Key takeaways
- Concrete cone failure occurs when the concrete gives way before the steel of the anchor.
- The European Technical Assessment defines the limit installation distances for each fixing diameter.
- A reduced spacing between two anchors causes their stress cones to overlap destructively.
- Going below the characteristic distance requires the permissible load to be reduced in accordance with the manufacturer.
Understanding concrete cone failure and the ETA reference values
When a metalworker installs a balustrade base plate or a light stair shoe, there is often a temptation to drill as close as possible to the slab edge in order to gain clear passage space or to respect the architectural alignment. Yet under a combined tensile or shear load, the mechanical or chemical anchor almost never slips out of its drill hole: it is the concrete itself that cracks and breaks away in the shape of a truncated cone. This phenomenon is called concrete cone failure. If the fixing is too close to the free edge, the concrete lacks lateral material to absorb the radial stresses created by mechanical expansion or chemical bond.
- Concrete cone failure
- Pull-out of a cone-shaped block of concrete whose apex starts at the anchorage zone of the anchor and whose base widens towards the free surface of the substrate under the effect of tensile stresses.
To size a fixing correctly, the metalworker must refer to the European Technical Assessment, abbreviated ETA. This official technical document, issued by a notified body, specifies the verified performance of the product according to its rod diameter and its effective embedment depth. The ETA makes a fundamental distinction between two levels of geometric dimensions: characteristic values and minimum values. The characteristic edge distance and the characteristic spacing represent the distances needed to develop one hundred per cent of the permissible tensile resistance of the anchor without mechanical interference.
| Anchor diameter | Effective embedment depth (mm) | Minimum edge distance (mm) | Minimum spacing between anchors (mm) |
|---|---|---|---|
| M8 | 40 | 45 | 40 |
| M10 | 50 | 55 | 50 |
| M12 | 70 | 70 | 60 |
| M16 | 85 | 90 | 80 |
Managing the reduction of permissible load at slab edges and with tight spacings
On a finishing work construction site, the raw balcony edge or the stair stringer often imposes space constraints that make it impossible to respect the characteristic edge distance. The ETA data sheets then allow going down to a threshold value called the minimum edge distance. As soon as the dimension measured between the drill axis and the free edge of the concrete is less than the characteristic distance, the nominal resistance of the fixing is no longer guaranteed: the metalworker must apply a load reduction coefficient, often expressed as a reduction factor between 0.40 and 1.
The same physical interaction occurs when two anchors are drilled in immediate proximity to one another under the same metalwork plate. As soon as the actual spacing falls below the characteristic spacing, the volumes of the two theoretical concrete cones overlap. The shared zone of material cannot take the tensile force twice: the minimum spacing between anchors is the absolute geometric limit below which the concrete already bursts when tightened to the prescribed torque, even before the structure is put into service.
- Recording the actual concrete dimensions on the drawing and on siteMeasure the actual width of the concrete substrate, identify the position of the free edge and check whether the passive reinforcement allows the required drilling depth to be reached without conflict.
- Consult the reduction table of the ETA-approved manufacturerExtract the reduction coefficient corresponding to the exact combination of actual spacing and actual edge distance for the envisaged diameter in the concrete class of the construction site.
- Adapt the geometry of the plate or the method of anchoringIf the remaining usable load is insufficient to take the overturning force of the balustrade post, widen the plate, opt for resin anchoring without expansion stress, or stagger the drill holes.
Adapting anchoring to narrow geometries: balustrade base plates and slab edges
On a building metalwork construction site, the ideal geometric configuration almost never exists. Installing a surface-mounted balustrade on a balcony slab edge or fixing a handrail to the floor along a stairwell opening almost systematically requires working below the characteristic distances defined by the manufacturer. When the edge distance or the spacing between fixings falls below the critical distance, the concrete can no longer develop its full anchorage capacity. The volume of concrete that can be mobilised to resist the tensile force decreases drastically, causing overlapping stress cones or premature failure by edge spalling.
The European Technical Assessment (ETA) of each anchor strictly distinguishes the characteristic distance, which allows 100% of the permissible load to be used, from the absolute minimum distance. Below the minimum edge distance or the minimum spacing between anchors, installation is prohibited, because tightening to the nominal torque or loading in tension immediately destroys the concrete edge. Between these two thresholds, a methodical reduction of resistance must be included in the fixing calculation note.
| Geometric configuration | Mechanical effect on the concrete substrate | Predominant failure mode | Indicative permissible residual capacity |
|---|---|---|---|
| Edge distance and spacing greater than the critical values | Full mobilisation of the concrete volume without interference | Failure of the steel of the threaded rod or pure pull-out | 100% of the ETA-certified permissible load |
| Reduced spacing between anchors (edges far away) | Partial overlap of the tension volumes of each anchor | Combined concrete cone failure encompassing both anchors | 70% to 85% of the nominal load per fixing |
| Reduced edge distance (standard spacing) | Absence of lateral material to contain the spreading thrust | Lateral spalling or bevelled breakout of the edge | 50% to 70% of the nominal load |
| Minimum edge distance and minimum spacing simultaneously | Extremely small confined volume of concrete around the anchors | Sudden wedge failure when the tightening torque is applied | 35% to 50% of the nominal load (limit of use) |
Compensation strategies: technology choice and layout changes
When the dimensional survey shows that it is impossible to respect the minimum edge distance or the nominal spacing required by a conventional anchor stud, the metalworker must change the design before drilling. Metal studs with an expansion sleeve generate very high permanent radial stresses in the concrete as soon as the nut is tightened. These bursting stresses are incompatible with thin edges or projecting balcony corners, where corner cracking often occurs even before the service loads of the SIA 261 standard are applied.
- Switching to chemical anchoring without expansion stressReplace the mechanical anchor with an ETA-approved epoxy or vinylester injection resin for cracked concrete. Chemical bond transmits the force without creating internal radial prestress at rest. This technology significantly lowers the minimum edge distance requirements and allows a much tighter drilling pattern on the plate.
- Adopting self-tapping concrete screwsThe concrete screw is a quick and effective alternative in light finishing work. By creating its own grip through indentation in the material, it applies splitting stresses clearly lower than those of a mechanical stud. The ETA documents for these screws specify reduced edge distances, which are very advantageous for balustrade shoes.
- Redesigning the fixing plate in the workshopModify the geometry of the plate to move the drill holes away from the outer edge. An asymmetric plate with suitably oriented slotted holes, or an offset of the fixing towards the inside of the slab, makes it possible to recover the required characteristic distances and avoids any load reduction.
- Preferring side-mounted installation on the slab edgeWhen installation on top of the slab places the anchors less than 60 mm from the finished edge, side fixing against the concrete edge face offers a greater anchorage height and moves the fixings away from the upper edge, which is the most vulnerable to water infiltration and frost.
Managing defects on the construction site: concrete spalling and technical remedies
When installing a balustrade or a metal rail, tightening a mechanical stud too close to the edge to the specified torque can cause sudden spalling or concrete cone failure. The same damage occurs when a drill hole deviates against a reinforcing bar or weakens an already chipped slab edge. Once the anchorage mass has failed in this way, the resistance of the fixing falls to zero. It is out of the question to conceal the break or to increase the driving depth at random: the mechanical hold of the element depends on it.
- Stopping the operation and recording the defectStop tightening the anchor concerned. Remove the balustrade plate to inspect the extent of the failure cone. Take clear photographs showing the actual edge distance and the geometry of the spalling in order to inform the site management.
- Filling according to the rules and neutralising the holeThe compromised hole can no longer receive a structural fixing. If a new drill hole is envisaged nearby, clean out the cavity and fill it with a non-shrink grout or a structural resin, observing a minimum distance of twice the depth of the hole.
- Modifying the plate or changing the methodTo keep the balustrade without weakening the edge, shift the layout in the workshop or have a wider plate made with a larger spacing. Using threaded rods anchored with chemical injection often reduces the radial expansion force and saves the fixing.
In the event of proven geometric impossibility in the structural work — an edge poured too short or reinforcement preventing the minimum spacings from being respected — the metalworker applies the procedure of notice of anomaly governed by the SIA 118 standard. Record the situation in writing before any modification of the works. Technical adjustments, such as switching from a mechanical anchor to a chemical system or installing a side-mounted plate, must be validated jointly by the technical office and the site management.
Frequently asked questions
Can a failed hole be filled with quick-setting mortar so that it can be re-drilled in the same place?
No, this practice is prohibited for a structural anchor. A levelling mortar or quick-setting cement never restores the tensile strength of the original concrete. An anchor reinstalled in this weakened zone will pull out the plug as soon as it is put under tension. The drill hole must be shifted by at least twice the nominal depth, or a certified resin adopted after technical agreement.
What should be done if a reinforcing bar blocks the drilling at the exact planned location?
Never cut a main reinforcing bar with the hammer drill without the prior agreement of the civil engineer responsible for the structure. Cutting through a load-bearing perimeter bar weakens the mechanical resistance of the slab. Inform the site management and adjust the metal plate: make a slotted hole in the workshop if the geometry allows, or shift the anchor axis within the tolerances given in the ETA document of the chosen anchor.
Why prefer chemical anchoring when the edge distance is critical?
Unlike metal studs, which exert a strong radial expansion stress when screwed in, chemical anchoring transmits forces by pure bond over the entire drilled surface. This absence of spreading pressure eliminates the risk of premature bursting of the concrete at the slab edge. The European Technical Assessment thus allows smaller edge distances and spacings than with an expansion stud, provided the hole is carefully cleaned of dust.
How should one react contractually if the slab edge is too narrow to install the balustrade?
When the actual concrete dimensions do not allow the minimum edge distances to be respected, apply the SIA 118 standard by sending the client a written notice of defects. Do not attempt any improvisation on site. Propose a compensating variant: side-mounted fixing on the edge face, offset plate or resin anchoring. Any additional costs of the change are covered by a technical addendum approved before installation.
Texts and standards cited
- norme SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction works (handling of notices of anomaly and claims relating to defective substrates)
