Key takeaways
- The inspector applies standard SIA 358 with a tape measure and a rigid sphere.
- Measure the finished height from the finished floor, including skirting and exterior coverings.
- The test sphere must not pass through any gap in the balusters or under the rail.
- Deal with remarks by means of adjustment profiles that have been approved before requesting an official follow-up inspection.
The four geometric checks to carry out before the municipal inspection
On Swiss construction sites, acceptance by the municipal authority does not involve destructive tests or complex engineering calculations. The building-police officer or the appointed expert arrives with two basic tools: a metal tape measure and a spherical gauge. To avoid any dispute when the occupancy permit is issued, the installation team must absolutely carry out a dry run of this inspection as soon as the metalwork is complete.
- Measuring the finished usable heightRun the tape strictly vertically between the top edge of the handrail and the finished level of the walking surface. If the final covering is not yet laid at the time of installation (slabs on pedestals, liquid screed or tiling), allow for its exact thickness. The minimum dimension required by standard SIA 358 allows no deduction from the finished floor.
- Low spherical gauge pass-through testPass the calibration sphere under the bottom rail or the lower profile of the guardrail. The gap between the underside of the work and the raw slab or the stair treads must not allow this volume to pass. Excessive ground clearance resulting from a badly calculated recess in the concrete is the most common error.
- Checking the vertical infill gapsPresent the gauge at each gap between the vertical balusters, perforated sheets or intermediate posts. The sphere must not enter any opening under moderate manual pressure. Always measure the first and last baluster against the masonry reveals, where façade tolerances often create a gap.
- Assessing the ladder effect on the railsRecord the height of any horizontal or inclined elements that could serve as a foothold for a child. Any horizontal profile located between the finished floor and the safety zone must either have a chamfer preventing a foot from gripping it, or comply with the geometric setbacks defined by the accident-prevention guidelines.
Usual reasons for non-conformity and the procedure for clearing reservations
When the municipal delegate records a notice of non-conformity, the issue of the operating authorisation or occupancy permit is immediately suspended. The reasons for refusal almost never concern the sizing of the steel in the workshop, but the unforeseen meeting of the finished work with the real environment of the building.
| Anomaly found | Origin on site | Workshop corrective measure |
|---|---|---|
| Usable height below the required dimension | Floor covering thickness underestimated | Addition of a welded or bolted tubular raising piece on the handrail |
| Sphere passes under the bottom rail | Water drainage slope or dip in the concrete | Fitting of a metal skirting angle fixed under the lower profile |
| Wall gap greater than the standard allows | External façade insulation thicker than planned | Extension of the handrail or addition of a compensating baluster |
| Risk of climbing on a crossbar | Intermediate bottom rail serving as a step | Fitting of a smooth backing sheet or a blanking glass panel |
Clearing a remark requires method. Rather than disputing the authority's report, the foreman must prepare a clear modification sheet. The metalworker intervenes on site to adapt the element: clean mechanical assembly, tamper-proof fasteners or metallisation touch-up according to the rules of the art of finishing work. Any welding carried out on powder-coated steel requires local stripping and careful anti-corrosion protection to avoid a subsequent refusal on aesthetic grounds.
Self-inspection file and documents handed to the building police
During the conformity visit with a view to granting the occupancy permit, the municipal building-police delegate no longer settles for a simple overall glance. The authority applies standard SIA 358 on guardrails strictly. To prevent the inspector from suspending the issue of the authorisation to occupy the premises, the site manager and the head of the metalwork workshop must present a signed self-inspection record before the authority even takes out its measuring equipment. This document certifies that each guardrail has been checked against the finished floor surface and under normal service loads.
The municipal inspector's physical inspection focuses on the interaction between the metal work and its immediate surroundings. Dimensional discrepancies almost systematically arise after the secondary trades have passed through, when floor finishes eat into the protection height shown on the metalworker's fabrication drawings.
| Checkpoint on the work | Reference geometric requirement | Supporting document to be provided |
|---|---|---|
| Residual height above the finished floor | Vertical measurement taken from the tiles or slabs on pedestals to the top of the handrail according to standard SIA 358 | Dated joint site survey sheet drawn up after the coverings are laid |
| Clear gap under the bottom rail | Rigid calibration sphere blocked under the balusters and at the return corners | Geometric self-inspection record with photos of the singular points |
| Ladder effect and intermediate supports | No climbable horizontal elements or base widenings that facilitate climbing | Execution section detail approved by site management and the engineer |
| Strength of the fixings at the slab edge | Anchors sized to withstand the regulatory lateral load | Calculation note for the fixings and technical data sheets for the anchors installed |
Comparing dimensions on site shows that the metalworker bears responsibility for the final dimension, even if the screeder or waterproofer raised the reference level without consultation. Spontaneously presenting the internal inspection records immediately defuses any challenge concerning the good faith of the executing contractor.
Handling municipal reservations, workshop corrections and the second inspection
If the control gauge test is failed, the municipal inspector records the non-conformity in an inspection report sent to site management. This finding automatically blocks the final validation of the work and the collection of the balance of the works. The metalworker must then act quickly to correct the defect without altering the structural performance or the overall appearance of the balustrade.
- Analysing the municipal inspection reportIdentify precisely the nature of the refusal: excessive spacing between balusters, a lower gap created by a poorly connected French-window threshold, or a climbing zone created by an adjoining window sill.
- Studying a compliant remedial solutionFavour the mechanical addition of stop profiles, discreet bolted raising pieces under the handrail or anti-climb perforated sheets, avoiding any improvised welding on site that would burn the powder coating.
- Execution and joint self-inspectionFit the corrective parts according to the rules of the art of metalwork, then repeat all the measurements with a rigid tape measure and a gauge rod before notifying site management.
- Calling the follow-up inspectionSend the municipality a written request for re-examination, accompanied by dimensioned photographs proving that the non-conforming gaps have been definitively eliminated.
The second visit by the municipal authority systematically generates administrative fees charged to the client, who immediately passes them on to the defaulting contractor as a deduction from the invoice. To protect the financial margin of the job and close the file, the installation manager must attend this second visit in person, equipped with his own calibrated gauge and the complete execution file.
Once the corrections have been formally validated in the record clearing the reservations, the municipality issues the operating authorisation. This signature releases the metalworker's civil liability, triggers the final account of the work under the rules of standard SIA 118 and authorises the release of the blocked bank guarantees.
Dispute at the municipal inspection: arbitration protocol and clearing of reservations
When the building-police delegate refuses to issue the occupancy permit because a guardrail is judged non-compliant, the construction site is blocked. The municipal inspector applies standard SIA 358 strictly using his control sphere and tape measure. Faced with a finding of non-conformity, the foreman or project manager must not dispute it orally on the spot, but must demand an inspection record stating the specific element at fault, the measurement taken and the exact point of impact.
- Immediate joint inspection recordRepeat the measurement in the presence of the inspector with a calibrated gauge and document the survey with photographs showing the tape laid on the actual finished floor, without compressing any soft joints.
- Analysis of the dimension chainCheck whether the discrepancy comes from a fabrication error in the workshop or from a drift in the structural work, in particular excess screed thickness or a balcony waterproofing layer higher than on the approved execution drawings.
- Corrective technical proposalWithin forty-eight hours, send site management a modification sketch: addition of a welded or bolted tubular raising profile under the handrail, a raised base plate, or reduction of the lower gap with a powder-coated angle.
- Follow-up inspection and written certificateAfter the work on site, submit a file for clearing the reservation including photos of the geometric rectification and request the formal second visit by the municipal authority.
To avoid a prolonged blockage, the corrective solution must blend discreetly into the existing metalwork without weakening the structural strength of the work. Once the municipality has approved the correction, the authority signs the remark-clearance form, thereby unblocking the administrative closure of the file.
Frequently asked questions
The municipal inspector refuses a guardrail because the 120 mm sphere passes under the bottom rail: what should be done?
An additional mechanical stop profile must be fitted, fixed directly to the guardrail structure or under the balusters, to bring the gap under the rail below the critical threshold. A powder-coated aluminium angle or flat bar fixed with concealed stainless-steel fasteners solves the problem without major rework of the metalwork. Have the modification recorded by photo with the tape measure before requesting a visit from the municipal authority.
What should be done if the guardrail height is 15 mm short because of an overly thick balcony screed?
Two technical solutions exist without replacing the posts: raise the handrail by adding a tubular rail fitted on machined spacers, or insert galvanised steel shims under the fixing plates if the ground clearance allows. This modification requires the formal agreement of site management and must preserve the anchor rigidity required by standard SIA 358 before the official follow-up inspection.
Who bears the cost of the second visit by the municipal authority?
Municipalities charge the re-inspection fee to the client. Under standard SIA 118, this cost is passed on to the awarded contractor if the non-conformity results from a workshop or installation error by the metalworker. If the defect results from an incorrect finished-floor level supplied by site management, the financial burden and the modification works must be covered by a daywork order.
Can a provisional occupancy permit be obtained if a guardrail has a geometric reservation?
Since the safety of users is compromised, the building police generally refuse any derogation on fall risk. Exceptionally, a temporary permit may be granted if the metalworker immediately installs a provisional, certified and impassable safeguard, such as a plywood panel screwed to the metalwork, during the manufacturing and powder-coating period of the definitive compliant replacement parts in accordance with standard SIA 358.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 358Guardrails: dimensional requirements, protection height, limitation of openings and prevention of climbing
- norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work: handling of defects, duties of the parties and acceptance of the work
