Key takeaways
- Fresh mortar sampling must be carried out directly at the point of discharge on the construction site.
- Standardised three-prism moulds require methodical compaction to eliminate air voids.
- Initial storage under a tight film ensures proper binder hydration before any transfer to the laboratory.
- Twenty-eight-day breaking load values constitute irrefutable proof of conformity of the initial mix.
Preparation and storage of prisms: the method that protects the screed layer
On Swiss construction sites, preparing control test specimens is not merely a paperwork formality: it represents the screed layer's only technical safeguard against late claims. Standard SIA 251 governs the requirements for screeds and precisely sets the compressive and flexural tensile strength thresholds. However, when mixes are pumped continuously at a sustained rate, sampling representative specimens is sometimes neglected due to a lack of time. A series of test specimens prepared in a professional manner makes it possible to formally separate the intrinsic quality of the delivered or mixed mortar from the uncertainties related to ambient site installation conditions and building drying.
- Sampling at the point of dischargeCollect the fresh mix directly at the outlet of the delivery hose on the working floor, after thoroughly purging the first section of the hose, to obtain a sample that is perfectly representative of the batch incorporated into the structure.
- Filling and compacting in the metal mouldUse a standardised three-prism metal mould with dimensions of forty by forty by one hundred and sixty millimetres. Pour the mortar in two successive layers, systematically compacted by regular rodding or on a site vibrating table to completely drive out trapped air bubbles.
- Levelling, sealing and identificationCarefully level the surface using a bevelled metal straightedge. Immediately place a tight sealing plate to prevent any premature evaporation of the mix water, then identify the mould with indelible labelling stating the date, time, level, cast room and exact mortar formulation.
Initial storage determines the technical and legal validity of the sample. During the first twenty-four hours, the moulds must strictly rest on a rigorously stable horizontal surface, protected from jolts, direct sunlight and drafts, in an environment maintained at a temperature close to twenty degrees Celsius. For a cement screed, demoulding generally takes place after twenty-four to forty-eight hours, followed by immersion in water or hermetic sealing in a moisture-saturated wrap. For a calcium sulphate-based screed, the prisms are carefully demoulded and then stored in a temperature-controlled atmosphere without direct contact with liquid water.
Mechanical testing and results exploitation: the lever that quashes the dispute
Two years after floor covering installation, the appearance of major defects such as general tile delamination, through-cracks or crazing frequently leads the site management to blame the screed. The reflexive approach often consists of commissioning on-site core drillings to assess the hardness of the in-place substrate. However, a core drilled late in a heated and loaded floor is subject to the impact of thermal cycles, adhesive bond stresses and residual building moisture. Only reference prisms sampled during casting and stored according to the rules allow the quality of the supplied mortar to be objectively isolated.
| Mortar designation | Main binder | Minimum flexural strength | Minimum compressive strength |
|---|---|---|---|
| C20-F4 | Cement | 4.0 N/mm² | 20.0 N/mm² |
| C25-F5 | Cement | 5.0 N/mm² | 25.0 N/mm² |
| CA-C25-F4 | Calcium sulphate | 4.0 N/mm² | 25.0 N/mm² |
| CA-C30-F5 | Calcium sulphate | 5.0 N/mm² | 30.0 N/mm² |
Mechanical testing is carried out in accordance with standardised test procedures within an accredited materials testing laboratory. The protocol begins with a three-point flexural breaking test on each of the three forty by forty by one hundred and sixty millimetre prisms. This first phase produces six half-prisms, which are immediately subjected to compression crushing on calibrated steel platens. The arithmetic mean of these six measurements yields the actual characteristic strength of the batch. Obtaining values that comply with or exceed the specified class demonstrates the perfect quality of the mixed batch on the day of work.
Within the framework of a dispute settled in accordance with standard SIA 118 and the Code of Obligations (CO), these official test results hold major probative force. If the test specimens achieve the class required in the specification, the screed layer's liability regarding dosage and intrinsic mechanical strength is completely lifted. The observed defects must then be investigated on the side of subsequent trades: absence of movement joints in the tiling, unsuitable adhesive, poorly managed heating commissioning protocol by the heating engineer or excessive mechanical loads during building operation.
Fresh mortar sampling and evidentiary storage according to standard SIA 251
On a construction site, compliance control cannot be improvised at the moment a crack or dusting appears. When the mechanical strength of a cement or calcium sulphate screed is subject to subsequent disputes, the test specimens prepared during casting constitute the sole objective proof of the intrinsic quality of the delivered and pumped mortar. Standard SIA 251 establishes the framework of requirements for screeds cast in Switzerland, referring for strength testing to the preparation of reference mortar prisms.
- Sampling at the delivery nozzleMortar sampling is carried out directly at the hose outlet in the work area, never in the mixer drum before pumping. The sampled batch must faithfully represent the screed installed in the test room, without clandestine addition of water on the floor.
- Filling and compacting in mouldsThe mortar is introduced in two regular layers into a standardised metal mould with three compartments measuring forty millimetres by forty millimetres and one hundred and sixty millimetres in length. Each layer is mechanically compacted on a jolting table or manually depending on the binder consistency to eliminate air inclusions, before careful levelling with a metal straightedge.
- Initial curing and on-site identificationThe moulds remain protected from shocks, drafts and direct solar radiation on site, under a tight film or glass plate, at a temperature maintained between fifteen and twenty degrees. The prisms are demoulded after twenty-four to forty-eight hours depending on the binder, then labelled with the batch number, floor level and exact date.
Two years later: comparing reference test specimens and in-situ core drillings
The classic dispute scenario frequently occurs upon expiry of the two-year warranty according to standard SIA 118, at the time when the client reports corner sagging, through-cracks or delamination of the bonded covering. The site management then directly challenges the mechanical strength of the screed. If the screed contractor has stored their reference prisms in a recognised laboratory or under controlled seals, the joint inspection expert procedure can begin without methodological bias.
Specialised laboratory testing begins with flexural breakage under central point load of the three prisms, followed by compression crushing on the six resulting half-prisms. The measured values make it possible to unequivocally place the actual strength class of the mortar in relation to the class specified in the construction contract, such as a common C25-F4 class for a cement screed or CA-C25-F5 for a fluid screed.
| Reference prism result | In-situ core result | Technical diagnosis | Attribution of responsibilities |
|---|---|---|---|
| Complies with specified class | Deficient strength on structure | Poor site curing, premature desiccation, brutal heating commissioning or freezing | Responsibility of site management or trades that altered the building environment |
| Non-compliant with specified class | Deficient strength on structure | Under-dosage of binder, excess mixing water, contaminated sand or defective formulation | Full and sole responsibility of the screed contractor or ready-mixed mortar supplier |
| Complies with specified class | Compliant but structural fracturing | Under-dimensioned thickness, abnormal operational surcharge or insulation settlement | Responsibility of designer, engineer or thermal and acoustic insulation installer |
Drawing up a sampling record countersigned by site management during casting, recording the exact location of the batch and mould reference, gives these three prisms unquestionable probative value. Faced with the Code of Obligations (CO) and the rules of standard SIA 118, these test specimens allow the screed contractor to refute any allegation of defective work on the mix and confine the technical debate to the actual operating conditions of the floating floor.
Recourse protocol and joint expert appraisal in the event of a late claim
The appearance of defects two years after delivery — through-cracks, spalling under bonded parquet or localised indentation under load — systematically triggers liability claims against the screed contractor. When site management or the insurance expert disputes the compactness of the mortar, the contractor opposes the prism preparation record and immediately triggers the arbitration procedure by an accredited laboratory, in accordance with the expert appraisal rules of standard SIA 118.
- Joint inspection record and seal removalThe three test specimens stored in a regulated room are presented before all parties summoned upon written notice. The expert checks the compliance of the indelible marking, the sampling date, the absence of mechanical shocks on the prisms and the exact match with the delivery note from the batching plant or central plant.
- Crushing in an accredited laboratoryThe independent laboratory carries out the flexural tensile breaking test and then axial compression on the half-prisms according to the guidelines of standard SIA 251. The values obtained reflect the intrinsic performance of the binder and aggregate skeleton mixed on the day of casting, neutralising subsequent site hazards.
- Comparison with in-situ core drillingsIf the test specimens reach the contractual class whereas cores drilled from the structure exhibit excessive friability, material failure is ruled out: the dispute shifts towards curing failure, brutal heating commissioning or premature drying caused by uncontrolled drafts.
| Reference test specimen result | In-situ core result | Established technical origin | Claim attribution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Complies with specified class | Insufficient mechanical strength | Curing defect, premature desiccation or surface water overdose | Site management or site manager |
| Complies with specified class | Mechanical strength compliant | Localised insulation settlement or abnormal operational surcharge | Insulation supplier or building user |
| Non-compliant with class | Non-compliant with class | Defective mortar formulation or poor water-binder ratio | Screed contractor or concrete plant |
Frequently asked questions
Who bears the financial cost of crushing tests in the event of a dispute?
According to customary practices governed by standard SIA 118, the party contesting the quality of the screed initially advances the laboratory costs. If the results demonstrate non-compliance of the mechanical strength relative to contract requirements, testing costs are borne by the screed contractor. Conversely, if the test specimens validate the specified strength class, the claimant assumes all invoices for sampling, transport and expert appraisal.
Why store three prisms rather than a single test specimen for the screed?
The preparation of three prisms measuring forty by forty by one hundred and sixty millimetres is prescribed by standard SIA 251 to obtain a reliable statistical average during destructive testing. The method requires eliminating any outlier value related to a localised compaction defect in the mould. Two half-prisms are generally used for preliminary tests, while the third intact prism remains sealed for potential judicial counter-expertise.
Where should reference test specimens be stored during the two-year contractual warranty?
After the initial twenty-eight days under a regulated environment at twenty degrees and controlled humidity, demoulded prisms must be stored dry in the company's warehouses, protected from frost and impacts. Each batch is archived in a labelled box mentioning the project name, batch number, floor level and casting date, ensuring inviolable traceability against insurance experts.
Can reference test specimens be replaced by a simple sclerometer test?
No. The spring-loaded sclerometer measures only the surface hardness of the screed and can under no circumstances replace a standardised mechanical crushing test. A carbonated surface may display a misleading rebound value while the core of the screed lacks binder. In legal arbitration situations, only tensile and compressive crushing tests performed in the laboratory on test specimens or cores possess indisputable probative value.
Texts and standards cited
- SIA 251Floating and bonded screeds in buildings, sampling and determination of mechanical strengths
- SIA 118General conditions for the execution of construction work, defect verification and expert appraisal procedure
