Key takeaways
- The ladder cage guides and slows the body but never prevents a violent impact.
- The OTConst and the safety rules require rest landings to break up the flights.
- Beyond a certain height, a change of flight with a hatch or an offset remains unavoidable.
- For frequent or very high access, a metal staircase or a rail-guided fall arrester is required.
Mechanical limits of the ladder cage and breaking up the climb with rest landings
In building metalwork practice, the fixed hooped ladder is still commonly specified to reach a technical roof terrace, a lift shaft or a maintenance platform for an air-handling unit. A persistent illusion is to regard the cage as fall-arrest equipment in the strict sense. In reality, an operator who suffers a dizzy spell or loses grip slides inside the metal basket. The circular hoops and the longitudinal straps prevent the body from being thrown out into the void behind, but they do not stop the vertical descent. The body strikes the rungs and the steel or aluminium stirrups one after another until the first horizontal obstacle, with a high risk of fractures or serious injuries.
To limit the speed gained and the kinetic energy developed during a fall inside the cage, the installation must be broken up into sections. On a continuous vertical structure, a single flight must not exceed a maximum height defined by the recognised rules of the trade. As soon as the total height difference exceeds this threshold, the metalwork contractor must split the climb into several offset sections, separated by an intermediate rest landing. This break interrupts the vertical trajectory and provides a solid floor on which a technician can catch their breath or be rescued.
| Component or interval | Required dimension | Technical function |
|---|---|---|
| Start of the first hoop | 2.20 m to 3.00 m above the ground | Clearance of the access zone at the foot of the ladder |
| Internal clear diameter | 650 mm to 800 mm | Holds the body without hindering progress while carrying a tool bag |
| Hoop spacing | 1.50 m maximum | Rigidity of the cage and continuous lateral guidance of the torso |
| Maximum height of a flight | 6.00 m (without landing) | Limiting the distance of an internal free fall |
| Distance between successive landings | 6.00 m maximum | Mechanical breaking-up of the climb over great heights |
The rest landing is not simply a bent sheet attached to the stringer. It is a rigid crossing platform, fitted with non-slip open-grid flooring, a toe board and side guardrails designed for the loads of normal use. Access to the next flight is made either by a lateral offset of the ladder axes of at least 700 mm, or by a tilting floor fitted with a return spring or a counterweight that keeps the hatch closed after the worker has passed.
Coordination with the OTConst, the SIA 358 standard and technical alternatives
The choice of a caged ladder must result from a rigorous access analysis and not from workshop habit. The SIA 358 standard sets out the safety principles for users, clearly distinguishing routes intended for the public, those reserved for general operation and strictly technical access reserved for informed specialists. A fixed ladder may under no circumstances serve an area accessible to untrained or uninformed users. As soon as the access is used for regular maintenance rounds, for emergency evacuation or for the frequent carrying of heavy spare parts, the vertical ladder becomes unsuitable.
- Restricted technical access
- A route reserved exclusively for qualified maintenance and servicing personnel, equipped with suitable personal protective equipment, for occasional inspection or minor repair work.
The ordinance on construction work sets strict requirements for fall prevention during the assembly, maintenance and future use of the structure. If the height to be climbed is significant or if the frequency of passage exceeds that of an annual visit, the metalworker must inform site management of the need to use a straight metal staircase, an inclined ship's ladder-type staircase, or an access ladder without a cage but fitted with a mobile fall-arrest system on a rigid lifeline.
- Metal staircase with stringers or industrial treads: priority solution as soon as the technician carries loads or intervenes more than once a month.
- Ladder without a cage with a mobile fall arrester on a rail or stainless-steel cable: almost instantaneous fall arrest without being crushed against metal hoops.
- Locking device at the foot of the ladder: closure by a lockable sheet-metal panel to prevent unauthorised persons from climbing.
- Self-closing access gate at the top: gravity- or spring-operated closing to restore the continuity of the perimeter guardrail on the roof.
On industrial façades or inner courtyards exposed to the weather, the design of the structure must take into account differential thermal expansion and the nature of the fixing substrate. The galvanised or stainless steel wall anchor brackets must be calculated to take the self-weight of the cage, the vertical service load and the horizontal pull-out force applied to the guardrail or to the cage in the event of a dynamic impact. The mechanical connection to the concrete or to the secondary façade sections must be subject to a systematic visual check on completion of the installation.
Geometry of rest landings and breaking up the flights
The design of a fixed ladder for technical access must not rest on the illusion that a cage prevents a worker from falling. The circular hoops and the continuous straps hold the body inside a defined envelope to avoid a direct fall into the void, but the vertical fall along the uprights continues until contact with a projection or a flat surface. The worker suffers a series of violent impacts against the steel or aluminium flat bars before being slowed down. To reduce this kinetic energy and limit bodily injury, breaking up the height with rest landings is the fundamental principle of protection.
The OTConst imposes clear requirements for securing vertical circulation and access to technical installations on roofs. Connecting a technical roof structure or an air-handling unit requires the route to be adapted to the structural work. As soon as the height difference to be climbed exceeds six metres, the ladder flight must be interrupted. The metalworker then installs an intermediate platform with a lateral offset of the next flight. This offset forces the user to take a step sideways, ensuring that if grip is lost on the upper flight, the body falls onto a fixed metal floor and not into the void below.
The rest landing consists of a welded frame of angles or tubes, covered with an electro-forged grating of hot-dip galvanised steel with a tight safety mesh. This flooring rests on wall brackets anchored by metal studs or threaded rods with chemical anchoring in the concrete wall. The open perimeter is edged with a sheet-metal toe board at least 100 millimetres high to retain feet and tools, supplemented by a rigid guardrail designed in accordance with the SIA 358 standard for access reserved for authorised technical personnel.
Limits of the ladder cage and transition to guided fall-arrest devices
The risk assessment quickly highlights the inherent mechanical limits of the cage. As soon as a fitter carries a bag of instruments, a pressure gauge or maintenance equipment, the basic rule of three permanent points of contact on the square or notched rungs becomes impossible to comply with. Moreover, the internal diameter of the cage, generally set between 650 and 750 millimetres, considerably reduces freedom of movement and easily jams bulky equipment. Although the SIA 358 standard reserves such access for instructed persons, this rules out neither muscle fatigue nor dizziness during a climb.
The other critical point concerns the emergency rescue of a person in distress or injured. Rescue services have the greatest difficulty in winching and extracting an unconscious body trapped inside a tube of hoops without destructively cutting the metal structure. Where the structure involves a great climbing height or a high frequency of intervention, the OTConst steers the design towards the outright removal of the cage in favour of a rigid guided fall-arrest device. The user connects to it by a sliding carriage attached to a central aluminium rail or a tensioned steel cable.
| Evaluation criterion | Standard caged ladder | Ladder with rail or cable fall arrester |
|---|---|---|
| Protection principle | Guidance of the body and successive impacts on hoops | Instantaneous mechanical locking by sliding carriage |
| Projection from the façade | Large projection of between 700 and 800 mm | Small footprint centred on the uprights |
| Emergency rescue | Very complex operation inside the tube | Direct vertical winching without obstacles |
| Equipment required | Ordinary work clothing without harness | Fall-arrest harness and lanyard with connector |
| Preferred field of use | Infrequent technical visits without heavy tools | Periodic maintenance carrying equipment |
The roof exit is the last sensitive interface under the metalworker's responsibility. To meet the requirements of the OTConst, the passage at the top of the parapet must be completely continuous. The ladder uprights extend upwards by at least 1 metre as curved access grab handles, the upper rungs widen to make it easier to place the feet, and a swinging safety gate with a return spring closes off access to the void as soon as the crossing is completed. This top fitting is anchored directly to the perimeter or free-standing guardrail of the roof in order to eliminate any risk of tripping.
Handling access non-conformities and using alternative solutions
On Romandy construction sites, the metalworker frequently encounters configurations in which the planned caged ladder proves impracticable or dangerous. The classic case arises when the openings in superimposed slabs do not allow the lateral offset needed to install a compliant rest landing, or when the concrete substrate has dense reinforcement that prevents the prescribed fixings. Faced with a technical shaft that is too narrow or a continuous height with no offset, insisting on installing metal hoops is an established technical fault. In the event of a fall, the user would strike the successive straps without being held by the cage. As soon as the geometric obstruction is established, the metalworker sends a written notice to site management to report the impossibility of executing a layout that complies with professional rules.
- Joint inspection record of the available clearanceCheck with a plumb line the real alignment of the openings and measure the usable setback. The lack of sufficient space to open a safety gate or tilt a rest floor rules out the conformity of the installation.
- Formal notification to site managementSend a detailed technical formal notice with a dimensioned survey, demonstrating the evident contradictions with the federal safety ordinances and the SIA 358 standard governing technical circulation routes.
- Study of a guided fall-arrest variantPropose replacing the cage with a narrow metal ladder fitted with a central safety rail, removing the constraints of bulky hoops while guaranteeing that the person is stopped cleanly in the event of a slip.
- Technical validation of pull-out forcesHave the civil engineer validate the sizing of the fixing anchors, since the impact forces of a guided fall-arrest device differ significantly from the usual static loads of a traditional ladder cage.
If the client persists in demanding a cage without an intermediate landing for budgetary reasons, the tradesperson must refuse to carry out the work. The civil and professional liability of the metalworker remains engaged if they deliver a vertical access whose lack of protection exposes technicians to serious bodily injury in the event of a fall.
Frequently asked questions
Why is the ladder cage disputed on high technical access?
The ladder cage is not an active fall-arrest system. In the event of a dizzy spell or a slip, the user strikes the successive hoops and the metal uprights violently before being slowed down, which causes serious injuries. As soon as the height climbed becomes significant or the access is used regularly for maintaining technical installations, inspectors and specialists recommend abandoning hoops in favour of ladders fitted with vertical fall-arrest rails or cables with a harness.
What minimum space must be provided to incorporate an offset rest landing?
Installing an intermediate landing with offset flights requires sufficient lateral setback to offset the ladders by at least seventy centimetres. The connecting platform must provide a usable surface secured by a perimeter guardrail and a self-closing gate. If the slab opening or the space in the shaft does not measure at least one metre fifty by one metre twenty, the offset becomes impracticable for the metalworker and another technical solution is required.
Can a retractable hatch be installed instead of offsetting the ladder flights?
In certain narrow shafts or technical ducts, offsetting the ladder flights is impossible for lack of space. A rest landing formed by a tilting floor or a retractable hatch is then still tolerated as a geometric compromise. This hatch serves as a waiting platform during the climb. However, handling it with one hand at height remains awkward for the technician, which often leads the inspection bodies to require direct fall-arrest equipment.
How can the ladder exit onto a technical roof be made safe?
At the upper exit, the ladder uprights must extend above the access level to give the worker a secure grip. A safety gate with gravity or spring self-closing prevents any accidental fall into the opening of the ladder. According to the SIA 358 standard and the requirements of the ordinance on construction work, the arrival area must also be protected laterally by guardrails connected to the parapet or to the surrounding flooring.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 358Guardrails and handrails - Construction provisions for user safety
- OTConstOrdinance on the safety and health protection of workers in construction work
