dimensional surveyMeasure the remaining height from the finished floor, the baluster spacing and the gap under the bottom rail. Take photographs of the anchorage points and record the deviations from the requirements of standard SIA 358 on the visit sheet.
  2. Drafting the remediation quote with variantsPrice the repair order requested by the client while necessarily presenting, as a separable variant, the full compliance upgrade of the guardrail, with express mention of the safety requirements.
  3. Written notification of refusal and discharge of liabilityIf the client maintains the request for a simple makeshift repair, notify the risks to users by registered letter and require the signing of an addendum confirming that the client assumes responsibility for keeping a non-compliant guardrail in place.
  4. Express reservations in the acceptance minutesAt completion of the works under standard SIA 118, state explicitly in the acceptance minutes that the intervention was limited to the mechanical repair ordered, without validating the overall compliance of the structure with the rules of the art.

Managing blockages: client refusal and the metalworker's disengagement

The owner's refusal to fund the upgrade of a dilapidated balustrade places the metalworker in a critical position. Where major renovation affects the structure of a balcony or changes the use of the premises, applying standard SIA 358 becomes mandatory. Faced with a client who demands a superficial repair without addressing the undersizing, the climbable balusters or a usable height below current requirements, the tradesperson must never repair in silence. Turning a blind eye to a dangerous guardrail directly engages the liability of the metal construction contractor in the event of a later fall.

  1. Immediate notification of the dangerAs soon as a critical deviation is spotted on the existing structure, record the precise dimensions and anchorage weaknesses. Send a letter of reservation to the client without delay, detailing the shortcomings against standard SIA 358 and the real risks of accident.
  2. Suspension of unsafe actionsStop any partial intervention likely to mislead users about the overall reliability of the guardrail. Formally refuse to re-weld a baluster or repaint a rail if the overall mechanical strength or geometry remains non-compliant.
  3. Requirement of a formal discharge or withdrawalIf the client refuses the compliance quote or the installation of an approved compensatory device, record the refusal in writing. In the event of manifest danger to the lives of others, refuse the assignment and notify by registered letter the immediate cessation of any service on this element.

To secure the file, the foreman compiles a time-stamped photographic record showing the cracked base plates, the excessive gaps and the absence of a height extension. This technical file, attached to the letter of reservation in line with the principles of the Code of Obligations (CO), demonstrates that the company fully discharged its duty to inform and clears its civil liability if an accident occurs after its departure.

Frequently asked questions

Does a simple metalwork repair trigger compliance of the whole guardrail?

A one-off routine maintenance intervention, such as replacing a screw or localised stripping, does not require complete renovation of the balustrade. However, if the repair involves dismantling load-bearing elements, replacing an entire panel or a structural modification of the anchorages, geometric and mechanical compliance under standard SIA 358 becomes mandatory in the treated area.

How should the written notice be worded if the owner refuses the upgrade?

The letter must be written on letterhead paper and sent by registered mail. It states the precise address of the construction site, details the non-compliances found against the rules of the art, expressly cites standard SIA 358 and describes the risks of tipping over or falling. The letter formally reminds the owner that they retain full responsibility for the structure if they refuse to adapt the ironwork.

Can a temporary net be fitted to compensate for baluster spacing that is too wide?

A mesh or synthetic net is only an emergency interim measure, valid while a construction site is in progress. This palliative in no way validates the final compliance of the existing structure. For a lasting, accepted solution, the metalworker must install a rigid perforated sheet panel, laminated glass or a backing of metal balusters mechanically fixed and not removable without a specific tool.

What is the metalworker's liability in the event of an accident on an old structure that has been reinforced?

If the metalworker worked on the guardrail without issuing written reservations, they bear joint liability in civil or criminal proceedings for breach of the rules of the art. By demonstrating, through an earlier written notice, that the client refused the regulatory upgrade despite the warnings, the tradesperson shifts full responsibility for the accident onto the owner of the building.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 358Guardrails: safety requirements for height, infill openings and permissible loads
  • SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction works: duty to notify and handling of the contractor's reservations

In the same section