Skip to content
Website
🧱 CFC 274Balustrades: height, infill and complianceChapter 2 of 10 in the section

Spacing: the control sphere, gaps at floor level and the forgotten gap under the bottom rail

After this chapter, you will be able to identify and systematically check the three dimensional leak zones that cause a guardrail to be rejected at acceptance. You will be able to use the spherical control gauge under SIA 358 on the construction site, adjust your installation clearances at the ends and anticipate floor tolerances to guarantee a work that is compliant from the outset.

Key takeaways

  • The official check is carried out exclusively on the construction site with a rigid, non-deformable spherical gauge.
  • The gap between the finished floor and the underside of the infill tolerates no passage.
  • The residual space under the bottom rail requires strict coordination with the heights of the kerbs and bases.
  • Guardrail ends against insulated façades are the main geometric trap during installation.

The gauge sphere: why the tape measure misleads the metalworker in the workshop

On the construction site or at the workbench, the natural reflex is to pull the steel tape between two posts or two vertical balusters. This flat linear measurement creates a false sense of safety. SIA 358 requires a three-dimensional spatial check that simulates a child's body: no part of a standardised control sphere may be able to pass through any gap or opening in the work up to the required protection height. This physical gauge acts in three dimensions and ruthlessly penalises diagonals, curved shapes, offset junctions and the transverse flexibility of light metal profiles.

Spherical control gauge
A rigid, non-deformable sphere of a diameter calibrated to the requirements of SIA 358, moved by hand over all faces, openings, assembly gaps and cut-outs of a guardrail to check that no gap allows it to pass.

Measuring baluster spacing with a tape measure systematically ignores manufacturing tolerances, thermal deformation from welding and, above all, the inherent elasticity of the balusters under manual pressure. A round baluster of small cross-section, theoretically evenly spaced, can spread slightly when an inspector from the bpa or the site management forces the gauge through with standardised pressure. If the sphere engages and passes through the balustrade, the work is declared non-compliant, requiring a complete rework of the frames or the unsightly addition of intermediate profiles.

Comparison between tape-measure checking and checking with the standardised sphere
Criterion checkedLinear tape measurementRigid sphere test
Straight vertical balustradeMeasures the raw clear gap between metal faces under no loadReveals elastic deflection under engagement pressure
Angles, diagonals and cut-outsHardly assesses the real hypotenuse in cornersInstantly penetrates any triangle or geometric gap
Underside and ground clearanceRecords a single height at the post axisDetects screed hollows and reverse falls in the waterproofing
Ends against façade renderMeasures an average distance on an uneven render faceFollows the hollows in the external insulation and passes through the gap

The three critical gaps that cause the work to be rejected at installation

The vast majority of non-conformity reports drawn up on construction sites in French-speaking Switzerland do not concern the standard balustrade, which is generally well calculated in the metalwork workshop. Rejections are concentrated in three transition zones that are frequently neglected when taking dimensions: the space under the infill panel relative to the finished floor, the clearance under the bottom rail where it overhangs a low wall or kerb, and the lateral gap at the ends against rendered or ventilated façades.

  1. Checking the gap between infill and finished floorThe lowest point of the frame or glazing must be measured from the real final finish (slabs on pedestals, sealed tiling, smoothed screed) and not from the raw concrete. If the tiler falls behind or lays thinner slabs than planned, the sphere passes under the panel. Fix the finished floor level contractually or incorporate an adjustable low metal skirting.
  2. Checking the height under the rail on a concrete low wallWhen the guardrail is fixed on a parapet or a narrow masonry kerb, the space under the metal bottom rail must never create a climbing zone nor let the spherical gauge slip through. This intermediate space adds together the mason's pouring tolerances and the adjustment of the metalworker's fixing plates.
  3. Probing the ends against reveals and façadesThe end connection between the last baluster and the external insulation is the major trap. Between the theoretical face on the drawing and the actual installation of the rendered insulation, differences of several centimetres are common. The gauge sphere goes straight into this lateral gap if the end post has not been designed with a telescopic adjustment bracket.

To forestall any dispute during installation, the metalworking foreman must carry his own spherical gauge, machined to the dimensions of SIA 358, in his toolbox. Every installed bay must be tested before leaving the construction site: systematically sweep the edge strip at floor level, the clearance under the lower rail and the residual gaps at the building's expansion joints. If a façade render has a batter or an insulation overrun, correct the spacing with slotted adjustment shims provided on your fixings rather than forcing the structure mechanically.

The gap under the rail and the interface with the finished floor: anticipating the waterproofing layers

On a light metalwork construction site, the error in the height reference is the main cause of a guardrail being rejected at the compliance check. The metalworker often works when the raw concrete slab has been stripped of its formwork but before the waterproofer or the tiler have laid their falls and finishing layers. If the bottom rail is positioned on the basis of the raw concrete without taking into account the waterproofing upstand, any insulation or the slabs on pedestals, the residual gap under the bottom rail will be wrong. Too generous a ground clearance will let the gauge sphere through, while too little will prevent normal drainage of rainwater under the lower rail.

SIA 358 requires that openings do not allow the passage of a test sphere up to a specified height. The gap between the infill and the finished floor is a critical passage zone. In the case of face-fixed installation (external bracket fixing) or fixing to the slab edge, the distance between the underside of the infill frame and the upper edge of the raw slab or coping must take into account the edge skirting or the flashing profile. When the guardrail has an infill of vertical balusters welded to a bottom rail, any offset greater than the limit value exposes the tradesman to dismantling the work or urgently adding a skirting plate.

Critical points for the gauge sphere passage according to fixing type
Geometric zonePhysical check pointTypical installation riskPreventive measure in metalwork
Underside of bottom rail (fixed on slab)Interval between the lower edge of the tube and the finished surfaceFinishing screed thinner than planned, creating a gap above the toleranceRequire the official level mark (PM +1.00 m) and wedge the plates with tapered shims or stacking washers
Underside of frame (fixed to slab edge)Free space between the concrete face and the back of the metal postSlab irregular after stripping, forcing an excessive lateral gapFit a continuous metal flashing or a stop profile on the underside of the post
Ends against masonry or façadeGap between the end baluster and the finished renderVentilated façade or external insulation adding an extra thickness not shown on the drawingsMeasure the space after the external insulation is installed and make a suitable closure piece
Underside of light staircasesTriangular gap between the stair nosing and the under-railProfile layout not adjusted to the slope of the stringerRun the under-rail parallel to the nosings or add a cut-out skirting

Gaps at the ends and the mechanical gauge verification method

The second recurring trap concerns the gap at the ends, located between the last vertical element of the guardrail and the façade, the window reveal or the stringer wall. In the workshop, the working drawing indicates a regular nominal distance between the balusters. On the construction site, masonry tolerances or render thicknesses applied after the dimensional survey change this spacing. If the last post is set away from the façade to house a drainage profile or to bypass a gutter, the gauge sphere enters it without obstruction. The site manager will refuse acceptance of the work, because the gap at the ends presents the same risk of a child falling or becoming trapped as an opening in the middle of the panel.

  1. Making the rigid spherical gaugeMake a rigid, non-deformable sphere in the workshop, fixed to a handle, or use a hemispherical aluminium gauge. The folding rule or tape cannot simulate three-dimensional penetration in angles or skewed intersections.
  2. Systematic sweep of the under-railRoll the sphere along the whole length of the finished floor, pressing the gauge against the underside of the bottom rail. Contact must block the passage of the tool on every linear centimetre, including at the anchors.
  3. Checking returns and wall endsPresent the sphere vertically in the slot between the edge post and the façade wall. At no point may the gauge be able to cross the imaginary line joining the structure to the wall.
  4. Mechanical rework before acceptanceIf passage is free, insert an adjustment plate under the posts, weld a compensating flat bar or fit a closed end return in order to eliminate the gap without weakening the structure.

Handling geometric non-conformities at acceptance

Finding a non-compliant sphere passage at the acceptance of a guardrail confronts the metalworker with an immediate rejection of the work by the site management or the safety engineer. When the gauge sphere passes through a gap at the ends, crosses the space under the bottom rail or enters between the balustrade and an uncompensated raw slab, the safety of users is no longer ensured under the criteria of SIA 358. On-site rectification requires a methodical approach to avoid complete removal of the powder-coated elements.

  1. Drawing up the joint surveyMark each passage point with the test sphere in the presence of the client. Record the real dimension measured with a calliper and identify the exact cause: variation in screed thickness, batter of the masonry or poorly distributed expansion clearance.
  2. Choosing the corrective measurePreferably add attached mechanical elements matching the original surface treatment. For an excessive gap at the ends against the render, design an angle or a closure flat bar screwed discreetly onto the end post.
  3. Correcting the gap under the lower railIf the finished floor level leaves too large a free gap, fix a flat-bar under-rail or an intermediate tubular profile under the bottom rail, or add a mechanically anchored metal skirting.
  4. Final validation with the gaugeSystematically pass the control sphere again over the whole modified length before signing the acceptance record for the metalwork.

In the event of a persistent dispute over financial responsibility, the provisions of the Code of Obligations (CO) govern the rectification of the defective work. The tradesman must demonstrate that the workshop dimension complied with the approved drawings and that the excess results from a finished floor level not conforming to the original design. In all cases, no dimensional deviation is permitted for aesthetic reasons, since SIA 358 prescribes that the opening must be impassable.

Frequently asked questions

How do you correct a gap exceeding the tolerance between the last baluster and the rendered façade?

The quickest solution is to fit a compensating profile or a closure plate made in the workshop, powder-coated in the colour of the guardrail. This flat bar or additional end baluster is fixed mechanically by riveting or concealed screwing onto the end post of the barrier. It reduces the opening without damaging the external insulation or requiring complete replacement of the bay.

Must the spherical gauge be pushed with a particular force during the test?

The test sphere serves as a clear geometric indicator and must not pass through the gaps under its own weight or under moderate manual pressure. However, on flexible infills such as stainless steel fabric, mesh nets or thin perforated sheets, elastic deformation under service load can enlarge the opening: the sphere must never pass through the gap even when the wall is loaded laterally.

Who is responsible if the gap under the rail increases after the tiling is laid?

If the metalworker relied on the official level marks supplied by the site management and the actual thickness of the screed and tiling build-up turns out to be less than on the drawings, responsibility lies with the site coordination. Nevertheless, the metalworker is obliged to check the height of the level mark before the plates are plugged and fixed, in order to report any foreseeable deviation.

Can a cut-out flat gauge be used instead of a real sphere?

No. A flat gauge made of cardboard or plywood does not reproduce the three-dimensional path of a round body. It jams on off-axis posts or sheet folds where a rigid sphere enters by rotating. Only a sphere machined to the standardised diameter guarantees repeatable checks and has legal weight in the joint acceptance procedures for the metalwork.

Texts and standards cited

  • SIA 358Guardrails: safety criteria, maximum permissible openings and fall prevention
  • SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work and acceptance of the work

In the same section